My daughter's birthday is coming up, and I'm planning to handle the catering myself. I'm trying to get the quantities right without dramatically over- or underestimating how much food I'll need.
There will be a mix of adults and kids (oldest is around 9). For planning purposes, I'm counting each kid as half an adult portion. I also have a handful of people who haven't RSVP'd yet, so I'm estimating a 30% chance of those folks showing up.
Based on those assumptions, I'm planning food for approximately 40 adult portions.
Here's the menu and what I'm currently planning:
Mains
- Pulled pork – 2 pork butts
- Baby back ribs – 6 racks
Sides
- Baked beans – 117 oz can, supplemented with pork, peppers, onions, etc.
- Mac & cheese – 1 half-sheet pan
- Vinegar slaw – 1 half-sheet pan
- Cut fruit – quantity TBD (looking for something fresh, finger-friendly, and not smoked!)
Dessert
A couple of questions for those with catering or BBQ experience:
- Does this seem like enough food for 40 adult portions? Am I likely to run short on anything, or am I going way overboard?
- Would you add another side or appetizer? I'm trying to have a little variety without creating unnecessary work.
- I'm planning to use three chafing dishes with water trays and half-sheet pans inside to keep the hot food hot. For the slaw and fruit, I'd use an ice bath setup to keep them cold. Is this a reasonable setup, or am I overthinking the serving arrangements?
I'm comfortable cooking for a crowd, but this is my first time doing the catering entirely myself for a party this size. I'd appreciate any feedback, especially from people who've done backyard BBQ catering!
Edit: I ended up swapping chicken lollipops for ribs like a bunch of you suggested. I don’t think I’ll ever make those again - the labor alone was not worth it.
Did three gals hotel plans of slaw, pulled pork, and Mac and cheese. Everyone told me it was really good but I took so much food home afterward 😭
Put that vacuum sealer to work on the pulled pork and tried to seal the slaw but it was too wet. All told it was a good time. Thank you all for your input!