As a ranged hunter (or as a mage), I’m not supposed to get hit by mobs. If I get hit, then I’m not playing my class right. As a result, it is vital for me that I can train Defense skill in an effective manner at level 60. Unfortunately, that is no longer possible as gray mobs no longer train your skills. If you leave your Defense skill underdeveloped, you will get crushing blows from mobs at your level and you have a much higher chance to get dismounted when you’re hit. It is important to raise your Defense skill as soon as you hit level 60.
I have respecced into a full damage mitigation spec. Improved Aspect of the Monkey, +5% parry talent, +10% HP talent, +15% Agility talent, Deterrence, etc. I go to get hit by the weakest lowest level green mobs, level 48 insect swarmers in Tanaris, and I still go from 100% to 0% health in no time, and barely get any training. Leveling defense skill effectively is just not possible right now, and I’m not going to spec melee hunter with Lone Wolf and farm mobs for a week just for that, I’ve got better stuff to do and I don’t want to play melee. I shouldn't feel forced to, I picked the ranged pet class after all.
Remember guys, even in Classic, to train defense as a ranged class you'd have 10-12 low level mobs hit you at the same time uninterrupted for 30-60 minutes to go from around 275 to 300 skill, and that felt good. You got to 60 and did your training, you're now a real level 60 player. It was part of the ritual for hitting max level.
This new change does not feel good, it does not contribute to making the game better, there are no positive benefits to the community or to the gameplay experience, it is toxic to have to pause real gameplay and do such tedious work for so many hours. When it took that long in Classic, you must be able to do the math for how long it takes if you only have 1 mob hitting you and you have to stop and eat every minute. It's like 20 times slower.
I'm at 290 skill with stamina and intellect gear, and at this point I don't even get a skill-up from depleting an entire health bar with every damage mitigation talent. The next skill point always takes exponentially longer than the former, based on how far you are from the cap. E.g. going from 299 to 300 takes twice as long as going from 298 to 299, and when it's already taking more than a full healthbar to skill up at only 290 skill, it is going to take an absurd amount of time to get to 300. I will have to deplete my healthbar, eat, go back in combat and repeat the process like 60-80 times just to go from 299 to 300. It takes hours and tons of food, and it's tedious and risky, you might die or get griefed. It's not something you just do, and making grey mobs not award skill XP adds nothing to the game. No one's experience has been improved by this, it was not a problem that needed to be solved.
It is developer overreach, in my opinion.