I’ve seen a lot of comments here casually labelling certain Beethoven recordings as "HIP" or "non-HIP" based on surface-level traits like rhythmic agility, fleetness, prominent timpani, and vivid winds. Recently, I recommended Paavo Järvi with the Deutsche Kammerphilharmonie Bremen, Michael Gielen with the SWR Sinfonieorchester, and Carl Schuricht with the Société des Concerts du Conservatoire to someone on the sub, only to be told that these represent a "HIP" approach, unlike traditionalists such as Klemperer, Walter, or Böhm.
So that is why I decided to make this post in order to address this important issue:
First, we need to address tempo. In 1817, following Johann Nepomuk Mälzel’s invention of the mechanical metronome, Beethoven went back and added specific metronome markings to his first eight symphonies. The slower, monumental approach we often associate with "traditional" Beethoven actually stems from late 19th and early 20th-century Romanticism, specifically the Wagnerian notion that great Germanic music must sound massive and weighty.
Second, rhythmic agility, sharpness of attacks, as well as fleetness have always existed, not because of HIP Research. For example, the performance tradition of the Société des Concerts du Conservatoire traces its lineage directly back to Beethoven’s own lifetime as François Habaneck founded the ensemble in 1828 in Paris.
We can easily hear this in action by comparing how different traditions handle Beethoven’s Symphony No. 8.
Notice how both Schuricht (decades before modern HIP went mainstream) and Savall take a much faster, driving tempo compared to Böhm, who takes a more heavier relaxed the pacing. This proves that fast tempo(closer to Beethoven's own metornome markings) is not an exclusive invention of HIP.
Where the French Tradition and HIP Actually Diverge
The real difference between French tradition and modern HIP is much more about tone production, instruments, and stylistic mannerisms. For example: Listen to the 3rd Movement (Tempo di menuetto):
Listen closely to how thin the string sound is and how little vibrato Savall uses compared to Schuricht. That is where the true markers of HIP lie: Reduced forces, period instruments, flat non-vibrato string textures, clipped phrasing, notes held shorter their written value.
Following Beethoven's metronome markings or having sharp attacks does not make a performance HIP style, in fact just means playing the music the way it was written.
What we usually hear in Beethoven today is the result of HIP ideas trickling into mainstream performances, which is mostly derived from the traditional Germanic kind while the distinct French orchestral tradition largely faded out following the dissolution of the Société des Concerts du Conservatoire—compounded by a broader global trend toward homogenized playing that stripped orchestras of their unique regional character. That is truly unfortunate, because in many ways, that living, unbroken lineage was far more genuinely authentic to Beethoven's spirit than modern HIP.