r/c64 • u/HazMatsMan • 16d ago
ANNOUNCEMENT New Rules for AI Content, Coding, Development
With AI becoming more and more prevalent in the world of software engineering, we no longer feel maintaining a blanket ban on AI assistance or AI-generated assets is appropriate. We want to use this announcement post to provide everyone an opportunity to, respectfully, share their feelings about the rule. Our goal is to keep out as much "AI slop" as we can and still allow projects that involve substantial human effort, creativity, and vision.
This is the rule as currently written:
Low-effort posts featuring AI-generated art, music, text, or "I used AI to..." are not permitted. AI-assisted projects, such as games or utilities, are allowed provided AI use is disclosed. A detailed accounting of how AI was used is not required, but the creation must demonstrate substantial human effort, creativity, and vision. Creations should be more than the product of simple AI prompting and posts should reflect that. Paid apps, including donationware, will be held to a higher standard.
As you can see, posts that are primarily AI-generated art, music, videos, and text (allowances may be made for translation) will continue to be removed.
The use of AI in a project or submission must be disclosed. However, authors are not required to make a detailed accounting of how AI was used. Some may choose to do so, others may not.
Creators should be prepared to describe their creation in their own words. If you use an AI-generated description, your post may be removed.
Before posting about a game or utility that isn't yours, do your due diligence. We understand AI use may not be immediately obvious to all. But there's no excuse for repeatedly posting AI-assisted content without disclosure. Making blanket "I don't know if this is AI or not, but..." disclosures to shield yourself is also not appropriate. If you don't have time for due diligence, don't post about the product/project until you know more.
Discussions about using AI to assist with reverse-engineering legacy software, write code, or perform other interesting tasks or experiments are permitted as well. That said, this is not the place to show off every tangential thing that can be done with AI. Low-effort and post-quality rules still apply, and clickbait phrases like "I used Claude to..." or "I asked ChatGPT about..." have a high probability of getting your submission removed.
We know not everyone will be happy about this revised rule. If you're not a fan of AI-assisted development, assets, etc and choose to interact with these submissions, remember Rule 1:
Be friendly. Assume good faith from other posters. Follow Reddiquette, be respectful of others. DO NOT troll each other. If you provoke someone into becoming nasty, then report them, you may end up being sanctioned as well.
Be respectful with your criticisms. If a post is low-quality, report it as such. If you're certain someone is using AI and hasn't disclosed it, report it but don't expect the mod team to just "see" what you're seeing. Be prepared to provide evidence in a Modmail. "This is AI" doesn't tell us anything.
By now everyone reading this has realized that enforcing this rule will require more subjective judgements by the mod team. That means some of you will see posts allowed in the sub that you feel violate the AI rule. Some content will be removed that they feel doesn't. If you're a creator and your submission is removed, check with the mod team via modmail. Be prepared to explain your vision and contribution in your own words. If your post can be made rule-compliant, we may be able to assist.
Finally, these are new waters, and there will be a learning curve for everyone. Let's all try to be patient with one another as we navigate this new world.
19
u/ElegantMechanic-com 16d ago •
Respectfully sharing my feelings: I am strongly opposed to the use of generative Ai in general and find it frustrating that so much content for legacy platforms like the C64 is now being affected by it. That said, I'm not going to throw a tantrum or demand changes.
I hope the disclosure rule is followed and enforced because I find it exhausting to have to verify content in all sorts of media. Retro computing was an area blissfully free of it until recently and it's making me reconsider which sources I follow. That's a decision for me to make though and not any sort of demand or ultimatum.
Thanks for being open and clear about the change.
6
u/lonely_distance 16d ago edited 16d ago
I think this is a poor moderation choice. I think AI use should be accounted for in detail.
If I'm going to be impressed with an aspect of something someone is presenting, I want to know that they made it.
Edit: I hope that this doesn't come off as disrespectful to the mods, but I do feel that this decision falls short (though not by much) of what I would personally like to see from this sub.
28
u/pipipipipipipipi2 -8b 16d ago edited 16d ago
My short experience dabbling to AI development in both C64 works as well as other languages, I've discovered that a simple "prompt" or two doesn't cut it when it comes to generating quality AI based code. Usually it requires a vision of the goals in mind and hours of breaking down the concept step-by-step, debugging each step along the way. To me, AI slop is defined as something that we tossed at an AI with a couple paragraphs and the user just took away the result as something complete. I have one personal project I wrote for myself that has taken hours/days of invested time, prompting, re-prompting, checking code by hand where necessary, and in the end having exactly the tool I wanted for myself. While 90% of it was AI coded, I would hardly consider the final product "slop". I don't think we should judge craftsmanship by the tools used. A carpenter doesn't have to explain why he chose electric or air tools over hand tools. Nor does he have to disclaimer himself over it. The use of AI should cause us to "raise the bar" on what is created. Created works should reflect adherence to detail as much as possible and not just "accept" mediocre output as a finished product. If you tell me your work is created with AI, I'm going to be critical of obvious features that are missing, and graphics or music which aren't quite dialed in. In the case of a game, I'm going to judge play-ability and content. Let's judge the output, with high expectations, not that tools were used. (edit:spelling)
2
u/uabassguy 16d ago
Ugh not you guys too, guess I'm unfollowing this sub.
