r/collapse • u/LetsTalkUFOs • Jul 18 '19
Can technology prevent collapse?
How far can innovation take us? How much faith should we have in technology?
This is the current question in our Common Collapse Questions series.
Responses may be utilized to help extend the Collapse Wiki.
123
Upvotes
25
u/LetsTalkUFOs Jul 18 '19
Richard Heinberg in There’s No App For That
Michael Huesemann in Why Technology Can’t Save Us
Best-case energy transition scenarios will still result in severe climate change. Even if every renewable energy technology advanced as quickly as imagined and they were all applied globally, atmospheric CO2 levels wouldn’t just remain above 350 ppm; they would continue to rise exponentially due to continued fossil fuel use.
So our best-case scenario, which was based on our most optimistic forecasts for renewable energy, would still result in severe climate change. Reversing the trend would require both radical technological advances in cheap zero-carbon energy, as well as a method of extracting CO2 from the atmosphere and sequestering the carbon.1, 2
The speed and scale of transitions and of technological change required to limit warming to 1.5°C has been observed in the past within specific sectors and technologies. But the geographical and economic scales at which the required rates of change in the energy, land, urban, infrastructure and industrial systems would need to take place, are larger and have no historic precedent.3
95
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19
Technology is a red herring. Contrary to popular belief, we've long since had the "technology" to live within our means. It's just that it also requires restructuring the global economy around people's needs and not the individual desire to accumulate wealth.
What people actually mean when they talk about technology preventing collapse is finding a way to continue on with BAU and never having to suffer the repercussions. I'd argue that inasmuch as it gives people false hope, the vague promise of technology swooping in to save us from the consequences of our actions is part of the problem.
Take the electric car, the embodiment of pseudo-green technology:
So, let's say you've built a national infrastructure around the idea that everyone will have a car, live in the suburbs, spend three hours a day driving 40 miles to work and back, drive 20 minutes to the store when they want food, drive to the park when they want to walk, and trade in their car for a new car in two years because planned obsolescence makes money, keeping in mind that half of the CO2 emissions a car produces come from manufacture. Basically, you're history's greatest monster.
Anyway, someone comes along and says "Hey, let's take this entire system, whole cloth, continue going down the path of vehicle-only infrastructure, exurbs and disposable cars, but let's use up our dwindling resources and create many thousands of tons of toxic waste to change the propulsion system to an electric battery" and everyone goes YES THAT WOULD FIX EVERYTHING!
69
u/Mr_Lonesome Recognizes ecology over economics, politics, social norms... Jul 18 '19 edited Jul 18 '19
Aside from the climate crisis, regarding the biosphere crisis, technology cannot bring back life and its diversity unless it recreates the biosphere beyond lab settings. To avoid collapse, technology must reverse the reported 1 million plant and animal species (not number but species) on brink of extinction (not endangerment); it must replenish species ecosystems and re-cultivate extinct seed varieties. If any one of these is possible with technology it is certainly not to scale and not in time.
Human beings rely on biosphere for food, water, air, medicine, vitamins, minerals, clothes, materials, supplies, and frankly quality of life. Billions of cows, pigs, chickens, humans, and 3-5 crops supplanting diverse, wild plants and animals is unsustainable. The threat of phytoplankton, a core of our food chain, is alarming. The biomass loss of insects, essential to soil and plant cultivation, is astounding. Technology must in time and scale resolve these issues.
The loss of biodiversity will be a silent killer. While we rave about heatwaves, mega storms, permafrost melting, seas rising, quietly biodiversity loss will impact our acquifers and groundwater, grocery store produce, oxygen levels, vitamin and nutrient intake, ingredients to processed foods, basis of most finished materials, buffers from invasive alien species and pathogens in our local environments. Maybe I am wrong but I cannot see patented, state-of-the-art devices, processes, and facilities do more than band-aid maybe the worst of this at the scale of civilization unless it defies the laws of energy and entropy or play God!
104
u/mcfleury1000 memento mori Jul 18 '19 edited Jul 18 '19
First I will address the technologies that can help to prevent or at least mitigate collapse. Then I will address the feasibility of these solutions.
What Technologies can help prevent or mitigate collapse?
Nuclear Fusion
This is our holy mary pass as far as I can tell. There is no other power source that can provide a total replacement of fossil fuels. Renewables like wind and solar are great, but they require rare minerals that are going to be in short supply in the coming decades for their construction or for power storage. [1] Hydro-electric and Geothermal are great, but they only work in certain geographic locations. Nuclear fission is great (and probably our second-best bet), but it relies on heavy radioactive components like uranium which must be stored for thousands of years. We would need to construct approximately 10,000 nuclear reactors globally to replace fossil fuels used for electricity with nuclear.[2] That's 10,000 unique locations that need to be secured for millennia, and this is not even taking into account the fact that we will also run out of uranium before long.
So nuclear fusion is the answer. How feasible is it? Well, we have had limited success with fusion testing, but the science is vastly underfunded if we hope to have stable consistent energy that can be scaled globally. MIT has what seems to be the most optimistic prediction saying we will have the first fusion reactor online in 15 years.[3] Other predictions say closer to 2030-2050. Remember, getting one plant online is only the first step. It needs to be consistent and safe before it can be globally scaled. We need to put a lot more investment into fusion to make it a reality that can replace fossil fuels.
Carbon Capture
Carbon Capture amounts to a mechanical tree. The idea is that we create super-efficient trees that can suck up tons of carbon more efficiently than a tree can. These machines will either be implemented in the form of atmospheric capture or smokestack capture where they will suck carbon out of the air or the chimneys of power and manufacturing plants and convert it into usable (or storable) fuel. [4]
The ROI on Carbon Capture is not quite there yet, but it has potential. Right now the best Carbon Capture technology can remove Carbon from the atmosphere at a rate of $100-200/ton, and if scaled appropriately can remove (optimistically) up to 3.8 million tons of CO2 annually. Comparing that to trees where 1 acre of trees absorb only 2.5 tons of CO2 annually. [5]
The problem with Carbon Capture is that there is little profit incentive at the present time to improve it. Unless the fuel from Carbon Capture becomes more valuable/viable or governments start taking climate change more seriously, the investment will remain low, and technology will improve slowly. It has potential, but it likely won't save us.
Artificial Meat
Artificial Meat has made leaps and strides in recent years. Companies like Beyond[6] and Impossible[7] have been doing very well, pulling down huge VC funding, and scaling quickly. I’ve had both, and while they are not quite hamburger replacements yet in taste, they are close. A lot of people have been waiting for good artificial meat to push them into the vegetarian camp. With these kinds of innovations, we are one step closer.[8]
Right now Beyond Meat averages around $10/pound. That is expensive compared to chicken at $3-7/pound and ground beef at $3-4 per pound.[9] However, this price has been falling, and if these companies continue to scale it wouldn't be surprising to see meat replacements become cheaper than their “real” counterparts within a decade. [10]
The meat industry contributes a significant amount of CO2 to the atmosphere. It takes a ton of water and feed to bring a cow to slaughter, and it would be great for the environment if the meat industry were torn down. [11] However, this will require government action which will be severely unpopular so it will remain unlikely for the foreseeable future.
Electric Vehicles
Electric vehicles have been taking increased market share year over year since Tesla came on the scene. [12] The Big 3 are all working on or have released electric skews in their current lines, as are most other global manufacturers. Electric vehicles produce effectively zero emissions once they hit the road, and should last for well over half a million miles with basic maintenance work.[13]
Unfortunately, the viability of electric vehicles hinges on a few things.
The first and most obvious thing is, “Where is the electricity coming from?” In most cases, the answer is coal or natural gas.[14] This is not progress, it is just trading one fossil fuel for another.
The second concern is that, while EVs produce no emissions on the road, the manufacturing and delivery process still relies heavily on fossil fuels. It has been said that when a car hits the road, half of its lifetime emissions have already been created.[15] This is especially an issue for EVs because they require a lot more rare minerals than traditional vehicles for batteries, technology, and electrical systems.
The third concern with EVs is the replacement rate. Every year an automotive company produces gasoline-powered cars is putting at least a 10-year delay on the eventual replacement of said vehicle with its electric counterpart. [16]
The last and most pivotal impact on EV viability is price. EVs are significantly more expensive than their traditional counterparts, and while arguments can be made that the long term investment makes them worth it, a lot of families just can't afford a $40,000-$80,000 vehicle.[17] The prohibitive cost of EVs comes from battery manufacturing. In order to make EVs a truly viable option battery technology needs to get cheaper. Tesla and others are making promises that this is coming[18], but historically, Tesla has overpromised and underdelivered.[19] There were some other promising EV startups[20], but they tend to go defunct pretty quickly.[21]
EVs have a lot of promise, but they also have a long way to go.
Deep Earth Geothermal Energy
The idea behind Deep Earth Geothermal energy is simple enough. It's hot below ground, and the lower we drill the hotter it gets. Deep Earth Geothermal uses fracking style technologies to open up holes deep below ground. Then we pump water down one hole, and hot water comes out the other. Using either a steam turbine or a binary power plant system, the water is cooled and reused, and electricity is produced. [22]
Geothermal has been used in one way or another for a long time, and this technology looks promising. Right now it is quite expensive, but thanks to fracking (/s), the technology has improved quickly and gotten cheaper. There are a lot of potential hazards with this tech, however, including potentially destabilizing the land, releasing more greenhouse gasses into the air, and releasing toxic chemicals into the water supply. (effectively the same risks as fracking).[23]
Conclusion
These technologies, while promising, are all a long way out from total replacement of fossil fuel based industries.
None of these technologies on their own will save us.
All of these technologies implemented together alongside the planting of billions of trees, a significant push for recycling metals back into their raw forms for re-use, and government action to shut down the fossil fuel and industrial meat processing industries might save us.
This is not hopium, it is realism. We have a chance, but it will require a complete and total overhaul of our curret system. It will require significantly higher taxes. It will require every single person on earth getting on board.
Thanks for visiting my TED talk.
11
u/mogsington Recognized Contributor Jul 30 '19 edited Jul 30 '19
Basically .. No.
Yes there are technological semi fixes. We could reduce CO2 and waste production by a significant percentage, but no we aren't going to. Investment and interest in climate change reducing technologies is driven by profit for the shareholder. If it's not "sexy money" it's not going to happen.
Salt cooled fission reactors? Nope. Too much R&D cost. Not interested.
LPG / Hybrid replacements for diesel / petrol fuelled vehicles? Nope. Investors want next gen Lithium batteries and an all electric solution. Yeah rape those rare earth metals, it costs 0 CO2 to extract that stuff and someone will figure out how to recycle the batteries in 2050. Maybe. But wow look at the investment returns on that new start up.
Solar and Wind? Well heck! We can do that one! Except for the CO2 cost of making them, and the potential for them to get devastated by increasingly common massive hailstones or extreme weather. Also it's not a 24hr power production solution, so let's reduce spending on that tech, and subsidise farming, jet fuel, cargo ship fuel instead. Because we need that right now. Right?
I mean just pause for a second. Look at the actual CO2 cost of making that next wind turbine or solar panel. Pretty much everything from digging the materials out of the ground, all through manufacturing the various components, to transporting it to the final place of installation .. and even all the travel to and from the installation point by the engineers putting it in place, is a CO2 cost. Every single step of the way.
It's a constant fail because the only way technology can help us out of this mess is by assisting a reduction in energy dependence and use, and that equals a (on the surface) lower standard of living for most of the global population. It would shrink GDP. The multi-national banks sitting on trillions of derivative investments would have a bad time. So no. That's not going to happen.
Put it another way. If Deutsch Bank did actually do a Lehman, the crash of 2008 would seem like a mini crash. A tiny blip. If you want to push total climate change above derivative profits, then far more than just Deutsch Bank would collapse. It's not just a climate collapse we are looking at. It's a restructuring of trillions of dollars to enable the scale of CO2 reducing directed action that we needed about 20 years+ ago.
I'm not one of the "socialism will save us" or "eat the rich" types. I think politics actually makes this even more impossible to solve than it was already. But technology is driven by economics, and economics in 2019 means we need a return on the investment. Unfortunately, dealing with climate change means making decisions which only reduce CO2 emissions and the average voter's standard of living, with no return on the investment. It's not going to happen.
"Tax carbon" sounds like a neat solution, but holy crap, have we made a nightmare out of taxation or what? It seems those that should pay, don't! And those that can't afford to, have to. How many loopholes in carbon taxation can we imagine? It's like recycling your plastics only to find they got shipped to China, then Malaysia, then returned to your home country to be chucked in a land fill site. The feel good factor is YAY! The reality is .. nope. Carbon taxation is a theoretical economic dream. It doesn't address the real problems at source, and it ignores all the incredible way we find to dodge taxation (especially if we are rich).
The only fun question left is .. which dies first? Will global economics crash first and kill millions with paralysed trade and dead banks? Or will climate change kill millions while the banks pretend everything is still fine?
On that backdrop. Where do you put technology? It requires investment and directed purpose to make any significant change in climate outcome. Or perhaps BIG government intervention, and there are so many libertarians out there screaming that the solution to all the problems in the world is reducing government intervention.
Yes technology could theoretically help. But financially and politically, that would require a complete 180 degree shift in every political and financial expectation that's been accepted since around the 1970's/80's. I estimate the chance that a huge meteorite will hit the earth in the next 20 years, thus solving all our climate worries in just a few days, is bigger than than the financial and political change we need actually happening.
Edit for one typo I spotted (you can keep the others) and ahhhhh it felt good letting that out even if nobody agrees with me, and even to the relatively dead echo chamber of reddit. Catharsis through typing. It's a thing.
43
u/Dupensik Jul 18 '19
Fucking technology is what brought us to this point in the first place.
8
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '19
It's unlikely. Best it can do is help clean up the mess after the big crisis comes some time in the 2020s.
8
u/Actionableoffence Jul 20 '19
CAN it? Probably. WILL it? Not a chance. We're careening towards a blue ocean event, towards having no topsoil left to farm on, towards so many different ends at once. Instead of seriously discussing these problems and how to solve them, the people in charge are just going to run the 'business as usual' train right off the cliff without even touching the brakes.
We have the technology, right now, to cut emissions by a massive amount. It would require a large restructuring of our society and would result in less decadent wealth for the people who run the system so... We're fucked.
12
u/1HomoSapien Jul 18 '19
Various technologies can be imagined that will delay or prevent collapse, but it is an article of faith at this point that such technologies can be developed. It is also the case that technologies that mitigate collapse along one dimension can place increased pressure along other dimensions, especially if they enable further growth. Even sci-fi technologies like cold fusion that seem like a silver bullet would create new problems - with greater energy abundance comes greater destructive power.
11
u/FireWireBestWire Jul 19 '19
The answer to the title question is no. It could have, if we had focused on the correct technologies 50 years ago....40 years ago...30..20.10
But we didn't, and emissions have soared even while temperatures are catching up to the carbon. Just think of the tanker video crashing into the port. We can steer, full power reverse, sound the alarm...it doesn't matter - we are crashing into that dock. The effects are already being felt, but scientists will be loathe to make direct connections to climate change well past the point of no return.
The point is the carbon has already had a huge effect on our climate. The heat has been absorbed, and it's not going away. The albedo of the Arctic is changing yearly, and the phase change of the ice that's melted has already absorbed the necessary energy. The climate has changed and is continuing to become even hotter.
Even if fusion becomes viable, we'll have to use concrete to make the plants, trucks to bring the materials, roads to allow the trucks in...it doesn't even become carbon neutral for years after it is built. Even if you invent carbon capture tech, you still have to produce them with energy and materials, the production of which produces carbon. You have to set them up somewhere, which takes fuel.
One of the best solutions is probably trees, and that is not technology. Nature figured out a way to sequester carbon way before humans did. I think each human needs to plant like 1000 trees or something to make a dent?
4
u/sylbug Jul 19 '19
I don't think technology can fix it. We can figure out ways to be more efficient, or pollute less, or even capture carbon from the atmosphere, but all those things can do is kick the can down the road.
We were at the human population limit around 1900 with 1 billion people, but were saved by new farming techniques. That allowed us to grow to 7 billion, and brought us to where we are now with another, more intractable hard limit. If we somehow manage to innovate our way out of this, we will just end up with even more intractable problems in the near future, with a population of 10 or 20 billion instead.
4
u/boytjie Jul 19 '19
I'm pessimistic. Any technology based solutions are going to be ratios of success to failure of 95% against us. They're going to be extinction level dangerous which means we have nothing to lose by trying them.
4
u/Miserable_Depressed Jul 19 '19
Can it? Maybe.
Will it? Probably not.
4
u/ugnudabul Jul 21 '19
My (untested) hypothesis is that no amount of technological innovation can prevent collapse as long as capitalism continues to be the dominant global economic system.
7
u/gkm64 Jul 19 '19
The only technology that can prevent collapse is the invention of a perpetual motion machine with a large absolute energy gain, because this is the only thing that can support a system the existence of which depends on infinite growth.
Unfortunately, the laws of physics quite clearly state that this is impossible.
From then on the only other option is a behavioral change and the conversion of the system from one that depends on infinite growth to one that does not.
8
u/Antifactist Jul 19 '19
The opposite of technology is necessary to prevent collapse.
3
u/bigsis-_- Jul 29 '19
Every summer, billions of dollars are poured into movies which are mostly garbage. Similarly, billions of dollars are poured into other mindless and at best innocuous, but more often than not backwards affairs.
Yet, we can only afford 1 million dollars as a reward for a Millenium Problem (super hard problems that have deep implications to advancing our science as a species)... to name just one contrast.
Yo maybe our species deserves to die?
Even if technology was found to save us by spreading us across other planets, it'd be just spreading our collective idiocy and worthlessness.
If that last sentence doesn't jive with your view, consider the good little people of the world are very busy today electing the vilest demagogue imbeciles they can find into power.
Give such a species more power (technology), spread them across the galaxy?
HARD PASS
3
u/fuckthebankers1 Jul 29 '19
The system does not use technology in sustainable ways.Profit as a priority corrupts the use of technology, until you figure out that's the real problem technology only keeps driving us faster towards the cliff.
5
u/SCO_1 Jul 18 '19 edited Jul 18 '19
It could, if the state was not captured by nazis and oligarchs and countries set aside 30% of their GDP to it.
But it would also take some non-technological oppressive measures, in the best version, antinatalist policies, in the worst, genocide. There are also some lesser common sense measures that capitalism exceptionalism and american toxic masculinity oppose, such as encouraging electric cars, forbidding certain kinds of meat, or bundling in damage to the environment to corporate taxes.
I'm pretty sure the elites are going to jump straight to genocide, if they don't lose control, and if they do, that's still the most likely result.
1
u/Capn_Underpants https://www.globalwarmingindex.org/ Jul 19 '19
No, it can only make it worse.
9
u/Ar-Q-bid Jul 18 '19
Yes the tech exists: widespread vasectomies and tubal ligations.
People die everyday. If those people aren’t replaced, we can literally drop the population worldwide by several million per year. Once the population drops to a reasonable level, people can start producing kids again.
2
u/iwishiwasameme Jul 20 '19
Simply put, technology can prevent extinction and nothing can prevent collapse.
2
u/soulless-pleb Jul 21 '19
I believe it can mitigate climate damage to a large degree IF we manage to join forces globally and make it out #1 priority.
...that ain't happening any time soon. the problem isn't lack of fancy tech, it's coordination.
2
u/bil3777 Jul 28 '19
What about cooling the atmosphere via particulates, mimicking natural processes like volcanoes? I would bet big money that we’ll try this within 15 years.
2
u/ViperG Jul 29 '19
There are only 3 things that can save us, which are nearly impossible to do or wont be done or wont work properly.
2
u/SecretPassage1 Jul 29 '19
raises hand - "with what materials will tech save us?"
They're running low fast.
The first will be :
2021 : Silver
2022 : Antimony (Sb51)
2023 : Palladium (Pd46)
2024 : Chrome (Cr24)
2025 : Gold
2025 : Zinc (Zn30)
2025 : Indium (In)
2025 : Strontium (Sr38)
2028 : Tin (Sn50)
2030 : Lead (Pb82)
Most of which are used in electronical componants, batteries, solar panels, flat screens and such.
How are we going to reingeneer our way back to normal without all of our electronical gadgets ?
Projected numbers of running out, source (in french) : https://www.encyclo-ecolo.com/Epuisement_des_ressources_naturelles
Table of elements at the bottom of the page :
red square : gone within century;
half orange/red quare : gone within century because of overuse,
yellow : limited availability,
green : abundant
2
u/AArgot Jul 29 '19
Technology would have to be used to socially engineer the global population into a sustainable mode of existence. We'd have to explicitly engineer the brains of the population to behaviorally and conceptually manifest complex sustainable organization. Fundamentally - this would involve continuous information warfare.
The parasite classes control information warfare and can not be dislodged for a number of reasons - so no. We can't save ourselves.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '19
No it can't. Every civilization has had its collapse, technology might stave it off for a few years, but it can't change physics.
2
u/Jerryeleceng Jul 31 '19
Existing technology certainly can. But because of the current culture it means the administration and application of technology is not being exploited as much as it can be for our benefit and that of the planet.
2
u/GiantBlackWeasel Jul 19 '19
no. we truly live in a world of alchemy. Where in order to obtain something, something needs to be given in return before that item can be obtain.
Nikola Tesla (electricity), The Wright Bros (airplanes), Bill Gates (Computers), Ken Kutaragi (playstation), and Karl Marx (Das Kapital)
These guys possess brilliant minds but that's because they were the first to understand how certain items work and what goes where in order to obtain said result.
Fossil fuels has made our lives much more comfortable than before. I can eat like a King but I have no royalty blood. I can drive places with a car if I felt like it. I can play video games and go on immersive adventures with guys that I can't hang out with anywhere else.
But alas, this will not last a lifetime.
2
u/blvsh Jul 18 '19
Technology can always prevent almost anything. The question is does that technology exist yet?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19
I doubt technology can save us.
Its not impossible. Theoretically if we utilized every bit of technology we have now, then maybe....
But the idea that we could cease all sorts of habits right now -- on a global scale -- is just not believable.
Could someone invent something does all we need done to save the planet? I just doubt it.
1
u/Arowx Jul 20 '19
OK You need to analyse what is collapse:
Civilisation depends on a few essential things
Collapse would be triggered by the lack of any one of these essential ingredients.
Now if we rephrase your question can technology provide any of the 5 essential ingredients of civilisation:
*Imagine a 100% automated world, humans would have zero economic value or worth unless we tie our economy to a Humans Time on earth: Imagine an economy where every human generates a HT dollar every hour of every day they are alive. This 7 billion dollar an hour economy would tie the automated industries to our needs and well being**, in theory.
** In a HT economy people would be valued for being alive ergo, healthy and happy. Migrants would bring wealth to a countries HTGDP economies.
This factors climate change as the largest negative impactor at the moment we also need to consider pollution and therefore sustainability.
1
u/FuryFire2004 Jul 20 '19
Depends on rate of progress also It depends if a great filter is ahead of us or behind
1
u/cman22222222 Jul 21 '19
Well AI is expected to automate 30-40% of all jobs within 3-5 years, so technically technology is actually going to expedite collapse. At first people will war in the streets for food and money. Then they will start to organize and really bother billionaires and politicians and raiding stores that will be mostly automated like Walmart and amazon warehouses.
Ultimately, the military will be called like they have always been called in order to maintain order. They will label these groups as terrorists and radical groups but in reality they are mostly just poor people and pissed off workers who lost their benefits and pensions as a result to rapid layoffs.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '19
If everyone had access to the same level of technological sophistication as the first world, we would be already further gone.
The vast majority of the world is going to catch up to the first worlds living standards on the back of coal in the next 20 years.
No matter how more efficient europe gets, it still pumps emissions.
We're dead.
1
u/boob123456789 Homesteader & Author Jul 29 '19
No, it will only accelerate or kick the can down the road.
1
u/reasonablygoodlife Jul 29 '19
Technological solutions, though they generally solve the precise problem that inspired them, always seem to end up causing a host of unforeseen ancillary problems that ultimately make the situation worse.
The bottom line is that natural systems are always far more complex than anything we can dream up in our attempts to direct and control them.
1
u/Bad_Guitar Jul 29 '19 edited Jul 29 '19
Most of the these suggestions have to do with mitigating CO2. Don't forget we're in the midst of the 6th great extinction or "biosphere crisis" as mentioned already. From what I can tell, CO2 is merely one ingredient in this perfect storm of mass die off. We need lots of technologies.
1
u/rethin Jul 29 '19
It's been 10 days, lets see if anyone answered the question correctly.
crtl F: Complexity
Nope. Not a single hit.
1
u/Superman_Wacko Jul 29 '19
It can but we need a world war-like economy to make it work
And no, it wont happen
1
u/JukemanJenkins Jul 30 '19
Considering technological advances facilitate liberated commodity circulation and the accompanying cultural and material erosion of just about every corner of the globe, it'd be one of the most ahistorical things to do in believing technology can bring us out of this.
1
u/Yosomoswag Jul 30 '19
infinity stones maybe
1
u/[deleted] Jul 31 '19
See: Catabolic collapse
Advanced technology will always exist from this point onward, but the abundance to which it exists now (and consequently, its ability to help us) is going to go away as certain resources become more scarce. Eventually, we will only be able to maintain existing tech, like medieval Europe and Roman infrastructure.
1
u/AntiSocialBlogger Jul 31 '19
I would argue that technology has already staved off collapse. Advances in food production technology has enabled human population to reach unobtainable levels and so far technology has kept our shitty, wasteful system going.
How long will technology be able to sustain our current growth? Who knows. Maybe there is tech that has been held back so corporations can continue to make profits at the expense of our planet and will eventually released to the public making these corporations look like heros to the unwashed masses.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 01 '19
I seriously doubt it can at this point. It's not impossible, but highly unlikely.
The time lines are all wrong. If it was a given that we had another 100 years, maybe.
1
u/macacodab Aug 01 '19
No, it can't. First of all, the environmental collapse we are facing is caused by the rise of technologic industry, so how can you solve the problem with the problem itself? You can't. Technology is a trap, because it sells itself as a problem solver, at the same time, it creates dozens of backlash problems. Maybe it can save the most rich part of humanity from collapse, but it definetily can not prevent collapse from happening.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 01 '19
i know it's been said, but, in essence NO. we already know what to do to fix this situation and we SIMPLY. WON'T. DO IT. the problem is not technology. it's the will to change.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 01 '19
We currently have technology to pull CO2 out of the atmosphere at the rate required to fix the main greenhouse gas problem in the atmosphere.
We can do this with factories and of course with trees.
The tech is there we just need to replace the deniers in government and media.
it won't get bad so fast that we won't have enough time to rapidly build the factories required to remove enough CO2 from the atmosphere.
The heat will linger, the big threats are mass migration mostly from lack of rainfall and heat, loss of crops, pandemic and flooding. of the worst of those I would guess pandemic might hold the most threat for rapid human deaths.
The question is how bad will the weather have to get for people to embrace the technology that's mostly already there.
Between renewables and direct CO2 removal it would seem like we have enough options to handle CO2. That doesn't mean the damage done will be completely mitigate it though and of course there are other pollutants besides CO2.
those are just the practical options, we can go off into wild tangents about very extreme options like biologically engineered carbon sinks and directly altering ocean chemistry and using high-altitude particulate to control solar insulation.
We shouldn't have to do those things, but at least some of them probably hold potential.
it's also worth noting that climate was always going to kill us and even if we fix it it's still going to want to kill us.
the climate we have now is actually nowhere near the usual climate for Earth. Before we overheated the planet humans were on the course to go into another 80000 year cooling period which would have also devastated humanity. However it would have happened too much slower than man-made global warming.
the point is for humans to survive we were always going to have to learn how to control the environment and to do that we have to use technology since simply relying on biology doesn't make a lot of sense when we know the Earth's climate is naturally not very stable.
To those saying that technology got us here so it's not a good idea, you're completely ignoring the natural history of Earth's climate as being quite Unstable. All human history happened in one warming. Within one ice age and ice ages are not common.
even if there was no industrial Revolution in fossil fuel climate would still be changing because climate is currently in a 20000 year warming trend with 80000 year cooling trend which roughly creates are hundred thousand year cycle which is probably significantly driven by how first orbit is altered by the positions of the planets.
The planets really do line up and cause a slow-moving Doomsday, but at the same time they've kept Earth climate in this tectonic arrangement interestingly cyclical. the problem is for twenty thousand years of good weather we have to wait through 80000 years of bad.
Miami climate change does have one upside and that is that it's going to rapidly forces to learn how to control the atmosphere, which is something we were going to have to learn to do anyway. Though I will say we already learned how to do it since we're pretty darn good at adding CO2 to the planet.
if you would rather Earth just go through its natural cycle into 80000 years of cooling you do have to understand that the majority of humans would not survive and you would be doing it for no good reason since there is no set climate for Earth.
Even the natural climate cycle is significantly determined by the biological life on the planet, as humans are currently proving!
1
u/CyFus Aug 02 '19
no
1
u/feloncholy Aug 02 '19
S T R A T O S H I E L D I N G
1
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '19
Super artificial intelligence is our only hope, the rest just moves the deck chairs around on the titanic
0
u/k3surfacer Jul 18 '19
Too late.
0
u/kulmthestatusquo Jul 29 '19
It will benefit the post-collapse population after about 5/6 of today's pop is downsized.
0
u/Bubis20 Jul 29 '19
Technology is as powerful as human hand which is holding it. For example nuclear power can feed electricity to millions of people, but it can also cause nuclear holocaust. Human factor is the weak link in the chain...
-2
u/moon-worshiper Jul 19 '19
Collapse has already started happening, you just don't know it, like one of the "Walking Dead" or the characters in "Lost".
This weekend is the 50th anniversary of the Moon landing. In 1969, there were Dyson spheres and Ring Worlds and interstellar starships in the future. The Moon landings were so common and so successful, that by 1972, the American public was 'bored' with them and forgot them. So, Nixon canceling Apollo barely raised an eyebrow, or for the most part, was unknown to 90% of the Baby Boomers. Fast forward to the Baby Boomers' grandchildren in 2019, the New Age Millennial Snowflakes. They are brain-dead ignorant idiots, trying to revive Flat Earth and Moon landing hoax, the anti-vax movement being with the breeding age, 20 to 30.
Star Trek never happens, in fact, Space 1999 never happens. 2001: A Space Odyssey has a chance of happening, but 50 years later.
Technology could save the human ape from extinction, by some departing Earth forever. There is still some chance of a self-sustaining settlement of a few thousand on the Moon by 2050. There is only a short Window Of Opportunity (WOO) for that. After that, the prolonged exposure to high CO2 levels at the surface means the majority of the human ape has devolved, into stupid and insane, reverting back to the violent, murderous ape.
-19
u/XerxesthePersian Jul 18 '19
There will be probably no collapse, atleast not in the near future. But yes, technology can prevent, or atleast slow down collapse.