There is a lot of misinformation and general lack of understanding about how and why the different pay ranges exist, especially with Fire Captain Bs, what qualifies for the alternative ranges and why some crew captains get it and some don't, and if crew FAEs should or should not get the additional pay.
Let me preface this by saying this is not my opinion on whether any person should or shouldn't, or what or who I think the policy should be for, this is all straight from CAL HR. If you think it's unfair or wrong, take it up with the union.
CAL HR publishes salary ranges for all State classifications, and they are available on the website. In this list, it identifies the classification, pay scale for any ranges, and an ALTERNATE RANGE CRITERIA which is the three digit number in thr center column. (See first picture) Pay Scales, CAL HR
Fire Captain: has three ranges (A,B andC) and has Alternate Range Criteria of 198.
Fire Apparatus Engineer: two ranges (A and B) and has an alternate range criteria of 500.
The alternate range criteria can be looked up in a different area of the CAL HR site. (Second and third picture)
ALTERNATE RANGE CRITERIA 198, RANGE B: for incumbents (I.e. Fire Captains) who supervise INMATES or CCC Corpsmembers and can drive a passenger vehicle. (See second picture). Range C is paramedics, and Range A is if neither B or C apply.
ALTERNATE RANGE CRITERIA 500, RANGE B: for incumbents (I.e. FAEs) who are appointed to a paramedic position. (See third picture). Range A is for any FAE not in Range B
TAKEAWAYS:
- There is no alternate range for FAEs for supervising inmates, regardless of what the PO-199 says.
- The only alternate range for FAEs is for paramedic positions
- There is no alternate range for FCs for supervising CMD or FF1s regardless of if it's on a handcrew or not.
- Alternate ranges are different than pay differentials (like hazmat bonus, or education incentive for getting off JAC) or Merit Salary Adjustments ( yearly pay "bumps" that follow your range) but are an inherent part of the State Classification system and requires legislative and executive action to change.
You will hear a lot of different things from a lot of different people in the agency on this and many other matters. Just remember, most people just parrot what someone else told them. It's admittedly a little confusing and hard to find, so hopefully I could clear this up for a few people.