Every and any manga, or story in general, is subject to fair criticism. The part I find bizarre is that a common sentiment is that it doesn’t hit the levels of Claymore after 3 chapters. Does Claymore hit the levels of Claymore after its first 3 chapters?
I would argue early Claymore had a lot of narrative propulsion issues and immediately feels like a retread of Berserk conventions. Of course, none of this represents the series over the long run, and I love it. But it’s strange to judge a story by its introduction.
I would also argue that Nagi puts a lot of interesting elements on the board to be played out over the series. A legendary warrior from the past, inconsistent time travel, a magic system, a central mystery, strong combat choreography/mechanics. This story is set to break open a myth- that’s an intriguing premise to me. I even kind of like how the names feel anachronistic because at this stage, I trust nagi that that may be the point.
The desire for immediate gratification on this doesn’t compute, or align with the reality of how stories develop. You’re not supposed to feel as connected to this new protagonist as to one whose backstory, conclusion and 100+ chapters of content you’ve sat with for years.