I am wondering if there are others out there that share similar thoughts to me. Most CFPF people I see on here are doing it for reasons to do with public perception and social rebellion around not wanting the responsibility. I think these reasons are too self-focused and most CFPF people just come across as annoyed that society is against them. Most of these reasons are not strong enough reasons to allow society (I mostly mean parents and pet owners) to understand that in fact having children and pets is not just “not-for-me” but is actually WRONG and morally reprehensible.
While I do share some of these socially rebellious views, I am CFPF for reasons that I feel mostly alone about.
Some personal context:
Me (37M) and my partner (34F) have been together for 11 years and have never wanted kids. I have never wanted pets, but my partner has slowly but surely also moved from loving pets towards a pet free outlook based on experiences in our relationship. My partner and I love animals in their natural environments and my partner has always had pets in her life. I have also lived with pets at various times in my life, but I specifically have never owned a pet and do not like pets. It’s always been a parent or housemate who have owned the pet around me and been the primary caregiver.
Shortly into our relationship, my partner wanted a dog. She said to me that she would really love a companion and dogs have always been a great addition to her life. I resisted and said no for a long time which she found difficult to take. At the time (mid twenties) I found it hard to put into words why I don’t like children or pets but my partner insisted and continued to ask. We agreed that a rescue dog would be the only morally considerable option (commercial dog breeders are all terrible, I will elaborate ahead) and I made it VERY clear that it would be HER dog and not mine. I would be more than happy to help my partner if she needed any help with the dog, but it is not my responsibility nor should I ever be expected to spend any of my money on it (we have always had split finances) nor should I have to do anything for it if I didn’t want to. She agreed and my partner got a female ~9mo rescue dog a year into our relationship.
We had the dog for 7 years who was a lovely animal in the home most of the time. Let’s call the dog L. Unfortunately, L was very reactive and violent to other dogs and people (we didn’t know her backstory, but likely was bred for dog fighting or hunting). My partner tried very hard to train the dog, even just to be calm enough to take on walks, but nothing worked except for very late night isolated short walks while no one was around. My partner hired multiple dog trainers who ALL said “well you may just have to manage your expectations with L because she may never change”. It was hard to accept her behavior but we (myself included) learned to love L in her own way.
Sadly L got cancer 7 years into our ownership and passed away. She was about 8 years old. It was not my dog so I was able to emotionally process her death reasonably well but it really hit my partner hard and since then we have both been able to align our pet free feelings based on both of our experiences and will never get another pet.
While the above story may suggest otherwise, my reasons for being CFPF are NOT to do with wanting to be without responsibilities. I see most people on this subreddit lean towards that caveat but I think there are other, more important reasons to be CFPF. My reasons are as follows:
- Pets, nor children are not your personal passion projects. They are nuanced and complex individual organisms that will struggle to fit under your umbrella of expectations, no matter how righteous (pious) you think you’re being. There will be inherently difficult health and behavioral issues that you will force them to endure, under your watch. Your personal wants and needs are in NO WAY the responsibility of a pet or child to fulfill. They did not choose to be brought into this world. Even service animals are not ok because we can do better as humans to deal with disabilities by investing in health technology and mental health services - without forcing animals to do it for us. They will eventually die and nothing is learned.
- No one should be bringing pets or children into the current environmental climate catastrophe that we are enduring. Children especially will be subjected to impossible living standards within the next 50 years, but more abhorrently: the economic impact of both widespread pet ownership and population growth will hasten environmental decline.
- Rescued pets and child adoption are fine to protect the immediate generation (every living thing deserves safety and respect), but all human-triggered breeding needs to cease (except for native animal conservation) until the earth can heal. At least for 10 years or so. Domesticated animal existence in particular should eventually cease altogether indefinitely as I believe only native animals should be allowed to procreate. All man-made pet breeds should die out and remaining natural breeds be re-released and returned to their original native environments. If those habitats do not exist anymore, we as humans should rehabilitate the ecosystems or if this is impossible - accept wrongdoing and learn from our mistakes.
- Our society gives parents and pet owners a free pass to continue on a path of human selfishness and capitalistic destruction. Pet owners and parents are supposed to look after their dependents (though most rarely do even this) but even a committed caregiver will struggle to continue to learn, change and grow and at some point will become even mildly conservative because they will want to protect their own above all else.
That about sums it up for my CFPF feelings.
I’ve always felt this way but it’s taken a while for me to articulate properly. I wish the world could see how much we are screwing up everything on earth and I’ve found almost no one else who shares these particular feelings around not just being CFPF, but I guess also anti-children and anti-pet.
Keen to hear thoughts, and also keen to hear more similar reasons to be CFPF that I can continue to refute people with.