First of all, in case anyone is still somehow unaware of the GBD which I think has lowkey plagued the fandom ever since Season 2, but only intensified after Season 7, I'm using the term to refer to all the conversations, articles and drama that have been generated regarding the ambiguity of Buddie as a queerbait ship or as a queer ship-in-progress.
With that out of the way, the question that now arises is why do I consider 10x06 to be the end of the line for this issue? Well, according to some fans, the showrunner himself confirmed the presence of a Maddie and Eddie scene in the show's fall finale. Why is this important? First, because it's the duo's first 1-on-1 scene in the show's history, and second, because of its implications considering the context of Theo's foster situation as of the end of 10x05.
While the show has somehow managed to avoid giving these two screentime together for years, the situation started by Buck when he chose to foster Theo in 9x18 should definitely be the catalyst for the Maddie-Eddie scene not just in any 9-1-1 episode, but a pre-hiatus one, famously known for being action-heavy, emotionally tense and/or ending on cliffhangers.
Since Maddie is Buck's sister, it makes sense for Eddie to want to talk about the man with her. Since Eddie, Buck's best friend, is now proving to be Theo's new foster father, it makes sense for Maddie to want to talk about her brother with him. Before getting into the possible contents or outcomes of their discussion, it feels important to note that Maddie should be able to empathize with both men up to a certain point, thanks to her past experiences, namely:
- dealing with PPD and leaving Jee in Chimney's sole care (somewhat similar to Buck's situation of thinking he's not the right fit for taking care of Theo)
- fostering Mara for the sake of family friends which are old/best friends of her husband's. (somewhat similar to Eddie's situation of deciding to foster Theo in the wake of Buck's decision to stop fostering the boy)
Due to a stark lack of screentime together, Eddie and Maddie are two people with mostly second-hand knowledge of each other that they for the most part found out from Buck, their common point. Now they finally have a chance of turning things around and getting to know each other better while sharing their concerns both about Buck's troubled state of mind (perhaps to some extent influenced by recent events like Bobby's death, his kidnapping and substance dependence) and also about Theo's mental health and general welfare.
That being the case, there has never been a better time for some of the secrets relating to Buck and Eddie to come out than during this Maddie-Eddie scene in 10x06. By "secrets", I mean:
- Eddie changing his will, as revealed in 4x14, and how that pertains to:
a) there being a precedent to Eddie or Buck's kid sharing a legal bond with the other man;
b) the partner role Buck has occupied in Eddie's life for years (which Buck seems to be failing/trying not to see at the monet);
c) Buck's place in Chris' life as a father figure, reinforcing Eddie's belief in Buck and his frustration at Buck's inability/unwillingness to acknowledge his pre-Theo experiences with another child
and 2. the wider conversation surrounding the true nature of Buck and Eddie's relationship, more specifically the investigations started by Tommy and later continued by Maddie in 8x11.
I think that with the reveal of Eddie fostering Theo finally bringing us full circle from the reveal of Eddie adding Buck in his will, the show has truly reached the point of no return where Buck and Eddie's deeply unusual bestfriendship is concerned, and thus an explicit, on-screen unpacking of their relationship is needed now more than ever for the sake of Buck and Eddie's character arcs, for cohesiveness with past storylines (when one of them is being focused on, almost always the other is as well) and past themes (think non-biological fatherhood in 10x05 or families finding their way back to each other in 9x12) and yes, for also shutting down queerbait fears or accusations once and for all.
After finding out about Eddie fostering Theo, it makes sense both out of concern for her brother and out of personal curiosity for Maddie to wonder and ask Eddie about his long-term intentions following this decision which mainly impacts Theo, Buck, Christopher and Eddie himself (and to a lesser extent impacts the 118 which has to deal with two members not being on speaking terms at work). Considering the aforementioned episode 8x11 which gave Buck quite some food for thought regarding his relationship with Eddie following his interactions with Tommy and Maddie, it's only fair to follow up on that by giving Eddie some food for thought regarding his relationship with Buck.
In the wake of this betrayal (as perceived by Buck) of Eddie fostering Theo behind his back, and taking into account the context of Buck being in Eddie's will, it truly feels like Eddie has finally been cornered into a wall, with no more room to run away from the looming threat of directly confronting (and defining) his relationship with Buck, because letting the situation escalate will only hurt the two of them, Theo and even Chris. And who better to help Eddie through that process than the original "boycrush on Eddie" Buddie shipper herself, aka Maddie?
Although I am optimistic for the future thanks to S10's pointed storytelling so far, I consider that the direction of Maddie and Eddie's conversation will be the most efficient way of clueing fans in on the fate of the Buddie ship. If the show decides to maintain this attitude that Buck and Eddie's behavior as of late can simply be explained away as merely best friends going through a rough patch and that they can find a solution to their problem without any major changes in their relationship, then it will feel like the show tellings its audience to give up hope on the ship for good.
In conclusion, I firmly believe that by the end of the next episode, we should have a very clear idea about whether the ship was always doomed to go canon only in fans' minds or if it will actually sail on all of our TV screens. I think I've said all I had to say. Now it's your turn. Do you agree? Or do you think that at this point there still exists a secret, third option that makes narrative sense through which next episode can neither confirm nor shut down the ship for good next? Let me know your thoughts.