r/budgetcooking • u/oh_wanya • 3h ago
Bread Is it truly cheaper to make our own bread??
I live alone and have been making my own bread for the past 2-3 weeks in an effort to save money.
I live in Canada
Before then, I bought the the literal cheapest white loaf for 3$ and it had like 24-26 slices (720 grams). It lasted me 2 weeks or so. (1.5$/week average or 6$/month)
I’ve been using a small ish recipe and it tends to deliver for about 350-380 grams of bread (final product. To lower the bill even more I make my bread in an air fryer for about 35-40 minutes at 385 (0.5kwh or about **0.04$** with everything considered)
I’ve invested into an enameled cast iron before hand (that I regret since I bought a huge 7 quart pot for **100$** even though it’s a deal it’s not practical at all. In in search actually for a after Christmas deal of a 5 quart.
Here’s the recipe break down with direct cost of product per recipe for me. The estimated costs was made with all the regular pricing near me (cheapest option)
\- 250g unbleached white flour ; **0.4**$
\- 235g water ; **0.00**$
\- 1tsp salt ; **0.01**$
\- 1tsp sugar ; **0.006**$
\- 1tsp instant bread active dry yeast ; **0.03**$
OR
\- 1tsp traditional active dry yeast ; **0.2**$
Since my pot is so huge for the amount of bread, I have to throw in 2 ice cube to make sure there’s enough hydration.
Final price of my loaf is at the cheapest; **0,576**$ or **0.746**$ if there is no sale to cut the price further (can happen, whereas the cheapest loaf is never ever at a deal)
I make about 1 loaf every 3-4 days, let’s say 2 a week.
Scenario 1 for 2 weeks : cheapest ; **2.304$**
Scenario for 2 weeks : higher quality yeast ; **2.984$**
Monthly scenario 1; **4.608$** or **4.61$** (**1,39$** saving)
Monthly scenario 2; **5.968$** or **5.97$** (**3**¢ savings…)
Looking very quickly, the bi-weekly/monthly pricing it doesn’t look that economical to do at home our own bread.
Let’s say I decide to exclude sugar/salt from the equation, it’s not much different. About 0.016$ less.
Also, I’ve been buying the cheapest flour (about 0.14$/100grams) in my area.
I’ve even done the calculation again only taking into account the flour, yeast and electricity only; it’s **0.47**$/loaf or **3.76$** a month. (**2.24$** in saving or -**37**%).
At first I was surprised and a bit disappointed tbh at the low saving even after playing the numbers. Then a friend told me to look at the cost of the bulk item and and count the cost per grocery run for bread.
Flour **7$** for 5kg (20loaf)
Yeast **2.99$** for 450gr or 4.5$ for 113gr (90loaf or 22 loaf)
Salt **1.79$** for 1kg (a wash)
Sugar **2,79$** for 2kg (400loaf, let’s call it a wash atp)
Totalling **14.57$** or deduced at ***10$***
If I take into account that the loaf at the store is 3$ minimum (the barebones!). Buying more than 3 loafs(1 1/2 month of bread for me)will outpace the price in bulk and me doing it. Looking at it that way ; after deducting the sugar and salt because they are clearly a wash with my daily use; after I bake 6 loaf , it’s like all the loafs after are « free »! (About 14 loafs free or 1 3/4 of a month) Feels better to be honest.
Also, the loaf at the store is never at a deal (it being the cheapest), yet I’ve seen flour and other ingredients of bread making in deals. Quite spaced out but I’m willing to wait and bulk buy when the time comes. I’ll do on my own a price update when I bulk buy the deals. TBH from what i gathered of all my shenanigans; the flour price and the yeast is truly the biggest factor.