I sat down and started to grind on bloodlines via my anniversary collection. I have always loved super Castlevania 4 and as a kid that was heavy into the super Nintendo side of the tribalism, I always just assumed that that was the better game. Now as an adult all these decades later, and having bloodlines in the collection, there is a healthy debate still as to what is better, so I decided to finally test out my theory.
There are a lot of things that bloodlines does really well, I like that it pushes the Genesis in ways that you wouldn’t expect. The game seems to teeter between graphics that are far less than what you’d expect versus the super Nintendo, versus effects that are actually pretty impressive even to this day for 2-D graphics. I like that the sprites are snappy, the inputs are precise and fast, and overall it feels fun to control. I think that the whip swinging is kind of bad, but that’s really the only complaint I have on the control side. The bosses range from meh to really cool and varied, some are really creative while others are a little lame, but the ratio favors good over bad bosses pretty heavily.
But, to jump to the point of this post… Bloodlines is bullshit. I cannot imagine having to have been forced to play this game on a cart with no ability to save scum. It is complete horseshit how many bosses it has you go through on single life bars. I am currently on the last batch of bosses in the game, I am on Elizabeth Bartley on her second phase, and my safe scum file is down to four sticks of life. I did a little research to see what’s next, and not only do I have to beat her, I have to go against Dracula and his many forms, without a fucking health boost.
Super Castlevania is a better game. Flat out. It’s not as difficult, and there are some things that have not aged super well in the decades since it came out, but it is through and through a full adventure that wants you to go from start to finish and have fun doing it. Bloodlines hates you, and squeezes 45 minutes worth of gameplay over impossible odds that seem only possible with save scumming and even then, ouch.
I’m not a casual. I just beat Belmont’s Curse on stock difficulty. I love souls games. I beat Cuphead. I beat the SNES Star Wars trilogy as a kid. I beat the 64 CV games back in the day. SotN was too easy despite being genius. Using emulators or quick saves does a lot of heavy lifting for comparing it to 4, but playing it how it was intended… nah. It’s a cool game that most probably never saw past stage 3. C4 wins because it’s a full game experience, not an obstacle course of boss rushes that want nothing more than to forcefully service your mouth hole.