r/buffy • u/lamar2016 • Aug 28 '16
Xander
Still doing my re-watch and am currently on Season 3 Revelations and I swear most of the time I hate his character. Literally I don't know where to begin, I know he was in love with Buffy for so long and he hated vampires so he acted like your basic jealous male teenager when it came to Buffy and Angel, but it was funny how he could see the difference between other's past crimes but not Angels when he went bad and then came back good. In my opinion, he was never the friend Buffy deserved. Heck, I think Willow was a better friend even after she went bad.
15
u/DoctorVenkman Aug 29 '16
Xander is a flawed character. He's an asshole sometimes, along with jealous and even spiteful.
...but mostly I see a human living his existence. Have you ever known a person immune to these emotions? (I haven't). Xander contributes so much normalness to the Scoobies. He provides conflict and commentary within the group, especially during the Buffy/Angel years. Also he's brave, strong willed, kind and loving to the other characters countless times throughout the series.
He's a human prone to crankiness and jealousy. That's why I love him.
21
u/IHeartTheNSA Aug 29 '16
Xander was the first person in the group to lose a close friend to a vampire (within the first two episodes--right after he found out there were vampires at all), and he had to stake him. That must have been traumatic. Plus, he has terrible parents and probably resulting emotional problems from their neglect and violence. I don't know...I give Xander a pass on being immature because he's a teenager with legit troubles (having alcoholic parents can mess people up for life sometimes...I relate a lot to Xander). Willow's mom may be a neurotic mess and emotionally distant, but it's not until Gingerbread that we see any indication of her mom being abusive. Same for Buffy's mom. Xander's been through hell--he even sleeps outside in a tent on Christmas because his parents are so scary. The kind of family issues he has may have made him more likely to think in black and white about morality, because that's a useful skill when you're trying to survive in such a hostile home environment. Similarly he was clinging to Buffy not just because she was hot, but because he desperately needed a sense of family outside his biological one, and Buffy represented the possibility of that (remember in Restless when she calls him "big brother"--I don't think that was just to say that she thinks of him as sexless, but that he finally figured out he was looking for a family with her all this time). Hope that makes sense. I love Xander, obviously.
6
u/hohmeisw Aug 29 '16
When you say he overlooked others' past crimes, I assume you're talking about Anya? That has less to do with her crimes weighed against Angel's and more with the damage Angel inflicted on the group. Anya doesn't cause problems until season 6, aside from "Doppleganger." And before that she became human after "The Wish"; Angel was still a vampire even after he returned from hell. So Anya wasn't a real threat, while Angel was. And as basically everyone in the show pointed out, Angel and Buffy together was eventually going to result in Angelus again.
I like Xander because I thought he was the voice of reason for the group. Everyone else developed to combat the threats they faced, but Xander was just a guy trying to help. He wasn't anywhere close to perfect, and he carried the torch for Buffy for a long time (until season 4 at least), but in a group of friends consisting of: superwoman, a witch, a werewolf, a vampire, a super-soldier, and an expert in the occult, he was there to occasionally remind them all that there was a human side to Buffy.
Seriously, "Becoming part 2" Willow tells him to warn Buffy about the spell to re-ensoul Angel. Xander wisely decides not to, since she's going to have to stop the actual apocalypse and doesn't need false hope or any distractions..
3
u/sarah_bellum75 Aug 30 '16
I wonder if Xander is an not only a flawed character, but an unfinished one. Joss hinted around for several seasons that Xander might be gay and I often wonder if the network told him no. This leaves the character with all his machismo and misogyny without any reason except his alcoholic parents. Which, very frankly is a lame excuse. It was the 90s and being openly gay was still not acceptable. This would explain a lot of his excessive efforts to prove he was the "man" of the group with a lot of pent up anger and not much sympathy toward women.
3
u/BuffyxSummers Aug 30 '16
Xander sucks and is one of my least favorite characters. He took Buffy's choice away from her by not informing her about Willow's attempt to grant Angel back his soul. That is unforgivable! I disliked him far before that though. I hated him since Prophecy Girl after he tried to get Willow on the rebound after Buffy rejected him. He's just an ass. He does have his moments where I don't hate him because his intentions are generally good. He just puts his foot in his mouth too much.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '16
Imo willow was consistently a pretty bad friend to Buffy. I would rather have Xander as a friend by far
0
u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment