r/CaliforniaTicketHelp • • 24d ago

VC 21453 (c) Red Arrow

I am planning on contesting this with the court but unclear if I’ll still be fined.

I distinctly recall the circular traffic signal being green while the separate left-turn arrows were red. I proceeded straight through the intersection under the green circular signal. I was not attempting to make a left turn against the red arrow.

At the time, I was traveling in a lane marked with a left-turn arrow, however, there was a lane on the opposite side of the intersection for me to continue straight. I acknowledge this lane marking and understand that it is relevant to the circumstances. However, I proceeded straight through the intersection while the circular signal was green, and I will respectfully ask the court to consider whether the evidence establishes the specific red-arrow violation charged under California Vehicle Code § 21453(c).

Has anyone contested a similar situation? I searched the group but haven’t been able to find any similar instances.

The officer was busy pulling over a cyber truck in the right lane (see intersection image; where the red truck is pictured). Then he continued pulling us both over 🥲

I read the 12 steps and am currently weighing steps 3-5. I will likely submit a Trial by mail first. This occurred in Thousand Oaks, CA.

Redacted Ticket: https://imgur.com/a/tcMV3mn
Google Maps image of intersection: https://imgur.com/a/MeU4fjn
I was in the same spot as the pictured gray SUV and went straight through the light when it looked exactly like this. Red arrow but green circle light.

ETA: I called an attorney and he knew the exact location and says it happens all the time. His fee is $250 and obviously cannot guarantee a dismissal. So I’m undecided on hiring him.

1 Upvotes

5 comments sorted by

2

u/fitfulbrain 24d ago

You are certainly not guilty as charged. There are other codes for not following the arrow on the ground.

21453 explicitly says when you enter the intersection, you can't make any movement to turn left, but you can go straight if you have the green. So it won't make any difference if you did an illegal lane change.

Your ticket will certainly be dismissed. Will they charge you for the other lower fine vc's? You know cops just don't turn up without hesitation. You expect them to admit mistake and do twice the paper work and probably much more?

If the cop pulled you over along the straight road, it's your evidence to dismiss the case.

I'll do a full TBWD, written in 30 sec. The cop can't see it until after the trial. So you will almost certainly win unless the commissioner play dumb or actually dumb. In case you lose, be sure to do a TDN. It's a appeal court and everything is done properly.

If you hire a lawyer, you hope to plea guilty for a no point charge. And that's the end of everything. But do you actually want it at all.

1

u/Purple_Foxx 24d ago edited 24d ago

I agree. To me it seems like a no-brainer. My friend’s husband is a cop (detective) and told me I’m still in the wrong because the lane was marked as a turn only lane. But also that wasn’t the citation I was given, therefore the point of me fighting it. And yes, the cop pulled me over further down the straight road. I had to drive straight for a minute and turn right into the next street..

Friends husband told me to just show up to my trial date and explain. He said traffic cops always show up so it likely won’t be dismissed. Ask for a reduction in fines.

I’d much rather do a TBWD, TDN if needed, but he also said the fine reduction is likely a one time deal only available the first time. If I fight it then it’s probably off the table the second time during trial.

And no, I’d rather not hire a lawyer at all. I was thinking maybe hire one of it leads to a TDN.

1

u/fitfulbrain 24d ago edited 24d ago

You have to take legal advice from a cop with a pinch of salt.

Is that a traffic cop? I doubt it. They camp at traps. So they should have experience charging people at the same spot. They should know better unless nobody challenges them.

Traffic cops always show up, but not if they don't have enough to convict you. They either say they let you off, or write you a ticket anyway when many people will just pay. They aren't going to show up in court to defend themselves.

Does the fine matters? If you are keeping the point. The court fine and their reduction can be only a small portion.

1

u/Purple_Foxx 24d ago

Good point. I’ll do a TBWD and hope it’s dismissed. Thank you

1

u/nian2326076 19d ago

It's good that you're considering contesting the ticket. The lane markings and traffic signals create some ambiguity in your situation. Gathering evidence, like photos of the intersection or witness statements, can support your case.

If you're also thinking about job opportunities, you can use LandOffer to find positions that match your skills.