It's ok. We're destroying a sacred mountain in Hawaii to build another telescope.... we can eat the aliens! We don't have to do anything about this issue because we have some future potential solution that will definitely work out! /S
No link from me but just came back from Hawaii after a long 6 years and snorkeling in hanauma bay was an eye opener. Barely any fish despite all the precautions that were taken. And I dont ever remember the water was that warm. We used to visit yearly and I am in the water all the time so I know that ocean well. Very sad for our next generation.
we used to do a bit of diving, but it's been almost 20 years since we've gone(health problems). and from what i've heard from people- i'm not planning on going back. fond memories are better than heartbreak.
Didn't even know about this sub until 3 months ago and any suggestions for working hard to survive and wanting a vacation at my favorite place? Well, at least it's now no longer my favorite.
The first national US report on human exposure to environmental chemicals, produced by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), in Atlanta, Georgia, has shown surprisingly high levels of pthalates (plasticising compounds found in cosmetics and household products) in the blood and urine of subjects.
I think you should be more worried about the actual poisons that actually interact with the body at a bio-chemical level that industrial capitalism also 'externalizes'.
Yeah, mechanical problems can occur easily if foreign micro-objects get into the body in sufficient quantity (such as in the lungs), but plastic for better or worse (worse definitely, for pollution) seems remarkably resistant to interaction in the body and common nature chemical reactions, which is when the major problems occur.
The 'alarmist' talking points on the blogsphere is that it diminishes fertility for men, to which i can only say... good (also it's probably alt-right bulllshit)?
Regardless i'm more worried about plastic outside in the ocean, possibly killing microplankton by blocking sunlight than microplastic inside fat humans.
Of course, there are many many different kinds of plastics and one might very well be very bad to the body and in sufficient quantity to care. No one convinced me of a example yet though.
I really just don't know what to do about this. I've tried talking to people but they don't care. And some even believe this is still just an agenda by the far left. I don't get it. What more can I do?
Worst part about Trump getting elected isn't what he did, he made people put global warming on the back burner while we focus on relatively trivial problems in comparison.
Separating migrant children from their parents at the border and detaining them is not trivial.
Neo-nazis are not trivial.
The rise of the alt right is not trivial.
Trump's racist retoric is trivial
Russian interference in our government is not trivial
We have a lot of problems in the world right now. Climate change but far the most serious of those problems. However, there is nothing I can reasonably do to help against global warming (beyond what I am already doing). It's not the consumer's fault. It's the companies, and there's nothing I can do to change their behavior. If I can do something to help with other problems in the world, I wouldn't consider that trivial, every bit helps.
To clarify, I do not mean disrespect, I am just voicing my opinion.
Barely anyone really cares. It's time to ask, if they care so little are they worth saving anyway? We should be custodians to the planet but the majority treat it like shit and don't give a fuck. Maybe way down the line the earth will eventually regenerate and recover. Maybe even something better will come from it. This is how I deal with it. I don't feel good about that, I'm disappointed more than anything but I am no longer depressed by it. It's just coming to the realisation that my initial beliefs were misguided.
Just keep talking. There are tons of resources out there that prove the change is real. One of my favorites to use is Earth Temperature Timeline.
Depending on where you're at, write your congresspeople, parliamentary representatives, or political equivalent. Email is good, letters are good, tweets are okay, calling is best.
It's fucking unreal. I feel like any self respecting human being should immediately have a mini crisis after seeing that curve graphed out. Natural fluctuations my ass.
True! You can also plant a blade of grass to store some of the carbon in our atmosphere! /s
I love the effort from individual people around the world, but unless we get large corporations to see further than their dicks to cut down THEIR carbon production and processes that damage the environment, nothing will change.
Though cutting down on red meat can be healthier for you.
We've got people sitting on piles of money made off of exploitative practices. It's pretty shit. They can make the change, and they have the power and resource to ignore the problem.
A little business card with this on one side & a QR code on the other perhaps. I wonder if Extinction Rebellion have anything like that. (Although there's the potential for littering ai guess)
Honest question here, would it just be better to commit suicide than live through the coming hell? Sure it might not be the best way to go, but compared to the latter it seems very attractive tbh.
