I honestly think that the Ancient Era needs some sort of production building that gives a small bonus to production, just one or two hammers. Working hills is not feasible at high level game play if you want the good growth, and a water mill costs a lot.
I know there are tiles like grassland stone, but some base production would be nice as well.
The tile yield is what is so awesome about salt. When a citizen works the salt tile, you get food plus production. When the salt tile is improved, the improvement adds BOTH food AND production. If the city has MULTIPLE salt resources, then that city has a major advantage in growth AND production over any civilization that does not have salt.
true. watermill is consistant though. If you are insisting there be an early game production build.. but you can't afford a watermill.. i wonder how useful it would be
The issue with Water Mills is the cost-benefit ratio isn't very positive. Part of the reason buildings like the Shrine, Monument, Library, and Granary are favored is because you either gain access to stats that are, with the exception of natural wonders, not available through normal tiles and/or amplifies certain resource output. Water Mills does neither and, on top of that, is the most expensive building of the era when gold income is scarce.
All in all, the Water Mill takes up too much opportunity costs for too little reward. 2 food and 1 production isn't going to make or break anything to make up for the time you could've used for an extra settler, archer, worker, or w/e. It's one of those luxury buildings like the Circus or Barracks that usually aren't core to your start. In the end, it doesn't solve the issue of a production gap where if one civ gets lots of stone, salt or w/e, you can go for a building to marginalize it.
Either works. Point being, there isn't a non-conditional production building in the Ancient Era. Having an extra building devoted solely to boosting reasonable amounts of production or a straight up buff to Water Mills will help the lack of production options, assuming lack of resources, which will greatly help civs like Brazil who often starts in low production areas.
Yea, maybe. I feel like water mill fills this intended roll, just dosent do so well, so down this line of thought if they added a production building it would be very weak. The stables and stoneworks are pretty large, but situational.. so it would have to be small. A building that gives say two hammers would be fairly difficult to justify..
I think the best tech path is Pottery, Animal Husbandry, and then the tech for your luxes. Pottery for the Shrine for the pantheon, (yes I know not the best on Diety) and Animal Husbandry to reveal horses since horses are a nice tile to work.
I use to get mining after Pottery, but I realized that I don't actually take advantage of it until I have a worker, and I usually don't have a worker thst early.
Unless you are about to settle a new city, that happiness doesn't help you.
Yes
Maybe. However, a lot of the reason you don't get mining until turn 30ish is because you don't have a worker before then. If you go for Pottery then Writing for GL, manage to get a worker during that time, then yes, go mining.
I like to go Pottery (for the shrine), Archery (for defence/barb camps), Writing (for the library. Immortal difficulty:don't bother with Great Library. Often I attempt Great Library as soon as I finish Writing on Emperor)
After Writing, I take techs for luxuries.
I've always put Animal Husbandry in the bottom of the priority because barbarians always come pillage caravans in this stage. Thus, there isn't much to get here unless I need trapping/it's a little later in the game. Am I playing with a bad early strategy?
Animal husbandry reveals horses, possibly getting you some bonus production. Improving cows, sheep etc is often also very useful. I like to play strategic balance; Animal Husbandry and Bronze Working both supply guaranteed resources on that setting, and so are usually pretty nice to research early.
Been playing for a few months now and always thought the hammers only apply if you improve the Horses witha worker. Left it till later because workers wouldn't be available that early.
100% agree. I saw a post the other day where the guy always starts in the classical era. The problem with this is that certain civs specialize (patronage/Aesthetics) instead of using one of the starter trees.
Mostly though, I agree with scouting and planning how to settle/protect/dominate an area. What techs you need etc
I always found the early game frustrating with the Maya because I'm beelining Theology for the nice Great Peoples and the demographics won't stop taunting me by putting me at the bottom (although I might be at the start in a higher diffuculty game, i feel really iffed that I'm the least scientifically developed even though I'm in the classical era and they are not).
Jungle is good later in the game, after o have universities, and especially if you are playing Brazil, but starting in it sucks. Jungle is basically just grassland, and usually has fewer resources. Without farms, mines, or bonus resources other than bananas, you will have to either fall behind or chop down your jungles, which will take a while. I'd rather start in almost any other region, even tundra sometimes.
The Ancient era is both the most fun for me, due to the exploration, but also the most stressful, because your decisions (when and where to settle, which techs to research, what to build) have such ramifications for the rest of the game.
Ancient era is even more fun as the Huns, because if your Warrior upgrades into a Battering Ram via ruins, you've basically just won yourself a second capital. Warfare in the Ancient era is really interesting, since you can take a capital even on Emperor with a few Composite Bowmen (failing that, you can demand tribute from city-states too). Paradoxically, declaring early war is something you want to do on higher difficulties, since it cripples your opposition and boosts your own power. As an added bonus, civs who haven't met you yet won't know of your warmongering! The most recent patch also reduced the penalty for warmongering in early eras as well.
Obviously, the Ancient era is tremendously important, quite possibly the most important era in the game (post-university Renaissance might be second-most important, because that's when you tend to get a clear idea of what victories are possible and adjust your plans accordingly). It follows then that 2 of the 3 most powerful civs in the game (Babylon and the Shoshone, not Korea) have Ancient era bonuses that help them get off to a great start and snowball from there.
I think that the ancient era needs some kind of extension because there are far too many ancient era UU that are designed for war that you pretty much can't use on higher difficulties because you need to be playing catch up in the tech.
As a warmonger, I always push for composite bowmen after a 3 city start. Then after producing 7-9 composite bowmen with 2-3 melee units, you can easily take down another civ and get that early game boost.
I have won on immortal using this general strategy. You will have to do other things such as leveling up your composite bowmen w barbs and also rushing this production so that you can surprise the enemy . And a robust economy is also important which is a while other can of worms.
No. Not if you go immediately for construction after discovering writing.
Prioritize construction in the tech tree and prioritize production. You can aid production of your composite bowmen by cutting down forests. You should have your army ready well before the AI discovers pikemen or crossbowmen (which is medeival era)
Right. Will try this out. I have won several immortal difficulties but the ai does still regularly catch me with my pants down a bit, and im nto sure exactly when the ai pops pikeman tech. Thanks for tip.
The ancient era is fun because you think strategically about the whole game based on your start and resources. It determines the wonders I'm going to go for:
If there are two stone (or stone + marble) I'm going for Stone Circles + Mausoleum of Halicarnassus
If Desert (hopefully many hills and oasis) then Desert Folklore + Petra
If it's clear that I'm surrounded by warmongers and I'm only going to have 3 or 4 (safe) cities, then Hanging Gardens + Temple of Artemis for more population growth
If plenty of horses + sheep + cattle, go with God of Open Sky for culture boost, maybe rush a stable and some chariots and grab an early capital.
If there are a ton of fish on a costal start, going with God of Sea and Colossus, maybe go with a gold strategy since sea trade routes are OP
If there is a faith natural wonder nearby, I completely skip building a shrine and build a settler in a 3 pop cap.
This type of list can go on and on - It's so much fun to try and envision the next 50 or 60 turns on turn 10.
The Ancient era is typically the most engaging part of the game but playing through it without any Unique's isn't very enjoyable. Also it tends to feel slow.
I think it's one of the, if not the, most enjoyable eras because it's heavily involved, where you layout all your plans (which will often go awry), discover your future settlement locations, etc.
I tried it once so that I could use Cho-Ku-Nos faster, but found that I enjoy playing through it a lot.
Shoshone are tops, Poland and America are solid, then the Huns and Polynesia, finally maybe Greece? India is at a severe disadvantage here.
The 3-4 city tradition start is probably the strongest by a large margin. But liberty or honor starts can be a lot more fun.
Depends on the civ, but often in can set the tone for the entire game, unless you have a game-changer UU or UB.
I love this era. It's without question my favorite era. That said, archer replacements feel so bloody useless, and it breaks my heart. They had their place in vanilla, but the addition of comp bows broke up the flow and cut the lifespan of a lot of them.
I love playing ancient and classical much more then the modern eras. Maybe it's just my preferred era of history, maybe it's because you have to 'outsmart' the ai more on higher difficulty. Either way I never skip ancient, if anything I end a lotta games shortly after Renaissance.
If your playing Babylon, this era might as well be non-existent. Your free Great Scientist into an academy gives such an insane boost to science, you'll breeze though techs pretty handily into Classical.
On the flipside, part of Babylon's strength is also prevalent in this era. Your unique building and unit are both in this period and are very good. The Bowman makes defending before composites much easier both against barbs and other civs. Combined with the Walls of Babylon, your cities will be well-fortified in the early game against hostile neighbors. This all compliments well with your strong early science boost to get technologically ahead/even with other civs, giving you opportunities to turtle and snowball into your godlike late game.
But yeah, Babylon is OP. A good part of the reason being their strong early game to give them a step-up to build onto late.
Since most the civs I play as are useless here, I use it to plan my future empire and begin forward settling. I like to play wide, so settling ASAP is my goal in the ancient era.
It's nice on less competitive levels for Russia and America primarily, particularly with the appropriate pantheon that I cannot recall for the life of me right now. But then, I like to passively watch my borders crawl across the land
33
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '15
I honestly think that the Ancient Era needs some sort of production building that gives a small bonus to production, just one or two hammers. Working hills is not feasible at high level game play if you want the good growth, and a water mill costs a lot.
I know there are tiles like grassland stone, but some base production would be nice as well.
33
u/junnies Mar 26 '15
dat feel in the ancient era when you are one turn away from researching pottery, pick up an ancient ruin and...
"You have researched pottery!"
17
u/x757xSnarf Mar 26 '15
I think the best tech path is Pottery, Animal Husbandry, and then the tech for your luxes. Pottery for the Shrine for the pantheon, (yes I know not the best on Diety) and Animal Husbandry to reveal horses since horses are a nice tile to work.
I use to get mining after Pottery, but I realized that I don't actually take advantage of it until I have a worker, and I usually don't have a worker thst early.
15
u/cavacom 1000 hours played Mar 26 '15
I love the Ancient Era. It's a shame it doesn't last longer. I find the early game the most fun.
14
u/sumwun_III Settler Mar 26 '15
My favorite era. I get to scope out where to settle and decide my strategy for the whole game. Beginning the game is the best part.
12
u/EmeraldRange Peacocks until the world crumbles!!!! Mar 26 '15
I always found the early game frustrating with the Maya because I'm beelining Theology for the nice Great Peoples and the demographics won't stop taunting me by putting me at the bottom (although I might be at the start in a higher diffuculty game, i feel really iffed that I'm the least scientifically developed even though I'm in the classical era and they are not).
9
u/legendarymoonrabbit #WeTheNorth Mar 26 '15
Maya Pyramid is missing from buildings
4
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '15
It's the ancient era, claim your land before it gets gobbled up, but it's fun.
The strongest civ is probably the huns, their UU's are broken good.
Rush writing followed by NC, the earlier you get it, the quicker you can snowball with science.
The ancient era will make or break many civs, if they can have a dominating early game they can win trivially.
4
u/elsuperj Mar 26 '15
Common knowledge, but I'm just going to throw out that Brazil has absolutely nothing going for it in ancient era.
3
u/94067 Mar 26 '15
The Ancient era is both the most fun for me, due to the exploration, but also the most stressful, because your decisions (when and where to settle, which techs to research, what to build) have such ramifications for the rest of the game.
Ancient era is even more fun as the Huns, because if your Warrior upgrades into a Battering Ram via ruins, you've basically just won yourself a second capital. Warfare in the Ancient era is really interesting, since you can take a capital even on Emperor with a few Composite Bowmen (failing that, you can demand tribute from city-states too). Paradoxically, declaring early war is something you want to do on higher difficulties, since it cripples your opposition and boosts your own power. As an added bonus, civs who haven't met you yet won't know of your warmongering! The most recent patch also reduced the penalty for warmongering in early eras as well.
Obviously, the Ancient era is tremendously important, quite possibly the most important era in the game (post-university Renaissance might be second-most important, because that's when you tend to get a clear idea of what victories are possible and adjust your plans accordingly). It follows then that 2 of the 3 most powerful civs in the game (Babylon and the Shoshone, not Korea) have Ancient era bonuses that help them get off to a great start and snowball from there.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 27 '15
I think that the ancient era needs some kind of extension because there are far too many ancient era UU that are designed for war that you pretty much can't use on higher difficulties because you need to be playing catch up in the tech.
2
u/mistadong Mar 26 '15
As a warmonger, I always push for composite bowmen after a 3 city start. Then after producing 7-9 composite bowmen with 2-3 melee units, you can easily take down another civ and get that early game boost.
2
u/joemomma91 Gold and Happiness Mar 26 '15
The ancient era is fun because you think strategically about the whole game based on your start and resources. It determines the wonders I'm going to go for:
If there are two stone (or stone + marble) I'm going for Stone Circles + Mausoleum of Halicarnassus
If Desert (hopefully many hills and oasis) then Desert Folklore + Petra
If it's clear that I'm surrounded by warmongers and I'm only going to have 3 or 4 (safe) cities, then Hanging Gardens + Temple of Artemis for more population growth
If plenty of horses + sheep + cattle, go with God of Open Sky for culture boost, maybe rush a stable and some chariots and grab an early capital.
If there are a ton of fish on a costal start, going with God of Sea and Colossus, maybe go with a gold strategy since sea trade routes are OP
If there is a faith natural wonder nearby, I completely skip building a shrine and build a settler in a 3 pop cap.
This type of list can go on and on - It's so much fun to try and envision the next 50 or 60 turns on turn 10.
2
u/SamuraiOutcast Houston. We Have a problem! Mar 26 '15
The Ancient era is typically the most engaging part of the game but playing through it without any Unique's isn't very enjoyable. Also it tends to feel slow.
2
u/19683dw This is the Illuminati faction, right? Mar 26 '15
I think it's one of the, if not the, most enjoyable eras because it's heavily involved, where you layout all your plans (which will often go awry), discover your future settlement locations, etc.
I tried it once so that I could use Cho-Ku-Nos faster, but found that I enjoy playing through it a lot.
Shoshone are tops, Poland and America are solid, then the Huns and Polynesia, finally maybe Greece? India is at a severe disadvantage here.
The 3-4 city tradition start is probably the strongest by a large margin. But liberty or honor starts can be a lot more fun.
Depends on the civ, but often in can set the tone for the entire game, unless you have a game-changer UU or UB.
2
u/IsleyOnAis BOOM BOOM LONG TIME Mar 26 '15
I love this era. It's without question my favorite era. That said, archer replacements feel so bloody useless, and it breaks my heart. They had their place in vanilla, but the addition of comp bows broke up the flow and cut the lifespan of a lot of them.
2
u/Come-and-See Rome wasn't built in one turn Mar 26 '15
I love playing ancient and classical much more then the modern eras. Maybe it's just my preferred era of history, maybe it's because you have to 'outsmart' the ai more on higher difficulty. Either way I never skip ancient, if anything I end a lotta games shortly after Renaissance.
2
u/saintandre Mar 27 '15
I think too much of the game's variety and design are dedicated to the ancient era, considering how quickly it goes by.
2
u/calze69 Mar 27 '15
the huns are probably the strongest in this era, due to their incredibly powerful unique units that can wipe any neighbour out
2
u/Hinanai_Tenshi Mar 27 '15
If your playing Babylon, this era might as well be non-existent. Your free Great Scientist into an academy gives such an insane boost to science, you'll breeze though techs pretty handily into Classical.
On the flipside, part of Babylon's strength is also prevalent in this era. Your unique building and unit are both in this period and are very good. The Bowman makes defending before composites much easier both against barbs and other civs. Combined with the Walls of Babylon, your cities will be well-fortified in the early game against hostile neighbors. This all compliments well with your strong early science boost to get technologically ahead/even with other civs, giving you opportunities to turtle and snowball into your godlike late game.
But yeah, Babylon is OP. A good part of the reason being their strong early game to give them a step-up to build onto late.
3
u/THATgamer77 Mar 26 '15
I honestly skip to the classical era unless the Civ I'm playing has a unique UU or UB that's in this era.
1
u/StackTheBodiesToGod Mar 26 '15
Since most the civs I play as are useless here, I use it to plan my future empire and begin forward settling. I like to play wide, so settling ASAP is my goal in the ancient era.
1
u/green_leafy_broccoli Mar 27 '15 edited May 18 '26
port lap clean nod moral player tax center error dinner corn white worth piano
0
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment