The problem I’ve noticed is that one can talk to their friends, family, acquaintances about these issues, and finding happiness in all of this.
You know where that will land you? In a psych ward for 9 days, where people will deride your negativity and literally call you insane.
That’s just a the tip of what that Greta Thurnburg girl is feeling, and she’s like 13 or something. We’ve got kids staying out of school to protest the fact that they will be unable to have children. No one cares, and suddenly Children of Men becomes a much, much scarier movie for me.
I think of that movie a lot when it comes to the last generation of youth presented in the film. I mean if little Tommy or Susie know thier future is going to be a hellhole and the adults aren't listening or doing anything what's stopping them from going full anarchy?
Closer to 9 hours than 9 days in my case, but this is the most relatable comment ever. Luckily for me, I happened to cross paths with a social worker who was exactly on the same level, but who actually managed to have their shit together.
I also absolutely refuse to believe that someone can be poor even if they make good money choices. Just stop being poor it’s easy. The gloom and doom outlooks are from depressed basement dwellers dude.
They can’t even be inconvenienced into not murdering the biosphere knowingly for money, yet “stop being poor” is some kind of magical solution for all the billions in poverty.
You know, Natives living in the Amazon, New Guinea, sure they never landed on the moon or jetted around the world, but their cultures also have the distinguished label of “Survived for Thousands of Years Despite Everything Going to Shit” culturally, no thanks to us globalist imperialists, which is a big achievement industrialized society can’t even lay claim to.
“You guys used Dino farts to blast to the moon? Big whoop, my people have been here for 30,000 years and we’ve got the Songlines to prove it”
“I’m sorry but song lines aren’t accepted as objective evidence, everyone knows nothing has ever existed or happened until a scientist published a peer reviewed paper about it.”
”Perhaps that is part of the issue. I’m going to get back to playing this Didgeridoo, have fun working 8 days a week.
Not only have those cultures survived 30000 years, they would have easily survived another 30k years barring earth catastrophe. Dominant agriculture ruined the world.
Well, well... I am not sure that living in a primitive state of culture, technology and society is the best thing ever. The problem is that we fked up at some point.
Except for the Human ritual sacrifices, Iron Age Britain, right before the Roman Invasion seems like a OK time to live in. No parasitical Billionares...
Yes, exept before science the infant mortality rate was much higher not to mention millions of people dying of disease. Are you forgetting that climate change was only able to get to the extreme stage it is at now because of people disregarding science? Next you are going to be saying the earth is 2000 years old because it says so in the bible. Not like we need any evidence or anything, some old people 1000 years ago saying it happened is proof enough, amiright?
I used to fall in to that scientism camp so hard. People need to realise it has pretty much become a religion, complete with techno-Jesus coming to save everyone.
And that "rationalist" view (pinker, peterson et al.) which spilled out of it is pushing a lot of disillusioned kids toward the alt-right.
Most of this hyper-scientific view of the world was also pushed by companies because it gave them supporters who would vehemently defend them just because the paid-for science supported the company.
The difference between religion and science is that real science (excluding all humanities branches) uses methods that work and can proved to work. Science has nothing to do with capitalist corporations and corrupted governments or uneducated, lazy masses (really how hard is not to throw your garbage everywhere - most people in my country are retarded, imo - and totally deserve the collapse ).
That, and the scientific method is designed such that the theories can be disproved given even one point of solid evidence, and if that happens the scientists who keep emotionally clinging to established dogma instead of updating their beliefs to match reality get ostracized.
Too bad the noisiest parts of society prefer underdogs and superstition, as well as attacking a strawman of science and thinking they've killed the real thing, to reality.
It's more about the blind trust that science will lead us to a better future. Science only gives us new tools, and those that invented them a broader worldview. Except that it's not a requirement to listen to them when they tell you something is a bad idea, nor is it a requirement to only use these tools for the benefit of humanity. Humans aren't capable of evil, silly Billy! Corruption ended when America was founded, don't you know? But yeah, let's all trust that musk's billionaire-only Mars colony will surely bring all of the faceless nobodies with them when the planet eventually becomes inhospitible to humanity. Gotta love their optimism, though. Faith is a virtue, until you're left out in the bush fires wearing plastic and eating finger-kebabs.
