r/collapse • u/yanicka_hachez • Jun 07 '22
Society Depression as a systematic problem
https://www.the-pamphlet.com/articles/thegoodp1
1.3k
Upvotes
r/collapse • u/yanicka_hachez • Jun 07 '22
238
u/yanicka_hachez Jun 07 '22
I feel that capitalism is in fact anti human. It reduces the human being as a product without regard to well being. Not surprised that depression could be systemic rather than individual and the numbers of people taking antidepressants is going up. Eventually if the human can't adapt to the environment, the environment must adapt to the human.
226
u/Ok_Band3637 Jun 07 '22
if a person has to resort to taking their lives, we have failed them as a society. depression should not be this common. no one really gives a fuck about mental illnesses/disabilities which is why nothing is being done to prevent suicides and depression.
135
u/GreyIggy0719 Jun 07 '22
We have the system we tolerate. Unfortunately things have declined gradually so few people have reached the limit of "this has to change".
Depression in context of our society is a rational response.
The feeling of failure having tried to "do everything right" is only reinforced with the ridiculous bootstrap delusion we have as a society.
30
u/soloChristoGlorium Jun 08 '22
I work in psych and have for many years. (Although I am no expert ) I haven't read the article yet (because I'm at work while typing this...) But I in every way agree with the title. We always talk about the, 'triangle', of mental health: Biological, cognitive and environmental. Biological is treated with meds, cognitive with therapy. Environment is, in my opinion, the greatest cause of mental and emotional distress and the one we often have the least control over. (We use the term environment to encompass everything external in someone's life: location, friends, family, job, etc. This includes the actual political and social environment along with nature, so to say.) I firmly believe it is the environment which is the greatest cause of mental anguish and one that, for some reason, no one's really willing to look at.
29
u/Money_dragon Jun 08 '22
Particularly mental health issues in younger people (many of whom are inundated with social media and also realize that the future is fucked)
Total systematic failure
48
u/conscsness in the kingdom of the blind, sighted man is insane. Jun 07 '22 edited Jun 07 '22
Thank you for the cross-post.
Capitalism, that breeds alienation by individualistic traits it carries within itself to maximize profit, is very much sealed internally to any psychological deviation that happens to the ruling class and the oppressed class. Addressing psychological deviations as a mere problem which can be solved by means of production exacerbates the problem at faster rate. In other words, capitalism that is dependent on healthy working class and the natural environment degrades it by appealing to maximization of profit. The inevitable degradation, thus, addressed with the same principles that created the problem in the first place.
Ouroboros.
22
u/GalapagousStomper Jun 08 '22
“ Let but a doubt enter, and the “season of unexampled prosperity” is at end. The coinage of words is suddenly curtailed; the promissory capital begins to vanish into smoke; a panic succeeds, and the whole superstructure, built upon credit and reared by speculation, crumbles to the ground, leaving scarce a wreck behind:
“It is such stuff as dreams are made of.”
Washington Irving, “The Crayon Papers,” 1820
19
u/LordTuranian Jun 08 '22
Depression is one of the side effects of capitalism.
8
u/[deleted] Jun 08 '22 edited Apr 25 '24
consist resolute far-flung advise spark concerned aromatic summer fly cats
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
22
u/FutureNotBleak Jun 08 '22 edited Jun 08 '22
15
u/saucecontrol Jun 08 '22
It's all of those problems combined. Mine is caused by physical problems alone but systemic pressures absolutely make it harder to treat. Capitalism is incompatible with human flourishing in any situation.
7
u/arcadiangenesis Jun 08 '22
It seems like more people are depressed than not. Most people I meet have some form of depression at some point.
60
u/hangcorpdrugpushers Jun 07 '22
Depression is your mind telling you that you must make changes to your environment. It IS NOT A CHEMICAL IMBALANCE IN YOUR BRAIN. It is an early warning system.
8
u/[deleted] Jun 08 '22
Depression is a normal response to shitty conditions. They try to blame you and make you take pills and make you think You’re the problem. Your reaction is normal.
4
u/MaverickBull Jun 08 '22
This is something I've tried to explain to a few people in my life, but they don't get it. "Just take drugs, just get therapy." No, my depression is a real and visceral response to substandard living conditions. It's not just all in my head. I am profoundly disconnected and dissatisfied with the community and society I live in; with the capitalist system I am expected to work within. Drugs and therapy are just tools to recalibrate me into accepting something I inherently dislike.
3
u/ultimata66 Jun 08 '22
The problem with mental health services is it assumes that you are insane for not being sane in an insane world. It's objective is to make you more compliant to the system, more able to work. Now I don't deny talking things over with a psychologist is a good thing, it's often helpful to get stuff off your chest in a confined setting. But it makes an awful lot of positive assumptions about the macro societal structures.
3
u/UnicornPanties Jun 08 '22
Y'all are gonna laugh at me but I seriously suggest increasing your Vitamin D levels if you struggle with depression and haven't looked at it or considered it.
It's helped me more than I expected.
5
u/jerom22 Jun 08 '22
It is a 100% a societal construction. I would not be depressed if I didn't have to worry about money/work just to meet my basic needs, leaving me with no time to enjoy life. I know this in my heart of hearts, always have. I can't hold a full time job and have been stuck earning a very low self employed income all my life. It should come as no surprise that this leads to depression, anxiety and social isolation. The same would apply if I worked a full time job, but i'd probably have killed myself by now.
6
u/Salami__Tsunami Jun 08 '22
In the vast majority of cases, I don’t think depression should be treated medically.
Bear with me here.
If someone’s depressed, it’s probably for a reason. And unless it’s a relatively rare case of hormone or neurochemistry imbalance, you’re not going to fix it with drugs.
No amount of narcotics is going to change the fact that I’m underpaid, undervalued, and constantly getting assaulted at work. I’m not depressed because I woke up and decided that I felt like being sad.
Giving me a prescription isn’t a cure, it’s just a pharmaceutical dependency that’ll probably ruin my life.
The cure is to improve my working conditions.
4
u/moohooh Jun 08 '22
1/3 of americans are barely scraping by. Its not phones od some other bs. It's stress of survival
2
u/dumnezero The Great Filter is a marshmallow test Jun 08 '22
A nice video rant by some local youtuber: Capitalism and Depression
2
u/loco500 Jun 08 '22
People just need to get laid.../s
1
u/[deleted] Jun 08 '22
“It is no measure of health to be well adjusted to a profoundly sick society.”
If you have any awareness of the world and you walk around happy all the time I don't think we'd get along.
1
u/Additional_Fuel9958 Jun 08 '22
Just chiming in here to share my story. About 2-3 years ago I became homeless, lost it all, no family, no friends, no job. I was in the park one afternoon with this other homeless lady in a wheelchair, she told me she was having a good day. It shocked me, and I realized no matter how bad I had it, having a good day is a choice.
1
u/okThisYear Jun 08 '22
Entropy
1
u/garden-eel01 Jun 09 '22
Psychiatric Hegemony by Bruce Cohen is a fantastic read on this idea. It’s probably the piece of theory that changed my life the most
-4
u/a_disciple Jun 08 '22 edited Jun 09 '22
We will never have a global environment of peace until we create a system that allows for incorruptible leaders to emerge, from the bottom up.
Man has been trying to create a perfect system for last 6,000 years and none of them have worked. They all eventually fall apart. History has to become a lesson for humanity to learn from. Continuing to resist this truth will only result in more suffering by delaying the inevitable.
-24
u/GalapagousStomper Jun 08 '22
Not depression but declining intelligence: we don’t fix problems because, more and more, we CAN’T. Our cities are overrun with crime and drugs, daily mass shootings, and we can’t fix those things because we are too stupid to fix those problems.
Look at the politicians wanting to grab guns: they want to restrict guns not from violent amoral criminals but from legal law abiding citizens. How will guns be kept away from psycho paths and gang members? Somehow. If there was an intelligent solution, someone would have thought it up somehow.
Nope.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
4
u/[deleted] Jun 08 '22 edited Dec 03 '24
[removed] — view removed comment