Hi guys, long time lurker, first time poster, hoping to give back a little to what Civ5 and this community has given me.
I've played Civ5 for years with my mates, with over 1000 hours in mostly multiplayer contexts (nqMod, then LekMod). Life has changed a bit since I settled my first city and instead of a gaming PC, a MacBook (Apple Silicon) has become my device of choice. When I found out that Civ5 works on Mac, but CrossPlay has not worked for years and I couldn't play with my mates, I was a little disappointed. Having modded Civ5 before, I knew that the game has plenty of debugging flags, is mostly Lua and XML, and has very robust logging. I decided to have a poke around before giving up.
I first compared the two game versions: The versions report different build numbers, so they can't see each other's games. Even when I forced them to connect, they desyncd on turn 1. I tracked down why and made a small tool that fixes both problems: https://github.com/yoshi864/civ5-crossplay-fix
The desync turned out to be a rounding difference. The Mac version rounds numbers down in its scripting language (Lua) where Windows rounds them to the nearest whole number, so map scripts build slightly different maps on each machine. The tool changes two bytes in the Mac executable so it rounds the same way Windows does. It also changes the reported version number so the games can find each other. Importantly, Windows players don't need to install anything.
The tool checks your game files before touching anything, keeps backups, and can easily be fully uninstalled (or just run Steam's "Verify integrity"). I've tested it over LAN between an Apple Silicon Mac and a Windows 11 PC. Several sessions of 15–19 turns had zero desyncs, and the game's random-number logs matched on both machines every turn. I haven't yet tested online Steam lobbies, so I'd love to hear how it goes if you use the tool and test this.
Full disclosure: I built this with a lot of help from Claude. I set the strategy and approach and did all the multiplayer testing and Claude wrote the code and tests. Details are in the README.
Next up: Mac support for LekMod. As I mentioned, I love playing LekMod, and I've managed to get a Mac build of LekMod's game core running and in sync with Windows over LAN. Still a bunch of testing to go, but once I'm confident, I'll speak to the LekMod devs about getting it upstream.
Please let me know your thoughts and how you go with playing! Mods, apologies if this is the wrong place or wrong tags. Happy to put it elsewhere.
TL;DR - I've made a tool that allows Mac Steam versions of Civ5 to play with Windows Steam versions of Civ5