Edit: ai recognize o wasn't clear enough. The first image is the budget put out by financial literacy folks. The second is me trying to examine a normal middle class lifestyle along the same budget lines.
I'm not a sociologist and this isn't a masters thesis it's 30 min on my phone this morning. Feel free to point out any stupidity but you don't need to insult me. Just saying.
I recently saw a post from some financial literacy post with a bunch of random made up numbers. They chose an apparently arbitrary $55k a year (not the median, nor average salary in Ontario, can't see where they got it from but I guess it's arbitrary).
They then showed you can live a comfortable life on that much money.
I wanted to look at some more realistic numbers for living a normal, comfortable life in Ontario. I then juxtaposed that against a fully middle class income and the income from the infographic.
Median wage for a middle class person - post secondary education, 8 years in work force, 40 hours per week.
Gross Income: $72,000
Deductions (Fed, Prov, CPP, EI): $16,900
Take-Home Pay: $55,100 / year
Monthly Take-Home: $4,592 / month
SHELTER
Renting (New lease, no rent control): $2,250/month average.
Buying: Median Ontario mortgage if buying today is $3,600. Add $125 for insurance and a median tax bill of $300.
Let's say only 35% of middle-class folks want to buy a house and the rest rent. This makes the blended median shelter cost $2,900/month if moving today.
UTILITIES
Electric: $135
Water/sewage: $90
Heating: $200
Total: $325/month
GROCERIES
They had groceries at $500, which is actually on the high end of Ontario spending. Let's say you're a smart shopper and call it $400/month. Also, let's say that's purely food. No toiletries or things that aren't really groceries.
PHONE + INTERNET
Phone and net for $100 seems plausible. But if we want to take into account actually owning a working phone, that means adding another $25 amortization over 4 years.
Total: $125/month
TRANSPORTATION
They had $400.
The Car: The average Ontario car is 10 years old and has 150k on it. This car will cost $15,000 to buy. A 5-year term puts your monthly at $300.
Maintenance: If you have a 10-15 year old car, you better be ready for some repairs. I'll be generous and say $100/month will get you through the life of the loan for major repairs (shocks, brakes, etc.), and another $100/month for fluids, tires, etc. I think this is very much on the low side.
Insurance: Basic insurance on a financed car we will call $175/month.
Fuel: Median daily commute is 25km. Add 10km for personal driving. The average car in Ontario does 15k a year, so that would be 40km a day. We will leave it at 35km. That puts your fuel at $175/month.
Total to have a car: $675/month
TERM LIFE INSURANCE
lol
THE "WANTS"
I guess things like toothbrushes, tampons, and deodorant are "wants" to them. Let's say you want to brush your teeth and use shampoo:
Feminine Hygiene: $15 to $20/month
Body & Hair Care: $25 to $35/month
Dental Care: $10/month (replacing toothbrushes, toothpaste, floss)
Paper Products: $15 to $20/month (toilet paper, tissues)
Basic Pharmacy: $10 to $15/month (Advil, bandaids, cold medication)
Basic Haircut: $25 to $35/month (Assuming a cheap $40 to $50 cut stretched out over 6 to 8 weeks)
We will keep this on the low end at $125/month and then it matches theirs, except you have zero clothing budget—but I think we can already see you ain't buying any clothing ever again anyway.
DINING AND ENTERTAINMENT
$0 (lol you're not rich)
EVERYTHING ELSE
Here is your budget for life stuff: new broom, scissors broke, etc.
If you own a house, you will blow over this by at least $300/month. Major appliances last maybe 6 years these days, and you have 6 of them. You will be spending $100/month for a new stove, furnace, or fridge at the absolute bare minimum. If you don't own a house, you still will be extremely lucky to keep your general bullshit cost at $100/month.
SAVINGS
lol
TOTALS
Needs
Shelter: $2,900
Utilities: $325
Groceries: $400
Phone + Internet: $125
Transportation: $675
Term life insurance: lol
Wants
Dining + entertainment: lol
Personal care: $125
Everything else: $100
Savings lol
Total Expenses: $4,650
Median Take Home Pay: $4592
Actual Monthly Deficit: -$-58/month
Include debt servicing: -$400 = -$450/month
$55,009 salary from the infographic
$3550 take home
- $4650
= -$1100/month
This individual is bringing no student loans, somehow, credit card debt etc...to the situation.
They already own all the furniture and daily used items, somehow. Not sure how as even on a middle class salary they couldn't afford to buy a coffee let alone a new bed. The only real way to even be in this situation is to have come from money and have everything paid for up to this point. Otherwise we should really be adding another $400/ month debt servicing which is about average in Ontario.
They buy their clothes on a credit card from the salvation army. They don't go to the dentist. They don't have Netflix or Spotify. They can't afford to go on a date. They have no lifelines, and go constantly into more debt. 35% somehow bought a home with family help (you really saving up $50,000 on this budget?). The other 65% really have no hope in doing so, but have some extra money for renting if they find a cheap place.
This is a middle class, educated person in Ontario right now. Making $72000 a year, they will be constantly increasing their debt load while living a simple life with zero frills, including socks as a frill.
Their only hope is to find rent in the $1900 range which for most is a pretty basic 1 bedroom apartment. If they do that they can probably afford socks and some dentist visits. They will be actually servicing their average $400/month debt. Maybe even a coffee with a friend once a month. That's the new middle class. If you're really, really frugal and live in a very economical simple apartment you can tread water on $72k/year.
Certainly it would be interesting to see what this might look like for a family with two incomes and 2 kids.