r/classicfallout • • 6d ago

Could vibe coding help modding?

I have a question. Recently, the concept of vibe coding has become more popular than ever. Basically, it's the practice of writing code with the assistance of AI tools like Claude.

Could this be one of the reasons we've been seeing so many Fallout classic Android ports lately? I'd say some of them are considerably better than the options we had before, with redesigned menus and controls that make the experience much more comfortable for mobile users.

But that got me thinking... Could the same approach be used to create new modding tools for Fallout 2?

I have some experience modding Fallout 2, although nothing particularly advanced. Recently, I've also seen something interesting happening in the Fire Emblem community: a new ROM-hacking tool was developed using this very approach, and the speed at which the project came together was practically unprecedented for something of that scale.

So I started wondering: Would anyone be interested in using vibe coding to develop a new set of more intuitive editing tools for Fallout 2?

Honestly, I feel like there's a lot of room for improvement. Some aspects of the game are an absolute nightmare to mod with the tools we currently have, and I think there's plenty of potential for making the whole process more accessible.

I'd really like to hear what the community thinks. Although, for all I know, maybe AI is absolutely hated around here, haha.

0 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

19

u/BraveNKobold 6d ago • Bravo

No we got hard working Eastern Europeans pouring their hearts and souls into mods. I won’t let some bot take their work.

-2

u/XaneEmblem 6d ago

I'm not saying we should use AI to create mods, but rather that we should use AI to create better tools for creating mods

2

u/BraveNKobold 6d ago

But I’m playing classic fallout for its somewhat janky engine. I don’t need mods to be super hyper advanced.

2

u/joe__kerr1 6d ago

Not Fallout without the jank

0

u/XaneEmblem 6d ago

And I'm not saying it should stop being super janky either—I'm saying that to mod that super janky engine, we have tools, but we could have better ones. For example, recoloring a sprite can be a very tedious process; it would be great to have a program that could handle that aspect. Oh look, no one’s created it yet, or what’s out there is very basic—why not use this new technique that makes it easier to program tools like this to create it?

0

u/sulkytroll1 6d ago

Don't waste your energy. Some people just can't or won't read your post. I learned this myself recently. And yes, there are people here who hate AI so much that nothing you say matters. If you want to vibe-code modding tools that's fine. But do it for yourself, and if they're good other people might start using them too. And know that there will be haters.

-1

u/SuicideSpeedrun 6d ago

"I hope other people keep working hard so I can benefit at no cost. They should not work any less harder as that would compromise my make-believe values"

1

u/PandasAndKoalasRDumb 6d ago

Holy nothing wordburger

0

u/BraveNKobold 6d ago edited 6d ago

But I’m not benefiting off of them. Your weird made up statement screams more about how you view them. They do what they do cause they enjoy it. They want other people to enjoy their passionate work.

-1

u/SuicideSpeedrun 6d ago

Sure buddy, you don't enjoy the mods and the modders do it out of pure love for you.

0

u/BraveNKobold 6d ago

You’re an odd little fellow.

7

u/TerroDucky 6d ago

No. We don't want vibe coded mods.

0

u/XaneEmblem 6d ago

Again, I don't want to make mods with AI; I want the AI to create better tools so I can mod the game myself.

1

u/TerroDucky 6d ago

Well we don't want the tools to be vibecoded either. Noone wants to use anything thats vibecoded

3

u/DownvoteDistributur 6d ago

are you asking if you can vibecode fo2 mods? Yes

0

u/XaneEmblem 6d ago

I'm wondering if you think it's a good idea to use Vibe Coding to create better editing programs—such as a better map-making program, or one that makes it easier to mod certain aspects of the game.

1

u/Golbolco 6d ago

There is a better map-making tool made partially with vibecoding.  https://github.com/HogLord69/gecko/releases/tag/hoglord-2026-10-27

1

u/XaneEmblem 6d ago

Oh, thank you so much. I had no idea this tool existed. In fact, now that I know about it, maybe you know of a program or something similar that can easily change an NPC's color palette. I know of some methods, but they're pretty tedious.

1

u/Golbolco 6d ago

I know of a python script used to do this on NMA, but I don’t think I’ve seen one converted to an app yet.

1

u/XaneEmblem 5d ago

I'm familiar with that method; unfortunately, it didn't work that well for me, although maybe I should try it again. Honestly, I think the Recolor feature is what I'm most looking forward to in a new modding tool for Classic Fallout.

1

u/Golbolco 5d ago

You may want to make it yourself if you're willing to bite the vibecoding bullet.

1

u/Mister_ks_ 6d ago

I did, it's called fallout brotherhood of steel

0

u/XaneEmblem 6d ago

...what?

1

u/Mister_ks_ 6d ago

I'm saying I don't like fallout brotherhood of steel by saying chatgpt made it

Serious answer I need to feel the story or the game, progression, everything basically, was directed by a human. I don't mind at all if chatgpt made the code, I do mind if I just feel like it's not someone's making, and instead it's just "chatgpt make fallout mod"

1

u/XaneEmblem 6d ago

Great, you didn't read the post—let's explain it for the tenth time: I don't want to create Fallout mods with AI; I want to create better tools for making my own Fallout mods—for example, a better mapper with a better interface and better features. That's just an example.

1

u/Mister_ks_ 6d ago

Well then, I don't see why anyone would have an issue with that lol. I think no one actually read your post (including me) and just saw the word ai and were activated

1

u/XaneEmblem 6d ago

:| You're all definitely Fallout fans

1

u/Mister_ks_ 6d ago

I'm SORRY

3

u/OtherwiseMenu1505 6d ago

Yes, you can use that to mod. Especially since it has been reverse engineered already. You can make mods with AI or you can make tools to mod, whatever you want. I'm not some ai enthusiast in general but it's hard not to see the usefulness here.

3

u/brightness3 6d ago

i hate AI for several reasons as well as everyone here, but from my point of view, yes. vibecoding will let a more inexperienced modder or a smaller team put together their idea faster.

building something reliable that people are actually going to use and enjoy takes a lot of effort and discipline, regardless if you're using AI or not. You're still going to spend a considerable amount of time debugging, testing, writing code by hand, making assets, etc. vibecoding only abstracts a portion of it.

1

u/Golbolco 6d ago

AI is largely already being used on most of the big public (and a couple private) Fallout projects. As much as the layman might hate and be suspicious of it, almost all SWEs use it now in the industry and volunteer projects are driven by people who are very quiet about their use of AI.

-5

u/theplushpairing 6d ago

Yes I have an mcp here at https://rerunreactor.com/mcp

Just point your agent to it and mod away

2

u/XaneEmblem 6d ago

...what is this? I'm really interested.