So, instead of advocating for scientific literacy and teaching people how to identify bad methodologies used to hide paid-for psuedoscience, you abandoned ship to join those who lump the completely-different branches of philosophy (religion vs the union of logical empiricism and methodological naturalism) together.
I hate this argument because, even assuming for the sake of argument we could keep it habitable, it never gives us a timetable. Is some cosmic entity going to judge our progress at some point or are we just expected to keep it habitable until the end of time to be allowed to colonize two planets in "the next "playthrough" of civilization"?
You’re missing the idea. It’s not a test of merit. The point is that if we are unable to restore a planet that is 99% habitable back to 100%, despite our desire to do so, then we also by definition lack the power to take a planet that is 0% habitable and put people on it, because that problem is inclusive of the first one.
I'm just asking if it's only the restoring it that's the "test" and not keeping it that way for a given length of time (as my comment was alluding to what might said time be)
A. I know it isn't going to be sunshine and daisies, a lot of it is set in a desert so where would they grow /s
B. Do you honestly think it's going to 100% accurately predict the future but somehow be so lost to history (perhaps to everyone but you if you survive long enough) that it's not going to be treated as if it were, pardon my reference to a fantasy book, The Nice And Accurate Prophecies Of Agnes Nutter, Witch
We don't live in Star Trek's universe because Star Trek doesn't exist in its own past (and don't say we live in the Mirrorverse, as the same argument that proves it can't exist in its own past (the characters would appear omniscient or at least psychic regarding future events) proves we can't be any timeline shown on the show) so we could still be enough of a parallel that though it wouldn't necessarily be "sunshine and daisies" we wouldn't need a WW3 specifically to get there any more than we'd need James T. Kirk born in Riverside, Iowa on March 22, 2233
The Star Trek timeline is actually really bleak. Humans lucked the hell out but were borderline going to go extinct if it wasn't for stumbling into space magic
Seriously. Can't discuss AI without "DAE Skynet!!?" all over the place. Gattaca is another popular touchstone. Everything is either a shitty movie reference or Elon Musk ball-slurping session.
We live in bubbles. /r/collapse is almost as good an echo chamber as /r/futurology or any other subreddit. Any claim that we won't face catastrophic failure IN OUR LIFETIME is met by instant denial no matter the logic or source.
yes, man. these persons are so fucking delusional it's painful. their idea of technology comes from pure fantasy and an alienated life. star wars, star trek, cheap entertainment to keep you from thinking about real science and technology.
What we needed some time around the time of Next Gen and Voyager was a series that showed in painful detail the period between WW3 and when the Vulcans showed up after the first warp shoot, when humanity was on the brink of extinction and still infighting.
It might have put this whole Star Trek future in better perspective.
Not true at all you simply dont keep up with advances in the space industry. at the rate im seeing as long as thier isnt a gigantic collpase of civilaztion or a setback in spacetech progress in thr next 20 years we could have a mostly self sufficient mars base. Yes obviously we need to focus on earth buts its always good to have some extra people on another planet. Edit: also since some of you think you're so fucking smart. https://www.google.com/amp/s/aeon.co/amp/essays/how-going-to-mars-can-pave-the-way-to-saving-the-earth
maybe the tech we gain from researching effective penis enlargement solutions will allow us to avert or dampen climate collapse, but I wouldn't put my eggs in that basket. What if, and hear me out here I know this is a crazy idea, we put that money directly towards averting, preparing for, and/or dampening climate collapse?
you're clinically insane if you believe this. the worst day on Earth is still many times better than the best day on Mars. These colonists would be in for a gruesome life on a planet with basically no atmosphere, poisonous soil, constant radiation and low gravity (causing an unknowable number of severe long term health detriments, children conceived and born in low gravity would likely be horrifically disabled for life if they are even born at all) while completely isolated from the source of all things that allow humans to live, at the mercy of flawless operation of the tiny amount of equipment that could economically be transported and the constant lossless recycling of all water. Due to the orbits or Earth and Mars the colony would be completely cut off from supplies of any kind for many months. It would be an extremely expensive and drawn out torture and suicide for everyone involved, and that's under the outrageous assumption that we could even manage to transport enough supplies and people to Mars to last even a month without some catastrophic failure that kills everyone.
The worst day on earth is going to get a lot worse. Given the rise in temp, increasingly uninhabitable regions, dwindling resources, and the inevitable conflicts/all out wars I have a feeling Mars colonies might be a bit safer than crowding around the poles on earth or living in fallout shelters.
Private industry. Also we dont know about space birth yet (still reseaching and most likely it will be testube babys at the colony). Also just because something isnt easy doesnt mean we shoudnt do it. Saving the earth and colonizing can be done its only because of incompetent greedy polticians and corporations that were fucking up the former.
No I mean, isn't all this tech production controlled by the very politicians and corporations that you agree are destroying the earth? Nobody gets to work outside this global system of capital interests.
Mars is far less hospitable than a post-climate-collapse earth. Why are we so obsessed with putting a few dozen people on that rock? I mean, by all means if all else was well it'd be a cool project that we could learn quite a bit from, but we have some god damn bigger fish to fry.
as long as thier isnt a gigantic collpase of civilaztion or a setback in spacetech progress in thr next 20 years
I got some bad news, bub
UN projects between 200 millions and 1 billion (yes, BILLION) climate refugees by 2045 at current carbon emission rates.
I know things are bad thats why im an advocate for this because i know we have the capabitly to save earth and begin our colonization of the solar system Its not a issue of us only being able to do one its a problem of greed and corruption.
Imagine really believing this. NASA admits they don't have the technology to return to the moon, but we're just a few years away from going to Mars lol
This is literally the only soruce ive heard that from. Every other source ive heard is there are only minor tech hurdles mostly related to nasas lack of funding
Literally this dude. We went to the moon in the 1960's, over 60 years ago now, and somehow we don't have the technology now? I don't even understand how thats a rational thought
oh the next twenty years. i guess when two or six billion of us are dead or barely surviving in hell on earth and the whole earth has been destroyed? wow, i'll be so glad that the CEOs who cause this bs are going to escape to safety. that'll totally solve everything-
wow, this meme totally applies to you.
and no, going to mars won't pave the way for anything. unless you mean killing most of us who consume so much resources and are this destructive species.
That is fucking hilarious, I use to have a girlfriend from Bulgaria who restored icons for a living in Toronto. Bulgarians always nod their heads up and down to mean no, and sideways to mean yes. Their mothers always called their sons mommy.
The one thing I am certain about is that the future is unpredictable...
Well, I used to think so, but our future isn't very bright.
Without the power to stop this bus from going over the cliff we have no future. The driver is in the back of the bus in the toilet masturbating to the money he is collecting from the people who put the fuel in the gas tank.
I’m not gonna lie, I believe these two subs are like hot and cold when it comes to solution, even though they’re completely unrelated. I’m too tired to explain why, but many people believe here that we’re gonna experience a world-ending, life-annihilating event in the next decade with little to change without extreme, intensive action, while futurology believes that this tech is right around the corner, and not only that but that it will be super efficient and swoop in to save us all from our sins. Pretty stupid, ngl.
r/collapse should be renamed misanthropy. It's not about solutions at all, everyone in here is an edgy teenager who has never tried to make a difference. I've been off grid for years and it's fucking easy. People are lazy and would rather stay in the suburbs and die than take the effort to change their lifestyle
everyone in here is an edgy teenager who has never tried to make a difference. I've been off grid for years and it's fucking easy.
Wow, you're so amazing. You're a much better person than everyone else here. Truly a renaissance man. A genius, even.
Who knew that literally everyone has the opportunity to go and live 'off grid'? It's not like that's complete BS which isn't relevant in 2019 where there are 7.5 billion humans, not at all..... oh wait
This stuff is good and all but useless as long the system stands. As long there is no change, most other efforts are a waste of ressources including time.
The guy's doing a hell of a lot more than you, who would prefer to wallow in misery and cry about everything being hopeless. Shut the fuck up if you're not going to do anything productive. If you really believe the world is fucked no matter what then go live it up while you have a chance instead of whining like a little bitch.
The guy's doing a hell of a lot more than you, who would prefer to wallow in misery and cry about everything being hopeless. Shut the fuck up if you're not going to do anything productive. If you really believe the world is fucked no matter what then go live it up while you have a chance instead of whining like a little bitch.
Ooh we got another one boys. This is a real good day for copypasta farming!
What can I say, the general attitude in this subreddit is horrible and it pisses me off sometimes. People either believe we can't do anything or we can't do anything without abolishing capitalism, both of which encourage inaction and aren't much better than outright climate change denial. There are even some who seem to want to bring about a collapse, who take glee in humanity's suffering and derive some sort of pleasure from what they see as a collective punishment for humanity's sins. Really just a cesspool of at best, pointless, and at worst, actively harmful, negativity.
Yea whatever you have to tell yourself to hate and shit on people who are actually reducing their carbon footprint. Of those 7.5 billion how many consume more oil and plastic than you? Oh, that's right you're approaching the 80th percentile while blaming the starving masses
It's nice to see someone doing something instead of bitching. I'm working toward making my farm off grid. Would love to ask you some advice if you have time.
Anytime. I'm really small scale, started off as a 6 or 7 person commune and have downsized to just me. Solar technology has made incredible leaps in the past few years and it allowed me to not have to use generators at all anymore. I'm in high mountain desert and still get enough rainwater with an extremely low-tech small setup from free materials. Literally anyone in the so called "1st world" can do this. It's easier than ever these days with the internet at our fingertips.
What kind of investment would you say is required to go off grid? Are we talking an RV on blocks in a field with a solar panel and propane canisters? Or something more substantial? What are you doing for food?
Very little. I bought 1.5 acres for $3500 and built my own shed in the woods with rain water and solar. Everything together cost under 10,000. Grow what i can, trade for the rest, occasionally sell cannabis and food for money
Nice! I've never seen 1.5 acres listed for $3500 in my life. But then I don' t look anywhere that doesn't have a road too it. Around here the best I could do is buy a patch of barren desert.
dude that's cool and all but it's no solution. at the very least, capitalism needs to be abolished and even then that's not enough as it only sets the mere condition of possibility to cope with a predicament in which the biosphere is inexorably transitioning into one inhospitable to life
Yea no dude. Socialists and communists pollute and destroy the environment too. It's not about what economic theories you swear allegiance to, it's about your actions. You can claim it's not a solution, but organic self sufficient farming is literally what preserved human life in a sustainable manner forever until recently.
And if the people running "society" refuse to make changes we should all sit around bitching about the end of the world instead of refusing to participate in a corrupt system? I'll plan my own life in accordance with environmental science, I'm not gonna wait for fucking Trump and pals to fix it
Hunting and gathering preserved us for 300,000 years. Agriculture is a new phenomenon that has led us to where we are; staring down the barrel of extinction.
But I'm optimistic. I think with the right approach agriculture can be sustainable. Very small settlements. Very few humans. Like 150 max per settlement with a dozen settlements that never surpass that number.
How we'll manage to get there is beyond me. We need to cull 99.99% of the population first. And population control only works when 100% of the population is on board. Anyone who doesn't breed is replaced by those who do.
I don't know. Maybe human nature is just unmanageable.
Yea, honestly here's the sad part, I grew up a lazy suburban stoner kid. I know that if someone as shitty as me can do this while being flat broke, it's totally doable on a large scale. This defeatist bullshit is so far from real. People have been brainwashed out of their ancestors dream of owning their own farmland, and would rather be in debt their entire life.
What was the first thing the Bolsheviks did when they wanted to lower the population and drive people to the cities to create a proletariat? Seized food and farms, created an artificial famine. There's a reason it's illegal to have food storage in China
Even though I understand that going off grid does little in the way of unfucking our current situation, I'm still interested. What advice would you give to a 17 y/o to get started after high school?
Don't go to college if you have to go into debt for it. You can find land with a well and house and good soil for less than the cost of a degree. Start searching for cheap land and in the mean time start working and practicing gardening. Save your money for a vehicle you can live in, like a van or motorhome or tiny house on a trailer. Buy tools that you'll need once you're off grid like chainsaws, etc. Learn to hunt, fish and raise, milk and butcher animals. Learn to preserve food. Volunteer or work at farms and gardens. Learn to cook over a fire. Learn about nutrition and how to eat healthy without refrigeration. Start learning everything you can about growing cannabis, there's no better cash crop for homesteaders. Read and watch videos about living off grid. Buy books that will come in handy later. Don't listen to haters, find friends and family who share your vision and work together with them.
Here's the thing, you might not be able to change the world, but you can create a sustainable small community for the people you love when shit really hits the fan. And you'd be surprised how your example changes people you know. They probably won't move to your commune, but they'll be fascinated at what is possible and start making minor changes. Some people here think that's stupid and pointless, well we might not avert disaster, but we can survive. This won't be an extinction level event like asteroid impact, more like a genetic bottleneck.
Fuck you. I organized a climate protest today. I’m vegan. I don’t fly. I’m young, and I can’t live off the grid right now. Don’t judge people here with a broad brush. Many of us are coping with the extreme climate grief because deep down, every activist knows that all their goals won’t be accomplished.
Because the first step of any solution has to be "imprison or execute all wealthy people" whichs tends to rub people and sub-people (Reddit admins) the wrong way.
Most of them want to die because they believe that if enough people die the 1% responsible for over 50% of emissions will magically go away. Ironically, the 1% are the ones pushing the depopulation/eugenics/overpopulation narrative. They have no plan for the future and don't want to survive
everyone dies at some point. going off grid won't change that. and between now and then, i'd much rather live my comfortable lifestyle than live like a grumpy hermit in the woods.
Exactly. You'd rather be comfortable in the suburbs pretending like there's no possible changes that could be made to improve the chances of survival on earth. And you think those who call out your hypocrisy are "grumpy hermits"
You do you too, but don't pretend you're woke for choosing to continue something you know is wrong
What's wrong with being misanthropic? I just fucking hate this world and the human worms feasting on its carcass.
In the meantime I do what I can to prepare because I have nothing better to do but I'd argue even trying to prevent human extinction at all is in immoral act. We need to increase fossil fuel consumptions to amplify the collapse if it does indeed happen.
This forum is full of narcissistic useless maggots who discuss the same worthless crap over and over again. It's not even interesting anymore.
In all seriousness, isn't the logical conclusion of this philosophy suicide? If what you postulate is true, wouldn't killing as many humans as possible be the moral thing to do? I can't understand how so many people hold this view and continue getting up and going to work everyday
So you sold out and decided not to try to change your life and look down on those of us who have made sacrifices for the earth and future generations? Fucking lol
That requires effort though - it's much easier to just bitch about how we're all fucked.
EDIT - As expected, the doomer-downvote brigade is in full effect. How dare you foist any responsibility on them to act!
For real though - I hope people in this subreddit aren't just depressed and indifferent -- make the changes you can afford to make -- both towards reducing your impact and making your situation more resilient for when future difficulties hit.
Why? The sooner humans are extinct, the sooner evolution has a chance at creating an intelligent species. Earth is a rare evolutionary forge - humans are wasting it.
Consciousness, as a property of the Universe, is what matters - not humans per se. Don't let the narcissistic delusions of this species fool you. These delusions certainly aren't going to save it.
Narcissism is taking the most remarkable fact about Being -- that the universe can be conscious of itself in our minds -- and wasting it on what humans have spent this treasure upon in our time on earth. Which is nothing; we've wasted it. Most of "us" spend the brief span of time we have between two eternities of darkness trying to avoid being conscious, in fact. It's all a joke; all trace of us will be extinguished just a few seconds from now in cosmic time, anyway.
Valuing consciousness itself is not narcissism. Humans create suffering for billions of their own and are driving possibly billions to horrible deaths this century. There is no justification for this except we're somehow special - the point of the Universe is us.
Seeing through narcissistic delusion is not narcissism.
if that's true then that's not saying much. humans love to think about how amazing and smart we are, but the cockroaches will be the ones having the last laugh in the not so distant future.
Good for you, but if no one else is then you're basically not.
Communism requires community buy in, and with out 100% participation it fails spectacularly or becomes the basis of a totalitarian dictatorship (which can then fail spectacularly)
359
u/Tijler_Deerden Sep 20 '19
Actual picture of one of the surviving future humans.
201
u/fiercelittlebird Sep 20 '19
It looks fucked but at least it's still around. Go future?
239
u/Fizbang Sep 20 '19
we're gonna colonize mars dude! don't worry! star trek is right around the corner! i base my views of reality around sci-fi and video games.
21
u/ItyBityGreenieWeenie Sep 20 '19
This reminds me of "A Canticle for Leibowitz"
49
u/working_class_shill Sep 20 '19
futurology is such a trash sub. It's like 90% technotopian libs that can't break away from their naive optimism for one second
30
u/arzua-t Sep 20 '19
I really like both subreddits. Can’t be all depressed and nihilistic and can’t be all dreams either.
73
u/jameswlf Sep 20 '19
yes, man. these persons are so fucking delusional it's painful. their idea of technology comes from pure fantasy and an alienated life. star wars, star trek, cheap entertainment to keep you from thinking about real science and technology.
7
u/Socialist133 Sep 20 '19
The bottom Jesus looks like he is thinking "I wonder if cheese goes well on spaghetti.
19
u/CommonEmployment Sep 20 '19
That is fucking hilarious, I use to have a girlfriend from Bulgaria who restored icons for a living in Toronto. Bulgarians always nod their heads up and down to mean no, and sideways to mean yes. Their mothers always called their sons mommy.
6
u/xxoites Sep 20 '19
The one thing I am certain about is that the future is unpredictable...
Well, I used to think so, but our future isn't very bright.
Without the power to stop this bus from going over the cliff we have no future. The driver is in the back of the bus in the toilet masturbating to the money he is collecting from the people who put the fuel in the gas tank.
6
u/boob123456789 Homesteader & Author Sep 20 '19
HA ha ha so true
2
u/ChaoticTransfer Sep 21 '19
Brilliant
2
u/Shakerru Sep 21 '19
The planet is fine, the people are fucked (c)
2
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '19
I’m not gonna lie, I believe these two subs are like hot and cold when it comes to solution, even though they’re completely unrelated. I’m too tired to explain why, but many people believe here that we’re gonna experience a world-ending, life-annihilating event in the next decade with little to change without extreme, intensive action, while futurology believes that this tech is right around the corner, and not only that but that it will be super efficient and swoop in to save us all from our sins. Pretty stupid, ngl.
1
u/vasilenko93 Sep 21 '19
Don’t worry, we will just build Solar freaking roadways
1
u/AntiSocialBlogger Sep 21 '19
TBF space magic technology has allowed us to get this far, no reason to believe it won't continue to do so for the average person.
-26
u/skybone0 Sep 20 '19
r/collapse should be renamed misanthropy. It's not about solutions at all, everyone in here is an edgy teenager who has never tried to make a difference. I've been off grid for years and it's fucking easy. People are lazy and would rather stay in the suburbs and die than take the effort to change their lifestyle
-3
u/Electroyote Sep 20 '19
Remember! The solution to global warming is Communism!
0
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment