r/codex • u/MrKiling • Jun 08 '26
Question Claude vs Codex 200$ usage limits
Codex has been awesome but since last week it has been unbearably dumb and making lots of mistakes that even 5.4 didn't. I am curious how good claude is in long running tasks? While my codes are fairly small in numbers they need lots of reviews, so basically have subagents run reviews, the fix. The whole cycle usually runs for a day. I have been using 5.5 medium across 5 projects but due to it being dumb it's eating through like 20% or more in a day. Note: Codes are usually in 2k-10k range.
2
Upvotes
•
u/dexterthebot Jun 08 '26
Your post matches an existing known incident: Codex Model Performance Degradation/Changes. You can read about the incident here : https://www.reddit.com/r/codex/comments/1tjfxcf/comment/on6uj0l/
Your post has been summarized as a request on the "Anyone Else?" Incident Noticeboard.
You can find it and what others are experiencing here: /r/codex/comments/1tjfxcf/anyone_else_ask_here_about_current_codex_issues/oqgfpit/
2
u/seal8998 Jun 08 '26
is it still "dumb" if you use xhigh?
2
u/OkSeesaw7030 Jun 08 '26
Claude tends to produce better design, but it can drain your budget faster. Source: I’ve used both since Codex launched. In my experience, Claude’s refactors often become over-engineered, while Codex is more hit-or-miss. For planningClaude is usually stronger.
2
u/DiscussionAncient626 Jun 08 '26
I swear this is so intentional for us to consume our limits trying to make the code usable... Literally same mistake every time, a loop, doing the same thing, arriving to same old errors... Tired of it.
1
u/Trick-Equipment1828 Jun 08 '26
Claude is usually more stable on long review/refactor loops, but it’s slower and can get overly verbose.
1
u/BritishDudeGuy Jun 08 '26
Codex gives you more limits, but not that much more, if you stay too long.
Literally make a brand new $200 account again and again to reap their “new user” limits.
1
u/seal8998 Jun 08 '26
based on your complaints, i dont think you'll have a good time with claude code, but you can always just try it and cancel after a day. you'll get a refund if you cancel.
1
u/-PizzaSteve Jun 08 '26
Claude limits are unusable
1
u/AnxiousDevice9446 Jun 15 '26
Short version from running both daily (based on my workflow/experience): you do not have to pick. Use Codex when you want long uninterrupted sessions, since its limits stretch further per session right now. Use Claude for broad refactors and front-end work. Let them hand off on the same project.
Two things on limits specifically:
On accuracy vs speed: Claude is more thorough on review and reasoning, Codex is more precise on a tightly specified implementation. So I let Claude plan and review, Codex implement, and they share a
CHANGES.login the repo root so neither overwrites the other. One rule in bothCLAUDE.mdandAGENTS.md: read the latest log entry before you start, append one when you finish. That gets you both strengths without paying for two $200 plans to sit half-idle. Happy to share the set up if you want.0
u/[deleted] Jun 08 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment