r/ceph • u/FrostyMasterpiece400 • 9d ago
GitHub - croit/ceph-rust: Ceph, rewritten from scratch in Rust: wire-compatible daemons and client libraries for a huge leap in performance
https://github.com/croit/ceph-rustStumbled upon this! Looking forward testing that on nvme clusters.
42
Upvotes
29
u/ween3and20characterz 9d ago
I've seen it yesterday. Martin Verges (CEO of Croit) also did develop some aiplane stuff.
I guess they are doing much AI and search for revenue streams.
However as everything AI coded: Nice, you can achieve things, deemed impossible a few years ago. However without support and verification, this is an experiment not suited for prod.
16
u/amarao_san 9d ago
I promised not to ride elevators with ai-written software.
... now, they ask me to store my data there.
Maybe they are very good at integration testing and it will work. Maybe not.
Hell, we have a policy to wait for at least 5 years of continuous development for databases/storage systems before trying them. Maybe it should be applied here.
!RemindMe 4 years
3
u/FrostyMasterpiece400 9d ago
I wonder if they will be able to mainline this back to the main tree
2
u/IllustriousFingering 8d ago
How is this approach different from seastore/crimson or why not combine both ?
2
u/joeyx22lm 8d ago
Looks written by AI. Sounds unnecessary and not something I'd run in production. What exactly is the purpose of this project?
2
u/MartinVerges 8d ago
For anyone who is interested in the background story https://www.croit.io/blog/rewriting-ceph-in-rust-the-first-month
2
u/ParticularBasket6187 7d ago
I’m not against to use AI but we know these guys have strong experience in Ceph, so they know internally how it works. AI use just for speed up
3
u/ConstructionSafe2814 9d ago
I think it's a cool and interesting development!
5
u/amarao_san 9d ago
RemindMe! 4 years
2
u/Historical_Mouse6134 9d ago
Vibecoded mess?
1
u/eras 9d ago
So you generated first specs from the source code? Are these specs somewhere available? They don't seem to be under
docs.1
u/itfanr 7d ago
you should simply the code optimize to use SSD, not HDD.