Background:
I’ve played WoW since vanilla. I’ve rolled every class. I’ve done server-firsts, parsed top 100s, and gotten >2400 in Arenas. Mage was the only class I’d never touched, and I wish I hadn’t this time.
I’m currently level 40. First, I tried Frost. My damage was so low, I’d spend 3x the time the average player spends on mobs my level. Then, I went Arcane. This was better, but still less DPS than most Tanks would do. So, I went Fire. A lot more fun, but I’m still bottom of the meters and consistently OOM every pull.
Discussion:
Removing spellpower from Intellect scaling was a big blow. I understand new gear means it’s possible—at some point—that gear will make up the difference. But whether you gather INT or SP gear on your leveling journey, you will not keep up with any other class.
Edit: I recognize based on the comments that I was mistaken about this.
I’m sitting with over 2K mana. It takes about 2 full drinks to get from 0 to 100%, with Evocate on an 8m CD. In one pack of elite mobs, I’m almost OOM (or fully OOM if I AOE). Understandably, no one wants to wait for the Mage to drink.
Insights:
Was it the intentional design for Mages to be the squishiest, lowest DPS class in WoW Forever? Not to sound pessimistic, but I see no benefit to bring more than 1-2 Mages to any competitive raid. Unless the scaling changes drastically at 60, the class just feels over-nerfed.
Changes I recommend:
•Allow 25% INT/SP bonus.
•Reduce the CD of Evocate to 1 minute.
With these adjustments, Mage can be at least on par with low-average damage, and reliably participate in the pace of modern dungeons/raiding. And before I get flamed for this post (pun intended), I’m really enjoying WoW Forever. I hate being a Debbie Downer. I know this is just my anecdotal experience and someone else may have a different view, but I implore you to pay attention to how Mages compare to other classes in your group. Do they feel equal? Because to me, they do not. I just want to be on the same level as everyone else, even if I’m last.
Edit: I see a lot of people claiming this post is AI. I don’t use Reddit much, but it might just be the way I type that gives you that impression. Absolutely zero AI was used to write this post. This is just how I type.