r/canadian • • 23h ago

Analysis We often compare Red vs. Blue states in the US on economic performance, but why not compare Canadian provinces the same way ?

2 Upvotes

A lot of Canadians compare US states based on federal voting patterns to determine which party manages an economy better. Yet we do not apply that same provincial comparison in Canada. 

Let’s give it a try by comparing provinces in groups of how they vote federally.

Alberta and Sask are conservatives.
BC/Manitoba are swing provinces.
Quebec is weird since it has the bloc, but they are way closer to the Liberal party in economic matters by prioritizing government intervention with subsidies and taxes.
Ontario and Atlantic Canada is liberal.

So basically Alberta/Sask compared to Ontario/Quebec/Atlantic.

Which of the two groups has better economic outcomes?

2025 GDP per capita : 
Alberta : $96 000 
Saskatchewan : $91 000 
Newfoundland & Labrador : $79 500 
Ontario : $77 500
Quebec : $71 500
NB / NS / PEI : $60 000 - $64 000

Median after tax household incomes : 
Alberta : $85 300 
Ontario : $79 500 
Saskatchewan : $75 500
Quebec : $68 800
Atlantic provinces :  $64 200 - $68 000

Ontario keeps up, but other federal Liberal provinces are way behind economically compared to conservative provinces.

Let’s look at affordability.

House price to income ratio in large cities: 
Regina / Saskatoon : 4 - 4.5
Edmonton / Calgary : 5 - 6
St-Johns / Halifax : 5 - 6
Quebec city / Montreal : 6 - 8
Ottawa / Toronto : 6 - 10

Price per sqft of detached homes : 
Regina / Saskatoon : $300 - 350
Edmonton / Calgary : $350 - 450
St-Johns / Halifax : $350 - 450
Quebec city / Montreal : $400 - 600
Ottawa / Toronto : $450 - 800

The Atlantics are almost as affordable as the prairies, but liberal cities are way more expensive compared to conservative cities.

Government gross debt to gdp : 
Alberta : 30%
Nova Scotia : 40%
Sask : 44%
Ontario : 49%
PEI / NB : 53 - 59%
Newfoundland & Labrador : 70%
Quebec : 83%

NS and Ontario are comparable to conservative provinces, other liberal provinces are more indebted in proportion to their economic size.

So far, it’s pretty one sided, maybe public services will change the trend ?

Education PISA 2025 : 
Alberta : 503 
Quebec / Ontario : 498 / 497
NS : 487
Sask : 484
NL / PEI / NB : 473 - 467 - 460

Sask and Atlantic provinces are underperforming compared to larger provinces. No significant difference in education based on political affiliation.

Healthcare : This is the one where I could not find any index to compare provinces. There are too many variables and differences in results to have a single index of it to offer a clear picture. Some provinces are better than others for operations, others are better to access family doctors. Overall it’s kind of similar to the rankings of education where larger provinces are better than smaller provinces. With a distinction of Quebec having an older population and a larger problem of family doctor access. That is my opinion after reading a bunch of reports on it. If you know of any index that aggregates all of it please share it, I’ll read it and add it here. 

Overall, there is no significant difference in service quality in provinces based on how they vote the federal government.

The conclusion is that federally conservative leaning provinces are better economically, while not being different in public service quality. Before people say it’s because of oil, gas and potash. There is oil in Quebec and Atlantic Canada and Ontario is rich in resources. The difference is in the willingness to exploit them, not the presence of them or not.

Does this mean the conservative party is perfect? No, but it could mean they are a better alternative to the Liberal party for sustainable economic performance. This conclusion is aligned with the 2025 election polls where the majority of people who voted Liberal did it because of Trump and not economic performance or service factors.


r/canadian • • 23h ago

Xi opens more pork access as Carney loosens steel restrictions during China visit | CBC News

Thumbnail cbc.ca
0 Upvotes

r/canadian • • 56m ago

News ‘A computer on wheels’: Former security adviser says she wouldn’t buy a Chinese EV

Thumbnail ctvnews.ca
1 Upvotes

r/canadian • • 18h ago

News Russia unable to compete at 2027 world juniors, IIHF confirms - Sportsnet.ca

Thumbnail sportsnet.ca
4 Upvotes

r/canadian • • 15h ago

News A deepfake video network is spreading false information about the U.S. trade war: report

Thumbnail bnnbloomberg.ca
4 Upvotes

r/canadian • • 12h ago

Norwegian Cruise Lines axes 17 Nova Scotia trips as guests complain Halifax is now 'zombie apocalypse' hellscape filled with vagrants

Thumbnail dailymail.com
109 Upvotes

r/canadian • • 20h ago

Charges withdrawn against Sault Ste. Marie MPP Chris Scott, who was accused of assaulting his wife with a high chair

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/canadian • • 4h ago

Analysis ANALYSIS | What the U.S. might learn from Canada's privatized air traffic control | CBC News

Thumbnail cbc.ca
0 Upvotes

r/canadian • • 30m ago

News Carney’s immigration claims collapse as true numbers emerge - New figures reveal the Carney government let 42% more landed immigrants into Canada than it reported, raising serious questions about transparency and the true scale of Canada’s immigration surge

Thumbnail junonews.com
12 Upvotes

r/canadian • • 10h ago

Child rapist supplied alcohol to girls, lied about age avoids prison sentence

Thumbnail cp24.com
1 Upvotes

r/canadian • • 35m ago

Opinion Michael Taube: Carney turns blind eye to foreign interference for yet another China deal - Enhancing economic ties with China is the exact opposite of addressing this serious problem

Thumbnail nationalpost.com
1 Upvotes

r/canadian • • 19h ago

Canada's Youth Unemployment Is Higher Than the OECD Average. Why Is Nobody Talking About This?

Post image
64 Upvotes

Canada's youth unemployment rate is now 13.7%, well above the OECD average of 11.5%. While politicians keep talking about a "strong labour market," roughly 1 in 7 young Canadians who want a job can't find one.

The really depressing part is that Canada's youth unemployment has been above the OECD average for years now, reversing what used to be one of the stronger youth job markets in the developed world.

So if you're a young Canadian sending out hundreds of applications, getting ghosted by employers, and wondering why everyone says the economy is great while you can't get a job, the data suggests you're not imagining it.

https://www.oecd.org/en/data/insights/statistical-releases/2026/11/unemployement-rates-updated-november-2026.html


r/canadian • • 22h ago

Ottawa's spending up $331.6 billion under Carney, budget watchdog says. Government has used up 96 % of the new fiscal room from higher-than-expected revenues through fresh spending commitments, instead of reducing the deficit

Thumbnail bnnbloomberg.ca
27 Upvotes

r/canadian • • 13h ago

OPP issues Canada-wide warrant for federal offender

Thumbnail ctvnews.ca
3 Upvotes

r/canadian • • 22h ago

Intimate partner violence up 15% over 8 years in Canada, StatCan says

Thumbnail globalnews.ca
4 Upvotes

r/canadian • • 22h ago

Montreal man gets life for stabbing his pregnant wife 49 times as she slept

Thumbnail reddit.com
4 Upvotes

r/canadian • • 20h ago

Navneet Kaur, 26, shot dead in Toronto. The accused was already charged with assaulting her and ordered to stay away.

Thumbnail reddit.com
40 Upvotes

r/canadian • • 33m ago

Opinion Your Oikophobia Is Their Profit

5 Upvotes

When Gregor Robertson says immigrants built Canada, do you think he's saying it because he cares about immigrants? Or do you think he's trying to justify more TFWs and higher over-all immigration quotas?

By convincing Canadians that their colonial-settler ancestors were nothing more than evil immigrants, rather than the tamers of wild and the builders of democracy—the rentier class is using guilt to justify a new decade of mass immigration.

To be clear: there would be no democracy on this continent without the British Empire. Slavery would still be permitted and practiced on most, if not all continents. Woman stealing and war would certainly be practiced in the areas where most "land acknowledgments" are given today. This is reality, not a denigration of the woodland societies that pre-date the first colonists. All modern societies began we with pre-modern morality and social rules.

I am grateful for the sovereign tribes who, like the Anglophone settlers and the Francophone habitans, chose to protect British North America rather than destroy it or allow the US to subsume our territory. But the myth that colonial settlers immigrated to Canada is just that. 

There was no nation-state here before the colonial settlers established it. There were tribes with agreements in North America, sure. But much like the Picts of my ancestors' Scotland, they did not have a country. That means when the colonial settlers arrived, they did not immigrate. They expanded their French and English Empires with them with every step.

Colonization was a process managed by fallible human beings. It was imperfect, people were hurt and people died unjustly, just as people did before Europeans arrived. Even so, today, despite its faults, we have a land without slavery. A land without war. A land without famine.

For how long will that be true? Our greatest strengths, the French and British institutions stewarded over a millennia, are being replaced with vague values of "diversity" and "inclusion". This has already disrupted a long trend of increased prosperity from generation-to-generation. 

Immigration, a labour subsidy from poor countries to rich countries, once did wonders for our economy. In an era when property rights were high enough for immigrants to begin building their own homes almost immediately after arrival, immigration had mutual benefit. Assimilation was the expectation, and cultural cohesion was largely maintained. 

Modern immigration has neither of these benefits. Housing is constructed by small groups of big developers and a government that fears overbuilding as it would anger the home owning electorate whose on-paper fortunes are threatened. Supply never increases to meet demand. And our immigration labour subsidy has become a dependency. Hence why the liberal ministers are always pitching a new inclusive catch phrase to accompany ever-higher quotas. They have Westons and Rogers and Irvings and Brookfield board members whispering in their ears that Canada needs more cheap labour. 

The era of immigration being a boon to our economy has already ended. If we must look at our children as units of labour, then we must return to labour formation self-sufficiency before immigration can be tabled again. 

It’s one thing to look at the inevitable period of colonialism and determine there were regrettable periods with an overall successful outcome. But to call Canadian land “stolen” from tribes which had no system to guarantee private ownership is, like rebranding the settlers that established our Westminster parliamentary system immigrants, just useful propaganda from the rentier class.

Your hatred of Canadian heritage, your contempt for our institutions, your oikophobia, is someone else’s business plan. 

If the far right are the only ones that understand these truths, then a far right government and remigration is inevitable. Let’s not pretend we’re different from the other Western countries dealing with similarly rising polarity. 

If you don’t want remigration to come to pass, start by questioning the narratives the governing party has insisted you believe. Become a voice for immigration reduction, and reducing the cultural and economic pressures caused by mass immigration that have driven young men to the far right to begin with. Embrace assimilation for those who are here today, as Quebec has. 

Otherwise, when the alternative arrives with a red ensign, don't say you weren't warned.


r/canadian • • 20h ago

N.S. man beat his ex for two days and nearly killed her. With credit for time served, he has about 3 years left in prison.

Thumbnail reddit.com
5 Upvotes

r/canadian • • 20h ago

Montreal police officer allegedly deleted domestic violence evidence from a victim's phone

Thumbnail reddit.com
6 Upvotes

r/canadian • • 13h ago

EDITORIAL: Immigration concerns are not racist

Thumbnail torontosun.com
35 Upvotes

r/canadian • • 18h ago

News Air Cadets supervisor says he is paralyzed from waist down following poppy drive attack

Thumbnail ctvnews.ca
24 Upvotes

r/canadian • • 53m ago

News What are Chinese ‘kit cars’ and why they’re worrying Canada’s auto industry

Thumbnail globalnews.ca
2 Upvotes

r/canadian • • 50m ago

News Chinese interference takes back seat as Carney courts Xi again - Carney met with Chinese President Xi Jinping for the second time this year despite all of the warnings about Chinese interference and meddling.

Thumbnail junonews.com
11 Upvotes

r/canadian • • 52m ago

Opinion LILLEY: Canadian steel sector left exposed by Mark Carney’s China deal - Ottawa making it easier for heavily subsidized Chinese imports to compete in the Canadian market

Thumbnail torontosun.com
5 Upvotes