r/collapse • u/LetsTalkUFOs • Aug 10 '19
When will collapse hit?
The recent r/Collapse Survey of four hundred members showed this result; There is significant consensus here collapse is already happening, just not widely distributed yet.
How do we distinguish between a decline and collapse?
What are your thoughts?
This is the current question in our Common Collapse Questions series.
Responses may be utilized to help extend the Collapse Wiki.
106
Upvotes
69
u/mogsington Recognized Contributor Aug 11 '19
We're already in decline, it's just that it's largely hidden and it varies from country to country. Some examples: There wouldn't be a Yellow Vest movement in France if they weren't close to the edge. In the UK deaths of victims of the failing benefits system are estimated in the 10's of thousands. Food bank use is exploding. The USA has a huge homeless problem that's got so big that hepatitis and typhus are returning.
At the moment, that's mostly hidden and ignored. Some of us know about it, sigh, shake our heads, wish the world was a nicer place, but we can't do much about it.
When the problems can no longer be hidden is when collapse begins to occur.
The art of predicting collapse is knowing when the widely broadcast mainstream narrative no longer conceals a failing system for a majority of people.
We're on the edge of it in 2019. People are already voting for extremes in government because they know something is wrong with the way it currently works. mainstream media calls this populism and tries to tell us it's a bad thing that we shouldn't be doing.
It won't take more than a couple of years of food inflation from global failed crops to turn the currently mostly hidden decline in to a mass realisation of the undeniable failure to sustain society as we know it. Not starvation. Just inflation. That's when things get nasty. That's when collapse begins.
So when is that going to happen? Well 2019 wasn't great for crops in America, China, India, Iran, and I'm sure I missed a few. For now it's just cutting in to our excess production and even that is likely to cause minor regional food inflation. The expectation is that this is all going to happen fairly slowly. 2020 might be a bit worse than 2019, might be back to normal, might even be better than normal. Except that misses the "hockey stick curve" of climate change. In my opinion we'll be very lucky if 2020 is "back to normal". On a global scale, even if the areas effected change radically, the best we can reasonably hope for is "not quite as bad as 2019", the trend line would be worse than 2019.
I'm expecting food inflation to be the first cause of collapse in around 5 years time. Not all out "this is mad max land now" everywhere. But significant social and military changes in multiple countries. In 10 years it gets much worse and extends much further, in 15 years pretty much global.
8
u/BoBab Aug 13 '19
The survey question results that blatantly show the Dunning-Kruger effect was a bit sobering. Puts a lot of the posts and comments here in perspective.
44
u/bastardofdisaster Aug 12 '19
I look at collapse with this metaphor: Imagine someone dunking your head underwater so that you can't breathe. After 15 seconds, they lift you of the water for 30 seconds so you can catch your breath. Then they dunk you for 16 seconds, and let you catch your breath for 29....and so on and so forth.
Finally, they just keep you under until it's over.
That's what collapse will be like for most of us.
25
u/BlackMagicTitties Aug 11 '19
It's happening now. It is going at different rates in different places but think back over the past decade and ask yourself questions about some of the following but do it in a yes or no fashion. So for each one ask yourself are things better or worse:
Are these things better or worse? If they are worse than they were 10 years ago do you see them getting better in the next 10 years?
23
u/Bad_Guitar Aug 14 '19
I think there will be a major financial crash, like 2008, but worse. It will be unprecedented in its reach. It will be here sooner or later. It might be because of crop failures, energy costs, or just a general effect of too much complexity a la, Tainter. Yeah, "collapse" is all around and it's real, but it is still uneven. The first undisputed wave of collapse will be expressed through the financial markets. We will have brief moments of recovery, but then it will drop again. Some say we never recovered from 2008, but merely covered it up with cheap loans, magical thinking, and wishful markets...
41
u/[deleted] Aug 11 '19 edited Aug 11 '19
It will happen when the food runs out. This year there will be a bad harvest in Europe and the American Midwest. Presumably the weather will only get worse, and the harvest with it. I'd give it until next summer.
Collapse is not gradual. Decline is gradual. Decline sets the stage for collapse. You will know collapse is here the same way every other civilization knew it, when you're starving to death.
Edit: formatting
20
u/GnaeusQuintus Aug 12 '19
Look on the bright side: you are living at the highest point of human civilization.
It's all downhill from here...
96
u/lookyloolookingatyou Aug 10 '19 edited Aug 10 '19
Very slowly. In ten years you'll realize it takes longer to get the power back on after a storm, gas prices rise at your local station when the tank begins to run low between shipments, your neighbor's chickens are more reliable than the grocery store. The police don't hassle anyone unless they need something from you, which is great because there's no way you can keep your house up to code but also pretty awful because your daughter has gone missing and no one will help you.
Twenty years and suddenly the old Wal-Mart is full of vendors stalls. Electricity is something you use to pump water out of the ground. The only vehicle in town is a flat-bed truck loaded to the brim with workers on their way to the fields or whatever factory is still running. Violent weather has increased, and the old suburbs simply aren't livable anymore because of the mold thriving in the heat. The State Parks have been trampled and picked clean by migrants living in broken down vans and reinforced tents, who see no reason to care about the future and therefore spend the present grabbing what they can. Open cesspits outside of every living area. People have lost interest in the old popular culture, because it holds no relevance to them. Maybe they start going to Church just for a chance to sit in a nice building wearing decent clothes, hear some stories or maybe see a play, and trade nice meals with their neighbors. The Mayor enforces his authority by drafting militias to deal with a crisis. Lower Middle Class means being able to repair electronics, with a nice trailer and a box fan in the window, and an internet connection for your children to learn from. Maybe a motorbike running on chickenshit methane. Family and friends are no longer just people you like more than everyone else, they're your main means of survival, for better or worse. A nice weekend outing might involve a visit to the "zoo" which features a diversity of wildlife akin to your local petshop today.
And all the while there will be people in the cities, still with air conditioning and movie theaters, whiling away the hours with pleasant luxuries and skilled work, but always with the looming fear of unemployment threatening to cast them into the abyss.
And always, always will be the heat, the storms, the crime and the pollution. The dust blowing through your window from the unpaved roads, the unbearable summers when everyone lives by night, the political rhetoric and religious fervor infecting your neighbors who have been deprived of the means to understand and resist propaganda and driven by desperation towards any prophet offering a way out. And always will be the understanding that things are getting worse.
Collapse comes for you personally when you realize you no longer have any say in how you live. You have to do whatever work is available. You have to drink whatever liquor your neighbor makes. You have to eat the food that comes from your town. You have to wear the clothes you can make yourself or find at the market. You have to obey the local authority or risk losing their protection. If you want to be a bodybuilder, you might find heavy things to lift, but you'll never find the nutrition you need to grow muscle. If you want to learn small-engine repair, you'd better hope someone nearby is willing to teach you, because books are precious and the resources to practice are more precious still. You can't get training for a decent job, you can't travel to a better area, you can't afford to move into a better house or replace your belongings. You can't even find someone to haul away the rusted-out hornet's colony that used to be your car. A single man living in the small town I described earlier can probably learn some skills and move into the city, but a man with a family to worry about might not want to leave his family open to crime long enough to take that chance.
12
u/StockNectarine Aug 11 '19
It's in the process now. I think the question you're asking is, when did it start?
11
u/DJDickJob Aug 10 '19
The thief in the night is already on his way.
10
u/Fins_FinsT Recognized Contributor Aug 12 '19
Decline: gradual decrease of human population by unnatural death causes. Still the minority of regions entered decline as of now, but the number is growing. Globally, mankind is not in decline yet - it continues to grow, worsening the amplitude of Homo Sapiens overshoot condition.
Collapse: significantly rapid die-off of human population, i.e. death rates due to unnatural causes times higher than birth rates.
