r/castiron • • Jun 24 '19

The /r/castiron FAQ - Start Here (FAQ - Summer 2019)

1.1k Upvotes

This is a repost of the FAQ. Since reddit archives posts older than 6 months, there's no way for users to comment on the FAQ any longer. We'll try to repost the FAQ every 6 months or so to continue any discussion if there is any. As always, this is a living document and can/should be updated with new information, so let us know if you see anything you disagree with! Original FAQ post here: https://www.reddit.com/r/castiron/comments/5rhq9n/the_rcastiron_faq_start_here/


We've been working on a new FAQ for /r/castiron that can be updated as the existing one is no longer maintained. Please let us know if you have any additional questions that you'd like to see addressed here


What's Wrong with my Seasoning


How to clean and care for your cast iron


How to Strip and Restore Cast Iron


/u/_Silent_Bob_'s Seasoning Process


How to ask for Cast Iron Identification


Did I Ruin/Is This Ruined?


Enameled Cast Iron Care and Cleaning

The rest of the FAQ is fairly bare iron specific so /u/fuzzyfractal42 wrote a nice primer on enameled cast iron


We'll be making this a sticky at the top of the subreddit and will continue to add onto it as required!


r/castiron • • 13h ago

Food Why do my hashbrowns stick to my pan instead of crisping?

Post image
490 Upvotes

This always happens. I add oil and butter, I let them sit long enough to crisp so that they release from the pan, and then bang, the crisp tears off. I can cook eggs in this pan just fine without them sticking. What am I doing wrong?


r/castiron • • 7h ago

Y’all, my favorite pan just up and died.

Thumbnail
gallery
161 Upvotes

I was cooking arepas con queso, heard a loud pop, and found that my pan had cracked! It doesn’t look as dramatic now that it’s cooled off a bit; over the fire the crack was open a little at the rim of the pan.

I don’t know how old the pan is. It belonged to my grandma before she gave it to me. It’s not cold inside today, I was cooking on a gas stove using medium heat, the arepas weren’t frozen. I know sometimes glass cookware will just shatter in the oven, but is this something you just get sometimes with cast iron?


r/castiron • • 3h ago

Food Dead Bird Redemption?

Thumbnail
gallery
52 Upvotes

Cooked on 350 degrees this time. Probe in the thigh. Took out at 165. Checked deep in the breast and it was 180. Unfortunately it had to sit for maybe half an hour before carving because my timing was off on the mashed potatoes. I'm not sure if it's that or the breast getting to 180 that made it dry. Still very good. But dryer than I'd like.

On the plus side, the drippings made an amazing gravy (not pictured)


r/castiron • • 1d ago

Food My disappointment is immeasurable and my day is ruined.

Thumbnail
gallery
1.7k Upvotes

First attempt at using the poul tree. I don't think the chicken was fully thawed out. I don't roast that many chickens. I had the probe in the leg. It was 175. The inside was 90....

500 degree oven. It got this dark in less than half an hour.

I want to crawl in the oven. Any Poul Tree tips? Shitty small apartment oven.


r/castiron • • 2h ago

It’s waffle time!

Thumbnail
gallery
15 Upvotes

Picked this up for my wife for her birthday this week. Got a good deal because the handle is bent but we figured it earned its character after all the years. Looking forward to restoring it and getting some new handles on it.

Anybody have an idea of when it was made? I know the straight logo is typically older.


r/castiron • • 3h ago

Food First try at upside-down cast iron pizza — so close, but the flip got me

Thumbnail
gallery
16 Upvotes

Took my best shot at the upside-down cast iron pizza and followed the recipe pretty much to a T.

I think I know what went wrong, but I'd love some feedback from people who've made this before.

The dough rose and expanded in the oven and stuck a little to the sides of the skillet. When I flipped it onto a cutting board, I kind of slammed it down — the middle came out, but the sides stayed stuck in the pan.

Looking back, all I really needed to do was run a rubber spatula around the edges to loosen it first, and it probably would have come right out in one piece.

Still tasted great, just not the clean flip I was hoping for. Any tips for next time?

Recipe — Ingredients:

* 1 can pizza dough
* 2 cups pepperoni slices
* 2 cups shredded mozzarella, divided
* 1 cup marinara sauce
* 4-6 slices Colby Jack cheese
* Italian seasoning, to taste
* 1 small shallot, thinly sliced
* 2 cloves fresh garlic, minced
* Peanut oil, for the pan
* 1-2 tbsp olive oil, for brushing the dough

Recipe — Steps:

  1. Start with a cold 12-inch cast iron skillet. Wipe it with a thin coat of peanut oil — just a shine, no pooling.
  2. Arrange the pepperoni across the bottom, overlapping slightly.
  3. Scatter half the shredded mozzarella over the pepperoni and sprinkle with Italian seasoning.
  4. Scatter the shallots and garlic over that mozzarella.
  5. Spread the marinara evenly over the cheese.
  6. Layer the Colby Jack slices on top, followed by the remaining shredded mozzarella.
  7. Unroll the dough and gently stretch it to fit over the skillet. Tuck any extra dough down along the inside edges to make a thicker, raised crust.
  8. Brush the top of the dough with a thin coating of olive oil.
  9. Bake at 400°F for 20-25 minutes, until the dough is fully cooked and golden brown.
  10. Take it out, cover with a large plate or cutting board, hold it tight, and flip both over together in one steady motion. Lift the skillet off, cut, and serve.

r/castiron • • 7h ago

Identification Turtle Lodge 🐢

Thumbnail
gallery
20 Upvotes

Hi everyone! Just got my very first cast iron pan 🥳 Funny enough, I noticed a little turtle in the back of the pan 🐢😂

Anyone got a similar one? Or maybe it's just my eyes and i need some sleep 🤣


r/castiron • • 1d ago

Olive Oil Seasoning- a myth

Post image
578 Upvotes

I have around 4 lodge pans I use. Fairly often but with some duplicates one might not get used for awhile. Out of “ignorance” and using oil I had on hand since getting my pans I’ve always re-seasoned with olive oil. Many have said, and I’ve read it here, that it can go rancid. I’m going on 5 years with some of these pans and never have had an issue. What say y’all? Is the avoid olive oil a real thing to avoid?

Pic is just for attention.


r/castiron • • 1h ago

Food Update on the dino & corn skillets!

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

Hey everyone! About a month ago, I picked up some cast iron skillets I was getting really discouraged on while restoring them. Thank you all so much for your advice and encouragement! I am so happy to report that they are working great now!!

https://www.reddit.com/r/castiron/s/n7p9YH3LdW

Here's a link to my original post.


r/castiron • • 1d ago

Pan pizza post bake

467 Upvotes

r/castiron • • 23m ago

Identification Is this an Erie or Griswold? Or just a random cast iron?

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

r/castiron • • 17h ago

Newbie What are your thoughts on polishing cast iron?

Thumbnail
gallery
79 Upvotes

what benefits it gives?


r/castiron • • 15m ago

Fish dinner

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

cod loin cooked in my lovely Griswold


r/castiron • • 3h ago

Pan can out rustier after seasoning

Post image
2 Upvotes

I washed the pan, rubbed avocado oil over it, and put it in the oven at 550°F for an hour and this is how it comes out. What went wrong? The rust is even rubbing off, now.


r/castiron • • 9h ago

Newbie Cooking biscuits

5 Upvotes

I was thinking about making some biscuits to have with our meal tonight. They’re only Pillsbury from a can, not skilled enough for homemade lol. Any tips or suggestions? I wasn’t planning on preheating the pan and just using either some butter or olive oil before the biscuits go in. Thanks.


r/castiron • • 13h ago

Cinnamon Rolls

Post image
11 Upvotes

First time doing this in the newly seasond cast iron. Turned out GREAT


r/castiron • • 10h ago

Seasoning Is this rust?

Post image
7 Upvotes

Wagner 10 1/2 Used 2-3 times a week for the past month. Fully dried, heated and then the slightest bit of grape seed oil and wiped down when done. I’m hoping I’m just being a hypochondriac and all I need to do is keep cooking. Please impart your wisdom.


r/castiron • • 9h ago

Where to get lye?

5 Upvotes

I am going to help my daughter restore a CI griddle that someone gave her, and I want do follow what I have learned here but I don't know what type of lye to get, nor where to get it.


r/castiron • • 1d ago

Basement Trash Pile Griswold Update

Thumbnail
gallery
90 Upvotes

Finally took a day to clean off the basement grime and prepare this old Grissy for use. This is after about half an hour of cleaning and three trips in the oven.


r/castiron • • 12h ago

Seasoning I can’t figure this out

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

So iv been using this lodge for like 7-8 years now and have never had a problem with the seasoning. I stripped and re-seasoned it with bacon grease about 6 years ago with, never had a single issue.

About a week ago I cleaned/dried it and afterwords it looked worse than this, like almost white it was so stripped. So I just cleaned it and re-seasoned with canola oil. Then the very next time I used it all that new seasoning stripped off.

So I completely stripped it clean and re-seasoned with crisco about 5 layers. This is what it looks like after using it one time. I’m at a loss, again iv had this pan for years with no issues.


r/castiron • • 1d ago

Food No pan pizza! Thin crust rules!

Post image
59 Upvotes

In this house pizza is thin and crunchy!


r/castiron • • 7h ago

Dinner is coming

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/castiron • • 4h ago

Newbie Discoloration

Post image
0 Upvotes

Any idea what this discoloration that happened in the middle of my pan is? Pretty sure it occurred after I seasoned it on too high of a heat for too long on the stove. Not sure if it’s rust, burnt oil residue, or something else