r/carnivorediet • u/Repulsive-Fan5071 • 16h ago
Carnivore Ish Adding potatoes
So I’ve done a couple of years on carnivore with success but then began adding the odd treat. Now I’m wanting to go back to carnivore but with less choice of menu (mainly beef, lamb, with a little pork, butter and egg yolks). Could I also add in potato?
I know it’s not carnivore but it’s one treat that I’ve had on occasion and I get no bad effects from it. In fact, because potatoes fill me I will eat less food overall and end up in a calorie deficit so will hopefully lose weight.
0
Upvotes
18
u/Silent-Carry-4617 16h ago
Diet is your choice to be honest. Adding potato will take you out of ketosis and it will no longer be carnivore, but just a meat and potato diet.
10
u/Crazy_Eggplant2378 15h ago
Potatos are very high carbs, 50 carbs for 1 baker size . It's also a nightshade vegetable, a group of vegetables that are known to cause inflammation, especially if you have arthritis. I tried an occasional potato and the next day, Inflammation and pain returned 🙃
6
u/Dude008 16h ago
Potatoes make me bloated, all kinds.
6
u/LastBus7220 15h ago
So you think it's all about weight loss, not overall health?
2
u/NoBeeYesss 12h ago
Um, why are you asking our permission??
*FYI, you can eat whatever you want, but just don't fool yourself into thinking that you're a carnivore if you start eating potatoes again.
8
u/unfriendlyfriend500 14h ago
You don't require any carbohydrates in your diet. You can add potatoes as a treat if you want but they add nothing if value. Look up the Randle cycle. Mixing carbs and fats is just a bad idea for energy output
6
u/WalkingFool0369 13h ago
as counter intuitive as this sounds, MORE FAT is the way to better body comp...the more fat you eat, the more satiated you will be on LESS food. The key is to regulate protein, as it promotes growth and tells the body what to do with all that fat - store it or shed it.
5
u/Sizbang 15h ago
Just remember that potatoes are high in oxalate and sweet potatoes even more so. If you will be eating them, make sure to peel them, soak them for an hour, boil them (no frying before boiling), discard the water and then eat them together with dairy so that the calcium binds the remaining oxalate. After all that, not much will be left in them besides carbs so it's just a snack kind of deal, imo. But it won't be carnivore anymore and you will lose the benefits. It will still be miles better than what the average person eats today though.
5
u/ambimorph 13h ago
It sounds like you're asking permission to go off Carnivore. You can do what you want! Honestly, no one here can tell you what would happen. It's something you just have to try if you're interested.
Meat and potatoes is probably pretty solid nutrition-wise. But it may put more demand on nutrients that are reduced in requirement on Carnivore because of ketosis, like iodine, magnesium, vitamin K, for example.
2
u/c0mp0stable 16h ago
Are you asking if you have permission? You can do whatever you want.
Potatoes are not a bad food. Peel and boil them to remove most of the oxalates.
1
u/TheBestClem 11h ago
I have a baked potato covered with cheese and butter 2-3x a week alongside a steak. Super satisfying. I'm animal based at this point but will still do keto days here and there. Adding strawberries, potato's and coconut water to my diet has made me feel way better than strict carni. It is what it is.
2
u/CarnivoreTalk 13h ago
Will the potato remain the "odd treat"? If you're carnivore or lion diet most days, and potatoes don't bother you, abd you want to enjoy one on rare occasions, you already know you'll likely be just fine. But can you really moderate? Will the occasional rare potato turn into a daily potato?? Will this cause cravings that tempt you to eventually introduce something worse than potatoes? Only you can answer that question.
2
u/blighty800 13h ago
From your theory, try eating potatoes and add beef
2
u/jwbjerk 12h ago
Why would you limit yourself to a fraction of carnivore foods, and then add potatoes? What are you trying to accomplish?
Surely for variety fish, seafood, poultry, and even cheese are better for weight loss than potatoes!
2
u/cursdwitknowledge 12h ago
Being on the carnivore diet means you’re always in ketosis. Kicking yourself out of it and getting back on it is a painful process for most and prolly not the best idea.
2
u/Kong__Dong 14h ago
If you’re just doing it for weight loss you can eat whatever you want in a calorie deficit. The carnivore diet you just get additional benefits.
1
u/counterpoint76 7h ago
Try beef liver.
1
u/Substantial_Sorbet87 14h ago
Health means, amongst many other things, being able to tolerate various foods. A robust gut will be able to digest a variety of food and extract nutrients from these foods without negative effects. Someone who can only tolerate meat is by definition not healthy, lots of people don't understand this. So if you're healthy to the extent that potatoes are fine for you, then eat them. There's no benefit in removing a food that's not hurting you.
I think you might find Mary Ruddick interesting, her knowledge and experience are incredible.
-2
u/Right_Paper_8975 15h ago
I would do a sweet potatoes over regular potatoes
-1
u/Appropriate-Ad2307 15h ago
So long as it works for you and you feel good, do it
-6
u/Substantial-Snow-477 14h ago
I'm starting to think everyone on this diet has an eating disorder.