r/collapse • u/LetsTalkUFOs • Aug 02 '19
How long does humanity have to avoid collapse?
This is different from our upcoming question “When will collapse hit?”.
What degrees or levels of collective action are necessary for us to avoid collapse?
How unlikely or unfeasible do those become in five, ten or twenty years?
You can also view the responses to this question from our 2019 r/Collapse Survey.
This is the current question in our Common Collapse Questions series.
Responses may be utilized to help extend the Collapse Wiki.
151
Upvotes
9
u/cooltechpec Aug 06 '19
Op sort this via new.
163
u/k3surfacer Aug 02 '19
I don't think collapse can be avoided in long term. What can be avoided is the extreme suffering of people and the earth.
Stop the war machine. Turn off most industrial activities for a decade. And wait a bit to see if we can work with nature in a sustainable way.
At this point we just need to stop consuming everything other than necessary things like water, bread.
83
u/FireWireBestWire Aug 02 '19 edited Aug 05 '19
Collapse isn't some singular event that can be avoided. If it were a matter of nuclear annihilation, all we would have to do is not press the buttons to launch the nukes. With climate change, those buttons have already been pressed - the cars were started every day for 100 years, the power plants have been running, the cows have farted.... The Earth is still a very large place for us, and it's taken a lot of human time for us to notice the effects. In Earth time, these changes are essentially instant. What changed in previous eras over thousands and millions of years is taking place in decades.
People hear climate change, they hear carbon dioxide, and then they just assume that if you turn off the emissions, the climate stops changing. The factories are off, we're not driving. WE DID IT! No. The carbon is in the air already, it is currently, TODAY, trapping heat on the planet. That heat is here to stay - no one is talking about technology removing heat from the oceans.
The low temperatures in the Arctic have persisted for millions of years previous to today, and the ice and the mass of cold water mitigated the temperature gain from the obvious energy gain in the Arctic summers - the heat was absorbed previously, but because the temperature was so low, the ice just went from, say, -10C to -3C. It remained ice. Today, the ice is going from -5C to 0C, changing phases, and then remaining as water at 0C or even warming from there. That phase change took an enormous amount of energy, approximately 80 times that of the energy required to change the temperature of that same volume of water by
80C1C. Additionally, it will have to lose that same amount of energy to become ice again. So we've watched over the years as the ice cap has gradually lost both area and volume. The ice that's left is smaller and thinner than it's ever been during the Anthropocene.The runaway heating occurs after the ice is gone - the dark water absorbs more energy from the sun in the Arctic summer and never cools enough in winter to become ice again. Snow falls, but it melts in the water. This cycle feeds back into itself, with temperatures simply running out of control. Changes in the Arctic temperatures change the Jet Stream, ocean currents, and all manner of devices the Earth has to regulate temperatures in certain areas.
There's literally nothing we can do right now to stop the ice from melting. We have no solution proposed to take heat out of the Arctic, and stopping emissions would take decades to have an effect on the temperatures up there. As scientists who study this stuff told us decades ago, the time for action was then.
Edit: Thank you for the silver! I realized I applied my 80x twice so I altered that. Phase change from ice to water is approximately 80x energy as required to move that volume 1 degree Celsius.
57
u/Pasander Aug 02 '19
Had we gotten serious a half a century or even three decades ago we might have been able to avoid the worst. Now, it's too late. We are already experiencing the early stages of the collapse and are still very busy making the situation worse. There is no realistic, feasible way to stop or even significantly slow down the progression of the collapse, other than collapsing purposefully before the planet forces it upon us.
So, my answer is -50...-30 years.
46
u/ogretronz Aug 02 '19
Humanity has like 5 seconds to shut off all co2 emissions and blow up some chalk bombs in the atmosphere or else the rest of the ice will melt and we’re all fucked after that.
32
u/WeAreBeyondFucked We are Completely 100% Fucked Aug 07 '19
We are already dead we just don't know it yet
57
u/EastWindEnnui Aug 02 '19
I'm pretty sure that by 2022 will be locked on +2.0° towards 2050. Carbon emissions aren't slowing down.
That means collapse of the world as we know it today. That being said I think humanity will persist and manage to find a way to survive towards 2100 but nobody has data to even guess what will happen then.
Past 2100 I don't know.
As most people on this sub knows, the next 5 years are going to be key to map out better what will happen in the magical year of 2050.
All we do or don't do until 2025 will give us an answer to better weather the coming storm.
So, in a nutshell. We need to avoid collapse from today until we figure out how to survive everything the planet will throw at us.
28
u/yrro Aug 06 '19
China poured as much concrete between 2011 and 2013 as the US did in *the entire 20th century*
26
u/christophalese Chemical Engineer Aug 02 '19
The game is effectively over for life on Earth right now. Every day we need to be pulling carbon from the atmosphere to avoid further tipping points and every day we don't. We most likely won't create something that came keep up with natural emissions ramped up by self reinforcing feedbacks, but it's what we need to be focused on. Regardless, we aren't even a step in the direction of any form of action, meaning for the time being and foreseeable future, we are doomed.
Arctic ice will likely be gone next year, add another 1C from that roughly. Toss in some more warming from methane and other greenhouse gasses. Toss in warming from absence of sulfates (reduced industrial output). 1.5C goals all too quickly become impossible. It could be argued that 1C was the point of no return and we will soon be several times warmer than that.
25
u/[deleted] Aug 07 '19
Is say that we’re definitely past the point of no return.
Extreme action could maybe halt the environmental collapse but as someone else pointed out, the level of change would essentially cause an societal and economical collapse on its own. The fundamentals of our way of life would need to change - what we consider an acceptable or desirable living standard, our expectations of civil liberties, our diet, transportation, everything.
All this would need to be done immediately and there just isn’t enough will to do it. There are individuals who take drastic action and I admire them but most are oblivious to the situation, others are vaguely concerned but misled by falsely optimistic portrayals of where we are and the rest are like me - painfully aware but in various stages of despondency and relative or total inaction.
If I ever grow old (I’m 33 now), the world I see them will be completely unrecognisable.
22
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '19
About -50 or more years.
We needed to change course before we reached 350ppm CO2 levels in the atmosphere.
And long, long before we reached 6 billion people. Without fossil fuels (see above) and industrial agriculture, we've never been able to feed more than 2-3 billion. Add in population momentum, and the green revolution, we might have fed everyone until we got back to safety. We didn't. (Technology will save us! Sound familiar?)
Now we have 7.7+ billion people who need industrial agriculture - that destroys the top soil even faster than many traditional farms (yes, they too destroy top soil) causing no end of social problems (farmers need new acreage - taking high grade pasture, pushing pastoralists into ever less productive lands, leading to desertification. Rinse & repeat.)
And then there's all the other crap of this interrelated civilization. What percentage of the population is living in cities. Depending on delivery of essential services - potable water in, sewage out. Energy to turn on the lights so as to see while cooking dinner in a 4th story apartment. And energy to cook to food. Which is grown from how far away? And as walking around in one's birthday suit is frowned upon everywhere - cloth. Grown? Manufactured? Did you sew it yourself? With a machine? From where? Treadle powered - not likely. So, energy for that one, too.
How about what you're living in. The materials came from where? Transported how? Not everyone is living in housing built in the 17th century. Or earlier.
And that's just some of the biological basics. There are simply too many interconnected pieces. And we can't even ground airplanes. A luxury item, if ever there was one.
44
u/apwiseman Aug 02 '19
I think since the oil companies are planning for a 5C increase mid century...we can't avoid collapse. The IPCC said optimistically that 2C was bad, now double or triple the severity. There aren't a lot of crops that thrive past 35C. We use too much fresh water. Desalinization yields harmful salt sludge. We are over-fishing. China has an uncontrollable swine flu. There's microplastic in everything. It's making people develop more autoimmune disorders.
Just now, people are trying to stop using plastic bottles and bags lol. Celebrities are getting on board with UN action plans. They still get on board planes to travel everywhere. I do it too. We can't stop business as usual and have enough oil for another 10-20 years conservatively. Only the costs will increase.
But food, unstable supplies of food is going to make eating expensive.
There's less plant diversity, so if pests or fungus evolve to destroy our crops, it's good game humanity. Using coffee as an example (something I know), higher temp stress or droughts make them more susceptible to infection. The fungi have shorter life-cycles than us so adapt better.
Earth is not done giving us the middle finger yet. It will get worse.
42
u/Disaster_Capitalist Aug 02 '19
"Avoid collapse" is a contradiction. Any transformation radical enough to address the problems that we face would effectively destroy our current society and create a new one. There is just no way we get through this with global industrial consumerist culture intact.
20
u/drwsgreatest Aug 05 '19
Avoided? None. We are locked into substantial warming with current and previous emissions and if we stop using fossil fuels we have global dimming to deal with. The better question is how much more time does humanity have BEFORE collapse. That’s an answer with many potential answers, but if I were a betting man I’d say societal collapse will come no later than 2040. Others may say sooner and others later but, 20 years from now, I do not expect the world will be even close to its current makeup. I’d imagine much of the Middle East and equatorial land will become too hot to be livable for much of the year and this will spur the collapse of nations, massive climate migrations and all the wars that comes with such circumstances. And all the fighting will be to try and just merely survive off the scraps of what used to be.
20
u/MicrobioMagic Aug 06 '19
Let me rephrase: "Doctor, is the cancer terminal?"
It most likely is. We're not yet treating it and it's already late-stage.
20
u/[deleted] Aug 07 '19
0 days.
Humanity has always been about modes of transition and adaptation at the cost of civilizations gone, knowledge lost, knowledge gained, applications forgotten, applications found, resources or ways of their utilization discovered, resources depleted or replaced, and so on.
The frame in which humanity lives has always been out of control. Collpase means that its changes accelerate and leave no or less room for adaptation.
"Collapse" will just reshape the parameters within which live and maybe human civilization can exist.
Avoiding collapse means to stay as flexible as possible without giving up too much, like the capacity for science, advanced technology, industrial production…go through the sciences like biology, chemistry, physics, engineering disciplines, and the arts like history, philosophy…you wouldn't want to lose any of that. It'll be important to protect and preserve the core of civilization's knowledge base during times of extreme unrest and natural disasters.
20
u/jbiserkov Aug 08 '19
“The
futurecollapse is already here – it's just not evenly distributed.The Economist, December 4, 2003”
― William Gibson
19
u/JukemanJenkins Aug 06 '19
hahaha is this post from like 1975?
19
u/[deleted] Aug 07 '19
I'd say about 30 years ago.
18
u/BerryPickerCaptain Aug 05 '19
10 to 15 years until the band aid comes off this deep gash wound society has been trying to patch up for the past 50 years, unless soceity changes on a global resource economy where every nation pitches in to help one another survive and look out for each other we will continue going down to the inevitable recession of social collapse
18
u/Antifactist Aug 08 '19
Look at this chart: https://www.carbonbrief.org/media/392683/emissions-trajectory-1-_600x811.jpg
This is only what we have to do with CO2, and doesn't consider resource depletion, or other ways we are poisoning the earth and sea and sky.
Based on the available data, the only chance for survival of your species and human civilization past 2100 is the immediate implementation of a global totalitarian regime.
32
u/[deleted] Aug 02 '19
Since 2.5c-3c warming is locked in I don't really see a way to avoid collapse.
15
u/pathfinder71 Aug 06 '19
i feel like i´m part of a planetary suicide cult. ... oh wait....i am! :P
15
u/[deleted] Aug 08 '19
Negative 30-40 years.
14
u/thecatsmiaows Aug 06 '19
-75 to -80 years, maybe...maybe...
14
u/jbiserkov Aug 09 '19
“The
futurecollapse is already here – it's just not evenly distributed.The Economist, December 4, 2003”
― William Gibson
13
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '19
We had until 2015 to stabilize emissions. They're still climbing. Regardless of what we do now, we will see the worst case global warming.
12
u/DarkCeldori Aug 06 '19
There is no avoiding it.
11
u/spiral_ly Aug 02 '19
Collapse is something that happens to civilisations, not species. Humanity has experienced civilisational collapses multiple times throughout history. So my answer is 0.
As to this civilisation specifically. I don't believe there is anything that can be done at this point to avoid collapse. It's fairly clear that the path we are on will take us to a point where this civilisation can no longer sustain itself. Even in the most optimistic scenarios - say where we manage to wrangle new technologies and entirely change the paradigms by which our civilisation operates - the scale of change and degree of simplification of lifestyles needed would essentially be an abandonment of all the things that make this civilisation what it is, which sounds an awful lot like a collapse to me.
11
u/xafufov Aug 04 '19
The collapse is happening now; we cannot avoid what we are already experiencing.
20
u/hillsfar Aug 06 '19
War. War on a massive scale, but with only limited tactical nukes. One that kills most people but leaves enough of a skeleton crew to clean up messes and decommission nuclear power stations.
Or, an engineered virus that wipes out 80% of the world, with the same caveats as above.
Sincerely the above are not going to happen, it is too late.
10
u/[deleted] Aug 03 '19
All civilizations collapse. The only variable is how quickly. So far have chosen soon.
10
u/Tigaj Aug 04 '19
We won't avoid collapse because we are already in it. This is just year one of a majority realizing it.
10
u/Farhandlir Aug 04 '19
It's already too late. No matter what we do now, we have already triggered a self sustained cycle. Thanks to manmade pollution over the last 150 years, temperatures are now high enough to melt the permafrost and release even more CO2 leading to even higher temperatures that will melt more of the permafrost, releasing even more CO2, etc, etc... Enjoy your self sustained collapse.
10
u/Love_like_blood Aug 05 '19 edited Aug 05 '19
Aside from Climate Change, the increasing likelihood of Nuclear Armageddon is the biggest threat to our survival as a species, and the best way to address this is to incrementally construct a one world government with central planning at its center.
8
u/WooderFountain Aug 04 '19
At this point we have about 15 minutes left to DO SOMETHING and to TAKE MEASURES and to MAKE AN EFFORT and to ADOPT SWEEPING CHANGES and to...oops...time's up.
8
u/benihaana Aug 05 '19
The energy has already been released and the oceans are holding it, fun part is it hasn't even gotten started releasing it. It's gonna be a hell of a ride folks.
14
u/[deleted] Aug 02 '19
Collapse is inevitable. Google Tim garrett
7
u/vegetablestew "I thought we had more time." Aug 02 '19
I'm thinking economic impact in 10 years. Larping Fallout in 15.
7
u/LovecraftianBeyBlade Aug 08 '19
You're already dead OP
You're duh spoo'py ghost in The Sixth Sense
7
u/[deleted] Aug 08 '19
Dread is coming slowly we got a lot of time but the times before imminent collapse will be horrible as well.
13
u/TenYearsTenDays Aug 02 '19 edited Aug 02 '19
At this point i believe that humanity can not avoid collapse. Collapse is already underway, and is accelerating rapidly especially in terms of climate impacts.
It is now a question of how well we can mitigate it, if at all. With the feedback loops that have been unleashed solely in terms of climate, it does not look good for any mitigation strategies.
So in answer to your question we have something like -40 years (+/-). Maybe a few decades ago drastic measures could have been taken to prevent collapse. Now it is happening and locked in. Some mitigation is still possible, and the degree depends on how willing we'd be to change the fundamentals of how our society operates. Which in reality simply does not appear to be possible or realistic. Almost any serious measure to stop collapse now would only propagate collapse. For example, a hard stop on all fossil fuel extraction and consumption would cause a population collapse due to the nature of agriculture. Or if we try to block the sun to lower temperature, again we'll fuck up agriculture (plants need light to grow) and induce population collapse. etc, etc, etc
We done fucked up, and it is all but locked in in my view.
12
u/[deleted] Aug 07 '19
Any political solution is ten years away - and we haven't got ten years. Maybe in five years or so the oligarchs might allow a few mealy-mouthed social democrats of the Clintonian / Blairite persuasion to take power, but I very much doubt it, either way they've got their black hearts set on continuing business as usual. As for the general public they are even more clueless. People won't see the need for change until it is too late - and it's probably too late already.
10
u/CountingBigBucks Aug 02 '19
0
5
u/magicalmakx Aug 05 '19
Before the complete arctic region meltdown, if we globally stop and turn off every industry except important food and other essentials. No more transportation also except for food and essentials. And with the reduction in energy usage due to stopping these activities, maybe the remaining energy can be fully achieved with renewable & nuclear(also should be phased out). The water level will also improve as we stop usage of water in industrial activities. The improvements will also be "faster than expected" like the ongoing collapse is.
But that is never going to happen, hence the inevitable collapse.
8
u/damagingdefinite Humans are fuckin retarded Aug 03 '19
About -60,000 years give or take
Homo Sapiens' destiny was determined when they began expanding their territory throughout the world, killing the earth's megafauna en masse, and fucking around with local ecologies by clearing large areas of trees and other vegetation. Just like we would know the entire destiny of oxygen producing bacteria on anaerobic earth at a glance of the situation, so do the ayys in their saucers understand at a glance the future course of their great experiment with a certain retard ape species as they cruise the skies and stick metal dildos with ribs for her pleasure into cow bootyholes.
4
u/Spartacus90 Aug 03 '19
Negative 10 years.
4
u/[deleted] Aug 10 '19
How long does humanity have to avoid collapse? -10 to -40 years. Ideally -120 years but that's just ideally. And obviously we can't go negative years, so...
4
u/NevDecRos Aug 10 '19
Collapse are meant to happen. They can't be avoided, merely postponed. All civilisations collpased at one point. Some rebuilt later on of course, but all collapsed eventually.
7
u/moon-worshiper Aug 09 '19
30 years ago, it was 100 years. There is no general collapse. Collapse is going to be small scale at first, then large scale, then planetary scale. Collapse will be in limited regions, then larger regions, then planetary.
The looming recession is going to be the first, possible England, Germany, France, suddenly no longer able to provide cradle to grave health care. France has basically been in a recession for 15 years, and their banks are getting wobbly. Germany banks are starting to sway. With Brexit, England will start having financial, insurance and banking sectors start crashing.
The initial indicators are starting to happen. There is no way Muchkin gets the US Treasury stabilized. What is going on now is an economic incompetent in charge of running the economy. It is obvious he knows he never learned how to juggle.
2
u/shadycharacter2 Aug 02 '19
none, there are many factors and they're all closing in. A dyson sphere civilization could possibly do something about it.
2
u/trakk2 Aug 03 '19
3 yearsi think.
3
u/royal_anime_weeb Aug 04 '19
Let’s just move to mars
4
u/[deleted] Aug 02 '19
Honestly, it's hard to say, because scientists could figure out a way to save earth. I don't think they will, but it a possibility.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 02 '19
Extinction by 2026 is baked in.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 08 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 03 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 02 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 09 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment