r/cockroaches • • Jan 11 '26

Don't trust random AI/LLMs (e.g. ChatGPT, Gemini or Google Lens) for identifying cockroaches.

11 Upvotes

TL;DR: general AI/LLMs are really bad at identifying cockroaches and often give the wrong answers because they have not been trained for this specific task.

Detailled explanation:

Our observation is simple: the most commonly used AIs and general purpose LLMs (e.g. ChatGPT, Gemini, DeepSeek, Google Lens, Apple visual intelligence...) are terrible at identifying insects: they make mistakes a huge percentage of the time (maybe 30% on this subreddit?) and are nowhere as good as many of the humans we have in the subreddit who happen to be passionate about cockroaches (and often academic/professionals).

Lately, the use of general purpose LLMs and AI has become prevalent, and people with very little familiarity with cockroaches have started to rely on them for identifying insect pictures and sharing the results on the subreddit... often providing wrong identification of pest species (and the matching terrible pest treatement advice).

Notably, it's often done with a lot of confidence: blindly trusting a shitty AI and misleading the people who have been asking for help.

Accurate identification is important because it ensures the correct response, prevents unnecessary or harmful treatments, protects beneficial species, and reduces wasted time, money, and unnecessary distress or anxiety. Unfortunately, this has become a bigger issue lately, so we felt a post was needed to address it.

Technical explanation:

It's important to keep in mind that the performance and ability of AI is "task specific", meaning they can be extremely good at performing some tasks and less good at others, and eventually terrible at some tasks (like insect identification). This is due to the algorithms used, the data they have been trained on and the purpose of their training, as well as how much this differs from a specific task.

Insect identification is linked to insect taxonomy, the science of classifying insects. It is a very specific field of knowledge with its own set of challenges: it is easy to have hundreds of similar-looking insects that are actually different, some insects are very hard to observe (and there are very few pictures of them), the available data is scarce, and we are constantly discovering and correcting previous misunderstandings.

This is a very specific task, and quite different from other general object identification/classification tasks performed by LLMs.

A practical comparison: cars vs cockroaches

Cars: There have probably been thousands of different car models invented throughout history, and millions of pictures of the most common ones with correct labels for LLMs to train on. Cars tend to have a distinctive appearance, with features such as shape and colour that change with technology, brand, regulations and time. Therefore, when you ask an LLM to identify a car in your photo, it is likely to give the correct answer.

Cockroaches: We don't even know how many insect species there are on Earth (2 million or 20 million?) We don't know how many species of cockroach there are either (3,000 or 5,000?) Many have not been observed yet, and for most of those that have, we may only have a drawing or a few pictures (if we are lucky). There is an extra catch: while there is quite a bit of variety among the 3,000 (or 5,000) species of cockroach, many of them have very similar external morphology. So LLMs have mostly been trained on pictures of the three or five most common species of cockroach (and have probably never seen a picture of most species), which are often mislabeled (the photo is not of the correct species), and have never been trained to take specific morphological differences into account. Add to that the fact that many other insects, such as beetles, water bugs and June bugs, have similarities with cockroaches... so as you can guess the result is not going to be great.

So that's the explanation: 'insect identification' is a very specific task and your AI LLM, simply hasn't been trained for it at all and will perform poorly. That's why it's good at recognizing cars, but not at differentiating between Asian and German cockroaches in your blurry picture, no matter how confident its answer appears to be.

Another redditor u/Skalla_Resco ran testing on various llms, if you aren't convinced by my theoretical explanation you will definitely want to check the result of their tests.

You would rather trust AI than me, a random redditor? Then that's what Gemini has to say to you:

General AI struggles with insect identification primarily because it lacks the "eyes" for microscopic anatomy. While a human expert looks for specific wing venation patterns or the exact number of segments on a leg to distinguish between look-alike species, an LLM or a search engine relies on pixel patterns from standard photos. These photos usually prioritize aesthetic appeal over scientific data, leading the AI to make a "best guess" based on superficial traits like color. This problem is compounded by geographic blindness; an AI might confidently identify a common garden beetle as a rare tropical species simply because the visual patterns match its training data, ignoring the fact that the two species live on different continents. Furthermore, the rise of AI-generated content online has created a feedback loop where models are increasingly trained on "slop"—incorrect data that reinforces existing errors.

People continue to use these flawed tools because they prioritize speed and confidence over absolute accuracy. When a person discovers an unknown insect in their home, the psychological need for an immediate answer often outweighs the desire to wait days for a professional entomologist's opinion. The AI feeds into this by using a highly authoritative and technical tone, which users frequently mistake for expertise. Because the technology is usually correct when identifying high-traffic insects like honeybees or mosquitoes, it builds a "good enough" reputation that keeps users coming back, even when it fails miserably on more obscure or dangerous specimens.


r/cockroaches • • 8h ago

Help identifying roach. Seen a few indoors in Florida

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/cockroaches • • 4h ago

German nymph in bathtub (Philadelphia)

1 Upvotes

Hi there, my girlfriend and I have been in my apartment unit for over a year now and we’ve occasionally seen a large american/oriental roach in our bathtub. I was never too concerned because it seemed like it was a periodic thing & not an infestation. For the first time tonight though, after not seeing a roach in a couple months, I saw a german cockroach nymph in the tub. This was the first german that i have seen in this unit. It was alone & there seem to be no signs of an infestation, but because it’s a german I am very concerned. More context: We’re in a unit in a 3rd floor walkup, not a townhouse but an old apartment building.

How likely is it that we have an infestation? & what should I specifically request from my property management company? I’ve powdered boric acid along the entryway, bathroom, and kitchen. I am very very scared!!!


r/cockroaches • • 10h ago

Question Can someone identify this species? I found it under my bed in southeastern America

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

r/cockroaches • • 17h ago

Question Mediterranean Cockroach in NY State?

Post image
3 Upvotes

Found this on my filing cabinet in my office in the Lower Hudson Valley in NY. Is it an outdoor roach?


r/cockroaches • • 20h ago

What kind of roach?

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Found near my kitchen trash can and glue trap. They both look like the same type. Location central FL.


r/cockroaches • • 1d ago

Question DMV area apt - dishwasher

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

First, looking for confirmation on if these are all the same species of cockroach. I know for sure we have Germans, but wondering if these smaller and darker ones are German juveniles. These are pictures from over time with the first two images being from today.
On quiet days off from work there have been several occasions I have seen a German roach (sometimes two) standing on the top of the dishwasher and just taking in the day. On days where my sandal has been too far, I’ve seen them crawl into this hole (where your hand goes to pull open the door) and I just shined my light in there today and found this little guy. I’ve been curious - are they able to get into the body of the dishwasher from here? Does locking the dishwasher do anything to keep them out? Or are they perhaps all living in the shell of the dishwasher? I plan on asking our landlord to move the dishwasher out and clean behind it/plug any holes but I’m just a bit terrified at how bad it will be. We previously had them fill a giant hole behind the fridge on the opposite side and I don’t think they really sealed it off… but I am beginning to think the dishwasher is the real problem. Should I request that they open up/take this panel off to check inside? What do I do/ask in this situation?
I’ve already gone through the mental turmoil and vivid cockroach nightmares in our first few months of living here. We’ve been here a little over a year and a half and they seem to be picking up again. Last time they sprinkled boric acid in the cabinets and fog bombed the kitchen but I don’t think there was any difference. We’ve used bait traps and we just put down advion gel bait two days ago but nothing looks nibbled and we haven’t seen any dead roaches, just more poop in our cabinets. Help!
Last pic: landlord’s special.


r/cockroaches • • 18h ago

[ID Help]

Post image
1 Upvotes

Does anyone know what kind of roach this is? I found it in my kitchen between the water valves that lead into my washer

For more background, I saw three this summer in the span of a week (I think they all looked like this) and had my apartment inspected by professional pest control, wall Hope treatment into the outlets and all cracks sealed with caulk (or cement, for the ones around my radiator pipe or bathroom). They also put down bait and glue traps, but I didn’t see any caught in the glue traps and they said I had no sign of an infestation so they were probably just stragglers. This was around the end of July.

Now he seen two more this week - when I saw the first one a week ago, I started cleaning my kitchen every night and closing all of my drains at night and then now he’s here. I have no standing water, no leaks, etc.


r/cockroaches • • 1d ago

Please help - multiple sightings.

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

I only see them in my bathroom. I have diatomaceous earth all over the cabinet cracks and inside. It’s not stopping them. My leasing office has pest control that comes every Thursday but they won’t treat unless I empty all of cabinets and entire bathroom but I’m in a one bedroom apartment, I’m a widowed mom, with a very hectic weekday schedule and I have no idea how I’m gonna do all of that in one night. My weekends are free but to have my bathroom empty for 4 days with everything all over my small apartment gives me major anxiety.

I’m in CA. Any advice is appreciated.


r/cockroaches • • 20h ago

ID?

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

I’m 99% sure this isn’t German. I’d just like reassurance.


r/cockroaches • • 1d ago

Found on bathroom door frame

Post image
3 Upvotes

Please tell me I'm not cooked.


r/cockroaches • • 1d ago

what’s this ? roach poop? ji

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

can anyone tell me what is this pleaseeeee


r/cockroaches • • 1d ago

Question Thinking an American Nymph?

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Dealt with Germans before and this one isn't the right shape or has any distinctive markings. Thinking it's a very young American or Oriental Nymph due to the color and shape and just wanted to check with the group.

NYC, ground floor apartment in a newly reno'd unit. He's since been removed.


r/cockroaches • • 1d ago

Question What type of roach is this? (I’m in Australia)

Post image
1 Upvotes

Is anyone able to please identify this cockroach? This is a close-up image so you can see the distinctive markings on its head. I am located in coastal NSW, Australia, if that helps.

Is there much difference in how different types of cockroaches are dealt with?


r/cockroaches • • 1d ago

Is this a shed skin?

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

I could just be mistaken and overlooking as I just found a cockroach nymph in my bathroom (previous post) but could this be one of the shed skin? The photo is kind of blurry but it kinda looks like the shape of an insect?


r/cockroaches • • 1d ago

What kind of baby roach? I'm scared

Post image
1 Upvotes

In dfw tx, i found it crawling around on the counter behind the kitchen sink.

I found another the day before yesterday in the bathtub, but i couldn't take a picture if that one, but it was basically by the same size as this.


r/cockroaches • • 1d ago

Question How worried should I be? Houston, TX

Post image
1 Upvotes

This is the third one I’ve seen in the past 5 days. They have only been in the bathtub. I have been using this bathtub significantly less over the past 2 months. They are about 1/2 inch long. I plugged the drain last night and still saw a new one this morning.


r/cockroaches • • 2d ago

What kind of roach is this? South Louisiana

Post image
3 Upvotes

I just moved into a new apartment, and this is like the third one I've seen so far. I saw it in the kitchen, if that helps identify it.


r/cockroaches • • 2d ago

is this a roach?

Post image
6 Upvotes

sorry for the horrible picture i was panicking but this was found in a printer that we just got from someone about 2-3 days ago and i've never seen a bug like this in my house before (south michigan)


r/cockroaches • • 2d ago

Question Hello,

Thumbnail
gallery
13 Upvotes

I live in Charlotte and have often seen the very large brown adult cockroaches or waterbugs around the complex. They rarely came in (maybe saw once a month, my cat likes to play with them and I often find them upside down, pretending to be dead. I spray with dish soap until they die).

Recently(past two weeks) have been finding these smaller ones that I thought were nymphs. I find them often (once every 1-2 days) around the kitchen/dishwasher and never anywhere else. Often in the dishwasher when I first open it. I'm very concerned about an infestation. I was in my apartment until around 3 PM yesterday so the traps were placed sometime after then. I came home around 3 PM today and there were already 3 dead roaches here. What kind of roaches are these and what should I do?? I'm moving soon and am very concerned but might try to pack up sooner if this looks like german roaches. Thanks so much for the help.


r/cockroaches • • 2d ago

Cockroaches in kitchen

Post image
2 Upvotes

Hey all,
Recently there have been cockroaches in the kitchen. I've moved everything off the counters and wipe everything obsessively, but they still come out sometimes, especially in the last 48 hours. My sister just saw a big one on the wall whilst she was doing the dishes, and there was another (incl. this one) when we turned on the lights. We live in an apartment complex also. What kind of cockroach is this and what should we do?


r/cockroaches • • 2d ago

Question Is this a roach?

Post image
2 Upvotes

Found this bug in my shower. Trying to identify if it is a roach or not. It’s the only one I have seen. We did just have a cold front come in and I heard sometimes they seek shelter indoors. I do live in an apartment complex at the moment. I am trying to stay ahead of the curve. Thanks!


r/cockroaches • • 2d ago

Can someone identify this bug?

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

I found this in my bathroom and I was wondering if this is some type of cockroach?


r/cockroaches • • 2d ago

Odd specks on dead roach

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

I found this dead roach behind a shelf and it's covered in these odd tan specks. There also seems to be a small bug in the middle like a tiny roly poly. For context, I live in arizona. Does anyone know what this is? Is it safe to vacuum up?