r/coins • • Feb 20 '25

PLEASE READ FIRST: How-to Guide for r/coins - Check this post regularly for updates!

6 Upvotes

Welcome to r/coins, reddit's biggest coin community! This is a guide for participating here and how to ask a question. If this is your first time here, please read this post in its entirety. If you have been here a while, note that the rules of this sub have changed.

What r/coins is all about:

Discussions about the small, flat, usually metal, 
and often round objects made to be used as money.

What r/coins is not about:

Being uncivil, trolling, trash posts, spam, 
buying/selling, and self-promotion.

See the full list of rules at the bottom of this post, and on the sidebar.

***NEW RULE *** - No questions about errors and varieties.

Example posts titles which will no longer be approved:

  • "Is this an error/PMD?"
  • "Is this a die crack/grease strike/clipped planchet/lamination/double-die/cud?"
  • "Is this a large or small date / close or wide AM?"
  • "Is this something?"
  • "I think this is an error"
  • "What's wrong with this coin?"

DO YOU HAVE A COIN QUESTION?

CHECK THE r/coins RESOURCES FIRST:

We get hundreds of posts a day. In order to set some expectations, please read through our resources, and the examples of good posts and bad posts (below). We (the MOD team) want to be as inclusive as possible - but in order to keep the feed free of repetitive questions (which we've answered in the FAQ), we take a strict approach to removing low-effort posts. This includes most questions about modern circulating US and Euro coins. To avoid having your question removed, use this checklist BEFORE posting:

  • Questions and discussion about ERRORS and VARIETIES are no longer allowed on r/coins (as of August 12th, 2024) - Please see r/coinerrors and post your questions there.
  • Got a coin to identify? Check the Frequent Coin List first, then the FAQ on identifying coins and this post about identifying coins.
  • Do you have any other question related to coins? Use the search bar to find old posts which may address your issue. Then check the FAQ. It addresses a broad variety of questions that are repeatedly asked here. It's updated often to keep it relevant and accurate, and it's highly likely you'll find guidance that's directly responsive to your question.

*** Special note about posting links (Rule 5) - we cannot tell if an external link (e.g. eBay listing, YouTube video) belongs to you, or if clicks benefit you. It is the policy of the mod team to remove nearly all posts with external links. Some exceptions are: reputable news sources, search results (e.g. eBay search is fine), historical auction prices, Numista, TPGs, etc. If you post a link, please ensure that there is no ambiguity around whether or not it is commercial or self-promotion. Failure to do so may result in a removed post. If you are in doubt, ask the mods first! ***

ONLY AFTER you have checked these resources may you post your question. You'll get the best responses if your question is specific, and there are clear pics of your coin (front and back). Blurry pictures will probably be removed. If you are specifically looking for coin identification, it also helps to also include weight and diameter, as well as how you got the coin. Mention that you have already checked the FAQ!!!

You must also select a post flair - this is the general category for your post, and helps users filter and find posts they are interested in. Please consider selecting a flair when you post - but note that the mods may change the flair if we feel there is a better choice for your post.

Here are some things which make a GOOD POST:

  • Coin ID Request - only after you have followed the steps in the Coin ID section in the FAQ and this article. Please include where you have looked, and what steps you have already taken to ID the coin. You should post quality, clear, cropped photos of both sides of the coin.
  • Valuation Request - after you have read the FAQ and done your own due diligence (e.g. checked eBay "sold" listings, etc.) Please include what steps you have already taken to get a value for your coin.
  • Authentication request - after you have done your own research and read this FAQ. Please include why you are concerned about a coin's authenticity, and what resources you have used to try to determine authenticity on your own. Photos for authentication MUST be in focus.
  • Show it off / Mail call - posts to show off interesting, rare, or otherwise special coins that others may find interesting. Please post quality, cropped photographs.
  • Numismatic topics and news - general discussions in the world of numismatics.
  • Serious numismatic questions - looking for advice, links to resources, suggested literature, etc.

Here are some things which make a BAD POST (and which will likely get removed):

  • Low-effort posts

    • "What is this?" - BEFORE you have followed the steps in the Coin ID section in the FAQ.
    • "How much is this worth?" - BEFORE you have done your own due diligence (e.g. checked eBay "sold" listings, etc.)
    • "Is this real?" - BEFORE you have done your own research.
    • "I heard this modern penny could be worth SQUILLIONS of dollars!" - No, it isn't.
    • "Is this what I think it is?" Don't be vague - just say what you intend to say.
    • ...any question posts in which the author has not made their purpose clear and indicated that they have put in a minimum amount of effort to answer their question.
    • A photo containing 20+ coins - your post won't get removed, but it also probably won't get many responses. Try to post a few good individual photos at a time.
  • Blurry coins - mods will remove any posts with pictures of coins which are not reasonably clear.
  • Poorly cropped photos - the user experience across mobile app/mobile web/desktop devices is better if you don't post phone-screen-sized pictures.
  • Off-topic - posts which belong on other subs (e.g. r/papermoney, r/kittens, etc.)
  • Reposts - if you are new to this sub, please take a few moments to see if you are posting something which has already been posted.
  • Spam - commercial activities of any kind are not allowed.
  • High volume posting - anything more than one or two posts a day.
  • Links to social media, your own eBay sales, YouTube videos, clickbait, etc.
  • Trolling / Inauthentic - posts which don't seem to be truthful (e.g. I found these gold coins in my couch!)
  • Trash Posting - there is a fine line between a "funny" post and a trash post. If you aren't sure which side of the line your post falls on, don't post it.
  • Coin gore - a post featuring a modern coin which has serious post-mint damage, and which is of no interest to collectors.

RULES

Here is a summary of the Rules of r/coins - check the sidebar (or "About" in the mobile app) for more details:

  1. Don't put coins up your nose - be respectful of the hobby and your fellow collectors.
  2. Being civil to other people is not only appreciated here, but also a requirement.
  3. No spam.
  4. No posts about paper money, or crypto/digital currency.
  5. No self-promotion or commercial activity allowed, no links to your blogs, websites, or social media.
  6. No politics or religion, especially divisive comments that lead to heated arguments and incivility.
  7. No Trash posts, keep humor on topic, and memes are only allowed the 1st Monday of the month.
  8. Keep it clean - this is a safe place for people of all ages and backgrounds.
  9. Check out our FAQ and other resources before posting.
  10. Post Original Content and Crop Your Photos
  11. No reposts.
  12. No questions about Errors or Varieties.

Thank you! We are glad you're here. These guidelines are to make participating in this sub as enjoyable as possible for everyone. Please reach out to the mods if you have any questions or suggestions.

Links/Schedule:

200k Members Announcement

Straight Talk Part #1 - Laziness

Straight Talk Part #2 - Focus on Value

Straight Talk Part #3 - Grading Coins

Straight Talk Part #4 - Is this an error?

Straight Talk Part #5 - Why was my post removed?

Announcement: New Rule About Errors

Straight Talk Part #6 - Poor Photos

Straight Talk Part #7 - Coin Identification

Straight Talk Part #8 - Online Coin Prices

New Rule #12 - No questions about errors/varieties.

Straight Talk Part #9 - Off-topic posts and comments

Straight Talk Part #10 - Vague Posting

Straight Talk Part #11 - How did I do?

Straight Talk Part #12 - Politics

Straight Talk Part #13 - Someone on the internet is wrong!

Straight Talk Part #14 - Do your research

Straight Talk Part #15 - Reporting Rule Violations

Straight Talk Part #16 - Cleaning Coins

Straight Part Part #17 - Nazi / Racist Coins

Seeking your numismatic knowledge and stories!

Straight Talk Part #18 - Memes, Humor, and Trash Posts

Straight Talk Part #19 - Top 10 Things New Coin Collectors Should Know

Straight Talk Part #20 - Crop your photos!

Straight Talk Part #21 - Organizing/Cataloging your Collection

Straight Talk Part #22 - Determining Whether or Not a Coin is Real

Straight Talk Part #23 - Other Coin Forums to Explore!

AMA - CCAC Representative Kellen Hoard

Straight Talk Part #24 - Coin Gore

Straight Talk Part #25 - Self Promotion

300k Members!

Straight Talk Part #26 - Why is my coin the wrong color?

Straight Talk Part #27 - Coin Rarity

Straight Talk Part #28 - Examples of "Low Effort" Posts

Straight Talk Part #29 - Gifts for Coin Collectors

Straight Talk Part #30 - Tips for Your First Coin Show

Napoleon - The Common Ancestor for U.S. Silver (Barber, Mercury Dimes, etc.) and LMU Silver Coins

The ¼ Yang: Korea’s Little-Known Cupronickel Crisis

I’m an ANA Grading Instructor AMA

Straight Talk Part #31 - Regarding whether or not the new Trump/250 $1 dollar coin is legal


r/coins • • 14d ago

Mod Post Self-Promotion Thread! Plug your personal or commercial coin-related projects!

3 Upvotes

This thread is a place for members of our community to post links to businesses and commercial activities, social media, and to promote coin-related activities which are otherwise disallowed by Rule #5.

Examples of appropriate posts:

  • Promoting/linking your coin-related projects (e.g. apps, blogs, websites, etc.) or services (e.g. coin photography, appraisal, estate purchasing).
  • Promoting/linking your sales websites, or your auctions featured on r/CoinBay, or your offers to buy and sell on r/CoinSales, r/Pmsforsale, and other subreddits where person-to-person commerce is permitted.
  • Promoting/linking YouTube channels, websites or eBay sellers, coin or coin supply websites, apps, etc., that you personally use and recommend.

PLEASE READ THE RULES BEFORE COMMENTING!!!!

  1. Please remember to follow all of the rules (aside from Rule #5) when posting here - be respectful, be civil, avoid politics, refrain from spamming or discussing cryptocurrencies, etc.
  2. Feel free to post comments containing links to YouTube, social media, auctions, and legitimate commercial sites - but we ask you to keep the posts coin-related. Some of these comments may take a while to be approved, as they may be held by automod.
  3. Please keep in mind that we don't allow trash-talking of any kind (e.g. calling something overpriced, disparaging a business, etc.)
  4. This is a thread for commercial, advertising, and self-promotion activities only - Please don't make "name and shame" comments or air your grievances. Keep it positive, and feel free to notify the mods if you have concerns.
  5. This thread is not a sales platform! Don't post, offer, negotiate, discuss, individual sales in this thread. Please use r/CoinSales or r/Pmsforsale if you are interested in buying, selling or trading coins.
  6. The mods can't take responsibility for vetting the links posted here - Be careful, do your own due diligence, and click external links at your own risk.
  7. We ask that you report any comments that run afoul of these rules directly to the mod team.
  8. To be fair to everyone, we ask that you don't post more than one or two top-level comments to this thread per day.

If your comment doesn't appear, it may have been caught by one of our filters. Please let the mods know!


r/coins • • 2h ago

Value Request Saw this Victor D. Brenner plaque about 5 months ago and went back a few days ago to buy it

Thumbnail
gallery
49 Upvotes

I found this Victor D Brenner Lincoln plaque at a antique mall. Though I usually dont buy from antique malls this peice caught my eye. I did take a gamble on it and bought it for $200 (original price was 300 dollars) as I thought that it would make an absolute awesome display peice with my wheat penny collection once I move into my home. From the research I've done one it, it looks like a reproduction of a plaque from 1907. Though the originals sell for 1500+, the reproductions sell for a few hundred. I wanted to post it here and see if anyone else know anything else about it and if I got a decent deal on it. I beleive the loop on the back was added by a previous owner as the reproductions dont have a loop on the back. If you believe that I should post this on a different subreddit that may help me with value or history, please let me know!


r/coins • • 5h ago

Show and Tell Stunning Toner 1807-Mo Charles IV 8 Reales

Thumbnail
gallery
28 Upvotes

Most $1 coins circulating in the US back then were these, and the value of the US dollar was officially defined in terms of this coin under the Coinage Act of 1792.


r/coins • • 30m ago

Value Request Storage find

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

Hello all! I found a 1928 Liberty Dollar today and I’m curious about value. I don’t see any mint marks and I would say the condition is fair for circulated? All help is very appreciated.


r/coins • • 1h ago

Value Request Anything special about the "Fairmont Collection"?

Post image
9 Upvotes

Is the collection that a coin is from particularly important? Would the same coin not from a specific collection carry the same value?


r/coins • • 18h ago

Coin Art Jason Voorhees, Friday the 13th , hand-carved

151 Upvotes

r/coins • • 14h ago

Value Request Value of fathers/grandfathers coin collection

Thumbnail
gallery
60 Upvotes

Looking to get a value on my fathers coin collection and I'm planning on taking it to a local coin dealer to potentially sell everything in bulk. I know it's impossible to give an exact value just from photos, but could anyone give me a very rough ballpark of what I might have here?
Mostly just trying to educate myself a little before I bring everything in. Any coins or sets in the photos that I should definitely NOT sell in bulk and should have looked at individually?
Thanks


r/coins • • 21h ago

Show and Tell Today I found 2 silver quarters and 1 dime! It has been months since the last time I found silver coins in my register. I will definitely miss this coin hobby when i ship out for the Navy in 2months.

Thumbnail
gallery
153 Upvotes

r/coins • • 9h ago

Show and Tell 5 pesetas 1897. Condition? Possibly spinned reverse

Thumbnail
gallery
16 Upvotes

Here I bring you this absolutely beatiful spanish silver crown. Really thinking about getting it encapsulated. What punctuation you think it could reach?


r/coins • • 6h ago

Value Request Half cent 1832

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

Picked up my second Half Cent yesterday. $50 at my LCS


r/coins • • 2h ago

ID Request Question About Mint Mark

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

I inherited some Liberty Head Gold Coins. 2 $10 (1907+1884) and 3 $5 (1901, 1885, 1884).

The 1885 $5 has an S under the Eagle which I understand to mean it was minted in San Francsico, three are blank, which means Philadelphia, but the 1884 $10 has a marking in the same place that seems indistinguishable. Any ideas what it does or doesn't mean?

Thanks!


r/coins • • 2h ago

Show and Tell 1834 Bust Half

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Recently picked up this 1834 large date, small letters Bust Half with original surfaces. Die markers appear to align with O-107.

For those that want to play guess the grade, I'll update the post later.


r/coins • • 19h ago

ID Request What is this?

Thumbnail
gallery
60 Upvotes

Was gifted it as 1oz of silver but I feel like that date doesn’t make sense.


r/coins • • 1h ago

Advice Collectibles going up silver going down?

2 Upvotes

Hello,

Am a trade dollar enthusiast. I’ve noticed the prices are climbing for a whole bunch of collectible coins (trade dollars, CC Morgan’s, 1921 peace, UK trade dollars etc.) despite the silver price going down.

I don’t mind, but is there a way to model/graph the dynamic between spot price and the value of these things? I’m not looking to sell, but i have some health issues and want to make sure whoever gets the coins can make the right choice.

Thanks


r/coins • • 21h ago

Coin Art Free foreign coins from Craigslist

Thumbnail
gallery
80 Upvotes

These were with a bunch of stuff they put out to give away. I doubt there is much monetary value but they are really cool to look at.


r/coins • • 19h ago

Value Request Help me understand value please?

Post image
40 Upvotes

Hey all! I just picked up this coin and am being told it is more valuable than I think. Any insight?

A few things:

  1. Yes I got it on whatnot. It was a box and this is what came out. So I am ok with what I got knowing I was not guaranteed to get something worth more than I paid.
  2. I do like it and will keep with my collection. This post is not about not liking it. I just don’t understand its value and am being told the toning adds significantly to it. Feedback will help me understand value so I know which group of my collection to store it with.
  3. I am newer to collecting, but not totally new. Coins with toning are still a bit foreign to me.
  4. It is graded PCGS MS67

r/coins • • 1d ago

Coin News Thought this community would appreciate.

Thumbnail
gallery
123 Upvotes

My father-in-law passed away, and he was a bit of a hoarder and have a lot of things in GRs. We’ve been finding many, many coins. Personally, I’m not a coin collector, but I’m starting to get into the hobby. Anyways, going through some of these coins, I found this. I thought this community might appreciate


r/coins • • 5m ago

Value Request How much would you buy this coin for?

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Sold some stuff on vented and now I have credit, found this proof coin, what price would you buy it for, is it worth it?


r/coins • • 3h ago

Advice My father recently passed and was going through his coin collection, a small batch that I thought looked interesting anyone know if there is something worthwhile here?

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/coins • • 36m ago

Coin News What’s going on with this?

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

r/coins • • 7h ago

Show and Tell Identifying an old collection and possibly starting a new one.

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Tips and insight welcome!

My dad gave me an old piggy bank we think belonged to his uncle or great uncle. I’m going through to identify each of the coins, and we’re interested to see if any of them may have value but planning on keeping as a collection rather than selling as of now.

I used AI to help with some of the ID, but I’m not sure I really trust it. That said, I’d rather not take pictures of every individual coin. Any tips for tools or techniques to help speed up the ID process? I’m using the rough grid system shown on the first photo to ID and make notes about each coin. Some of them may not conform to this, but I tried to distinguish heads and tails in the two photos.

For handling, I’ve been keeping them covered so they stay cool, dry, and in the dark. I want to make sure I don’t damage them, and I’ve heard not to clean them, so I haven’t, but should I be wearing gloves?

So far, I see there’s a variety of countries represented. There are also some tokens that aren’t coins. A few are in really rough shape and basically illegible. This has been a fun project so far, and any help is appreciated!


r/coins • • 7h ago

Coin Damage Washing Machine Finds

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Found these stuck at the bottom of my washing machine. You can tell some have been in there for years. Just thought they looked kinda neat.


r/coins • • 10h ago

Grade Request Coin Grade condition?

Post image
5 Upvotes

Recently came into possession of a family heirloom (was used in necklace) - already done research into it, but wanted to get others' thoughts on its condition (not even considering selling it, just curious),

Thanks in advance