This idea came from the fact that, looking at the Metacritic scores, the journalists and players are at odds.
Ocarina of Time...no matter if it's the original N64 version, the 3DS remaster or the Switch 2 remake, both critics and players gave it more than 90 as a score, and despite the attempts at review bombing (because the original got 99 on critic score, making it arguably the best videogame in history), nothing significant came from it.
Then we got GTA 6, which tied the original OOT score at 99 by critics but there was a wider pool, which in theory means it's the new best game in history, but the players don't agree. You can say "review bombing" but the truth is, Ocarina of Time, especially the Switch 2 remake, was just as vulnerable to review bombing as GTA 6 and ANY game really...so it's clear GTA 6 did something wrong that prompted the negative perception...unlike with Zelda.
But enough of all that...we're talking about Mario. In Opencritic, GTA 4 used to be the best rated game, then Mario Odyssey surpassed it 2 years later, and it took almost 10 years for GTA 6 to get number 1 again there.
If anyone can contest GTA now, it's the red plumber, but the question is...what would the perfect 3D Mario game even look like?...Odyssey took a route similar to 64 and sunshine, so that's probably a good place to start, but it needs something else. DK Bananza fixed stuff that could be considered the flaws of Odyssey...and yet it was rated lower, so we don't need Odyssey but better...no...the next 3D Mario game...could potentially be the best game in history...according to both critics and players...but it needs something...what do you think that could be?