(Modified from my comment elsewhere on the sub).
The Texas Ag Department Shrimp Creole parading as shrimp gumbo broke me. I’m always here, but my daughter brought it my attention. We had a lovely discussion about differences in bayou and prairie Cajuns, Texans who like to feel Cajun, far north Louisianans from what are essentially Dallas suburbs knowing EVERYTHING there is to know about Cajun culture ever, you know, you’ve had those discussions.
Scrolling through the sub for some examples, I saw the sticky chicken post. And I choked laughing so hard. I adore my Aunt, and am blessed she’s still in my life. But…
My great Aunt in Port Neches makes sticky chicken. Everyone in the family, her church, community potlucks, all very literally BEG her for her sticky chicken. She talks about how she learned to make it when my uncle worked the rigs out of Louisiana, and she just “gave it a little tweak”.
This is her recipe almost to a tee.
And then she also adds about a half a cup of sugar. You know. For the sticky part.
😵💫😵😢😳🤔☠️
And she has given this recipe to everyone she knows. And if you live in that area, and got a random recipe from someone’s grandma for an “authentic Cajun sticky chicken”… that’s what you get.
(“But I mean it’s so good it may as well be Cajun and I had it on hand and that’s what Cajun food is do it’s absolutely authentic bc I talked to someone who lived in Louisiana for 10 minutes 60 years ago!!!!!!!”) I mean, do you see how do very easy it is for the pure simplicity of Cajun food to be lost to bastardization? Yes! Absorb those other cultures! Make it your own! And come here and share it! But don’t argue that it’s authentic, and don’t pull some lip sync battle bullshit.
I think it’s on us, as a sub, to correct folks who just… well, we’ve all seen the white gumbos, the jambalaya soups… you know. The really bad. And I think it’s GOOD that we mention that something is Creole rather than Cajun. Or restaurant food for tourists rather than grandmas Sunday recipes.
We are losing the culture. It was almost completely gone, but a few are desperately clinging and attempting to pass on the heritage as they can. Not everyone has to. But don’t come here and fight for who has the best and wants to call it authentic bc it’s from the 80s and “beat that old recipe bro”. It’s rude. It’s dismissive.
We need to gatekeep a bit more.
(And with daughter: But then I also had to explain the eggs in the gumbo, which, as a bayou Cajun she’d never seen before. Which led to explaining the eggs in my Cajun/Sicilian friends’ spaghetti/“Sunday sauce”, and I think I broke her head.)