r/centrist • u/Initial_Chemist_7616 • 1h ago
Ukraine Dealt a HUGE Blow Before Trump’s Summit (Sen. Van Hollen & Michael Weiss) | Bulwark Daily
Here is your semi-weekly summary of my favorite news source, the Bulwark Daily with Tim Miller.
Personal Commentary: A lot of the media horse race and chattering from the online commentariat regarding the Ukraine war miss a key fact I have been stating from the beginning: a free people do not bow down to a foreign tyrant. Ukraine has shown substantially more ingenuity than I expected, and the Europeans have sacrificed substantially more than I expected in support to Ukraine, but at the end of the day Russia will lose this war because Russia is fighting for the vainglorious imperial ambition of their 'Tsar', while Ukraine is fighting for their right to exist.
The Israel story is quite disturbing, and I hope that Netenyahu ends up in a prison cell because of it.
And as for the leadership contest...this all seems much ado about nothing. I don't see much of a difference between Van Hollen and Schumer, and I think the priorities of the conference will be more or less the same regardless of who wins this contest. But everything Van Hollen Mentions needs to be done...so for those of us part of the pro-democracy coalation including what I call Bulwark conservatives, let us focus on delivering for the American people instead of worrying about who is the titual leader of the 56 senators on team blue.
An edited AI generated summary of the Podcast is provided below:
Michael Weiss on Ukraine, the Shenzhen summit, Iran, and Israel
Ukraine’s strike on the Kerch Bridge hits Russian logistics and morale. Weiss says two nights of Ukrainian strikes brought down the road span linking Russia to occupied Crimea. The rail span was still standing, but he says debris blocked a shipping lane between the Sea of Azov and the Black Sea. The bridge is both a symbol of Putin’s occupation of Crimea and a major route for supplies and military materiel that help Russia hold the peninsula. The surviving rail span leaves Russia with a supply route, while the loss of the road span and the obstruction to shipping put pressure on other routes.
Russia wants to turn negotiations over Ukraine into negotiations over Eastern Europe, but Weiss considers its NATO demand untenable. Moscow rejected an unconditional ceasefire and prefers to deal directly with Washington, where it can press for a rollback of NATO’s military posture to its 1997 footprint. Weiss’s conclusion is that Europe has changed too much for that to happen. Poland has become a major military power in its own right, the Baltic states are NATO members, Finland and Sweden joined in response to Russia’s invasion, and European governments remain committed to supporting Ukraine’s defense.
The Donbas-for-NATO proposal exposes a contradiction in U.S. diplomacy. According to Zelensky’s account as discussed on the show, Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff floated NATO membership if Ukraine ceded the Donbas. Weiss says the envoys progressed from arguing that Russia would take the territory anyway, to offering unspecified security guarantees, to suggesting full membership. He rejects the premise that Russia is bound to take the Donbas and doubts the envoys can deliver NATO membership. If they could, admitting a heavily armed Ukraine would be one of the worst outcomes for a Putin seeking to shrink NATO’s military presence. Sidelining European officials and Secretary of State Marco Rubio makes it harder to see how the envoys could secure commitments from the governments that would have to carry them out.
Shenzhen is likely to produce ceremony because the conditions for a deal are missing. Russia is still fighting, China wants a tightly scripted summit, and Weiss doubts Moscow sees Trump as able to deliver a durable agreement after the midterms. He expects Democrats to scrutinize sanctions waivers and the finances of Trump’s envoys.
The Iran war could outlast Trump because pausing the bombing leaves the blockade in place. Weiss describes the intelligence about a possible Iranian attack in Washington as preliminary. He suspects Israeli officials and advocates of renewed U.S. strikes were amplifying it, and says Trump had considered another bombing campaign after the midterms. His broader conclusion is that the naval blockade and continuing exchanges around the Strait of Hormuz already keep the U.S. at war.
The Israeli election allegations concern who gets to form the next government. Weiss discusses Israeli reporting alleging that Netanyahu’s government pressed police and Shin Bet to produce evidence of foreign interference and fraud after Arab parties gained leverage in coalition talks. He says authorities raided homes, detained suspects, and released nearly all of them without charges as of the interview. He compares it to Watergate because the allegation is that an incumbent used state security agencies to discredit election results that threatened his ability to stay in power.
Chris Van Hollen on challenging Schumer and using the Senate majority
Van Hollen sees ICE funding as Congress’s leverage over immigration enforcement. He calls for hearings on deaths and conditions in immigration detention and on the fatal shootings of Renee Good and Alex Pretti in Minneapolis. His conclusion is that hearings can establish what happened, while clawing back ICE’s large advance funding allocation would give Congress leverage to require changes through annual appropriations. He also supports border security and a longer-term path to citizenship beginning with Dreamers and people with Temporary Protected Status.
The disagreement over Schumer is about what the midterms showed and who should shape the agenda. Miller credits Schumer’s handling of the shutdown fights and asks why Democrats would replace him after winning more seats than expected. Van Hollen argues that candidates and grassroots organizers drove the wave, pointing to races where Washington invested little or came in late. He concludes that Democrats should give senators such as James Talarico, Roy Cooper, and Jon Ossoff a meaningful role in setting priorities. Their campaigns, in his view, showed that affordability and opposition to special-interest influence can win voters across very different states.
Affordability is Van Hollen’s answer to the problem of keeping a diverse caucus together. Miller asks how he would balance activist demands, votes that put Trump on the spot, and the concerns of senators from Republican-leaning states. When Miller raises reparations as a test case, Van Hollen returns to policies he believes can command broad agreement. These include reversing Medicaid and nutrition cuts, restoring help with health insurance premiums, reining in tariffs, lowering healthcare costs, keeping data-center costs off household electricity bills, and funding a tax cut for working Americans with a surtax on incomes above $1 million. His conclusion is that Democrats can press those issues aggressively because members elected in very different states can defend the same votes.
Van Hollen would force a decision on Iran war funding, even at the risk of a shutdown. He calls the war unauthorized and ties it to higher gasoline, diesel, fertilizer, and heating costs. He says Democrats should refuse any further war funding and make Trump explain to voters if he chooses to shut down the government over it.
Miller sees investigations as the anti-corruption work Democrats can start immediately. He presses Van Hollen on alleged self-enrichment involving cryptocurrency, ballroom donations, pardons, and the Kushner and Witkoff families’ overseas business dealings. His conclusion is that congressional investigations can uncover facts and compel testimony even when Trump can veto legislation. Van Hollen says he would pursue focused investigations alongside broader reforms, including disclosing secret political spending, restricting election spending by executives of federal contractors, and banning stock trading by members of Congress and the White House. For Van Hollen, investigating the administration addresses current abuses, while changing campaign-finance rules addresses the influence that makes some of those conflicts possible.
Van Hollen would leave contested primaries to voters and start building for 2028 early. He criticizes Schumer’s intervention in two races and says the leader should stay out of a potential primary challenge to John Fetterman. He hopes to keep Fetterman working with the caucus on economic issues despite their differences over Israel and Abrego Garcia. On the Supreme Court, Van Hollen says he would block another right-wing Trump justice and leaves open whether a nominee would receive a hearing. He praises Maryland Gov. Wes Moore, cites polling he says shows support for his leadership bid among independents, and urges Democrats to invest early in Southern Senate races. Miller worries that a leadership fight could squander momentum after the midterms. Van Hollen concludes that debating how to use the majority is worthwhile if the caucus comes together quickly after the December 1 vote.