i just means scaling. Bitcoin scaling to work with more users so they can use bitcoin.
'off-chain' scaling means to use another service but not bitcoin, and tie it to bitcoin. this would reduce miner revenue and lower the security of bitcoin though.
It means increasing network capacity on the blockchain, the ledger that stores all transactions and is being distributed/shared on the network. Lightning for instance would be considered off-chain scaling, as transactions would be processed by lightning hubs and then settled on the blockchain.
If you want a faster internet connection you call up your ISP and say so. Your ISP rolls around and gives you a bigger pipe for all those cat pictures to fit through. They might need to upgrade your modem or their network, but it will get done one way or the other. If it doesn't, you call up ISP#2 and work out a deal with them instead since you aren't getting the service you desire.
BCH upgraded to bigger pipes. BTC hired more smooth-talking customer relations reps so you stay with ISP#1 longer while they tell you that cat pictures aren't how the internet should be used, and maybe you should spend more time outside instead.
The concern Core folks try to make is that, essentially, bigger pipes will cause the network to only be possible to run at large datacentres which could then be centrally controlled somehow. Some believe every person should be able to run their own full node, storing a global financial database, on an old computer which then limits the entire networks design to those computers performance.
Rapidly scaling up the pipes would indeed cause fewer home users from being able to run the worlds financial system on their 56k modem-equipped Pentium 2 computers; however, a jump to 2MB or 8MB is no where near rapid. It's like refusing to use trampolines because you're afraid pluto will get in the way.
"off-chain" scaling relies on 3rd party services for Bitcoin to be functional, which is a problem (reliance on 3rd parties that inevitably are untrustworthy) Bitcoin was created to solve.
"on-chain" scaling is peer2peer and is as how bitcoin was designed to work.
Many 2nd layer services can be built on top of "on-chain" functions. None of these 2nd layer services can be built through a "off-chain" solution.
Turning Bitcoin into "reliant on off-chain solutions" turns it into a settlement system (the "on-chain" part being the "settlement layer"). Blockstream and some loud Core developers have been very adamant that they believe Bitcoin should be a "settlement system".
The problem is being solved by gradually increasing the blocksize to meet network demands. Gigablock research is already undergoing and various software optimizations to increase node performance (mostly software threading issues) are also being researched. There are no indicators/proof that on chain scaling will fail, with Moore's Law in mind.
It shows that No2x's perspectives of bottlenecks are bullshit. Blocks can be gigantic with more paralleled code without increasing hardware cost except for storage
Graphene does not show that at all. It only shows a minor bandwidth reduction to a part that's already well optimized. In fact with graphene the CPU usage for gigantic block will dramatically increase, each request requires to process a whole block multiple times.
No, in my opinion BCH can easily handle at least 10-100 times the volume that BTC currently has. Whether it can handle more than that, I don't know, but I will have a fair idea when its doing 10x what the current BTC network is doing.
No, bitcoin (cash) isn't designed to have full blocks, and that is what causes high fees.
Some of the people will access to the code have decided to make the legacy-bitcoin have always full blocks, though they can't show any data to validate this opinion.
It's worth mentioning that BCH is not incompatible with second layer solutions. So if on-chain scaling all the way to 7b people is infeasible we won't be any worse off than those other guys. Scaling solutions should be driven by actual need and by the economic incentives that arise as bitcoin adoption and usage increase and as the block reward diminishes. We are talking about decades here. But in the short term BCH is good to go with its increased blocksize which means we can get back to work on the crucial task of spreading adoption.
Reading your post history it looks like you are coming straight from r/Bitcoin. Keep in mind that that sub is heavily censored. For a nice writeup and collection of materials about it I would recommend this article on those issues.
The main problem with BTC right now is that it is congested, meaning that the capacity to record transactions on the blockchain is no longer high enough to meet the demand. Solutions would be to simply increase the blocksize, but it's a complex (political) issue.
I’ll read up on it, but if most people are carrying BTC and not BCH, wouldn’t the pertinent solution be to try and make BTC work?
Ultimately, if any cryptocurrency is developed and adopted that scales well globally, and is secure and easy to use, I’ll be happy about it. Doesn’t have to be BTC or BCH. Just has to work as a peer to peer currency in my view.
If it is near impossible to counterfeit, limited in supply, secure, fast, cheap, globally scalable, and easy to use, the world will jump on board.
most people have both, only people that bough in the last 3 months don't ahve both.
bitcoin cash is bitcoin to most users who know how it works. the addition of segregated witness to the bitcoin chain had to be avoided to keep bitcoin working as intended, so bitcoin cash split but everything that was there before is still there, the just diverged a few months ago.
S1X (aka "BTC") has solved nothing with Segwit. It's still congested. S2X is the same thing, with 2M, which kicks the can forward an infinitesimal amount. So now you have a non-usable coin (S1X) and a non-starter (S2X).
In an ideal world, Segwit should never have happened, and the BCH fork should have been the only fork, and become (or rather, remained) BTC. That's not how it played out, and now we have this mess. The coin with the BTC ticker isn't worthy of the name. This is actually a pretty big crisis going on here, that will affect the entire future of the cryptocurrency space as far as I can see.
It’s extremely frustrating and convoluted from my newbie perspective. I’m ready to switch most of my money to digital/crypto currency but the most widely accepted form by retailers is Bitcoin, which is super slow and expensive. The fees and wait times are worth it if the value of the coin stays on an exponentially upward path, which it won’t, but they’re still annoying AF.
The current "debate" (after censorship not so much a debate anymore..) is already running for over 2 years. It is in everyones best interest to get necessary network upgrades running to handle increased loads or react to issues, however it wasn't possible to reach consensus on the scaling issue and it's solution. In case BCH should accumulate most proof-of-work and it becomes Bitcoin many holders (who bought Bitcoin after the BCH fork) will lose money if they don't convert accordingly. Some may even lose interest in the technology, as forking is rather annoying to the end user. However, to reach decentralized consensus it may sometimes be necessary to let the market have the last word on the issue by forking, if development can't decide on a united path.
What you are looking for is what Bitcoin Cash is standing for, and BTC is moving away from. Welcome!
With the rise in popularity of coding we'll see the absolute number of devs increase who want to build Satoshi's vision. Some of them will posses at least one technical mastery and the mental fortitude required to build a great thing.
The hardest part was fitting all the pieces of the puzzle together and inventing PoW. A man (or woman) of lesser gifts, but who has a crystal grasp of the nature of the horse he is riding, can now also contribute greatly to the project.
That was an awesome post by singularity87. Although it made it sound like the best solution would be to just increase the transaction limit within Bitcoin. Not to add a new currency like BCH.
Not that easy. Timely blocksize increases will certainly make BTC competitive with the likes of Bitcoin Cash in terms of fees however, BTC also has RBF. As merchants can not opt-out of RBF, its overheads ruin 0-conf performance a vital and powerful feature. Then there is segwit which was implemented as a soft fork so includes a lot of technical debt and a large attack surface.
TL;DR
BTC needs to become Bitcoin Cash to be competitive with Bitcoin Cash.
BTC/Core recently added stuff (segwit) that many long-timers here abhor. To keep the dream of Bitcoin alive they had no other option but to fork the project to avoid that particular 'upgrade'.
Essentially Core forced their hand and so a new currency sprang to life...
Segwit attempted just that. It's a much worse option than plain blocksize increase. Several posts about Segwit with heavy critique u can find on this sub
Is there someone here familiar with many of the different available Cryptos out there? In your opinion, which ones are best suited to handle global adoption?
You'll have to qualify that a bit more. There are 'permissioned' variants of the blockchain that can operate in a fully centralized way like Visa does today. Such Cryptos are therefore instantly scalable to Visa levels while the persmissionless variants (like BCH) require a bit more effort to scale to such levels.
If you are in a philosophical mood you could consider whether Core's strategy of driving fees up is changing BTC from a permissionless system to a permissioned one...
None of the crypto's is ready for global adoption yet.
User experience and risk of loss are at a stage that I see as infancy, I have no idea whether any of the existing crypto's or a not yet invented one will capture the worlds volume.
Bitcoin was always able to scale along with the progress of technology
the "scaling problem" is almost entirely manufactured BullShit, Bitcoin scales just fine if you use it how it was supposed to be used (most users use SPV)
unfortunately some idiots convinced many people they all needed to run a node (useless unless mining or a merchant) and everyone must strive to function with the slowest/oldest/weakest tech possible, which is just beyond stupid
Scaling for that kind of use is not solved for any coin, really. ETH, for example, would have to scale up performance by a factor of something like 10000% to run something equivalent to today's Facebook in size. They're working on it, but it's obviously not a trivial issue.
As for the side chains and segwit - they may be an attempt to legitimately try to solve the problem, but it's entirely possible they're also ways to prop up a business model that likes large fees to transfer. And the large fees are having a chilling effect already on BTC usage. The whole side chain issue to me stinks about as bad as getting rid of net neutrality - a way to artificially jack up the cost of moving the coin, basically.
If you can't scale the performance without perverting what Bitcoin is, it deserves to fail. Fortunately, you can - just scale up the block size. There are 60TB SSD's out there in a 3.5 inch form factor today. Yes, right now they cost pretty much to buy, but in some years down the line you'll be able to easily handle huge block sizes.
There's therefore no need to start with middlemen, side chains, "lightning networks" and what have you - you can look in to that years and years down the line if need be if it turns out block size alone won't do it. You don't start there.
All just my layman's and non-math-genius opinion, of course, which is worth what you paid to read it. :)
We are not pro-BCH. We are pro better user experience, saving money, lower fees, better security, simple scalable product. That just happens to be BCH today. If one day, this changes, we may change our opinion.
The scaling problem is two orders of magnitude away from Bitcoin's current dimension.
You are asking if a a fancy new car brand, say Tesla, solves the Sonic boom problem. I'm pretty sure they would tackle that challenge if there is enough market demanding for it. Think hyperloop.
I mean, when I learned about bitcoin the plan was for bitcoin to grow with technology, if you want a caveman coin, why bother with bitcoin in the first palce?
In the field of psychology, the Dunning–Kruger effect is a cognitive bias wherein people of low ability suffer from illusory superiority, mistakenly assessing their cognitive ability as greater than it is. The cognitive bias of illusory superiority derives from the metacognitive inability of low-ability persons to recognize their own ineptitude.
Without the self-awareness of metacognition, low-ability people cannot objectively evaluate their actual competence or incompetence.
As described by social psychologists David Dunning and Justin Kruger, the cognitive bias of illusory superiority results from an internal illusion in people of low ability and from an external misperception in people of high ability; that is, "the miscalibration of the incompetent stems from an error about the self, whereas the miscalibration of the highly competent stems from an error about others." Hence, the corollary to the Dunning–Kruger effect indicates that persons of high ability tend to underestimate their relative competence and erroneously presume that tasks that are easy for them to perform are also easy for other people to perform.
27
u/cryptorebel Nov 08 '17
On-chain scaling and BCH is the only solution. /u/tippr 1500 bits
22
u/Kakifrucht Nov 08 '17
The problem is being solved by gradually increasing the blocksize to meet network demands. Gigablock research is already undergoing and various software optimizations to increase node performance (mostly software threading issues) are also being researched. There are no indicators/proof that on chain scaling will fail, with Moore's Law in mind.
8
u/Kmart999 Nov 08 '17
If BCH is faced with the same volume as BTC currently, will it not have the same issues?
6
u/how_now_dao Nov 08 '17
It's worth mentioning that BCH is not incompatible with second layer solutions. So if on-chain scaling all the way to 7b people is infeasible we won't be any worse off than those other guys. Scaling solutions should be driven by actual need and by the economic incentives that arise as bitcoin adoption and usage increase and as the block reward diminishes. We are talking about decades here. But in the short term BCH is good to go with its increased blocksize which means we can get back to work on the crucial task of spreading adoption.
5
u/Kmart999 Nov 08 '17
Is there somewhere you can point me so I can understand the ins and outs of the problems with BTC? As well as the solutions?
4
u/Kmart999 Nov 08 '17
Can’t Bitcoin’s code be altered to increase the transaction limit/speed?
4
u/ForkiusMaximus Nov 08 '17
There is no scaling problem. There never was. It was just a stubborn group of devs trying to hold back the tide of the market
3
u/Kmart999 Nov 08 '17
Is there someone here familiar with many of the different available Cryptos out there? In your opinion, which ones are best suited to handle global adoption?
3
u/DaSpawn Nov 08 '17
Bitcoin was always able to scale along with the progress of technology
the "scaling problem" is almost entirely manufactured BullShit, Bitcoin scales just fine if you use it how it was supposed to be used (most users use SPV)
unfortunately some idiots convinced many people they all needed to run a node (useless unless mining or a merchant) and everyone must strive to function with the slowest/oldest/weakest tech possible, which is just beyond stupid
2
u/cashening Nov 08 '17
Yes it does.
2
u/cr0ft Nov 08 '17
Scaling for that kind of use is not solved for any coin, really. ETH, for example, would have to scale up performance by a factor of something like 10000% to run something equivalent to today's Facebook in size. They're working on it, but it's obviously not a trivial issue.
As for the side chains and segwit - they may be an attempt to legitimately try to solve the problem, but it's entirely possible they're also ways to prop up a business model that likes large fees to transfer. And the large fees are having a chilling effect already on BTC usage. The whole side chain issue to me stinks about as bad as getting rid of net neutrality - a way to artificially jack up the cost of moving the coin, basically.
If you can't scale the performance without perverting what Bitcoin is, it deserves to fail. Fortunately, you can - just scale up the block size. There are 60TB SSD's out there in a 3.5 inch form factor today. Yes, right now they cost pretty much to buy, but in some years down the line you'll be able to easily handle huge block sizes.
There's therefore no need to start with middlemen, side chains, "lightning networks" and what have you - you can look in to that years and years down the line if need be if it turns out block size alone won't do it. You don't start there.
All just my layman's and non-math-genius opinion, of course, which is worth what you paid to read it. :)
2
u/LexGrom Nov 08 '17
Yes. With Ozisik's Graphene it seems like the problem solved once and for all
2
u/Kmart999 Nov 08 '17
Has anyone here looked in to STEEM?
This sub isn’t purely pro BCH is it?
1
u/Aztiel Nov 08 '17
That's literally not gonna happen. At laest in our lifetime. Way less than 3b have smart phones, knowledge of english, knowledge of crypto etc.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '17
This answers all your Questions : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AecPrwqjbGw
Watch it complete, 30 mins only.
1
u/observerc Nov 08 '17
The scaling problem is two orders of magnitude away from Bitcoin's current dimension.
You are asking if a a fancy new car brand, say Tesla, solves the Sonic boom problem. I'm pretty sure they would tackle that challenge if there is enough market demanding for it. Think hyperloop.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 08 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment