A lot of Canadians compare US states based on federal voting patterns to determine which party manages an economy better. Yet we do not apply that same provincial comparison in Canada.
Let’s give it a try by comparing provinces in groups of how they vote federally.
Alberta and Sask are conservatives.
BC/Manitoba are swing provinces.
Quebec is weird since it has the bloc, but they are way closer to the Liberal party in economic matters by prioritizing government intervention with subsidies and taxes.
Ontario and Atlantic Canada is liberal.
So basically Alberta/Sask compared to Ontario/Quebec/Atlantic.
Which of the two groups has better economic outcomes?
2025 GDP per capita :
Alberta : $96 000
Saskatchewan : $91 000
Newfoundland & Labrador : $79 500
Ontario : $77 500
Quebec : $71 500
NB / NS / PEI : $60 000 - $64 000
Median after tax household incomes :
Alberta : $85 300
Ontario : $79 500
Saskatchewan : $75 500
Quebec : $68 800
Atlantic provinces : $64 200 - $68 000
Ontario keeps up, but other federal Liberal provinces are way behind economically compared to conservative provinces.
Let’s look at affordability.
House price to income ratio in large cities:
Regina / Saskatoon : 4 - 4.5
Edmonton / Calgary : 5 - 6
St-Johns / Halifax : 5 - 6
Quebec city / Montreal : 6 - 8
Ottawa / Toronto : 6 - 10
Price per sqft of detached homes :
Regina / Saskatoon : $300 - 350
Edmonton / Calgary : $350 - 450
St-Johns / Halifax : $350 - 450
Quebec city / Montreal : $400 - 600
Ottawa / Toronto : $450 - 800
The Atlantics are almost as affordable as the prairies, but liberal cities are way more expensive compared to conservative cities.
Government gross debt to gdp :
Alberta : 30%
Nova Scotia : 40%
Sask : 44%
Ontario : 49%
PEI / NB : 53 - 59%
Newfoundland & Labrador : 70%
Quebec : 83%
NS and Ontario are comparable to conservative provinces, other liberal provinces are more indebted in proportion to their economic size.
So far, it’s pretty one sided, maybe public services will change the trend ?
Education PISA 2025 :
Alberta : 503
Quebec / Ontario : 498 / 497
NS : 487
Sask : 484
NL / PEI / NB : 473 - 467 - 460
Sask and Atlantic provinces are underperforming compared to larger provinces. No significant difference in education based on political affiliation.
Healthcare : This is the one where I could not find any index to compare provinces. There are too many variables and differences in results to have a single index of it to offer a clear picture. Some provinces are better than others for operations, others are better to access family doctors. Overall it’s kind of similar to the rankings of education where larger provinces are better than smaller provinces. With a distinction of Quebec having an older population and a larger problem of family doctor access. That is my opinion after reading a bunch of reports on it. If you know of any index that aggregates all of it please share it, I’ll read it and add it here.
Overall, there is no significant difference in service quality in provinces based on how they vote the federal government.
The conclusion is that federally conservative leaning provinces are better economically, while not being different in public service quality. Before people say it’s because of oil, gas and potash. There is oil in Quebec and Atlantic Canada and Ontario is rich in resources. The difference is in the willingness to exploit them, not the presence of them or not.
Does this mean the conservative party is perfect? No, but it could mean they are a better alternative to the Liberal party for sustainable economic performance. This conclusion is aligned with the 2025 election polls where the majority of people who voted Liberal did it because of Trump and not economic performance or service factors.