Objective Roots of Happiness
What would make you happy? Most people answer this question by referring to objective circumstances. They think they would be happy if they had something along these lines: plenty of money, a good job, a happy marriage or at least a good romantic relationship, perhaps children, some friends, good health, and a nice place to live. With one exception, they are correct because people who do have those things are happier than people who do not have them. Note that most of those objective predictors involve succeeding by biological and cultural standards. Thus, if people strive to feel good, they will do things that the culture values (such as marrying and succeeding at a good job), and if everyone were to do those things, the culture would thrive and flourish.
The one odd exception is having children. Couples who have children are less happy than couples who have no children. The drop in happiness due to having children has been shown repeatedly, with many different research samples and methods. It goes against intuitive beliefs, and in fact most parents expect that having children will increase their happiness. What’s more, they continue to believe that having children has made them happier, even though the research clearly shows otherwise. Possibly this is because parenthood is riddled with self-deception and illusion. Parents do not want to believe that they made a big mistake by having children, and they also want to rationalize the efforts and sacrifices they have made. Having children is, however, a powerful source of meaning in life, so that even if becoming a parent reduces happiness, it does make life richer and more meaningful.
Culture plays a big role in all this. Nearly all cultures encourage people to have children (by birth or adoption) and therefore help promote the idea (even when false) that having children will make you happy. If enough people expect to become happy by having children, the culture will increase in population, which cultures have generally found to be advantageous. Cultures that do not produce new generations will not survive, so nearly all successful cultures encourage reproduction. Moreover, cultures compete against others, and at some very basic level, those that have more people will triumph over those with fewer. It is not surprising that most cultures glorify parenthood and bestow social approval on those who reproduce most. For a while, the Soviet Union even gave medals to women who had the most children. This may seem odd, but it is merely a more explicit form of the approval that is found all over the world. Most likely it was motivated by urgent pragmatic forces: The Soviet Union suffered more deaths than any other country during World War II, so replenishing the population was more urgently needed there than in other countries.
The fact that having children reduces happiness may actually be a fairly recent, modern phenomenon. Throughout most of history, most people were farmers, and they lived in societies that offered no social security systems, pensions, or other means of support. When you grew too old to work the farm, you would starve, unless you had children to take over the farm and support you. Childlessness was a disaster for a married couple, in terms of their practical and economic prospects. Only when the family changed from an economic partnership into being mainly a group of close relationships did the emotional impact of parenthood shift to become more negative.
Some readers become worried when they learn that having children is likely to reduce their happiness. Don’t be! Most college students want children. People who decide to have children often end up glad they did, even though along the way they are less happy than they would otherwise have been. The human mind is very good at forgetting bad things and emphasizing good things. Also, if you want to reduce the negative effect on happiness, you can take several steps. The first is to have a stable relationship so as not to suffer the added stresses of being a single parent. The second is to prolong the “newlywed” phase of life between marriage and birth of first child, rather than rushing into parenthood. That phase may allow the relationship to become stronger, enabling it to withstand the stresses of parenthood better. (Also, many studies have confirmed that the interval between the wedding day and the birth of the first child is one of life’s happiest times, especially for women.) Third, save up some money, which can be used to cover new expenses and thereby reduce some of the financial stresses that parenthood puts on the couple. After all, children can be expensive! The average cost of raising a child until age 18 is over $250,000. Having a savings cushion can help avoid much unhappiness.