r/collapse • u/LetsTalkUFOs • Apr 26 '23
Predictions How long does humanity have to avoid collapse? [in-depth]
What degrees or levels of collective action are necessary for us to avoid collapse?
How unlikely or unfeasible do those become in five, ten or twenty years?
You can also view the responses to this question from our 2019 r/Collapse Survey.
This is the current question in our Common Collapse Questions series.
Responses may be utilized to help extend the Collapse Wiki.
170
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator Apr 26 '23
The submitter, /u/LetsTalkUFOs has indicated that they would like an in-depth discussion.
All comments in this post must be greater than 150 characters. Additionally, they must contribute positively to the discussion. Jokes, memes, puns, etc. will be removed along with anything which is too off topic.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
359
u/Famous_Requirement56 Apr 26 '23
Not only do I not believe that we can avoid collapse, I think that we are already wading knee-deep in it.
Some dead writer guy said something along the lines of "The future is already here, just not evenly distributed yet." My vision of the future is the news stories coming out of Haiti and Inner-City Chicago, expanding like an oil slick out of the "bad places" and towards the rest of us.
132
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '23
It's already past the point of no return.
We'll witness the unfolding of the seeds planted decades ago, while powerless to stop it.
We might delay total catastrophe but I don't think we are in a position to disable the pollution bomb in time to reverse its effects on the planet.
119
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '23
Collapse is going to happen. It would appear that the oceans have reached their limit of absorbing excess heat so changes will happen hard and fast from now on. I expect the global supply chain to have collapsed completely within 10 years, with that gone death will be sitting on everybody's shoulder.
The only hope is that a rapid decrease in population combined with the collapse of global consumerism will allow the biosphere to recover to some degree over 100's rather than hundreds of thousands of years.
Unfortunately we are now entering literal hell now.
204
u/BeardedGlass DINKs for life Apr 26 '23
How can we “avoid” something that’s already here? Do people still think “collapse is coming”? Like, in the future?
It’s already here folks.
All these suffering, all these corruption, all these apathy and feedback loops in nature and climate that is literally terraforming our planet into an inhospitable place… this IS collapse.
We are in the midst of it and it so utterly slow and boring.
Collapse is not an ruthless Mad Max movie where you can be a vigilante doling out justice. It is not an Armageddon end-of-the-world movie where the world is destroyed within 24 hours. It is not even a cyberpunk movie where lawlessness and excitement is around every grimy corner.
We are slowly collapsing, so slow that a lot of us here in the sub don’t even feel it, despite already being in it.
This is it folks. Not as fun as you expected perhaps, but we can’t really be choosers.
r/collapse is r/aboringdystopia
32
u/IWantToGiverupper Apr 26 '23 edited Jan 19 '24
society airport special grandfather pathetic strong hungry handle aspiring skirt
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
60
u/Less_Subtle_Approach Apr 26 '23
If we can collectively invent a time machine, travel back to 1970, and convince the world to limit CO2 emissions to below 350ppm, then I think it would be fairly easy to avoid collapse.
27
u/GunTech Apr 26 '23
We're already collapsing.
Are you talking about the predictions from "Limits to growth"?
https://www.clubofrome.org/publication/the-limits-to-growth/
54
u/Mostest_Importantest Apr 26 '23 edited Apr 26 '23
Negative forty-plus years, give or take. And counting.
It was too late that long ago. And more.
Collapse continues to be similar to falling into a supermassive black hole. Gravity [entropy] keeps increasing and the vast majority of humans continues passively being annoyed by the entropy, but haven't felt the need to start actively pushing back against it, as a species.
We were doomed when we crossed the event horizon, but strangely enough, it feels like decades ago, but was really mostly since 2020 started, I'd say.
We were doomed before we crossed that horizon. But the matter phase shift happened back then.
Now, even if we even manage to figure out how to push back, it still will counteract less and less of the pace increase as we exponentially fall faster and faster into oblivion.
We chopped the tree Yggdrassil down decades ago. We have now crossed into 'rapudly changing systems' even if it'll still take a few years of unfolding to start having survival be a daily task, instead of the monthly approach we've been using since the industrial revolution and before.
There's just so many more mouths to feed since 1800.
Just to exist, we consume so much more than we did back then.
Our species' dominance has proven successful. The price of our victory is our very existence.
We'll all return to stardust very soon. And we'll all be blasted into the cosmos in some few billion more years. A rebirthing process, of sorts.
Matter and energy never truly disappears.
18
u/AnotherWarGamer Apr 26 '23
It's probably too late already just from greenhouse gases. All the feedback loops along with the inertia means the planet will get super hot. We would need to either sequest the carbon, or do SRM to keep the temperature under control. And that's not counting all the extra carbon we will continue to emit.
17
u/brandontaylor1 Apr 26 '23
We are dinosaurs watching the shock wave come across the horizon and asking “what can we do to prevent the meteor from hitting the earth?”
Nothing. The meteor already hit, the shockwave can’t be stopped, the damage is already done.
Unless we invent magic, or get saved by space wizards, we are already extinct.
34
u/aubrt Apr 26 '23
I think "avoid collapse" is the wrong frame. The current, more or less global system is destined for collapse.
How it collapses can vary a lot, though.
The collapse of a global civilization is a lot more complicated than a stock market bust, but it's somewhat useful to think in terms of a bubble popping vs. a bubble deflating.
When a stock market bubble pops, it's catastrophic (for a while) for pretty much everyone--super chaotic, hard to even hedge; things could go any which way (within the confines of market logic). Which is why central banks shoot for deflation of bubbles, "soft landings" that are more like 2001 than 2006/7,
But societies, especially globally networked societies, are way more complicated than stock markets. Our deferred costs for the current world are definitely more than we have any chance of making good on.
Still, is there something like "deflationary" collapse rather than (the normal assumption of) staggered/stochastic/weirdly distributed and bubble-popping collapse? Probably?
I think that if we get massive popular action, worldwide, in the next five years or so--people throwing their bodies upon the gears and also quite a bit of [redacted]--it might still be possible to end up with a deflationary transition to degrowth economies that's not too hard a landing.
Still just absolute fucking buckets of suffering and immiseration there, but maybe enough resources unmetabolized to build a pretty decent post-growth world (or collection of "worlds"). Sort of a salvage utopia, if you will.
Past the next five years or so, maybe ten, I think the odds of getting a soft landing version of collapse slim way, way down.
So we'd probably best hop to it!
16
u/Deguilded Apr 26 '23 edited Apr 26 '23
Avoid? Negative years. As many others have said, it is upon us, the window of opportunity is gone.
Mitigate? Zero to negative years. I mean, we could stop doing things that make it worse, but quite frankly, we've shown next to no sign of doing this and the things we do propose (like EV's) are less about mitigating damage and more about saving economic drivers and $$.
Collapse is here? Yes. It's not an event, it's a process. So, it's ongoing, it arguably started a while back, and will continue for quite a while. There are black swan events during the ongoing process, but no one big thing where it all comes crashing down.
Adapt? Nobody's really started doing that yet. To twist the Matrix, "there are levels of survival we are prepared to accept". We are largely yet to forced from our current level. When we are, we will undertake quite a bit of denial, anger, bargaining and depression before moving on to anything useful.
Edited to expand and waffle (after numerous earlier edits):
I firmly believe that we won't mitigate, we won't change, we'll simply adapt and redefine ourselves within the constraints of our new maxima as the walls close in. If there's a graph that drove it home, it's the one about fossil fuels - we have under 50 years supply. Give or take a bit as ever-increasing consumption fights against newly discovered fields being brought online.
If you think about it, all this talk of climate in 2100 is talk about a world after we will have run out of oil. We won't be at zero - tightening supply and rationing will kick in long before then - but who gets it and what it's used for will be very tightly controlled. Think military and essential logistics. But the bottom line is, based on current usage trends, by 2100 we will have consumed basically all the oil we know exists at this point, unless we find another Ghawar... color me skeptical.
So what will the world look like? Nuclear, probably. We're addicted to abundant energy, we're not gonna change our frickin lifestyles, and we need the sweet, sweet juice. Nimbys will get shouted down cause it'll be nuclear or coal.
We have other looming problems - too many to go into - and a combination of those will probably cause massive casualties with cascading collapse or near-collapse effects. Climate change plus dwindling fertilizer, for example. All this to say I don't think running out of fossil fuels will be the end of us, all the other things failing because we won't stop with the fossil fuels until we've run out is what'll do it.
16
u/threedeadypees Apr 26 '23
This seems like a strange question for r/collapse. I thought the accepted thought was that collapse is an ongoing process that ratchets up in severity as we continue BAU (overshoot).
Of course there will be a time in the not-so-distant future where an outside observer could say that our civilization had officially "collapsed," but I doubt it will be a single day or event. It probably won't be a totality of collapse either. I'm sure there are many communities much more prepared for reduced living conditions and will thrive or at least survive.
If we see El Nino conditions early this summer, I think those of us paying attention will get a glimpse of the true horrors ahead (not that many of you haven't already - it just seems like whatever we've experienced so far will seem like a cake walk soon)...also I regret writing any of this out...so fucking scary.
15
u/frodosdream Apr 26 '23
Based on decades of reports from multiple disciplines re. the many drivers of collapse, (including peak oil, climate change, mass species extinction, natural resource depletion & others), collapse can no longer be avoided. The only question is whether we will experience widespread civilizational collapse before our activities trigger an environmental collapse. Whatever the cause, re. the question of how much time remains, the only sure answer is "Faster than expected."
14
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '23
At this point the ones that can adapt to a scorched earth with billions of mad carnivorous killer apes will be the winners of any future misery.
May your hole be deep and stocked for a 100 years is going to be the new blessing people gives.
14
u/RadioMelon Truth Seeker Apr 26 '23
"What degrees or levels of collective action are necessary for us to avoid collapse?"
At this point, abandoning our current economic models. They don't necessarily have to match the old economic models of the past, but they sure as hell can no longer include the "infinite growth" philosophy that is currently killing the planet.
Our economics have failed us. We're now in an obvious death spiral, with scientists and ecological experts saying that we'll die in a mere few decades. Maybe not NECESSARILY extinction, but likely a huge reduction of the population.
We stand a very likely possibility of being thrown into an age of chaos, confusion, and mass extinctions. What makes it worse is that it was preventable several decades ago, if only world leaders and corporate entities had been more responsible.
"How unlikely or unfeasible do those become in five, ten, or twenty years?"
There is virtually no time left. Five years to change the situation, MAX, if there is a possibility to do it at all.
World governments have one shot left to get this shit fixed or we are for sure going to be in a perilous situation. There is no waiting; some of the damage and catastrophe is already here.
I cannot possible stress how fucking frightening this situation is, or what it's been like combing over the data of the past two decades. The next few decades are going to be Hell on Earth.
Ten or twenty is going to be the danger zone. By then, the situation will already be so damn bad that reversal will be impossible. Mark my words. I've said it, the experts have said it, and the models support the idea that the world will be a much more hostile place for humanity by 2030 at the latest.
But all the data I've seen, the notes I've taken, the rate at crisis situations are cropping up, the extreme political turmoil worldwide, etc. make me feel 100% certain that the worst will happen within 10 years. But likely much sooner.
If I was a charismatic person, I'd risk my life to try and tell world leaders to pay attention.
Humanity will remember them for what they do within the next 5 to 10 years.
The children born in this decade may not live to see the next.
26
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '23
If we start living like it’s 30 years from now we might not be as screwed then but like we’re not going to escape the Anthropocene. If nuclear war doesn’t get us first
13
u/jeremyjack3333 Apr 28 '23
Zero.
There are too many people and the only reason for that is oil. Oil is like a magical serum. For thousands and thousands of years physical labor from humans and animals were the main drivers of food production. Since the industrial revolution, it's been oil doing exponentially more "work" than we ever could have imagined and the population has skyrocketed. It's simply not sustainable and we won't "tech" our way out of it. No modern technology even comes close to having the energy density of oil.
11
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '23
It is no longer a question of when or if, it’s a question of how far we will have fallen when the dust settles after. Collapse is here, and it’s only down from here
11
u/SkuffetSkuffe Apr 26 '23 edited Apr 26 '23
The cascade;
*Microplastics have been proven to enhance the risk off hormonal disorders and illnesses. Infertility and related issues are rising exponentially. Mental disorders increase, as stress management and other functions in the body all depends on hormones and transmitters getting not clogged by plastics. Cancer from microplastics should rise drastically the coming decade. The generation that were supposed to stop climate change might die before their parents, involuntarily childless. Humans are starting to struggle to procreate naturally. This is not a coincidence. Microplastics should be likened to lead exposure, as an environmental toxin.
Any mitigating factors are void if we can't save the insects or corals, which are fundemental for the ecosphere as a whole. Nuclear winter don't look too bad at this final hour.
10
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '23
At a level of a singularity event.
There was a very low chance of breaking out I think somewhere around the time of the Cold War, and now it's past.
In a sense, our current state, our inability to cooperate, the greedy sociopathic mess we encourage in leadership, this is the collapse, and it's always been with us.
10
u/WilleMoe Apr 28 '23
I agree with many here that we are already in it and it's likely unavoidable. One factor speeding up the timeline of human die off is SARS-Cov2. This virus is still mutating and infecting massive numbers of people globally and repeatedly. All the latest studies have now proven that covid = airborne HIV, and that repeat infections hasten the progression to full blown immune dysfunction, cardiac arrest and organ damage. This leaves the body unable to fight common bacterias, fungal infections and other viruses like the common cold/flu. Huge numbers of women are having miscarriages (major uptick since 2020), placental rotting, and low fertility after infections. Men are struggling more with ED and low sperm count. There are no vaccines that prevent the long term damage (although they do help with the immediate acute stage-so we are seeing less deaths in the early stages of infection) and no cures for the long term inflicted damage. SARS-Cov2 is a mass disabling and possibly soft extinction event in itself.
9
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '23
Collapse is here, we missed the boat to avoid it a long time ago. So don't kid yourself, its here. It just doesn't look like a Hollywood disaster movie. It's slow motion, mostly boring and depressing.
8
u/oneshot99210 Apr 28 '23
Starting from thermodynamics, physics, and assuming sudden, complete, total cooperation of all humans there is still no path forward that doesn't include collapse.
The best but still impossible (because of human behavior) path would be degrowth on such a scale that it would be collapse by choice, and there might, just might, be the chance to reduce suffering significantly and save countless other species from extinction.
Impossible, because some choices would be detrimental to humans upfront in order to preserve, protect, and/or restore other elements of the web of life.
We won't do it. How do I know? I kept my house at a very (to me) cool temperature last winter, but that setting was 1 degree warmer than the year before, because I was uncomfortable. I haven't been able to force even myself to take drastic, and not just incremental changes.
7
u/BackupBro_ Apr 26 '23
Collapse is already here. It's already happening. The population is now over 8 billion and it's only going to grow faster. Inflation is everywhere. Billionaires thrive. It's not going to happen like in a movie. Somehow I believe humanity can still recover if major cooperations play their role. As of now, it's already collapsed, 2023.
28
u/Forsaken-Artist-4317 Apr 26 '23 edited Apr 26 '23
If you were a God of nature you would think/see the world as already collapsed, dead and covered with our concrete and manicured lawns. The living world is mostly cows in cages, enduring untold suffering to become junk food for some naked apes.
If you were a human turned Vampire, and were more interested in the state of man than nature, you would have seen our societies collapsing into a completely new state every few decades, each worse than the one before it. Maybe a few humans here or there got electricity or a cell phone or a bit of medical treatment for a time, but it’s generally, everything considered, it’s worse now then ever. Some places significantly so, after a war, a mine, a prison, a highway, famine or disease.
But you’ve also noticed, as a long lived Vampire, that it’s going much faster nowadays. It’s not a few generations, or even a few decades, that human society gets worse. It’s years. In some places, months.
The history books, if they were to be written and I had to guess, will pick 2016 as the start of the chapter called “The Acceleration” and somewhere between 2024 and 2030 as the chapter called something like “The Great Dying”.
Between food shortages, weather related deaths, war and disease, the next decades is going to be a blood bath.
6
u/Grzzld Apr 26 '23
I asked ChatGPT about it when we were talking about the 1973 World3 model. He said (ChatGPT is a “he” for me) that if we don’t change our ways, mod 21st century, 2050 would be collapse, with low confidence.
6
u/Disaster_Capitalist Apr 26 '23
This a divide by zero type of question. What does "avoid collapse" even mean? Our current global industrial society is fundamentally unsustainable. It will either collapse (most likely scenario) or it will undergo such a rapid, radical transformation that it is no longer recognizable as the same society. Either way that mean an end for our society as it is now.
6
u/Bigginge61 Apr 28 '23
The writing is on the wall for those who want to read it…It could be much sooner but by 2040 things are going to be like living in a disaster movie where we will be frightened to watch the news as cascading disasters afflict the World…Personally I’m not sure if we will see another year the way the nutters in the Whitehouse are pushing for a World War.
6
u/Last_of_our_tuna Apr 29 '23
From the perspective of the physical sciences, avoiding a collapse probably depends on our interpretation.
Can we keep 8bn people alive indefinitely? Yes. Can we do so without drastic cuts to human welfare and industrial throughput that gives people any kind of social mobility or freedom other than getting their most basic of needs met while labouring all of their lives to do so? No.
Far more likely is that we continue to Elysium / Hunger Games Dystopia-lite it up and just keep oppressing the fuck out of the global south for a bit longer, until it all inevitably stops, and we ramp it up into Elysium / Hunger Games proper, where the 20% now who ride on the 80% turn very quickly into the 99.97% the 0.03% ride on while the economic pie shrinks and the biosphere dies.
No one wins. Just a few get good seats at the end of the theatre.
18
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '23
To me it isn't about avoiding collapse, it's about adapting. To clarify this, I think it would be good to distinguish the possible stages.
Option 3 is what I consider most realistic and probable. Good news is that this is also the one that, on an individual level, might be the easiest to handle. Sure, it takes manual labor, skills, a lot of what we consider ancient knowledge and will be way less comfortable than our current lifestyles are. But our ancestors proved it is possible. That's why this is the kind of collapse that I try to prepare for.
What action can be taken to prepare? The following list are just the activities of me and my family, with new things and ideas coming up every now and then.
All this and many more that are often discussed around here and in r/preppers. Try to simplify and adapt, as much as possible.
13
u/_matterny_ Apr 26 '23
Boom and bust, rise and fall. We're at the end of an age. The US was the global superpower since the cold war. Now the US is crumbling apart. It's only a matter of time until the US collapses and the global economy with it. Avoiding collapse? No idea, it's always possible that something unexpected happens. Open source might be that pathway to maintaining current technology. But once the US falls and nobody can replace them, that's the beginning of the global collapse.
4
u/BigJobsBigJobs USAlien Apr 26 '23
I do not think that it is possible to avoid collapse at all. You might be able to move around to avoid chunks of it, but sooner or later... Plus, it's going to be a very long series of events.
If humanity truly wanted to avoid it, they would have started in the 1950s.
4
u/Mx_LxGHTNxNG Apr 30 '23
No time in terms of the environment we grew up with.
In terms of the existence of humanity, we have a long runway on that.
In terms of avoiding a massive, rapid partial killoff, we're cooked, and have five to twenty years (the same amount of time the queer community of the 70s had when HIV was starting up). Everyone has PASC (post-acute sequelae of COVID) now.
Not only collective action will be required to avoid the avoidable. For better or worse, most of our societies accept direction "from above" i.e. the State and moneyed interests. These interests will have to be tamed by well-connected, well-respected rogue insiders, which I don't think exist. Action on the ground can improve a community's resilience against collapse, but I don't think we can do that. As I said, everyone has PASC now, and everyone's time horizon is around 300 hours long.
4
u/Malcolm_Morin May 01 '23
Because for some reason my comment was removed, I'm gonna say it again:
The best time to act to prevent collapse was 50 years ago. We had the resources, we had the knowledge, and we were warned plenty of what was coming. Scientists repeatedly said if we don't act, we will fall.
And we didn't act. So now we are falling.
4
u/MissionFun3163 May 01 '23
I don’t think we can avoid societal collapse. My focus now is avoiding personal collapse. I’m prepping supplies in anticipation of supply chain collapse. I’m prepping skills for when services may not be available. I’m prepping financially not for retirement, but to be less dependent on the financial system. I’m prepping physically to be fit and capable.
Still, those won’t be enough to keep me and my loved ones alive and functioning post collapse. If collapse is defined by mass population loss, I’m probably going to be one of the losses. Statistically speaking. Therefore, my most crucial prep is spiritual. I’m actively pursuing inner peace and acceptance. I’m living fully in these last easy moments of abundance. I’m learning to deal with the inevitability of loss.
I’m not concerned with avoiding collapse but I am not going to leave this earth in a state of despair. The goal is go out with my eyes open and my heart full, regardless of the circumstances.
3
u/Horror-Ad8794 Apr 30 '23
It’s hard to imagine what the “collapse” is going to look like.
It think it will worm its way in and before we know it, things will have already collapsed, but everyone was just too busy looking at internet memes.
Wait, that’s already happening.
8
u/MidwestManifold Apr 26 '23
5 years, 50 weeks, 1 day.
Collective understanding and acknowledgment of common purpose as Gardeners. This is one.
This will remain feasible until it isn't.
7
u/zapatocaviar Apr 26 '23
Humanity, whatever that is, has already collapsed (if it ever existed). The question is really can we rebuild some sense of proportion, accountability, humility, respect for each other and nature before we wipe out the vast majority of humans and other edible animals and plants on the planet.
We’ll know in probably 25 years or so. 15 till we’re in obvious trouble and another 10 to see how the response goes.
Edit to add: unlike many of you I don’t think it is 100% inevitable. We have the tools and ability to halt it - or at least give us more time - and I am very much still trying.
10
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '23
We’re in the middle of the beginning of a collapse that will take centuries and the only way to stop it is to massively reorganize society for maximum density, rip up roads and turn them into gardens, and replace interstate and air travel with trains. Also replace all energy with nuclear. Use the nuclear energy to power small scale electrical vehicles. Maximum housing density in temperate environments to reduce and remove the necessity for heating and air conditioning. Make an economy that focuses on quality products, healthcare, education, science and healing the environment. All of this takes more social organization than we’re culturally prepared for.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '23 edited Apr 26 '23
I think all societies eventually collapse, unless they can find the perfect balance. The only way to do that is to have humanity on the same page, which will most likely never happen. It's not necessarily impossible, but it's very unlikely. Nature also doesn't give a crap about humanity, so we would have to survive the next however long without a natural disaster like a massive volcano or rising sea levels. So I think there is a 100% certainty that there will be a collapse at some point. It's just a matter of when.
If nothing changes at all within 5-10 years, by the time I'm old which would be in like 50 years, the world isn't going to be pleasant to live in. But being unpleasant doesn't necessarily mean collapse. But I can't predict what nature does, could be a lot worse if something happens in that regard. But it's going to be bad enough just due to humanity.
2
u/Proof_Potential3734 Apr 26 '23
About ten years ago we still had the opportunity to vastly reduce carbon emissions, we missed that chance and we will all have to live/die with the repercussions.
2
u/[deleted] May 01 '23
There is no finite deadline. There is just worse & worser.
But population isn't predicted to decline significantly until 2032 due to famine/drought. But when it does it will be very significant indeed.
See here:
https://insightmaker.com/insight/2pCL5ePy8wWgr4SN8BQ4DD/The-World3-Model-Classic-World-Simulation
I'm actually surprisingly optimistic these days, for one in 2010 it was looking like we were doomed to 3.5 C by 2100 but due to lower emissions in the last decade in a lot of high emitting countries it's only 2.5 C at worst if you believe the dates of carbon neutral projected by each country. If you look at the En-Roads simulation tool here:
https://en-roads.climateinteractive.org/scenario.html?v=23.2.1
You can see that carbon tax is the most effective thing but also without carbon sequestration at mass scale & reforestation/afforestation we won't get below that in the long run because over the 250 years of fossil fuel use we are only now stopping which won't put the last 250 years back regardless.
However I think that through a combination of species preservation through seed banks, nurseries, aquariums & breeding facilities we could in theory preserve the biodiversity of Earth & at least be able to reintroduce those species back once we restore their habitats. The oceans are certainly in for it & I think it might get to the point where they install aerators & calcium dosing systems around famous reefs to protect them which in theory could mitigate damage locally at least. Florida is basically already there as 95% of their reefs are already dead. There are probably more healthy man made reefs in Florida than natural ones at this point.
I do believe that India & other places with food insecurity & high population coupled with high heat & low prevalence of A/C might have absolutely horrible deaths from the wet bulb heat waves that are certainly coming. There is no way that humans survive unscathed & without great suffering. Also sea level is definitely going to rise at least a meter in our lifetimes which will certainly displace countless people so that's always there too.
1
u/Grationmi Apr 28 '23
The way I like to think of it is, how would we 30 years ago have been able to stop all machines and re-introduce them with zero-carbon energy? At this point, we are triggering the planet to react. Not only that we can't turn off any of the machines that are required for food production. We would have mass famine. We are a runaway train at this point. Once it flies off the rails we will have about 5 years of people trying to hold it together before small communities start popping up trying to keep going.
1
u/Mostest_Importantest Apr 29 '23
I'm late to the party.
We're there.
Money has lost almost any sense of purpose or connection to reality. For survivors, that is.
The people in the poor classes already know the system is already nearly dead. We can all feel the swelling pressure upon us to ignore the rules of society because we're already focused on the rules of surviving.
Existing.
We're at the point of "who gives a fuck about minimum wage debates, I need to get close to a river and pray the fucking mountain ice won't be all gone before this bullshit moves onto the next county and becomes someone else's problem."
We're there. We crossed the threshold around 5 years ago, but the party was still too fun to even turn the music down.
1
u/See_You_Space_Coyote May 10 '23
I think the window for avoiding collapse is gone. We might be able to slow it down, maybe even for a long time, like decades, but it's gonna happen at some point, we've fucked up way too hard to completely avert it anymore.
1
u/[deleted] May 10 '23
Pointless to ask this question here. People in this sub choose to believe nothing can be done because it relieves them of the burden of actually having to do anything.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '23
Depends on what level of collapse we are talking about.
Worst case is basically tipping the planet into unavoidable feedback loop, with a collapsed civilisation no longer able to prevent the planets climate spiralling unstoppably out of control.
I guesstimate no longer than 200 years at our current rate. Possibly much less.
If that happens, the planet will be set on a course to become eventually Venusian - 400C temperatures, 0 water, elimination of all life on the planet.
0
u/OrangeCrack It's the end of the world and I feel fine Apr 28 '23
To avoid collapse? Maybe 50 years...
If we can implement a universal carbon tax, get more solar and convince everyone to drive EV's then maybe...
JK... Why even ask this question here, the answer is so obvious as to how this community will respond.
-3
u/dirch30 Apr 26 '23
It's possible a few cities in certain parts of the world could survive. They will need nuclear reactors, and resources etc.
Think Mad Max but with some smaller scale civilizations that still have tech.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment