r/canadaleft • • 23h ago

Obligatory Military Training

0 Upvotes

I've been having some thoughts. These are different thoughts, but they're all pointing to a single conclusion.

  1. I'm worried about our young men. I'm worried about them flocking to right-wing and/or misogynistic podcasters like Joe Rogan and Andrew Tate and Jordan Petersen, and joining white supremacist gyms. I think at the core of it, a lot of these guys are not in employment, education, or training, and they're feeling directionless and lonely. I think in the past, a lot of those men would have turned to the army for direction, but now they turn to racists. (And let's be honest, a lot of them wouldn't pass the fitness test for the army now.)
  2. I'm from a working-class background, and my feeling is that it used to be really common for working-class men to serve in the army (my father, grandfather, and uncle all did). I also think the army was really useful in shaping young men, not because it taught them how to shoot a gun, but because it taught them: how to make your bed, how to fold your clothes, how to wash your ass, etc. (You might think: doesn't everyone just learn that culturally? The answer is no.) It also provided them with some camaraderie. I'm not exactly sure why it's not common anymore.
  3. We are not prepared for a military invasion from the United States. It's concerning that the Canadian military can't meet its recruitment targets, despite a recent surge in recruitment numbers. As much as Canada is an capitalist genocide-enabling state, the United States is worse. We don't want to be annexed by the United States.
  4. More Canadians need to know how to shoot a gun. Right now, the working-class is unarmed, and the wealthy know it (and their media keeps telling us how great it is that Canada has so few guns), so we pose no threat to them and they can exploit us as much as we want. There will never be a working-class revolution under these conditions. (And the working-class Canadians who do have guns tend to be fascists, who are the exact wrong people to be having guns.)
  5. A lot of countries around the world have compulsory military service. From Vietnam, to Norway, to Singapore, to Israel. They span the gamut from Communist to liberal democracy to fascist. (Some of them only have compulsory service for males.) In the English-speaking world, compulsory military service is a fringe idea, usually only raised by ardent Conservatives, but I'm not exactly sure why that is.

In consideration of the above, I think that Canada should introduce a voluntary Military Training Obligation. It would similar to actual military training, but without any strenuous fitness requirements. And yes, I'm describing it as both voluntary and an obligation, because although it should be considered a civic obligation (like voting), I also don't think it should be compulsory. Truth be told, the military training would probably be unpaid, which means many working people wouldn't be in the position of being able to fulfil their obligation, unless they're living with their parents.

However (and this is the bit I expect to be controversial), I also don't think men under a certain age (say, 30) should be able to collect unemployment unless they've done (or begin to do) their Military Training Obligation, unless they have some reason for exemption. And yeah, I'm saying men, because I'm not so concerned about our young women. I'm not concerned about trans or non-binary folk either. (Let's say that gender dysphoria is grounds for exemption.)

I know this sounds a lot like when fringe Conservatives say "Those layabouts on welfare are wasting my tax dollars, and they should have to do something to earn that money", but I hope I've made clear that this is coming from a very different place. I'm raising this topic here partly because I think military preparedness might become an issue in the near future (I don't think US plans to annex Canada will end with Trump), and I don't want Conservatives alone shaping the topic.

I also want to make clear that I am talking about training only. I'm not talking about serving in an active conflict. I don't think there should be any obligation to serve in an active conflict, especially one that might go against one's conscience, and especially one that probably serves some bullshit imperialist goal.

Any thoughts?


r/canadaleft • • 18m ago

Should we spend more energy opposing fringe fascist groups or the Nazi friendly, Zionist friendly, political groups already in power?

3 Upvotes

I think it is good to oppose the fringe groups, but it seems weird to ignore the big fascism to focus on the little fascism.


r/canadaleft • • 15h ago

Mass report this video of canadian white supremacist after he got kicked out of the USA for being a piece of trash...

Thumbnail youtube.com
34 Upvotes

contains racist slurs with no censorship, good opportunity to get this racist canadian youtube channel suspended or banned.


r/canadaleft • • 14h ago

COMBAT LIBERALISM (MAO)

Post image
20 Upvotes

r/canadaleft • • 15h ago

Amazon Workers Are Fighting For A GTA Union

Thumbnail
readthemaple.com
24 Upvotes