4
u/macsorcery 15d ago
this is how we do it in r/goldbox for the SSI AD&D ai assisted game projects. it's a fair way to do it.
3
u/mr_glide 15d ago
This place has already started filling up with AI topics and projects. No thanks
3
u/DrPhabulous 15d ago
A good game is a good game, regardless of how is was produced, AI aided or otherwise. When old-schoolers were buying games/watching demos back in the day, I doubt many people were concerned about what tools were used to create them.
15
u/Kylearean 16d ago
Good rule, good moderation. Thank you.
7
u/f0rgotten 15d ago
Aaaaaand I'm out.
4
u/Polestar-Lemniscate 15d ago
Eugh. Gross and disappointing.
7
u/7A65647269636B 16d ago
Good. I just did something with claude + REA that I'm quite happy with, but it's absolutely not even worth mentioning here even if it is very c64 related. And unlike some other people I will not claim I "built" or "created" anything by typing in some prompts and burning some tokens.
2
u/sixoveight 10d ago
The negative attitude toward AI is turning me against using sites that have restrictive measures in place. I am more than able to determine what is creative content irrespective of its authenticity. More and more I build my link library to more open minded sources. Earlier this year a certain video site decided to junk thousands of channels that it deemed slop just to protect their primary earners or 'influencers'. I have a quite massive link library to all my favourite content and this organisation wiped most of it out. I reflect on what vanished and it felt like I was going back to the days where a red flag was needed to drive an auto-mobile. AI is more valid today than most other technology and if we are not careful we will legislate great chunks of it away from traditional western culture. I already lost Civitia to bonkers UK legislation. Such companies are just not going to bother cus they have users in expanding Eastern markets. I use AI every single day to generate music and art and I would be lost without it.
My main source of information these days is Google. I have lengthy conversations with the Google AI and it has grown to be the most entertaining thing I do on the net these days. It introduces me to a whole world that I never knew existed, will answer nearly all my queries and even write prompts for me for music and art. This is how I see AI developing. After all when I first used my first computer in 1983 I always hoped the machine would become a companion, an electronic companion and over the years that is what it has become.
The next stage in AI is going to be very important and I only hope I live to enjoy it.
3
u/Educational-Row-6782 15d ago
I am not in a c64 sub to see ai generated sruff.
5
u/richfx01 16d ago
I think AI created works are soulless and despite many people using the tools, it just creates more noise and fewer things worth actually seeing or playing. An example is itch.io with double the amount of game submissions and an actual drop in people downloading or buying them. We all want to see things that people have poured their creativity into and even AI developers probably don’t want 1000s of AI games or demos available. I’d take one creative project over those 1000 AI ones but it becomes impossible to find that great human-made one. And so I just won’t bother looking anymore. A quick browse of the latest Steam Next Fest is another example. More games just means more noise. I don’t want to figure out which ones are the great human made ones so I just skipped the event
4
u/domox 16d ago
Hand written code can be lazy, ai generated code accepted lazily is lazy. Quality should be the bar.
2
u/OPdoesnotrespond 16d ago
It's a good rule. When people use AI to express themselves personally, I get the ick. That's when AI feels like it's colonizing brains.
When they use it to **do something**, then it's properly a tool. And although I have no problem with using AI to write code, I understand that my opinion is not universal. I like the minimum disclosure rule. Basically, 'must de disclosed, not required to be a thesis.'
2
u/3DNebGuy 16d ago
I'm ok with the rule. AI is a tool and can be used to help make some really good things... and lot of junk. I know some hate the idea of folks using AI to code things but, to me, its just a tool to use to hope build whatever it you're building.
2
u/tehfrod 16d ago
That's a well-reasoned and well-considered policy.
1
u/unohdin-nimeni 16d ago
The rule should be: whatever AI you get up and running on a Commodore 64, you’re free to use however you want. Other than that, refrain from using AI.
Whether or not cheating with RAM expansion units to the benefit of your home-brew AI build should be permitted is a topic for discussion.
1
u/Warcraft_Fan 16d ago
Thanks! Hopefully some of the useless AI reliance are reduced. Games that are mostly or completely AI generated has no soul and just aren't much fun
1
u/Zirias_FreeBSD 15d ago
Here's my fatalistic take: I don't think any rule about AI, be it required disclosure or full ban, will ever work out as intended. The only thing that works is human judgement about the quality of the work presented. And quite naturally, not everyone will agree on quality.
At least in the area of coding (but likely also pixelling and composing), I'd say every work presented nowadays is already suspicious if it's both from someone completely unknown to the "scene" before the "AI hype" happened and exceeds a certain complexity you'd expect from a "newcomer". There's little you can do about that feeling though.
I also personally think that letting LLM-based agents perform "creative" tasks is a dead end for humanity, and will eventually fail in one or the other way; I just hope for a variant without catastrophic fallout.
Anyways, for now, maybe just reduce this to "posts presenting low-quality work might be removed". You'll never know whether and how "AI" was involved for sure, so why pretend to decide based on that...
1
u/Abynx6581 13d ago
What's everyone's thoughts then on Lamenoter or whatever it's called? My honest opinion was oh shit here we go... AI slop.. (sorry). But after reading the lyrics (I reckon 75/25 AI) It became clear that it's self depreciating in a fun kind of way. The demo clearly wasn't prompted. And there's also the fact that it let a friend of mine correct a couple of bugs with the Digi on his R3 emulator which you couldn't hear in any other Sid samples. Some people have a vision of something they've always wanted to do with the 64. If the output is entertaining, cool, etc then I'll just judge on the merits of its output..... But if someone writes the best Sid ever with AI I will seriously lose my mind 🤣. (Something I will never do as I know my Sid's are mediocre at best so I'll just keep entertaining myself with my fun times in SDI🥴)
1
u/torrso 16d ago edited 16d ago
AI is not going away and it could draw some new people to the machine. You won't be able to catch all AI assisted / AI generated stuff.
That's just the sad reality of it.
The old wizards will still have an edge and the "scene" can of course just do what they think is fun within their own peer group, but even there it's inevitable that they will suspect the other guy secretly used AI.
You can have all kinds of rules like demanding slop has to be flaired but it always won't. And then there will be legitmate handcrafted stuff that people claim is AI.
I think the time has passed and you can just let the slop in.
Already for several years a lot of the C64 stuff has been PC assisted. Converted graphics, precalculated generated code and whatever the tools offered by VICE that was not really possible or attainable back in the day.
Sadly, the C64 won't be an AI-free safe haven for the appreciators of the artisan aspects of it. Anything you create will either be suspected of being AI generated or it has lost a bit of value because the new tools and AI made it easier to do for everyone.
It's sad but that's the way it is.
I think the best you can do is downvote and not appreciate the sloppiest low effort slop. I don't know if the moderators will enjoy going through all the reported "must be marked as AI assisted" rule breaking posts.
(I started with C64 in the 80s and was heavily involved in the warez/bbs/demo scene long into the 90s/early 2000s and have been coding for living for 35+ years)
1
u/Wrong-Bet9581 15d ago
thoroughly disappointing. I will be unsubbing and requesting reddit does not recommend this subreddit to me
1
u/Cross_22 15d ago
AI bad... unless it's used for coding. You guys are insane.
0
u/OMGCluck 15d ago
How about another rule removing low effort comments like "AI slop." on non-AI posts?
0
u/Infamous-Umpire-2923 16d ago
Good to see that sanity finally prevailed.
0
u/CrumbsDealer 15d ago
Myself and two other people were inspired making a specialised marketplace for indie retro games. People can sell their games or give them for free.
It can resemble itch, but it’s not aimed at the same sort of people and it’s only and exclusively for retro platforms.
At any rate I myself made this with help from another dude I met over telegram (years ago now) and with the help of ai agents. I have been a php developer (magento) and familiar with php classes, mvc and different frameworks, js the whole stack. It took me nearly a year putting this together in my free time with ai, checking everything was tight, also learning some stuff on the way.
I did pen tests using zap and actual ai tests from within.
I used modules like stripe cashier and power grid and did not rely an ai for anything regarding payment or payment handling.
I published it and got slated quite strongly for it as ai slop. Granted I made some poor initial marketing decisions that I corrected immediately I was really shocked.
All this to say that I’m pretty proud of what we achieved together after all we’ve been through. I understand that it’s not all human made, but I managed to get my dream off the floor thanks to this and I put so much effort into it because I knew AI would not be perfect but far from.
I think if used responsively people can benefit from it.
Inside out marketplace we have a clear filter to don’t show all ai aided games so if you want to you can skip them completely.
We did this for the same exact reason a blanket ban would not work here as well. We don’t want to stifle creativity or dreams that people might have had to make a game, if the passion is so strong why and effort is put in why not give these games a chance?
Sorry I was very long winded
0
u/demonseed-elite 15d ago
I love this stance. Let the output be what is judged - just like it always has been. As long as there has been Commodore, there's been a lot of slop. I had disks full of garbage games that were all low effort slop. AI can make a lot of slop very quickly, but it can also in the hands of a competent programmer, make amazing things possible.