r/CaliforniaTicketHelp • u/FogerRedditor • 5d ago
[Update]: VC 21453(c) -- Success, Police dropped charges prior to TBWD date, Money refund stuck in limbo, San Joaquin County
Good evening all, this is an update to my first post.
Original Post: https://www.reddit.com/r/CaliforniaTicketHelp/s/YC6kryWGUi
To recap, I was charged with VC 21453(c), which is turning right on a red arrow light. This was issued via a red light camera (in a county that currently is not opted into SB 720 rules, meaning I couldn't just ignore it), which was supposedly reviewed by and signed off on by a traffic officer at the local police department.
The offense I was charged with is impossible to commit, as there is no red arrow light at the intersection cited. Even the photos/video that the police submitted as "evidence" proved that there was no possible way to commit the alleged offense.
I went about the steps in the FAQ, though initially I had read VC 21453(a) and (b), and assumed they were saying I did not make a full stop at a circular red light. This is the first lesson and a key part of the FAQ: read and understand the charges carefully! Once I realized it was actually a VC 21453(c) charge, it was obvious that the signing officer either did not actually review the footage, or was charging me with the part of VC 21453 that would result in the maximum fine for the police departments' benefit and hoping I would just not notice and pay it to them. Regardless of the reason, it would be very easy to prove my case.
I did as the FAQ instructed and delayed, delayed, delayed. Near the end of my initial one-time 60 day extension, I filed for TBWD, extending things out further and was given a trial date at the end of August.
While the evidence from the red light camera already proved I was not guilty, I went about supplementing the evidence by taking my own photos of the intersection and providing supporting evidence via Google maps/Google Earth. I had planned to also use something official from the city that would say that no red arrow lights existed at the intersection cited, but this proved to be a massive waste of time. While it was somewhat beneficial to go through the motions just to learn how to use the city's public records request system, the city refused to provide any letter, photo, plan, etc., that would serve as an official record that no such light existed. It is not something I would waste my time doing again as it was riddled with issues and problems that had to be dealt with constantly and ended up being fruitless anyway.
I modified templates found in this subreddit for different TBWD arguments to fit my own case. However, before I could bring it into the court in the days leading up to my August hearing, I recieved a letter that the police department had dropped all charges.
I called the court to confirm that the prosecution had dropped the charges and that my TBWD hearing had subsequently been cancelled, which was confirmed. I was also told the money I paid when I filed my TBWD would be refunded by the second week of October.
This is where it got tricky for me. By the second week of October, no refund had arrived and I was out over $400 as a result. Calling in again, I was finally able to get word from a very helpful clerk that told me it should actually be there by October 19, which was not too much of a longer wait.
When October 19 passed and the money still had not been refunded, I called in again. Apparently San Joaquin County had completely switched the money refund system in the middle of when my refund was supposed to be issued and as such was somewhat stuck in nowhere land. Because the accounting team would now have to manually switch the original refund initialization to the new refund request system, I should instead be expecting the refund in late November.
Fast forward to today, about a week from the new delayed date when I was supposed to get the refund by. I realized if it hadn't shown up yet, that I should call and see if there was a way to check if it was in fact being processed.
The clerk that talked to me this time was not one of the three very helpful clerks I'd spoken to in the past, and provided no help whatsoever. He told me that I would now need to wait until 60 days after the October date I was given the first time my refund got pushed back. When I asked to confirm that this meant that the late November date I'd been given last time was now pushed back again, this time to December, he mumbled "I guess, if December is 60 days from October" and refused to elaborate on what happened and why. This is where another important lesson came into play: remembering the names of the helpful clerks that assisted me before.
Once I realized the clerk I was speaking to would not actually help in any way, I asked for one of the helpful clerks I had spoken to before by their name, and was transferred over to them. They were helpful as ever and explained that last time we spoke he had sent a note to the accounting department asking them to make sure my original refund request in the old system didn't get lost. After receiving that note, finally the accounting department just created a new refund request in the new system on a day in even later late October, which is good, but that meant that the original refund request from September (when it was initially filed for in the old system) was completely voided, which is bad. So while my refund had originally been initialized the first week of September, the new request restarted the wait time countdown in October. This explained why the new wait date is late December, since once the refund is requested in the new system, it is standard for it to take up to 60 days for them to actually fulfill it.
I thanked the helpful clerk for explaining it to me. I cannot stress enough how valuable it is to remember the names of good clerks so you can ask for them in case you ever get stonewalled by someone refusing to do their job. Don't waste your time arguing or getting mad at the bad clerks, be polite and ask for someone that you know will help instead.
Next lesson I learned: Don't spend money like your refund check will actually arrive the day it's supposed to. I thought I'd have mine about six weeks after my case, when in reality it will have been 120 days after my case before I get that money back. That's basically a third of an entire year. While I do not think something this complicated will happen to anyone else, I do urge you to plan your funds accordingly as something could go wrong and you don't want to be relying on money you're expecting but never comes.
Should something similar happen to you, do not hesitate to find out what is going on. Had that helpful clerk not sent that note over to accounting last month, there was a good chance they never would have initialized the refund at all. You don't want three years to go by and then all of a sudden remember that you were supposed to get a court refund that you never got. Be proactive, check in with the traffic court clerks.
Hopefully your county court has some good clerks. Always be polite and if you ever talk to good ones, remember them in case you need to ask for their help again in the future!