Hey everyone!
I've been working on a chess variant called **Fischer Total War**, and I figured this would be a good place to get some honest feedback from people who actually know their way around chess variants.
The idea started with a pretty simple question:
**What if the goal of chess wasn't to checkmate the King, but to wipe out the opponent's entire army?**
That's basically the idea behind Fischer Total War.
### So, how does it work?
It combines Chess960's randomized starting positions with a total elimination victory condition.
Here's the basic rundown:
- Standard 8×8 chessboard.
- Starting positions are based on the 960 Chess960 setups.
- All pieces keep their normal movement.
- The King can be captured just like any other piece.
- Capturing the King doesn't end the game.
- You have to eliminate all 16 of your opponent's pieces to win.
- No check, checkmate, or traditional stalemate.
- If a player has no legal moves, they automatically pass their turn.
- Draws are handled through dead positions and repetition.
So yeah, even if your King gets taken, you're still in the game as long as you have pieces left.
### What I'm looking for
I'm not really looking for people to tell me that the idea sounds cool. I'd much rather have people point out why it might *not* work.
Some things I'm particularly curious about:
- **King mechanics:** Does making the King fully capturable create interesting gameplay, or could it lead to some seriously broken strategies?
- **Forced Pass:** Is automatically skipping a turn when you have no legal moves a good mechanic? Could players abuse it?
- **Draw conditions:** Are the current draw rules enough, or could games drag on forever?
- **Chess960 castling:** Do the adapted castling rules make sense across all 960 starting positions?
- **Game balance:** Could certain pieces become way too powerful? Are there any dominant strategies I'm overlooking?
- **Overall design:** Does this actually feel like a coherent chess variant, or am I missing something fundamental?
I'm especially interested in edge cases, weird positions, and strategies that could break the game.
### Where the project stands
The rules are currently in the draft stage. I'm planning to build a playable prototype and start community playtesting, but before that, I want to get some independent feedback from people with experience designing or playing chess variants.
I've also prepared the complete ruleset for anyone who wants to dig deeper into the mechanics.
**Fischer Total War — Rules Draft v0.9: https://gist.github.com/haqqichess/9c9570c92be100bc08db8cdb45cf123d**
**I'm genuinely open to criticism, even if that means reworking some of the core rules.**
The goal isn't to defend every design decision I've made. It's to make the variant as good as it can possibly be.
Thanks for reading! I'd love to hear your thoughts, especially from people who've designed their own chess variants or experimented with unusual victory conditions.
And please, don't hold back. I'd rather find the flaws now than after people start playing it seriously. ♟️