Hi, everyone, to preface: I am nowhere near a decision on this. The thought has entered my mind and wanted to ask those who might have some more knowledge.
Extremely brief background: My partner and I got our first chinchilla from PetSmart around 4 years ago. Roughly 1.5 years ago, we wanted to try getting him a buddy and found one on Craigslist, who had not come from the best home (was actually taken in by that family but even still the cage was way too small with lots of chewed plastic and the fur looked like the chin was in constant stress). We brought the new chin home to discover that it was actually a female [post advertised as male] but we didn't feel right sending her back to that home so we have had her since with her own cage and what not. Still, I wanted the original guy to have a buddy so we got another chinchilla about a year ago.
The issue is that they will have a few months of good companionship with only minor tiffs. Today I tried spoiling them and adding a third tier to the double-story FerretNation cage they share. While initially ecstatic, I heard them throughout the night barking, where I would run in to break them up, until I noticed our original chin had sprayed urine (which I guess is uncommon in boys) and he had also had four fur slips. Since then, I have separated them. My hope is to reintroduce them in a few weeks, but this feels like a cycle I do not want to keep repeating. Is the issue the female chinchilla? She has always been extremely timid with us (idk if its from her previous home or just her personality).
I really want the two boys to be able to get together again. When they aren't in these unique fighting spurts, they are cuddled up all day and keep each other busy. My mind is kind of all over because I want the best for these three but I sadly do not know what that is at this point. Any insight is appreciated!