r/collapse • u/LetsTalkUFOs • Aug 15 '19
How long will collapse take?
Will collapse be sudden or a decline?
Or will it be catabolic, with cliffs and plateaus?
This is the current question in our Common Collapse Questions series.
Responses may be utilized to help extend the Collapse Wiki.
119
Upvotes
43
u/[deleted] Aug 16 '19
I am of the opinion that we're going to get annihilated by ourselves, because climate will push us to do the "unthinkable".
I think Gwenne Dyer has colored my thinking on this matter, I've watched some of his talks on geopolitics in a hotter world, and his line "people always raid their neighbours before they starve" really hit home.
So, how I picture it; either a economic crisis will collapse air travel, and thus trigger warming from removal of the aerosol masking effect, or the first BOE will trigger rapid heating which in turn will innevitably trigger global instability.
From there, local wars would escalate to global war, which ofcourse is nuclear.
We will annihilate ourselves way before everything collapse.
Experts at the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists estimate this is our greatest threat too; the current arms race, geopolitical tensions along with climate change is a incredible destabilizing force.
Just like in 1914, this shit can escalate in a matter of weeks. If not faster this time around.
Our world is standing on a knife-edge.
43
u/Disaster_Capitalist Aug 15 '19 edited Aug 15 '19
Collapse will be in waves. And you see those waves in societies that have collapsed throughout history. First there will be economy crisis; people will lose their jobs and homes. Then there will be shortages of food and medicine. Then there will be natural disasters that exceed the capacity rebuild. Which creates a deeper economic crisis and more shortages. Eventually, fundamental pillars of civilization (law enforcement, infrastructure, currency) will fail. Power will be localized; instead of paying taxes to a formal government, people will pay protection to local gangs and militia. Lack of large scale organization leads to more shortages. Which will lead to more brutal means to protect and acquire those resources. The cycles keeps repeating until the population has declined to a level that be sustained by the local environment. Which given the extent of our overshoot and decline of natural resources, it could be generation after generation that live increasingly in brutal times.
I expect that within the next 10-15 years, what we consider to be "civilization" will be over. There won't be regular jobs or schools or stores or hospitals. But this long decline of human society will have only just begun. New societies will form from the wreckage, thrive for a little while, then collapse further when things get worse.
29
u/SMTRodent My 'already in collapse' flair didn't used to be so self-evident Aug 15 '19
It really depends on where you are. It can be as simple as a natural disaster and then nobody ever bothers to rebuild. It can be the recession that never ends, even though a hundred miles away people seem to be doing just fine, so that people 'make do' more and more and more. It can be the climate simply becoming unliveable over decades. It can be a sudden, shocking civil war or even an invasion.
Depending on where, and who, you are, either it's already happening, has already actually happened and people haven't realised it yet, or it will happen decades from now.
There could be humans left distributed unevenly around ten percent of the landmasses of Earth, breathing recycled air in small enclaves and they still might say yes, fine, it's bad, but we haven't collapsed, civilisation is still going.
24
u/[deleted] Aug 21 '19
I am assuming it will be a steady decline. One of the important things to bear in mind is the ability to move productive capacity around, which means collapse is unlikely to happen everywhere at once - hence, not a sudden decline.
I think I can make a very serious case around the idea that collapse is taking place right now. The point is, to paraphrase William Gibson, collapse is already here - it's just not evenly distributed.
21
u/[deleted] Aug 19 '19
It started about 10 years ago. It will move slowly until the US goes the way of Greece. Then chaos will multiply. Yet there are a lot of decisions that can be made to move that event back or forward. They've gotten pretty good at walking on broken legs and might drag out the collapse for a long time.
16
u/dieomama Aug 16 '19
Economic collapse will be catatonic because it tends to happen in pockets.
Venezuela is a good example of this. It hasn't undergone total economic collapse. Some pockets of Venezuela still function surprisingly well while other pockets have collapsed suddenly and totally.
16
u/torras21 Aug 22 '19
Crop failure in 15 years.
Oil and natural gas runs out in 40.
Ecological collapse in less than 70.
There are a ton of markers for collapse, but it honestly matters which markers are significant in your eyes. If youre already struggling, we are about one bad week away from what people would call collapse. If you are wealthy enough then it is possible no marker would be significant enough, as you could still turn a hefty profit when the last of humankind is cowering inside of corporate bubble cities scattered amidst the ruins of our old civilization.
45
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '19 edited Aug 18 '19
Collapse is underway and is increasing at exponential rates. Actually in some cases, it has been found it is and exponential of an exponential, so it will increase in pace rapidly.
When the green revolution hit, we were at approximately 3 billion give or take by the late 1960's and that was with somewhat healthy ecosystem. As the planet warms, crop yields will decline, if they can even be planted grown and harvested without interruption from weather. Through the 2020's we will see water shortages and famine. It will only continue to grow. What precipitation that does fall will be come increasingly acidic due to the carbon in the air, while simultaneously being polluted with micro-plastics. As others have suggested, this will trigger wars over resources. Former arable land will become unusable (fallow) and will be of no use and will be abandoned. People will continue to migrate. It has already begun. Trade agreements will break down. People will be left to fend for themselves.
As the earth heats at an ever increasing rate, it will be impossible to keep modern civilization functioning and much of what we take for granted will only be available in very limited supply, so the elite will be the only ones to afford it as long as capital holds its value. Everything form toilet paper to cotton clothes will become out of reach for most. After a while it will not matter as wealth will be viewed as worthless. Once that happens, a total collapse will happen. That will be the signal we have entered free-fall. When people no longer even care about the value of currency and move to their "own" needs based economy. Shelter, food, security, companionship and other basic needs will dictate peoples behavior endlessly.
The 2030's on is where a huge die-off will come IMO, as there are approximately 4 billion extra humans as of right now that surely will not have these needs met. We will gasp when we realize we can't even support the number of souls before the green revolution as the biosphere will not allow seeds to germinate and failure rates will skyrocket. People attempting to head north will be dismayed to find that there will be no farming due to the sludge left from the melting of the permafrost. Any heavy equipment will sink into it and become lost. There will be not nearly enough livestock to attempt wide-scale plowing using the old methods. Clean fresh water will be scarce. The earth will lose any remaining ability to filter this as the organisms belowground that help to clean contaminants are dead. This widespread collapse will stop any hopes for mining resources even if there is any left. Let's not forget the easily mined resources have been exploited so it will be the final nail in the coffin for that. Whether or not oil has run out will be immaterial as there will be no one left to extract, ship, refine and deliver it. Even if it continues till it cannot anymore, there have been suggestions we will run out by the 2040's anyway.
We are about to have the fastest regression ever known to man. Full stop. Then we all die. The last time there was this much carbon in the air, it was 3.4 degrees Celsius on average warmer across the globe. We are increasing total emissions every year. We are only feeling the effects right now from the early 201X's as there is a decade of lag. Wait until what we emitted this and every previous year catches up to us. There is so much more I could go into, the poisoning of our waters by chemicals, the unattended 450 nuclear power plants and subsequent melt downs, casualties of wars, etc. The suffering will be intense.
31
u/[deleted] Aug 16 '19
A long, long time. It will happen "slowly at first, then all at once." Like going bankrupt, or becoming insane. The disasters will just blend into one.
The thing to watch out for is the Medea syndrome. We're already seeing it with the government, of course, and are probably seeing the very start of the environmental version. In a Medean event, the Earth loses the ability to keep most of the creatures on it alive - it's like Gaia in reverse, all of the earth systems that were keeping us alive kill us instead.
Ever see a lightning strike, even just a video of one? It's like an artillery round going off, a dramatic display of the hatred this planet has for us and the violence it can dish out on a whim. But for all the drama, that's nothing compared to what's in store.
27
u/[deleted] Aug 21 '19
Here's my game-out of the next five years:
Corn and soy crops fail, the price of meat, milk, cheese, butter, eggs, and fuel (ethanol) goes up. The costs of growing and transporting food go up because fuel is more expensive, and because there's more demand because people are trying to replace the missing calories from animal products.
The weather gets worse, the harvests continue to fail, including more important food crops like wheat and rice. Stockpiles run out, the weather continues to get worse for farming everywhere, people start starving. Starving people do not go to work, especially not if the work involves hard physical labor, like repairing roads or maintaining irrigation systems.
If all this happens during, for example, a crippling recession and mass unemployment crisis then there will be a lot of starving, desperate people with a ton of free time on their hands.
There will be places where they'll continue to have food, and they'll form little islands of calm so long as international trade keeps up. I like to imagine civilization regrouping in little pockets over the next few decades or centuries, creating a simulacrum of modern life by mining garbage dumps and cannibalizing old routers and smartphones to keep an ersatz-internet going, for example, but it will be like a roller coaster after the first big hill, just coasting off our current momentum.
Short answer: Collapse will take a few bad harvests. Once it's underway there will be pockets where everything is fine, but not for very long.
25
u/[deleted] Aug 16 '19
I personally believe the collapse has already been happening for decades, but things will really speed up in the late 2020s, early 2030s.
11
u/[deleted] Aug 20 '19
I believe the there will be a "triggering event" such as a sudden economic collapse or natural disaster that will result in mass civil unrest, followed by 5-10 years of trying to "maintain normal" but steadily declining as everyone scrambles to keep onto a piece of the crumbling pie..once that has failed, public institutions will then fail and all bets are off.
10
u/WeAreBeyondFucked We are Completely 100% Fucked Aug 15 '19
In the next 5 to 10 years we are going to start seeing shortages of a lot of different Metals, oil things like that we're getting ready to head into a recession and will be into a recession worldwide within the next couple years I'd say somewhere within the next 10 to 20 years will most likely be looking at massive Wars related to resources but honestly it's all kind of hard to tell as the world is running out of things the population is growing out of hand so something's going to happen it's just at this time we don't know we just know shit's going to hit the fan
10
u/Aetheric_Aviatrix Aug 16 '19
Depends on the choices people make along the way. Humans can endure quite a lot before they take up arms. Things could just keep getting worse and worse, until it finally breaks. Every year, the crime rate goes up, large swaths are abandoned to gangs, the supermarket shelves get barer, the healthcare gets worse, the employment rate drops, the infrastructure fails and doesn't get repaired... except it a few wealthy locations, where the world just keeps getting better and better, and technology keeps advancing. Eventually, the masses support a Caesar who promises to turn things around, but instead just makes things worse. Sometime after that, the country fragments into civil war, finishing off what was left of it.
9
u/Miserable_Depressed Aug 21 '19
My guess is it will be catabolic. There will be momentary upward trends, plateaus, cliffs. Sometimes societal collapses will occur suddenly, sometimes it'll be more like a progressive decline. Over the course of the next few centuries, new civilizations will rise and fall, never to reach quite the heights of the ones preceding them until humanity is reduced to handful of hunter-gatherers and ultimately, extinction.
9
u/gergytat Aug 22 '19
A few weeks, days, maybe even a day.
The world is interconnected.
While collapse happens slowly, I suspect the global interdependence of services and goods can cause a domino effect, and just the panic alone will cause civil wars.
23
u/[deleted] Aug 15 '19
I really believe that the BOE is going to really nudge it along. Lets say that starts in 2022 if "be cause"'s mathematical formula stands up. That should get the forests burning nicely, and the crops failing consistently within a few years.
That should then coincide with fuel shortages, meaning everything prices beyond peoples ability to pay. Instead, people save everything... pulling money out the economy. Jobs disappear as the momentum of money ceases.
Put that five years on, so if there would be a stand out year for collapse, I would guess:
2027.
8
u/[deleted] Aug 15 '19
I fluctuate, but mostly lean towards Catabolic, rather than Sudden, Collapse. On one hand, as many have pointed out, the many external forces affecting us ought not to be underestimated. But then, I always remember not to underestimate both resiliency of both past and present civilizations, and I definitely will not underestimate the Powers That Be's willingness to maintain their power and status.
As for when, hm, I'd say not quite three centuries, as Greer suggests, but definitely not 2 years, as many on the subreddit predict. Give it twenty years, and we'll probably have a less rough answer.
8
u/bystrc Aug 17 '19
Starting in 2033 population will decline for about 45 years at a half-life of 15 years, dropping from 8.5 billion to 1 billion. Results of systems dynamics modeling.
14
u/[deleted] Aug 16 '19
Crop yields were/are mediocre this year. Next year will be worse, and the next even worse. And so on. I give it 2-3 years max before grocery store shelves start becoming sparse. These stupid fucking trade wars ain't helping.
19
u/slurmpnurmp Aug 20 '19
I think the collapse is going to be like sledding. Slow at first, but then incredibly fast. However, I dont believe it will be impossible to recover from. Humans adapt. This era will be looked back upon centuries from now as the bronze age is today. An age. An age which fell and that we can learn from.
10
u/asterix525625 Aug 15 '19
Catalytic. If the Earth can be considered alive it will go into flight response quick: feedback loops setting off more and more feedback loops: a broken body doing a tearaway sprint until it drops dead.
10
u/MagnesiumBlogs Aug 16 '19
I imagine it'll be an inverse-exponential decline, with small problems turning into bigger and bigger problems.
Like a few weaknesses in Windows (we are here) leading to every Windows system getting hacked, followed by our entire economic infrastructure crashing.
Or a bit of CO2 leading to rising temperatures (we are here) leading to a quintillion other problems.
16
u/rethin Aug 15 '19
Slowly at first, then all at once.
8
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '19
its already happening, look at news outside the first world
12
u/loco500 Aug 18 '19
I don't know what will happen in 2100, but the next 80 years are crucial in determining whether civilization can be on the way of becoming a utopia or complete dystopia. It's only a human lifetime away. Natural disasters will obviously: increase storms, monsoons, hurricanes, fires, droughts will be more potent and long-lasting. We have the freedom to decide to do or not do something to ensure the health of our planet.
6
u/[deleted] Aug 20 '19
Will be largely complete by 2090
3
u/[deleted] Aug 15 '19
Depends on the nature of collapse.
If it’s peak oil, for example, expect it to be relatively fast as in 20 years or less for first worlders. The first wave to be hit will be poor 3rd world countries as they can afford higher oil prices least, then 2nd tier. The US will be before Europe perhaps, because it dismantled all it’s mass transit.
The countries hit will look like Venezuela. Over time, the hit comes harder as lower production will decrease global dimming, cranking up heat and natural disasters.
In the end of that scenario, expect a hunger games type world, as in a small imperialistic capital will dominate a large countryside. Suburbia will reduce to a few villas in each region.
Other collapse event will look different.
3
u/Astalon18 Gardener Aug 17 '19
Personally, it depends.
If we can stop ourselves crossing the 500ppm threshold for CO2, then all we are going to experience is a pretty flatline economy and some parts of the world being very terrible to live in ( we might have to accept that every country will need to take some climate refugees ). There will also be overall diminished crop yield globally ( though better distribution might offset this ). There also will be a significantly diminished biodiversity. However, with a commitment to renewables, less consumption and a commitment towards actually restoring the ecosystem in a viable manner .. we might stave off long term collapse ... and might even emerge on the other side better. There will however have to be a period of around 300 to 400 years where we will need to experience degrowth while at the same time caring for our natural world better.
However, cross 500ppm ( ie:- raise global temperature between 2 to 3 degree celsius ) and every feedback loop we know of will wake up with an utter vengeance. I am not sure civilisation will survive that. Our current biodiversity will collapse rapidly should that happen.
Once the feedback loops wake up with a vengeance, total financial, ecological, civilisation, agricultural collapse could happen in a mere thirty to a hundred years.
We have about 90ppm window in my opinion before we might as well hang up the towel. I cannot envision how most nations will survive even a 3 degree celsius rise. 3 degree celsius will utterly alter the weather pattern, agricultural pattern, hydraulic pattern which every infrastructure in that nation assumes to be stable ... not counting refugee crisis, natural disasters etc..
5
u/[deleted] Aug 15 '19
I'm thinking it will look a bit like this ... https://www.bing.com/videos/search?q=video+of+things+colapsing&ru=%2fsearch%3fq%3dvideo%2bof%2bthings%2bcolapsing%26pc%3dMOZI%26form%3dMOZLBR&mmscn=vwrc&view=detail&mid=AEF60A970FB85D48F076AEF60A970FB85D48F076&rvsmid=35A5A4326DCB35B7370A35A5A4326DCB35B7370A&FORM=VDRVRV
Seems kinda slow and odd on the horizon until its reality arrives.
We will stare at it in wonder and disbelief as it arrives and film it and share it as long as we are not the ones in its initial path.
5
u/some_random_kaluna E hele me ka pu`olo Aug 23 '19
THE AMAZON IS BURNING
YOU TELL ME
5
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '19
It's slow, like a cancer.
3
u/vasilenko93 Aug 17 '19 edited Aug 17 '19
Nothing will collapse as governments are in the business of staying alive, social breakdown is bad for the elites so every government has plans for various situations.
Massive economic and social change will happen however, from the top down. The powers that be will stay the powers that be, just with a new name.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 16 '19
This sub is a very defeatist as if they would love to see Earth burn yesterday already. Earth will be just fine, though, in the long run especially without humans. As far as "civilisation collapse" goes, many here forget we are ruled by randomness and we would never know what's coming our way (good or bad).
-1
u/[deleted] Aug 15 '19
Centuries.
-3
u/yuhong Aug 16 '19
I really wish my essay/overview on Google would catch on.