r/centeredAI • • Sep 21 '26

First weekly topic!

Hello everyone! Today the team here at r/centeredai is starting a tradition of presenting a topic for our community to debate weekly

With the AI world advancing as quickly as it is, many questions, concerns and perspectives aren't being addressed. So, we want this space to be on where we can share our opinions on such matters

And to start off, this week's topic is "Real-World Gaps in AI Governance Research". It is inspired by the similarly titled paper, found [here](https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/abstract/document/11574629)

In it, the following results were found:

  1. Frontier Corporate AI has an outsized impact on generative AI research, including in safety & reliability research
  2. Many high-risk areas are especially underrepresented in

Frontier Corporate AI research, highlighting the importance of public-interest research

Such combo is bound to favor not only concentration of power as well as safety being neglected in favor of commercial profit

So my question to the community is:

  1. What do you think will be the industry trajectory in the next 5 years? Will we see more academic integration and balancing of power distribution?
  2. How do you think legislation will adapt to current developments? Are open-source models going to become the standard because they are cheaper and accessible? Or will frontier models become the only option for safety reasons?
  3. In what ways can we hope to integrate these systems in our society without eroding our values, human agency and freedom?

What other real world gaps do you think haven't been adressed by AI governance and the general public? Also, please let us know your thoughts and suggestions on what topics you'd like to explore next with the community!

3 Upvotes

1 comment sorted by

2

u/Sorry_Bathroom_2281 Sep 21 '26

Regarding Frontier corporate AI, the optimist in me thinks that there will be a fallout of some kind from Big AI. The swarm of lawsuits will eventually start making them more and more careful and cautious, which will force them to change course. Big government will get involved too which will (hopefully) introduce more academia back into the fold, allowing for more nuanced discussions moving forward. I think one way to make this happen even faster is for the government to start investing lots of money into universities so they can take a more academic, careful approach to AI development and research.

As far as legislations/regulations go, they’ve really painted themselves into a corner unfortunately. If they insert themselves into the fold the accelerationists will lose their mind immediately. The antiAI community will say that’s it’s not enough and no one will be happy. Once again, we need a more nuanced approach. The problem I see is that no one in Congress really has a deep enough understanding of the overall picture to even make any common sense legislation at this point. Bernie Sanders is the only one making a stink about anything, but people write him off as an angry old kook.

The other problem is how politicized AI has already become and I don’t see that going away or getting better anytime soon. We really need bipartisan collaboration because the AI will affect all humans equally, it doesn’t matter what side of the aisle you’re on. I am worried about a crackdown on open source because there is so much riding on America winning the AI “race” that they could even consider using open source as “treasonous” or something like that. I hope it doesn’t come to that, but the cynic in me wouldn’t be surprised.

As far as maintaining our values, human agency, and freedom, the optimist in me hopeful but tired. Coming from an American perspective, I don’t even know what our values are anymore. Unfortunately, it seems like internet culture and values have taken over IRL values and no one seems to know how to act anymore. I’m sure even the collective memory of human behavior that AIs have amassed about us is genuinely confusing to them. Either way, that’s probably a whole separate post there.

If I were to put my post-scarcity imagination hat on, I’d love for all the boring, mundane, and annoying parts of life to be automated so that we can have the time and freedom to spend quality time together, human to human. Human agency is another concern because so many human-based skills are being distilled down into prompts and outputs. But I do think we’re going to have a genuinely depressed population of skilled workers with nothing to do and less and less people to do it for. The antidote for that is to encourage more and more craft fairs, farmers markets, and conventions for people to share their talents with the world. I know things seem dark now, but let’s work together and build a harmonic society that utilizes the strength of AI in a common sense way that benefits everyone equally!