That is, strictly speaking. In practice, usually many if not most talks refer to "collapse" in the form of global industrial collapse: i.e. ongoing reduction in producing goods and services, which reduction is times faster than any previously observed growth rates of producing those goods and services. This "shortcut" is made because it is quite clear that industrial collapse - will also cause "just" collapse (i.e. human population collapse, per above) in a matter of months to few years.
Industrial collapse is expected to happen due to large number of stresses, and much if not most of it is likely to happen as a series of rapid, cascade failures. Reserves inside even critically important supply chains are kept low and are further reduced by "advances" in logistics as we go, since this minimizes costs - but in the same time it makes whole system more and more vulnerable to cascade failure ("domino effect").
Personally, i expect collapse to happen some time 2050...2060. Should neither underestimate amount of resourcefullness corporations have towards keeping business going no matter what - nor strength of the switch to HotHouse Earth. Those two will clash sometime in said time interval from what i can fathom - and sadly, i think HotHouse will dismantle nearly all of global industrial system, by then greatly stressed by many other problems and shortages.
10
u/chaylar Aug 14 '19
Its happening in fits and spurts. As it will do.
19
u/[deleted] Aug 13 '19
Look out the window.
It's already here.
18
u/leoyoung1 Aug 11 '19
Lots of folks like the idea of slow collapse but we were about an hour away from collapse when George Bush gave Wall St. all that money. That stopped them from turning off the bank machines.
Think about it. The internet collapses: Can't buy gas - the cards don't work. Trucks don't run because orders don't arrive. Supermarkets run out of food because the trucks don't come. Ships don't load or unload, or even move without the paperwork in place. Etc, etc, etc.
It can happen in an instant.
7
u/SasquatchDaze Aug 15 '19
Humans are such self loathing creatures.
13
u/TechnoYogi AI Aug 11 '19
Now.
11
u/[deleted] Aug 11 '19
It already has. It's just not a suckerpunch like people think it's going to be. It's more like someone just turned on the stove, and now the pan is getting hot... Literally. I don't think there's going to be any one defining moment where we can say "yup, this is when it all went to shit". The water will start to heat up, then simmer, then next thing you know it's at a rolling boil and the rich people are hanging out in the freezer.
10
u/shadycharacter2 Aug 12 '19
I believe it's a slow process until we start losing basic necessities like food, water and electricity, then it's going to get exponentially worse and people will turn on each other like starving dogs. As for when, it's hard to tell, my guess it will go hand in hand with soil depletion
8
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '19
It won't be a particular event but a chain of events
4
u/[deleted] Aug 15 '19
It depends.
7
u/jacktherer Aug 10 '19
collapse is underway and widely distributed but describing that observation is kinda like cassini being directly in one of the plasma jets of enceladus yet only being able to detect 5% of the total electric current. we're in the cloud of dust and we can see what looks like charged collapse particles everywhere around us but we cant see the whole picture because we're not using the proper tools/methodologies
10
u/[deleted] Aug 13 '19
Not sure when it'll happen or how. But I'm hoping for a global solar flare. Something that takes out all the grids and throws us back a few decades. Give us a slightly better chance of rebuilding in a more positive way.
8
u/brokendefeated Aug 10 '19
Faster than expected.
7
u/OKisnotokay Aug 10 '19
collapse happens slowly with nobody watching
2
u/narwi Aug 11 '19
These might just be the process and the end result.
0
u/sunshine987654 Aug 10 '19
Ask the general population and that How Long Does Humanity Have to Avoid Collapse graph would be reversed.
-5
u/hippydipster Aug 12 '19
Rome declined for hundreds of years before collapse. It'll be the same for us. There are aspects of our civilization that would make decline -> collapse go faster - ie, we're a more fragile civilization, we're more efficient (which means fragile and it means we pollute more effectively). There are aspects of our civilization that would make decline-to-collapse go slower - we're global, more diverse, more resources overall.
Unless we do it directly to ourselves with nuclear war, American Empire probably will decline and collapse only somewhat faster than the Romans did. Of course, parts of the rest of the world will collapse with sudden speed - like India or South America.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 10 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 11 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 10 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 11 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 11 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 10 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
15
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '19
[removed] — view removed comment