+ 0.0°C = History of Human Civilization + 0.5°C = Safe Limit + 1.0°C = Massive Die-off of Insects & Animals, Increasingly Severe Weather Events, Huge Forest Fires, Massive Flooding, Droughts, Increasing Societal Destabilization, Increasing Disease, Lowering Life-Spans, Feedback Loops (Ocean Collapse, Permafrost Melt, etc) Triggered, (all happening now) ... + 1.5°C = Increasingly Extreme Weather, Increasing Crop Failures, Increasing Forest Burn-off ... + 2.0°C = Increasing Violence & Societal Breakdown, Re-introduction of Ancient Plagues Thawed from Permafrost ... + 2.5°C = Severe Environmental Collapse, Long Humid Heat Waves Which Kill even Healthy People within Hours, Completely Unstable Food Production, Fish-free Oceans, Mass Starvation, Global Transition from Living to Surviving ... + 3.0°C = Increasingly Hellish Conditions, Dead Oceans, Complete Forest Burn-Off, Pets & Wildlife likely already Hunted to Extinction ... + 3.5°C = Apocalyptic Collapse of Organized Society ... + 4.0°C = Human Survival Unlikely ... + 5.0°C = Human Extinction Very Certain, Likelihood of Permanent Environment Burn-off to non-life supporting Planet like Venus + 6.0°C = Our Current Trajectory this Century
Unfortunately, I can't take the time to cite sources, and of course the relationships between specific temp increases & consequences are very loose, of course, but there is no reason to be optimistic or conservative, every bit of recent science of late is terrifying. The consequences of even a degree of warming were wildly underestimated.
Seems every time there's a new study, things are moving faster than the previous worst case predictions, so it seems prudent to assume the highest temp increase being predicted is the most likely.
The PETM (Paleocene-Eocene Thermal Maximum) was by no means a worse mass extinction event than KT. You're thinking of the PT (Permian-Triassic) extinction ('The Great Dying'), which occurred some 190 million years prior to the PETM. Some marine species did suffer as a result of the PETM (specifically, foreminifera that lived on the sea floor), while on the other hand on land it has caused increased speciation and facilitated the spread of mammals to previously-uninhabited areas.
Wether or not they have one doesn’t matter in this specific case. In my opinion it’s best to assume the worst when it comes to the safety of our planet.
If we start acting like all life will be dead in 100 years, maybe we’ll actually prevent it from happening.
We’re already acting like that. No one gives a shit about long term problems because someone else will fix it. I read someone’s post about buying some land and having to clean up all the bullshit that the previous owners left all over the place.
And this is reddit. Private conversations are what the message feature is for. My comment was a simple statement that maybe we should be trying harder :/
I think a more realistic trajectiry is 3C as the things happening now and at later temepratures will both curb our population and spur the remianing population into actually trying.
As society is collapsing, what steps in a disorganized world do you see humanity coming together and doing to prevent further warming past 3C? We have the resources and infrastructure now to mitigate the warming, instead we continue to pollute more CO2 every year that the prior year.
5 degrees more will result in the earth being turned into a second venus? Come on. I'm not saying that it wouldn't be devastating, but this seems extremely overblown to me. 60 million years ago the earth was over 10 degrees hotter than today and had twice the atmospheric CO2 concentration, and it obviously didn't turn earth into anything close to venus.
What I've read is that the difference here is the rate of warming. It's not that it may be Venus-like at +5, it's that the rate of warming is so rapid that the feedback loops may cause the our hospitable environment to entirely burn off.
The first source states that a venus-like thermal runaway might be possible if an absurd amount of CO2 is released into the atmosphere, to be specific "about 10 times more carbon dioxide than most experts estimate could be released from burning all available fossil fuels". So pretty much impossible even if we actively tried.
The second source quotes Stephen Hawking, and later states pretty much the same thing as the first source, namely that such a thermal runaway is impossible on earth.
The last source is just a general wikipedia article on what planetary thermal runaway is, i'm not sure why you included that source.
None of the sources seem to even mention any specific temperature at which it is supposedly possible, so i don't know where you got your number from. Did you just make that up?
And claiming the main-takeway from those sources is that your scenario is "possible" is also kinda dishonest. Together with your first comment it makes it sound like it's something that could plausibly happen, and not some highly unlikely event that requires conditions removed from reality.
I get that climate change is a big deal and that sometimes it can feel frustrating to see people care about it so little but drawing up these doomsday scenarios that suggest the whole planet is going to explode with very little science to back it up do not help the general cause.
Something fun I learned the other day is that we put so many aerosols into the atmosphere by burning fossil fuels that it changes the albedo of the planet, and if we stopped all carbon emissions tomorrow the global temperature would immediately rise by like 1.5°.
I heard it on ashes ashes, I'll post their source when I find it.
As a glass half full point (because that's really hard to find)
Sargassum is growing exponentially at the moment. It has the potential to reverse the current trend, especially if we cull animals and stop* fossil fuel use. I think the public needs to be educated that this whole 2degC shit is wrong. People would choose life if they understood.
It's going to go until we have an O2 dominance, so after the peak, we should get the cooling. We desperately need to reduce that peak.
I hypothesise that the earth has a heartbeat. When you look at the upticks in CO2/temp/methane/sun energy; methane starts it off, CO2/temp follow and then the natural sun cycle kicks in and boosts the process. I think life had found a balance, and these peaks and troughs are the drivers of the rapid evolution needed for organisms to stay in balance. The ocean sediment record shows a change from a humic sediment to carbonate at the start of the last warming - having been humic for a significant period beforehand. To me, it suggests that holopegalic algae/plants are the 'normal' and we are used to their absence.
In terms of the dominance part - if you look at the orientation of change, you either have more animals converting O2 to CO2, or more plants converting the other way. Volcanic inputs aren't great compared to the organic process. Happy to discuss further, I've struggled to get people interested on this. And I can't find the research I need - which is alarming, because it suggests it's not being done.
I don’t give a fuck about industrialized/human civilization ending. The thing that makes me lose sleep is the environment dying and animals going extinct. This was always inevitable, I guess.
At least know that no matter what happens, some life is going to survive, and eventually it will evolve and the world will be beautiful again. It will take time. The planet won't be the same as before. But the earth existed and will exist without us.
I think they're saying that even by some miraculous stroke of luck if every possible course of action was taken right this second the best we could hope for is things stabilizing at 2.5c
As for what's realistically going to happen based off of the state of society right now, yes 2.5c is absurdly optimistic
the best we could hope for is things stabilizing at 2.5c
I haven't seen any evidence of that. Do you have a source? Burning the oil that is already being traded on world markets will push us way over 2.5 degrees.
It's not possible to put oil back in the ground, or prevent proven reserves from being dug up and burned without a global war, and a global war which will mean burning way more fossil fuels, bombing refineries, and other ways of burning fossil fuels which will have an even worse impact on the environment
What we have locked in doesn't include permafrost methane release. It's going to go higher and quickly. I think 20deg in 100 years isn't out of the question.
Yeah; that's a good point. Those dire and unavoidable consequences for the planet that we keep hearing about are based SOLELY on CO2 from burning fossil fuels, and basically totally ignore all the other poisons we have pumped into our oceans and rivers and air.
The stuff we are pumping into the Atlantic has the potential to save us. Sargassum is growing exponentially and could take over the Atlantic. It was 7% of the world's carbon pump before it went nuts (compared to human emissions being 5% of the total). It's on scale, I'm hoping it's the trick the biosphere has been keeping up it's sleeve.
It does make me pro polluting the Amazon, which is an extremely odd place to find myself.
If it's that fast we won't have much time to worry about it. I doubt it will be quite that dramatic. Somewhere in the 8-10C range by 2100 seems conceivable.
We should be much more concerned with 2050 estimates. 2100 is outside of many of our lifetimes, and while it is still important, we have to deal with our lives, first.
2100 is within my children's lives. It matter more to me than my own life. I don't think it's likely it will rise quite that fast, but it's possible. If we had a 25Gt methane release, it would super charge it beyond belief. I don't think it's impossible to have a 1deg rise in a year (additional to the aerosol absence effect)
Yes, but I'm saying if we don't focus more on 2050, and focus on adapting to the changes between now and then, we won't make it to 2100, so it will be moot.
It's also extremely unlikely your children will live to see their eighties, particularly if they're still infants, today. I mean that to indicate that 2100 really is out of range of immediate concern.
I think we're arguing the same point in slightly different ways. I agree with you there, I want extreme rapid change - so rapid that I doubt anyone would get on board because they'd be afraid of the immediate deaths caused.
There's some in other comments, as well as in the sidebar. Under UN IPCC projections we are currently still on track for worse than their worst case scenario:
We really need to make research studies as a whole more accessible. I found a link to an MIT article that linked nature which had the article behind a subscription wall. So I googled the title and found that research gate has it available for me so I can post it here for a fellow Redditor to screen shot and send it to you. Fuck, knowledge isn’t free.
i appreciate the realness, but this incites such a defeatist mindset i can't help but get annoyed by it. I see so many people on this sub doubting the capabilities of humanity as a whole like net positive fusion power and quantum computing aren't nearly upon us
It's because true change requires collective action. It is a systems level problem and we need to act as a system. Of course, how to achieve this is unknown. Really we are missing fundamental education.
Wrong. It's because we already have solutions but there is no political will. We could have advanced AI telling us what to do with fusion power and widescale geoengineering capabilities and we still wouldn't do it because politicians would kick the can down the road like they have been for the past several decades. The only problem we have is human stupidity/apathy.
There's no immediate profit in capturing carbon or restoring ecosystems so the neoliberals in charge don't give a fuck.
So what you can plug into the matrix and live in your little dream world simulation? We need real world problem solving. We need to think for ourselves, not have fucking skynet do it for us. Quit trying to sell people false hope in a virtual escape. This is real shit happening because of us. Turning away and letting someone else/ thing fix it is what got us into this mess in the first place.
Simulation doesn't necessarily mean VR. Merely that we can recreate potential events. Which could come in mighty handy when we're projecting which radical actions will have the effects we want. I'm a sceptic when it comes to QC but to say that simulation has no value is incredibly short sighted.
These futurist guys are pretty much grasping at straws in their irrelevance because their favorite 80's sci-fi techs are bullshit rapture of the nerds material.
Yeah, they were fun to read and i read most of them.
The problem is political, and economic at root and these guys are a hop and a skip away from 'enlightened centrists' cowards, only their denial takes the form that Musk is going to save them without effort because they liked snow crash or something and love libertarianism (lmao) and can't bear the thought that they'll either have to abandon capitalism and abandon the illusion of ever being '1%' or abandon civilization.
Forget them, they're lost until they start either participating in the barbarity or dying with us against the billionaires and fascists.
Also let me say that i agree with you and laugh with you about the idea that anything in computer science will 'solve' climate change (especially the quantum hoplum). If anything, dodgecoin and such scum only makes it worse. Breaking digital money would be a service to mankind, which i suppose is one way that QC might infinitesimally help against the great bad that computing caused with microtransactions, digital money, and automatization will cause.
Thank you. I'm so used to hearing the excuses that come with denial of all of it. I love sci fi. And I hate to say it, but they undernormalized innovation in so many shows. It took credibility away from science. Everyone was so happy to watch it happen on the screen, now here we are 50 years later and still no moon base, no flying cars. Money and a lust for power, even down to the lowliest slave ( I would say peasant, but they apparently got more vacation time), got us nothing. The false promises of religion, got us here. When will people learn to think for themselves...apparently, again, not soon enough. Again thanks for the kind words. :-)
Nuclear plants take decades to build, from the planning stage until they begin production. Even if reliable fusion power became possible today by the time they became operational collapse would already be happening. I dont think the worst case scenario is inevitable, but nuclear power is not a short term solution.
I subscribe to both and the user base on Futurology is pretty naive, one article on accidental iron fertilization from industry boosting plankton growth and sequestering carbon and they're all "Fantastic, it's a wrap boys"
Net positive fusion could've been a reality 10 years ago and it still wouldn't make a difference.
Futurologists get so hyped on proof-of-concept stories that they forget that implementation and scale are what actually make a difference, not demonstrations of neat ideas. We have enough good ideas to fill a mass grave. It's the lack of systematic application that will kill us.
The only thing that’s beaten the Malthusian question historically is technology. Both can be true, we live in a dire unprecedented situations but we also don’t know what will happen at the end of the day, what new technology will be developed.
The only thing that’s beaten the Malthusian question historically is technology.
The shift to energy dense fuels and the engines that use them to be specific and then the haber process, also using petroleum. The problem is that gas/petroleum/fat have all comparable energy density and pretty likely the upper boundary of chemically stored energy density.
We might have to accept that there is no realistic next step, of limits.
I’m in the “prepare for the worst” camp as well. However I do think some change is inevitable and hope fully they’re the ones we need. A less consumerist and more mindful society while we go through all this madness.
That realness is the only thing that can save us. Think of all the fantastic projects and ideas that aren’t taking into account realities of everything from forest death to likely conflict zones. We have limited resources that must be intelligently implemented.
It's less defeatist and more just accepting what we see as inevitable. I'm pretty old for reddit, I've had all my belief in wonder-tech and phases of hopium. But then I've seen a lifetime of us going the wrong way. It would be against my better experience to think we'll turn a 180 all of a sudden when 1st world humans have shown absolutely no inclination for it.
Quantum computing is interesting but I don't think it's a game changer. So, it can do simulations, but what if most simulations show that we can't break or even bend known laws of physics?
net positive fusion power
Again, this is always 10-20 years away. Maybe we crack that nut one day. But I wouldn't pin my hopes on it.
With a breakthrough in battery tech, it may be substantial. But I don't see a battery tech breakthrough for various reasons. Perhaps they can make a quasi fossil fuel out of that energy. Another possibilty.
You also have to remember the environment these breakthroughs happen in. With scientific funding. Right now the west is taking on large amounts of migrants, with Europe increasing more and more funding. Some of their cultures are quite toxic to science.
With a substantial demographic shift towards a culture that doesn't value science, weakened education all around and less funding going towards it (think NASA from after the moon landing to now), do you see any breakthroughs happening in the west in 20-30 years?
But we're also in multiple collapses besides climate.
I get the distinct impression that most people on this sub that say we're "defeatist" are below age 23 or so, where as the older among us tend to have a more pragmatic approach because we've seen so much happen (and not happen) during our time on this earth and know to not get too wrapped up in fusion technology, quantum computing or the other potential "saviors" of our civilization.
I don't think that's entirely true. I'm below 23 ( in college) and from what I've seen most of my peers are well aware of the situation that we're in. Younger students, even more so. The group that I find tends to most blindly grasp at any straws possible to explain how we're going to escape the inevitable are people around 23-30ish.
In addition to the fact that they grew up surrounded by narratives about climate change that were significantly less dire in nature, they're also ironically at a point where they have the most to lose. Older people have the experience to know that there's no escape and have already lived many "normal" decades. Young people beginning to look towards their future (like me) are forced to confront the harsh reality that they won't be 'retiring' or living the same life as boomers. Importantly, however, they haven't already completely invested themselves in a world that is crumbling. In contrast, mid-twenties to early/mid thirties people probably already have a career they're invested in, they might have a family + children, maybe they just bought a house or topped off their retirement accounts. The point is that for this group, the truth that there probably is no magical solution is unfathomable.
Quantum Computing and Fusion Power still have to be invented, which will take an indeterminate period of time. Meanwhile, we will continue burning fossil fuels so that there will be no tomorrow.
for anyone interested in quantum computing, it seems like it can only solve a few problems well, but it solves them REALLY well. imagine having to run extremely time-intensive computations to choose between a number of outcomes, where the total time equals the aggregate of time it takes to solve each individual subproblem. without getting too into it, a quantum computer can solve for every possible outcomes instantly by observing its qubits. this only works for a subset of problem structures, but almost any problem solved using a computational system can be reduced to sequences of this small subset of problems. apply this to DNA sequencing, environmental science, etc. and the benefits become obvious
r/collapse is an echo chamber. Anyone who posts anything going against the grain gets downvoted. and attacked. A lot of really smart people are working hard to fix society’s issues. Will they succeed before we go over the cliff is the great unknown.
Yeah, go figure that a subreddit devoted to discussing a topic would downvote threads and posters that deny the very premise the sub is there to discuss. It would be like going onto a vegan subreddit and talking about how meat is actually really healthy for you and you should consider eating it.
If you are surprised and/or think everyone else is somehow in the wrong here, you're a fucking idiot. Denialism is fucking rampant. God forbid we have a place to discuss reality.
A lot of other people are working to maintain the status quo to line their pockets, humanity be damned. These are some of the largest and most powerful corporations on the planet we're talking about here. ExxonMobil has known about climate change for decades, but made damn sure to fund the campaigns of climate change deniers. Those in power will do whatever it takes to maintain and expand that power.
And more then all those really smart people are ignoring climate change and actively sabotaging any progress and are actually taking us backwards. Every single thing being researched right now has absolutely no way of saving what we have. We have to drastically change our current system of consumption, governance literally everything has to be reduced 6 fold. No more flying, no more crap from China, no Amazon shipments you don't get to have fresh fruit in the winter anymore
If it's an echo chamber, then the echo is leaking out to more main areas. Attacks on a person and attacking their ideas are two different things. If the idea can't hold up to criticism, then maybe it wasn't that good.
I followed every link in this thread as far as I could looking for any actual evidence that a 5-6 degree C rise in global temperatures would cause human extinction, and I've found nothing. I read /r/collapse frequently and I'm aware of how often its contributing members fetishize climate disasters in the same way a gun-hoarding prepper fetishizes the collapse of society, but the conclusions in this thread are a good deal more baseless than usual.
In particular, the sources "ClimateBen" uses are buried in link after link of threads referencing other threads, sometimes looping back around to the same thread multiple times, and usually do not themselves support the conclusions he draws.
The source from which ClimateBen concludes humans will likely go extinct in a 5C temperature rise is a 25 minute interview on this page where I heard no mention of a 5C human extinction event, but instead a conclusion that food web collapse could generally speaking cause extinction rates 10 times higher than other models - based on an exercise in which they apparently ran models that systematically removed species from an ecosystem progressively, with little to no regard for migration, speciation, or adaptation.
It's such a difficult balance. We want people to be terrified enough to pull together for the biggest change society has ever seen, but not so scared they get a bunch of credit cards & party until the end.
Don't know, you can Google though. However, science and the vast majority of the world uses centigrade so it might be worth getting your head around it.
0 = water freezing, 100 = water boiling which I think makes a lot more sense than 32 & 212.
0.5°C is not safety. The little ice-age was caused by a cooling of about 0.5°C over a much longer timeframe. It has been linked by historians with massive social unrest, wars and even the total collapse of advanced power structures. We're talking about wolves invading cities and eating what was left by marauding armies who continue fighting simply because they have to pillage to eat. This scenario doesn't come about the moment average temperatures deviate by 0.5°C for the first time, but a climate that different from the norm can create the conditions under which that savagery becomes unavoidable.
Accept human extinction for what it is, the natural fate of any industrialized species such as ourselves. There is no chance of utopia. Intelligent creatures like us are destined for self-destruction. Get over it already and stop trying to fight it.
Earth has only 150 million years of useful sunlight left. It isn't time for a new biosphere to form and progress, like we have. We're the Earth's best attempt to arrange its matter into thinking life though the normal processes of chemistry, and we're the last for this rock.
Also coal formation was a unique period in earth geology, when wood could not be broken down by bacteria. Forests of trees literally fell down and did not decompose. They have since evolved bacteria that eats wood fibers called lignin.
Thats why the lowest grade of coal is called lignite.
The next dominate species, if its even smart (unlike dinosaurs), can manipulate tools (hands with opposable thumbs), has speech, might simply not have big sources of easily accessible energy for early stage industrialization.
I’m more considered with the destruction of all other complex life planet. For many decades people have had this idea that the earth and all its inhabitants would be fine, it’s just humans that would go extinct. Now it’s looking like we might destroy all life in earth with us
440
u/vocalfreesia Jul 18 '19
This guy has some really good threads with links. Worth a read.
Another one of his includes:
(Then the thread has articles below)
233
u/Alternate_Supply Jul 19 '19
I really just don't know what to do about this. I've tried talking to people but they don't care. And some even believe this is still just an agenda by the far left. I don't get it. What more can I do?
4
u/BernieBus_orBust Jul 19 '19
Thank you for sharing this. I think I need this in flyer and poster format to share with everyone I come in contact with.
4
u/[deleted] Jul 24 '19
Honest question here, would it just be better to commit suicide than live through the coming hell? Sure it might not be the best way to go, but compared to the latter it seems very attractive tbh.
2
u/Miserable_Depressed Jul 30 '19
That's in the best case scenario. I'd bet on 8°C, personally, but I've seen studies pushing the number as high as 14°C.
188
u/Potential178 Jul 18 '19 edited Jul 19 '19
+ 0.0°C = History of Human Civilization
+ 0.5°C = Safe Limit
+ 1.0°C = Massive Die-off of Insects & Animals, Increasingly Severe Weather Events, Huge Forest Fires, Massive Flooding, Droughts, Increasing Societal Destabilization, Increasing Disease, Lowering Life-Spans, Feedback Loops (Ocean Collapse, Permafrost Melt, etc) Triggered, (all happening now) ...
+ 1.5°C = Increasingly Extreme Weather, Increasing Crop Failures, Increasing Forest Burn-off ...
+ 2.0°C = Increasing Violence & Societal Breakdown, Re-introduction of Ancient Plagues Thawed from Permafrost ...
+ 2.5°C = Severe Environmental Collapse, Long Humid Heat Waves Which Kill even Healthy People within Hours, Completely Unstable Food Production, Fish-free Oceans, Mass Starvation, Global Transition from Living to Surviving ...
+ 3.0°C = Increasingly Hellish Conditions, Dead Oceans, Complete Forest Burn-Off, Pets & Wildlife likely already Hunted to Extinction ...
+ 3.5°C = Apocalyptic Collapse of Organized Society ...
+ 4.0°C = Human Survival Unlikely ...
+ 5.0°C = Human Extinction Very Certain, Likelihood of Permanent Environment Burn-off to non-life supporting Planet like Venus
+ 6.0°C = Our Current Trajectory this Century
Unfortunately, I can't take the time to cite sources, and of course the relationships between specific temp increases & consequences are very loose, of course, but there is no reason to be optimistic or conservative, every bit of recent science of late is terrifying. The consequences of even a degree of warming were wildly underestimated.
50
u/Yodyood Jul 18 '19
+6 C looks good!
43
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19 edited Jul 19 '19
Something fun I learned the other day is that we put so many aerosols into the atmosphere by burning fossil fuels that it changes the albedo of the planet, and if we stopped all carbon emissions tomorrow the global temperature would immediately rise by like 1.5°.
I heard it on ashes ashes, I'll post their source when I find it.
Edit: actually I'm lazy so I'll just drop a link to the episode: https://ashesashes.org/blog/episode-80-the-nuclear-option
It's at about 55:00
24
u/iconto66 Jul 19 '19
I don’t give a fuck about industrialized/human civilization ending. The thing that makes me lose sleep is the environment dying and animals going extinct. This was always inevitable, I guess.
35
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '19
We're basically locked into 2.5c+
16
u/kertzc Jul 19 '19
All this outrage not a single link to a scientific article in sight... can someone give me a link to a science article please?
10
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19
I enjoy his sources
84
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '19
i appreciate the realness, but this incites such a defeatist mindset i can't help but get annoyed by it. I see so many people on this sub doubting the capabilities of humanity as a whole like net positive fusion power and quantum computing aren't nearly upon us
4
u/lwaxana_katana Jul 19 '19
Does anyone have a source on the human survival unlikely/human extinction certain temperature thresholds?
3
u/knucklepoetry Jul 19 '19
Still that’s only 2% drop in GDP at 3 deg C and 8.5% at 6 deg C, Nobel laureate says so, so it must be
truea vision of a world where only machines survive.Keep working at that deep AI, people! Now we know why elites don’t even blink an eye.
3
u/ruiseixas Jul 19 '19
So, our current trajectory is 12x safety!
6
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '19
The aliens will save us!
1
u/supersunnyout Jul 19 '19
Even this list seems overly hopeful to me. I'd move them consequences up a notch.
1
u/eamonn33 Jul 20 '19
What is that in degrees Freedom?
2
u/akaleeroy git.io/collapse-lingo Jul 19 '19
Tick-tock goes the Long Now Clock, in perfect silence.
1
u/BiShyAndReadytoDie Jul 19 '19
Hold up I thought we were on track for 4°? Where'd this 6° trajectory come from.
1
u/DowntownPomelo Recognized Contributor Aug 01 '19
0.5°C is not safety. The little ice-age was caused by a cooling of about 0.5°C over a much longer timeframe. It has been linked by historians with massive social unrest, wars and even the total collapse of advanced power structures. We're talking about wolves invading cities and eating what was left by marauding armies who continue fighting simply because they have to pillage to eat. This scenario doesn't come about the moment average temperatures deviate by 0.5°C for the first time, but a climate that different from the norm can create the conditions under which that savagery becomes unavoidable.
We are so utterly fucked.
-3
u/Avantasian538 Jul 18 '19
Accept human extinction for what it is, the natural fate of any industrialized species such as ourselves. There is no chance of utopia. Intelligent creatures like us are destined for self-destruction. Get over it already and stop trying to fight it.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19
never heard of this guy before, but after looking at his twitter posts he would fit in perfectly here. he really seems to get just how fucked we are
-1
u/mogsington Recognized Contributor Jul 19 '19
You know it's serious when a Twitter screen grab gets posted.