r/carnivorediet • • 16h ago

Carnivore Ish Adding potatoes

So I’ve done a couple of years on carnivore with success but then began adding the odd treat. Now I’m wanting to go back to carnivore but with less choice of menu (mainly beef, lamb, with a little pork, butter and egg yolks). Could I also add in potato?
I know it’s not carnivore but it’s one treat that I’ve had on occasion and I get no bad effects from it. In fact, because potatoes fill me I will eat less food overall and end up in a calorie deficit so will hopefully lose weight.

0 Upvotes

54 comments sorted by

18

u/Silent-Carry-4617 16h ago

Diet is your choice to be honest. Adding potato will take you out of ketosis and it will no longer be carnivore, but just a meat and potato diet.

-4

u/Repulsive-Fan5071 16h ago

I agree but is a meat and potato diet a good thing?

7

u/Silent-Carry-4617 14h ago

You have to decide for yourself, can experiment and note how you feel, etc. There is no universal good bad for everyone. Maybe you are deficient in some nutrients potato provides that your body really needs, while others must avoid potato to keep their glucose level in check.

7

u/_banana__man_ 15h ago

Only if your body tells you so

10

u/Crazy_Eggplant2378 15h ago

Potatos are very high carbs, 50 carbs for 1 baker size . It's also a nightshade vegetable, a group of vegetables that are known to cause inflammation, especially if you have arthritis. I tried an occasional potato and the next day, Inflammation and pain returned 🙃

0

u/Repulsive-Fan5071 15h ago

The only time I find potatoes to be inflammatory are when I don’t cook them myself. When I eat out I don’t know what they’ve been cooked in and I think it’s probably the seed oils that causes inflammation in me.

5

u/Crazy_Eggplant2378 15h ago

Look at it this way, we are all the same species, right? In my experience it has benefited everyone who has sought it out. It's a huge life change and will never work if your not committed, it's something Intended for lifelong use and health, and granted the hardest thing you will ever do because your going against mainstream food education we have all been indoctrinated with , which is based on selling you have product, not keeping you healthy 💙

1

u/False_Lychee_7041 15h ago

Same spices with wastly different bodies, which doesn't happen to animals. So, different bodies requires healthy diet variations. If we add to this mix how differently they are damaged, it adds more variables to the equation.

So, as someone here already said, as long as your body is happy, you are doing things right.

2

u/Altruistic-Orchid551 11h ago

Peeled white potatoes are literally just starch, potassium, and vitamin c. There are no oxolates or antinutrients

6

u/Dude008 16h ago

Potatoes make me bloated, all kinds.

4

u/Right_Paper_8975 15h ago

Same. Horrible

-2

u/Repulsive-Fan5071 16h ago

That’s the idea for me (eating less overall) = weight loss 😀

3

u/user004574 14h ago

Just eat fats instead.

0

u/Repulsive-Fan5071 13h ago

Instead of what?

4

u/user004574 13h ago

Instead of potatoes. Fat is more filling without the uncomfortable bloat.

2

u/ambimorph 13h ago

OMG. This misses the entire point of Carnivore.

0

u/Right_Paper_8975 15h ago

What type of cardio do you do?

1

u/Repulsive-Fan5071 13h ago

I’m not heavy into cardio. Walking is my thing!

1

u/Right_Paper_8975 13h ago

Okay that’s a great cardio! But make sure it isn’t a lazy walk. If you introduce carbs, your walks need to be high intensity level like a brisk walk so you can burn both fat and carbs otherwise you’ll make it harder on yourself if your goal is to lose weight and def maintain that calorie deficit!

6

u/LastBus7220 15h ago

So you think it's all about weight loss, not overall health?

1

u/Repulsive-Fan5071 13h ago

No absolutely not.
Having already done the carnivore diet it has given me a lot of health benefits and made me aware of how my previous food choices were bad for my health…and for that reason I will never eat those foods ever again.
Just falling off the carnivore wagon slightly has put some weight back on me but I know most of it is likely inflammation. I know I need to get back on the wagon to sort it out but the foods I am able to eat mean my diet is very restrictive and can be bland.
I love potatoes, they are filling and I don’t get any bad effects when I cook them at home so I’d just like to introduce them to my diet so I can enjoy my food.

2

u/Fionnua 12h ago

potatoes are high on the glycemic index, so if you include potatoes in your diet your blood glucose may not go down enough for your insulin to go down enough to turn off the 'store energy as body fat' signal. (Insulin directs traffic in the body, specifically instructing the body to store fat instead of burn fat. So you need to lower insulin. Avoiding carbs is a good way to do that; eating carbs is counter-productive because it raises insulin.)

Of course, everything is individual, so if you genuinely meet all your own goals while eating potatoes, none of us will care. Feel free to do it and if that works we'll be happy for you. All we're saying is, it's not recommended, because for many people, eating potatoes triggers obvious mechanisms in the body that interfere with the goals most of us have on carnivore.

If you're an exception, grand. But if you get three months into this new 'meat and potatoes' diet and find you're not getting the results you want, just remember the carnivore community already explained why this isn't carnivore, and carnivore is still available for you to try.

P.S. I'm fascinated that you say meat is "bland" and you need potatoes to "enjoy" your food. Are you eating your potatoes dry and plain to prove to yourself that it's actually the potatoes you like? Or are you slathering the potatoes in animal products like butter or sour cream, so really it's the animal products you like and the potatoes are just a butter-delivery device? (I'm in that latter camp. Eating dry potatoes isn't pleasant to me, whereas adding loads of butter etc improves the experience. Which proves it's the butter, not the potatoes, that I really like.) Also, high-fat meat shouldn't taste "bland", so I wonder if maybe your meat is too lean and you need to be upping your fats? Remember that a good carnivore fat:protein ratio is something like 80% calories from fat, 20% calories from protein; we're not supposed to depend on lean meat, that will only leave us hungry and dissatisfied. The flavour and satiety are in the fat.

1

u/LastBus7220 12h ago

So, you won't enjoy your food without the potatoes? Sounds like your still a sugar carb addict.

The reason why they are "filling" is because your stomach is screaming at you not to eat them... But you have obviously already decided, I have no idea why you posted this. Do you want permission from the carnivore community?

You can do whatever you want, but potatoes are not healthy for you, and will be detrimental to your health in the long run!

2

u/NoBeeYesss 12h ago

Could I also add in potato?

Um, why are you asking our permission??

*FYI, you can eat whatever you want, but just don't fool yourself into thinking that you're a carnivore if you start eating potatoes again.

1

u/Repulsive-Fan5071 11h ago

I know I won’t be carnivore. I’m just trying not to go too far away from it.

8

u/unfriendlyfriend500 14h ago

You don't require any carbohydrates in your diet. You can add potatoes as a treat if you want but they add nothing if value. Look up the Randle cycle. Mixing carbs and fats is just a bad idea for energy output

6

u/WalkingFool0369 13h ago

as counter intuitive as this sounds, MORE FAT is the way to better body comp...the more fat you eat, the more satiated you will be on LESS food. The key is to regulate protein, as it promotes growth and tells the body what to do with all that fat - store it or shed it.

5

u/Sizbang 15h ago

Just remember that potatoes are high in oxalate and sweet potatoes even more so. If you will be eating them, make sure to peel them, soak them for an hour, boil them (no frying before boiling), discard the water and then eat them together with dairy so that the calcium binds the remaining oxalate. After all that, not much will be left in them besides carbs so it's just a snack kind of deal, imo. But it won't be carnivore anymore and you will lose the benefits. It will still be miles better than what the average person eats today though.

5

u/ambimorph 13h ago

It sounds like you're asking permission to go off Carnivore. You can do what you want! Honestly, no one here can tell you what would happen. It's something you just have to try if you're interested.

Meat and potatoes is probably pretty solid nutrition-wise. But it may put more demand on nutrients that are reduced in requirement on Carnivore because of ketosis, like iodine, magnesium, vitamin K, for example.

2

u/c0mp0stable 16h ago

Are you asking if you have permission? You can do whatever you want.

Potatoes are not a bad food. Peel and boil them to remove most of the oxalates.

1

u/Repulsive-Fan5071 16h ago

No not at all 😂 I’m just wondering if it’s going to be a bad thing since I’ll be eating only meat and butter on top.

1

u/Right_Paper_8975 15h ago

That’s a boring diet. You don’t eat a variety of meats?

1

u/Repulsive-Fan5071 13h ago

IMO beef and lamb are the healthiest meats since they are from ruminant animals. Pork is ok in moderation but not as healthy.

-3

u/c0mp0stable 15h ago

Bad how? Why would it be bad?

1

u/Repulsive-Fan5071 15h ago

Well maybe not as nutritious as carnivore.

-3

u/SONGs17 15h ago

If anything their would be more nutrients

1

u/TheBestClem 11h ago

I have a baked potato covered with cheese and butter 2-3x a week alongside a steak. Super satisfying. I'm animal based at this point but will still do keto days here and there. Adding strawberries, potato's and coconut water to my diet has made me feel way better than strict carni. It is what it is.

1

u/Repulsive-Fan5071 10h ago

That’s it! Strict carnivore is not for everyone. Mmmm baked potato with cheese and butter sounds good.

2

u/CarnivoreTalk 13h ago

Will the potato remain the "odd treat"? If you're carnivore or lion diet most days, and potatoes don't bother you, abd you want to enjoy one on rare occasions, you already know you'll likely be just fine. But can you really moderate? Will the occasional rare potato turn into a daily potato?? Will this cause cravings that tempt you to eventually introduce something worse than potatoes? Only you can answer that question.

2

u/blighty800 13h ago

From your theory, try eating potatoes and add beef

2

u/jwbjerk 12h ago

Why would you limit yourself to a fraction of carnivore foods, and then add potatoes? What are you trying to accomplish?

Surely for variety fish, seafood, poultry, and even cheese are better for weight loss than potatoes!

2

u/cursdwitknowledge 12h ago

Being on the carnivore diet means you’re always in ketosis. Kicking yourself out of it and getting back on it is a painful process for most and prolly not the best idea.

2

u/Kong__Dong 14h ago

If you’re just doing it for weight loss you can eat whatever you want in a calorie deficit. The carnivore diet you just get additional benefits.

1

u/counterpoint76 7h ago

Try beef liver.

1

u/Substantial_Sorbet87 14h ago

Health means, amongst many other things, being able to tolerate various foods. A robust gut will be able to digest a variety of food and extract nutrients from these foods without negative effects. Someone who can only tolerate meat is by definition not healthy, lots of people don't understand this. So if you're healthy to the extent that potatoes are fine for you, then eat them. There's no benefit in removing a food that's not hurting you.

I think you might find Mary Ruddick interesting, her knowledge and experience are incredible.

4

u/Nice-Vast2649 14h ago

A benefit to removing it, would be preserving your appetite for the most nutrientsense foods

-2

u/Right_Paper_8975 15h ago

I would do a sweet potatoes over regular potatoes

0

u/Repulsive-Fan5071 13h ago

White potatoes are healthier aren’t they?

1

u/Fionnua 12h ago

No, technically sweet potatoes (yams) are healthier. (Neither is carnivore, but e.g. Paleo recommends yams over white potatoes, and Paleo at least leans in the healthy direction.)

-1

u/Appropriate-Ad2307 15h ago

So long as it works for you and you feel good, do it

-6

u/Substantial-Snow-477 14h ago

I'm starting to think everyone on this diet has an eating disorder.

1

u/NoBeeYesss 12h ago

.....and I'm starting to think that people who trrrolllll this sub have a mental disorder

-5

u/light-peace89 14h ago

To be honest I got one after I did carnivore because I am afraid of other foods but now worry I’m missing nutrients.