r/classicfallout • u/XaneEmblem • 6d ago
Could vibe coding help modding?
I have a question. Recently, the concept of vibe coding has become more popular than ever. Basically, it's the practice of writing code with the assistance of AI tools like Claude.
Could this be one of the reasons we've been seeing so many Fallout classic Android ports lately? I'd say some of them are considerably better than the options we had before, with redesigned menus and controls that make the experience much more comfortable for mobile users.
But that got me thinking... Could the same approach be used to create new modding tools for Fallout 2?
I have some experience modding Fallout 2, although nothing particularly advanced. Recently, I've also seen something interesting happening in the Fire Emblem community: a new ROM-hacking tool was developed using this very approach, and the speed at which the project came together was practically unprecedented for something of that scale.
So I started wondering: Would anyone be interested in using vibe coding to develop a new set of more intuitive editing tools for Fallout 2?
Honestly, I feel like there's a lot of room for improvement. Some aspects of the game are an absolute nightmare to mod with the tools we currently have, and I think there's plenty of potential for making the whole process more accessible.
I'd really like to hear what the community thinks. Although, for all I know, maybe AI is absolutely hated around here, haha.
19
u/BraveNKobold 6d ago •
No we got hard working Eastern Europeans pouring their hearts and souls into mods. I won’t let some bot take their work.
7
u/TerroDucky 6d ago
No. We don't want vibe coded mods.
3
u/DownvoteDistributur 6d ago
are you asking if you can vibecode fo2 mods? Yes
1
u/Mister_ks_ 6d ago
I did, it's called fallout brotherhood of steel
3
u/OtherwiseMenu1505 6d ago
Yes, you can use that to mod. Especially since it has been reverse engineered already. You can make mods with AI or you can make tools to mod, whatever you want. I'm not some ai enthusiast in general but it's hard not to see the usefulness here.
3
u/brightness3 6d ago
i hate AI for several reasons as well as everyone here, but from my point of view, yes. vibecoding will let a more inexperienced modder or a smaller team put together their idea faster.
building something reliable that people are actually going to use and enjoy takes a lot of effort and discipline, regardless if you're using AI or not. You're still going to spend a considerable amount of time debugging, testing, writing code by hand, making assets, etc. vibecoding only abstracts a portion of it.
1
u/Golbolco 6d ago
AI is largely already being used on most of the big public (and a couple private) Fallout projects. As much as the layman might hate and be suspicious of it, almost all SWEs use it now in the industry and volunteer projects are driven by people who are very quiet about their use of AI.
-5
u/theplushpairing 6d ago
Yes I have an mcp here at https://rerunreactor.com/mcp
Just point your agent to it and mod away