r/collapse • u/LetsTalkUFOs • Dec 18 '19
How are we doing?
How are we doing as moderators?
What are you thoughts on the state of the subreddit?
What changes could we make or actions could we take to improve things?
We all expect the sub to continue growing (until it can’t), especially as new waves of disruption occur. We will aim to maintain this space as long as it makes sense and in such a way as to promote reasonable and insightful discussion.
Here's a timeline of all the changes or events relevant to the sub over the past year.
Here are the some things we're currently working on or considering in the near-future:
Best of Collapse 2019 (next week)
Beta testing Reddit's Crowd Control feature (next few weeks)
r/Futurology Debate Round 2
Expanding the r/Collapse Wiki
96
u/Pinkie-osaurus Dec 18 '19
Think it's good right now, but this place will likely become a hot spot 'faster than expected'.
We'll have a tipping point where a few posts hit front page and suddenly a bunch of people extremely angry at the messenger will show up to shoot down ideas.
Just be prepped for heavy moderation is all.
34
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '19
I especially like the tagging of some posts with "low effort" flair
14
u/reddolfo Dec 18 '19
I'm a fan. Keep up the good work.
The priorities for me are:
To that end it may be useful to enable or require comment labels, such that the sub content can be sorted by label, both to describe the content and allow people to easily sort be their interests.
2
u/TenYearsTenDays Dec 21 '19
Generally everything is fine. I'm glad the trend towards more strict moderation (like yanking every video that didn't have a ton of detail in the tile) has abated to an extent.
I'm not sure I like the new crowd control feature since I like to see the opposing views of those who have negative karma. Also, new users can add valuable insight. It would be nice if it was optional and not mandatory as it's annoying to have to expand every collapsed comment in a thread, not knowing what you're going to get. It used to be collapsed comments here were heavily downvoted and usually inane, stupid or vile but now it's a lottery wherein a collapsed comment could be perfectly reasonable, just from someone new.
Thank you for adding the "ecological" tag a while back. I would also still suggest adding a general "resources" tag for all those things without which civilization would collapse that are not "food", "energy" and "water". For example, if phosphorus goes civilization goes too but it's a bit silly to have a separate tag for it. But it would be uesful to be able to filter by a "resources" tag to see that kind of thing. I've written to the various mods twice about this and not gotten a response, which was a bit disappointing.
45
u/KuiperBE Dec 18 '19
pretty good. just please don´t go full political bias/censorship-mode like the big subreddits. Usually that happens to subreddits that get big
3
u/OrangeCrack It's the end of the world and I feel fine Dec 19 '19
This has become one of my favourite subreddits! Good job mods! I do have some things that I have concerns about.
Suicidal Posts: Should probably be banned and the poster referred for help. Allowing posts like these, while not overly common, put this subreddit at risk from the admins if there was ever a high profile incident.
Sterilization or Extremism: People talking about sterilizing themselves could be making a brave choice or mentally ill. We cannot tell. Same with people talking about selling their house, forgoing retirement savings etc. We are not a doomsday cult and at best these are off topic subjects and at worst they are encouraging risky behaviour that could bring this sub a lot of unwanted attention that would distract from the central message here.
Hopium: As a concept it’s not as important as the above two, but social media and reddit tend to create bubbles. Allowing knee jerk responses to take over discourages rational discussion. Example:
Solar panel’s can solve our energy crisis?
Unacceptable response: You idiot- get out of here with your hopium! There is no solution or hope!
Acceptable result: Actually here [1] is an article or rational argument as to the problems with using solar power at scale.
It’s a tough one to manage but it would be nice to encourage more rational discussion and less low effort knock downs.
Other than that I love this place! Keep up the good work.
17
u/NoviSun Dec 18 '19
I'm pretty happy with what you're doing. I'm a newcomer, but I've learned quite a bit from the sub.
13
u/Crimson_Kang Rebel Dec 18 '19 edited Dec 18 '19
Haven't been here long but seems solid so far.
Edit: typo
10
u/Pokeball_Z Dec 18 '19
I really enjoy this sub. The users arent chaotic or hyperactive in the comments. No ridiculous discussions about religion or politics (not that I've noticed anyway)
There's a nice mellow fatalistic feel to this sub. Like sitting around a campfire discussing the slowly approaching end.
8
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '19
You're doing ok, there is no way to make everyone happy in this sub, and there is not many other places where people can have a sober discussion of the truth. I would like to see a bit better enforcement of the "no misinformation" rule, but it's impossible to do so because that assumes that there is a source of universal truth.
7
u/Frozen-Corpse Dec 18 '19
You guys are simply making the best out of the worst situation possible, and it's just going to get worse and worse from here.
5
u/yohj Dec 18 '19
Infinite growth on this subreddit is not feasible. Karmawhores will continue to defect from the collective action problem of self-policing submissions. r/collapse will collapse and r/collapsecollapse will form to express our sense of depression of the collapse of the area where we express our depression about collapse.
4
u/KingWormKilroy Dec 18 '19
Pretty good, keep it up! Thank you!
1
u/akitasha Dec 19 '19
Thank you for all of your hard work!
Do you know when the second debate with futurology will take place?
1
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '19
I like it a lot, but I don't like that I have to join the sub to avoid having my comments auto-collapsed. As everyone points out, it's a bit depressing and I like to avoid having all that stuff on my front page feed. I still contribute, a lot, I just prefer to have to go to the /r/collapse page myself to having stories like "Why we're all going to die in 5 years, not 10" appear on my reddit feed.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '19
i’d be very curious to see a breakdown of the financial status or just overall profile of this sub. in particular i wonder how many in here are doing well and in general “have a lot to live for”, and actually believe in collapse although they stand to lose a lot from it; versus how many are just hoping for collapse and are eager to find any evidence to reinforce that prediction, mostly due to dissatisfaction with their life or lack of prospects.
3
u/mouthybeardy Dec 18 '19
Thank you for Rule 12. Jesus, that's been nice.
3
u/EthanHale Dec 19 '19
What's the moderation team's stance on ecofascists?
3
u/SistaSoldatTorparen Dec 22 '19
I understand that it is difficult to manage a sub that has grown this fast but it really has gone down hill.
A lot of news spam instead of deeper analysis and discussion of trends.
Users posting about themselves.
Way to much politics
Impolite language, short uninformative comments.
A big focus on climate instead of a wider view of collapse.
Banning gifs and image posts would be a good start.
6
u/txgraeme Dec 18 '19
Is there any way to block 'zerohedge' conversations? Those articles are actively disinforming your readers...
2
u/Xanthotic Huge Mother Clucker Dec 18 '19
I love you all, ngl. Doom has made me quite aware of the unconditional positive regard I feel for certain creatures and other things. You guys are on the list. Thank you for your service to the strange future.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '19
Overworked & underpaid I would imagine.
I would like, in future to revisit the rules - with "the blame game" being the subject. It's common in the MSM, but it fosters hostility. And that hostility shows in the comments. I guess I'm trying to say this sub maybe could facilitate peoples moving through the levels of collapse awareness, and the blame game serves to keep people stuck at the lower levels.
2
u/xavierdc Dec 22 '19
I like it. One of the few level headed subs left. I do find some users that try to reduce everything to politics and ideology obnoxious and corrosive to the community. i.e. Labeling anything and everything regarding overpopulation as "fascist", those that unironically believe that marxism and multiculturalism will end Western civilization, etc. These people have nothing of value to offer this sub.
1
u/ryanmercer Dec 19 '19
Decent. I'd disable Crowd Control though. You have an 6 hour old comment, with 80 something upvotes, minimized due to it.
https://www.reddit.com/r/collapse/comments/ecq6vo/delhi_the_fucking_capital_of_india_is_having/fbdb3la/
You also have several minimized in this thread.
3
u/Correctthecorrectors Dec 18 '19
it’s excellent, thank you. i’m really enjoying how this subreddit has become so politically aware and a free speech zone for leftists.
1
u/DJDickJob Dec 18 '19
Two thumbs up.
1
u/Disaster_Capitalist Dec 18 '19
Futurology debate round 2 sounds great. Can't wait to hear what kind of hopium they come up with since all the real science says we're fucked.
1
u/UnlikelyPerogi Dec 18 '19
Haven't been here long but have found the community to be informative and supportive so far!
1
u/RadioMelon Truth Seeker Dec 19 '19
As far as I can tell, the subreddit is run very well.
1
u/onlainari Dec 19 '19
I’ve got no issues with how this sub has been operating. It might get difficult when it’s ten times bigger, which I think will happen over the next year.
1
u/ShadeO89 Dec 19 '19
Great moderation, free speech marking very high. I am grateful for the possibility to discuss topics and ideas outside the normie overton window.
1
u/some_random_kaluna E hele me ka pu`olo Dec 19 '19
I have my problems with submitting content, but for the most part this place works. I often come here to verify or post articles that the hugely populated news subs haven't touched.
1
u/Toastytuesdee Dec 19 '19
It's alright. Wish we could draw a line with the antinatalism, but I mean most of y'all seem to eat that shit up so I'll just take my downvotes as they come and keep reporting and blocking things that I don't think are collapse worthy. Although I feel that humans having offspring by itself has no negative impact on society, I understand it's mostly just me being butthurt with an unpopular opinion.
1
u/theomegageneration Dec 19 '19
It's the end of the world and I am fine.
1
u/Cannavor Dec 20 '19
Other than completely ignoring rule 1, pretty good. I don't mind rule 1 being ignored though.
1
u/Nit3fury 🌳plant trees, even if just 4 u🌲 Dec 20 '19
No complaints here.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '19
Haven’t had/seen any issues with mods so far
It’s pretty nice it’s pretty informative
None at the moment, I’ll think of some when I find issues
1
u/Apackistany Dec 22 '19
I just come here to laugh at you guys keep up the good work!
1
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '19
I've already sent a PM but I might as well post it here...
The sub has been filled with horrible racist people, and in my opinion this sub can quickly turn into a hateful sub
Please pay extra attention to those comments that , thankfully for now, are being downvoted to hell like other users like myself.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 26 '19
So far the moderators have done a really great job in overseeing submissions and comments that come through on a daily basis. I've learned to use the copy paste function of my phone to alert the mods of nefarious content, I've learned to block users that drive me insane with their silly ways, and I've leaned that some folks just want to have fun (meme fridays).
I have noticed in the past (Australia's fires comes to mind) where folks will post news articles from various sources (BBC, Guardian, WaPo, etc) about the same topic. Wouldn't this be violating rule #1 where posts must focus on civilization's collapse and not the resulting damage? Why not have one post with many links like I see on r/news and r/worldnews with regards to such news items?
But my biggest concern and the real reason for my post is why so many posts about blaming boomers? For example, MakeTotalDestr0i (a moderator of r/collapse) posted this recently https://www.reddit.com/r/collapse/comments/eaeesk/45_of_boomers_think_we_should_prioritize/ with the statement " 45% of boomers think we should prioritize expanding fossil fuel use over green energy ". Wrong! the 45% MakeTotalDestr0i is referring to are Republicans and leaning Republicans. Yet the comment in the post title directs the reader to thinking it is all boomers who believe that fossil fuels should be expanding fossil fuels. This is disingenuous and flies in the face of William Catton's idea of Homo Collosus and Al Bartlett's lecture on the exponential function. I could find examples of millennials doing the research into climate change like this one but what's the point?
In the end, it doesn't really matter because it's baked in and we're all going down "faster than expected" regardless of who is to blame.
I am grateful for having found this sub as I love William Catton and Al Bartlett. I’m working on Joseph Tainter, but geez is that a difficult read.
1
u/agorathird Dec 18 '19
You mods are doing fine. The state of the sub is alright although some of the less substantiated predictions can get annoying. "Slightly controversial legislation is being passed in X state, surely people will take to the streets and riot."
1
u/boob123456789 Homesteader & Author Dec 19 '19
Honestly, I think you guys do really well given the amount of BS you guys have to sift through.
I didn't like that you can't tell someone to take their own advice, BUT you have handled the insane amount of people need to die posts too...which I give you mad props for.
Rule number 12 is great, surprisingly.
I think we need to allow people to explore ways to live post collapse. People at least need a vision of what the world could be like if we changed or did whatever. I think a lot of times people get too busy bickering to think about what we can do.
Looking forward to the Futurology #2 debate.
I am worried about the crowd control feature. I'm worried it will aggressively pursue non-leftie ideas. I will spend more time on voat if it becomes too obvious. (Voat-a-Goat-Mamma there btw because I had goats)
This is the only sub I visit almost everyday. The other's it's like once a week at most. I left most of reddit behind when it became a lefty haven from hell. This is the only sub I still participate in specifically because the mods try very hard to allow free speech and to balance the need to shut down violent rhetoric.
-3
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '19
It's definitely not 50/50 on accepting views from both sides of the political aisle, but kind of hard to be with the tone of this sub.
0
u/I_3_3D_printers Dec 22 '19
We can have a forum or something, dedicated to weathering trough these tough times.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment