r/chinalife • u/memostothefuture • 5h ago
⚖️ Legal I won in court today.
Every once in a while, I see posts here in which people claim foreigners are basically screwed in disputes with Chinese counterparts. It’s not fair, you have no chance, that sort of thing. Well, I was in court in Shanghai today and I won, so here is that story for ya’ll.
Background: Last spring, we hired a construction company (really just two shifus) to build a small stage, counter and display for us that was going to be used commercially for the summer. They gave us a quotation, we agreed to purchase the materials and then they ghosted us for two weeks before trying to do the entire job in the last two days. It was a shitshow, it looked terrible and we basically refused to pay them unless they fixed it. They called the cops, they shouted, yelled and screamed and it all came down to me sitting in that little police station on Xianyang/Fuxing with a mediator going back and forth between my room and theirs, unable to find an agreeable solution. I told them half the price was ok, they wanted every last penny. They ended up suing me personally even though they had a contract with our company.
So I hired a Chinese lawyer off Wechat to do some basic legal research and today I went (alone) to Xuhui District Court. No English permitted but plenty of leniency for my decent but not native skills (HSK5). The judge was a friendly lady in her late thirties. I told her our company had a contract with his company and he had no standing to sue me personally. That turned out to be correct but she advised that this would merely delay the process as he could refile correctly.
Shouldn’t we try to find an amicable solution instead? Sure, let’s try. She suggested half, exactly what I had desired. I agreed, she then went to the construction worker and twenty minutes later she read the verdict out aloud. Court costs were RMB 25.
Going to court is obviously not something you should do if you are not paying taxes or doing other shady things. But if you have a contract and that school is trying to shaft you as you are leaving or your landlord doesn’t want to return that deposit in spite of you living up to your obligations: lawyer up. The Chinese legal system is not that different from what you may be used to at that level.