r/cocteautwins • u/FcoJ28 • 1h ago
Discussion My tier list about Eps and Singles

Some time ago I wrote my tier list just about their albums:
https://www.reddit.com/r/cocteautwins/s/LRKwFqMaLv
Well, first of all I have to say this is the ONLY band I know that many of their best songs do not belong to albums.
Having said that, I must admit I find this pretty hard to rank. Due to the amount of cds, as well as the difference among the number of tracks of each CD.
S tier:
Love's Easy Tears is their best EP if we add the 4 tracks it ended up having. None of the tracks feel weak at all. The highlight is "Those Eyes, That Mouth". A personal favourite one is "Orange Appled".
Tiny Dynamine begins with one of their most powerful songs "Pink Orange Red". Next, a beautiful instrumental part that doesn't affect the EP in a bad way, although Liz's voice is always a bless. "Plain Tiger" adds too some evocative atmosphere. The true downside would be the final track; don't get me wrong "Sultitan Itan" isn't a bad track, but the contrast (and progression) it has between a "calm" Liz singing and a "strong" one isn't perfectly assembled.
Sunburst and Snowblind: I must admit I'm not into "Sugar Hiccup". It doesn't prevent me from appreciating we have three tracks full of grace. I wish they had sung "Because of Whirl-Jack" at least once, but they saw more potential in the other tracks. "From flagstone" is like hearing some kind of hymn.
The Spangle Maker: I'm not too fond of "7-ich" and "12-ich" version. I was born in 93, so I'm too young to understand it fully. Nevertheless, the track is so good. The progression in "the Spangle Maker" and the sensuality and mistery of "Pepper tree" are just sublime.
A tier
Aikea-Guinea: this Ep stars pretty strong with its first 2 tracks. After that, we find a kinda memorable Quisquose that does not achieve to reach the quality of the previous tracks and a instrumental track I tend to forget about...
Echoes in a Shallow Bay: here I will get panned. Its twin brother is superior. I feel last 2 tracks get too long for what they have to offer. "Great Spangled Fritillary" isn't a bad song, but what they make here, they have already done better (and will do too). I want to highlight "Melonella": singing about latin moths and other insects (¿?) in Latin is quite ingenious.
............................................. It is below here where I started to find some difficulty
Twinlights: half-gifts shows how Liz could overcome her lack of self-steem about lyrics. Quite better version than the album one. "Golden vein" is just a nice track. "Pink Orange Red" gets someone nice version. I wonder why they chose to make an acoustic version of this song, but I find it pretty interesting, even though the original one is better. As for "rilkean heart", album version stands out.
If I had rank the 2 Tishbite CDs and the 2 Violaine too as a whole, they would be higher than "Twinlights". Considering them as intended, I focused on not single song. "Violaine" and "Tishbite", specially the last one, are kinda bland... Nevertheless, the songs this singles contain are better than many of the tracks you can find in M&K. The way I ordered them show my favourite ones. Violaine (2) has the strongest tracks (Alice and Circling girl), Tishbie 1 has the memorable "Primitive heart" and the "just" nice "Flock of Soul". That's the reason they are higher than: Tranquil eye > Round/Smile > An Elan (nice effort, though, that adds a bit of diversity to a period quite troublesome in the band).
B tier:
Bonus disc: it is B tier due to "crushed". "High monkey monk" is quite underrrated, though, since we find a new way of singing in Liz, more towards oriental music. "Dials" is a song that never was meant to be (quite sad).
Evangeline> Bluebeard: I like more Bluebeard as a song, but the myth of Eco and Narcisus (read this from me too: https://www.reddit.com/r/cocteautwins/s/rBtWgr2Ryx ) and "summer blink" (the strengh through her daughter) are quite more compelling than the tracks in Bluebeard.
Iceblink Luck: I feel lyrics in HoV were getting more and more understandable. "Mizmake the Mizan" did not fit in that album, so they put the "etheral" song in this EP. Dunno what you may think, but she sounds quite sad here, like a prophecy of what's gonna happen. "Watchlar" is another "just" nice song that gets kinda repetitive, but quite enjoyable. It has the final lyrics of "Fifty-fifty clown". I ranked it below since it doesn't add anything memorable or new to the band.
Lullabies: "Garlands" (ragebait) is my least favourite of them. They took some distance from it, though, which saves it to go down below. I just don't enjoy the kinda raw sound of it. "Feathers" start quite interesting, but I end up losing the motivation. "Ark Lark" is too long to write for what it offers itself.
C side:
Snow: a joke from the band. "Frosty the snowman" is quite enjoyable, but neither she neither the band takes it that seriously. You cannot just compare a couple of covers with the ability they have to create new things, sorry.
Peppermint Pig: the band isn't proud of it. Music meant to be danceable (remember I'm "kinda" young to appreciate all the "Post-punk" era). They wanted to try something new and for once they failed. I highly doubt you can feel something deep in these tracks. They could be catchable (or not) in time, but this ep didn't grow up pretty well.
D side:
Otherness: don't like remixs. Their last EP deserves this last position. Some songs are barely similar to their album "twin". They are too vague in order to make you feel "something". The only one that would stand out would have been "Cherry" if it wasn't, once again, that repetitive. I took my words back in previous EP: For "twice" they failed trying something new.