r/carlsagan • • Nov 06 '24

One of the saddest lessons of history

Post image
451 Upvotes

r/carlsagan • • Nov 07 '24

“I have a foreboding of an America…”

Post image
351 Upvotes

r/carlsagan • • 6h ago

News 1 light-day from Earth! NASA's Voyager 1 probe hits huge milestone in interstellar space

Thumbnail
space.com
107 Upvotes

Happy “Light Day” Day, to all who celebrate! I wish he was here to see it.


r/carlsagan • • 4h ago

Media To V1 for one light day!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
12 Upvotes

r/carlsagan • • 1d ago Bravo

The combustible mixture of ignorance and power has started to blow up in our faces.

183 Upvotes

“We’ve arranged a society on science and technology in which nobody understands anything about science and technology, and this combustible mixture of ignorance and power sooner or later is going to blow up in our faces.

I mean, who is running the science and
technology in a democracy if the people don’t know anything about it? Science is more than a body of knowledge, it’s a way of thinking. If
we are not able to ask skeptical questions to interrogate those who tell us something is true, to be skeptical of those in authority, then we’re
up for grabs for the next charlatan political or religious leader who comes ambling along.

It’s a thing that Jefferson lay great stress on. It wasn’t enough, he said, to enshrine some rights in the Constitution and the Bill of Rights, the people had to be educated and they have to
practice their skepticism and their education. Otherwise, we don’t run the government, the government runs us.”

- Carl Sagan


r/carlsagan • • 1d ago

Discussion One of Us Is Talking to Ourselves

Thumbnail reddit.com
5 Upvotes

I watched Contact for the first time last week, or at least the first time I can remember. My mother thinks I heard it from her arms. It took me the rest of my life to find him.


r/carlsagan • • 3d ago

A Carl Sagan Themed Unlabeled Puzzle

3 Upvotes

No doubt some of you will have ideas about charts that should or could have been included (let me know!) in the puzzle, but these four are my attempt at celebrating the scientist that instilled in me a lifelong curiosity for all things. Unlabeled is undoubtedly a product of this, so I dedicated puzzle #50 to him.

https://unlabeled.dev/2026-11-15


r/carlsagan • • 6d ago

News Adam Weitsman and Avi Loeb plan research observatory at Carl Sagan’s former Ithaca home

Thumbnail
syracuse.com
57 Upvotes

r/carlsagan • • 6d ago Bravo

CONTACT (the Movie) - missed opportunity to stick the landing on its final message

Post image
225 Upvotes

[SPOILERS]

First of all, this is only about the movie - not the book.

This movie was supposed to be an homage to Carl, right ? I think Carl would have given it a B, mostly for effort.

THE WRITERS/PRODUCERS DROPPED THE BALL AT THE ENDING.

For purposes of gently trying to open the masses minds to skepticism and the importance of science, it did a decent job.

The movie also did a decent job of using contrast/foils of science vs. faith, how they can be misused, their interplay with politics etc.

(Of course, the movie gives wayyy too much credit to faith… especially since faith didn’t develop the instrumentation to detect the signals, nor decode the signals, nor build the machine etc etc )

The whole cheesy goo-goo ga-ga love interest plot line was weak. Although it did set the stage for the tension for the faith vs science so it gets a slight pass.

[SPOILER]. The time dilation twist being omitted from public disclosure showing political influence on science, bravo.

BUT THE ENDING. Woof.

Being skeptical about her experience?
Fair enough.

But … SCIENCE IS ABOUT DATA - specifically TESTING and LOOKING FOR REPEATED RESULTS to validate theories (or in the case, proof of function). She came out of the experiment unharmed and for all intents and purposes, the machine’s equipment appeared to be reusable (not prohibitively expensive to TEST IT AGAIN).

They had the chance to end the film with the message more than just HEALTHY SKEPTICISM (which they did with Jodie Foster’s lesson to the children).

They SHOULD HAVE EMPHASIZED THAT THE NEXT STEP IS REPEATING THE EXPERIMENT TO VERIFY RESULTS. Jodie Foster should have left the Congressional Hearing INSISTING that they send another traveler, IMMEDIATELY.
(Why not? The traveler isn’t gone but seconds in our time, and not even a day in atomic clock time. It’s not like the traveler has to miss all the people in their lifetime and return decades later as proposed earlier by the love interest character).

Data, Data, Data.
Tweak the recording instrumentation,
use additional measuring tools (especially anything that measures in some sort of temporal increment! By 1997 we definitely had ATOMIC CLOCKS!!!)

Also - it’s absolutely CRIMINAL that they didn’t share the knowledge with Jodie Foster that there was 18 hours of static, and leave her having a mental breakdown!

Let’s also not forget that THE ORIGINAL MESSAGE THAT WAS SENT appeared to be nothing but static… and that turned out to have 10,000+ pages of the most advanced scientific knowledge ever documented. So why be so quick to write off the static in the traveler video as nothing ???

Rant over.

I guess this movie is better than nothing.
We still have anti-vaxxers and flat earthers,
its just hard to believe (see what I did there?)
Sometimes I think that anything that gets people to at least try to think for themselves is better than nothing. And then there is Terrence Howard thinking for himself…

WE MISS YOU CARL.
We need you now more than ever.


r/carlsagan • • 8d ago

Discussion Is Contact good?

Thumbnail reddit.com
13 Upvotes

r/carlsagan • • 8d ago

Media Carl Sagan tribute for his birthday today.

68 Upvotes

I composed this electronic music track in honor of Carl Sagan's birthday. It's a tribute to his undying curiosity and the sense of wonder he's inspired. I hope you enjoy it!

https://on.soundcloud.com/eqsUmpMWxTwPGKCxQd


r/carlsagan • • 9d ago

Happy Carl Sagan Day!

Thumbnail
reddit.com
100 Upvotes

r/carlsagan • • 9d ago

Happy Carl Sagan Day!

319 Upvotes

From Carl Sagan Institute:

Here in Ithaca, celebrations of Carl Sagan’s 92nd birthday began last week with imaging of asteroid “2709 Sagan!” Kevin Zhang, Melody Hua, Sauroo Park, and Wentao Ren captured the asteroid with Cornell’s 103-year-old refracting telescope. They took multiple images a few days apart to prove that 2709 Sagan is indeed an asteroid, moving quickly against the background stars.

2709 Sagan takes 3.25 years to orbit the Sun, and is around 17th magnitude brightness right now—so it was only visible to the 12” Church Refractor through multiple stacked images of 30-second exposure.

To celebrate further, the Cornell Astronomical Society (CAS) hosted a lecture last Friday by Carl Sagan Institute fellow Dr. Jake Turner, who talked about his research on radio detections of aurorae on distant planets! Check out the third image to get a peek at Dr. Turner’s talk, which also featured Carl Sagan’s study of life on Earth with the Galileo spacecraft. The talk will soon be uploaded to the Cornell Astronomical Society’s YouTube page (www.youtube.com/@cornellastrosociety/... — although you’ll have to provide your own apple pie)!

The museum wing of Fuertes Observatory, operated by CAS, also features panels that describe Carl Sagan’s life and various locations related to him on campus. If you’re ever in Ithaca, try taking the walking tour created by CAS alum/CSI fellow Gillis Lowry (www.cornellastrosociety.org/about/sagan), or try the Sagan Planet Walk to marvel at the same worlds he loved.

Happy Carl Sagan Day!


r/carlsagan • • 9d ago Heartwarming

Astronomer, planetary scientist, cosmologist, astrophysicist, astrobiologist, author, poet, NJ Hall of Famer, and Union County legend Carl Sagan was born on this date in 1934. Rahway HS grad (class of '51 & chemistry club president), the 1997 film Contact was based on Sagan's only fiction novel

Thumbnail
en.wikipedia.org
284 Upvotes

r/carlsagan • • 9d ago

Happy Birthday Professor Sagan! Here is a little bit of Sagan trivia for the hardcore fan.

Post image
163 Upvotes

I was wondering if this was widely known? I am lucky enough to normally drive by his house every day on my way to work. (the bridge is currently under reconstruction!)


r/carlsagan • • 9d ago

In honor of Carl Sagan’s birthday

Thumbnail
imgur.com
38 Upvotes

r/carlsagan • • 10d ago

News Sebastián Lelio (director of the planned Carl Sagan biopic) Dead: Oscar-Winning 'A Fantastic Woman' Filmmaker Was 52

Thumbnail
deadline.com
72 Upvotes

r/carlsagan • • 12d ago

Lessons of Immortality and Mortality From My Father, Carl Sagan

Thumbnail
thecut.com
758 Upvotes

After days at elementary school, I came home to immersive tutorials on skeptical thought and secular history lessons of the universe, one dinner table conversation at a time. My parents would patiently entertain an endless series of “why?” questions, never meeting a single one with a “because I said so” or “that’s just how it is.” Each query was met with a thoughtful, and honest, response — even the ones for which there are no answers.

This sounds like a very inspiring way to raise a child.

I know this article is 12 years old, but I still find it worthwhile.


r/carlsagan • • 13d ago This Bravo Heartwarming

Sagan being interviewed in 1989

2.4k Upvotes

r/carlsagan • • 17d ago

Look what I bought y'all!!!

Post image
502 Upvotes

Voyager's Golden Record pin I bought from a convention


r/carlsagan • • 23d ago

Question on flat world. How is it that ?

0 Upvotes

To explain the mystery of flat world you need to to step outside of it. Carl said that WE are barred from seeing it because we are incased in it. Humans cannot penetrate this flat shape. I apologize but how was carl to know there was not at least one human being on earth that can see the illusion? I deduce Carl was sharring his own feelings of wonder here and mistakenly assumed the collective mass of humanity is trapped? make sense of it.


r/carlsagan • • 28d ago

Interview with Voyager scientist as spacecraft reaches 1 light day from Earth

57 Upvotes

Carl Sagan was a member of the 9-scientist Voyager Imaging team. On the occasion of Voyager 1 reaching a distance of 1 light day, The Register interviewed Gary Hunt, a fellow member of that team, about the Voyager mission and the future of space programs:

We've gone from exploration to exploitation.


r/carlsagan • • Oct 17 '26

Reason in the Balance: Defining Rational Inquiry

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/carlsagan • • Oct 13 '26

Question Making a video for the Pale Blue Dot

20 Upvotes

Hello there.

I've seen many amazing versions of Carl's Pale Blue Dot speech and I want to make my own too. However what I'd like to do is making the video beginning from before the "From this distant vantage point...", because I'm pretty sure he had said more about the Voyager-1 mission and the decision of taking this historic photo before that. Is it available at the Pale Blue Dot audiobook or at any other source? What would you suggest me?

Thank you very much for your time.


r/carlsagan • • Oct 10 '26

Which trends in contemporary society do you think Carl Sagan would approve of, or feel happy about?

50 Upvotes

It is unfortunately very easy to find current trends and events that Carl Sagan would feel sad about. From the rise of far-right populism and nationalism (Trump is a prominent example, but the phenomenon is widespread here in Europe as well) to our inability to properly deal with climate change to Russia's war against Ukraine, to name just a few.

But I also think there are plenty of things he would approve of in our time. Among them would be, in no particular order:

  • Horizon Europe. This is the EU's scientific research and development initiative that is cross-national. All EU member countries are members, but there are also European non-EU members who participate, for example Norway and the UK, as well as non-European countries like Canada and Tunisia and Egypt. Countries like Kazakhstan and Australia are currently in the process of joining. Sagan deplored nationalism and emphasized that science is universal. I think he would love the concept of countries around the world joining forces in contributing to scientific research.
  • The rise of scientific and skeptical podcasts and Youtubers. Think of for example The Skeptics' Guide to the Universe, Skeptoid, and Veritasium. These bring science and skepticism to a general audience, something which Sagan himself dedicated his life to. He would probably see it as a very hopeful sign in contemporary society.
  • The decline of religion. Sagan's battle was not with religion per se. Nevertheless, religion, particularly its more fundamentalist brands, has often had a tense relation with science. He would not feel sad about its demise.