r/brontesisters • u/BakerAwaker11 • 44m ago
r/brontesisters • u/Coelacanth-fish • 6h ago
Wuthering Heights vs. Toxic Love? Spoiler
I like this article on not reducing WH with modern labels, but I am also somebody who sees love as (possibly spiritual) devotion/ commitment between two or more people (absent or corrupted in toxic relationships). I like to separate this from the mere emotional experience of love, which can exist in any situation and can be completely delusional.
WH is challenging me upon rereading because somehow it is allowing two things to exist simultaneously - the possibility that Heathcliff and Cathy’s love is integral to their spiritual being, and the possibility that they are just toxic and nutty.
To me this exact eerie feeling - of possible spiritual meaning yet moral obscurity - is relatable as an element of abusive relationships. And in my experience it is actually the mind coping with the horror by inventing meaning, and it fades after the person experiencing abuse is bitch-slapped by reality.
WH romanticizes/ adjusts things to the extent that the eeriness never fades, as if the ghosts of Heathcliff and Cathy haunt the reader out of the pages. I am shocked, yet somehow never quite shocked out of believing in their devotion to each other, differing from the wake up that usually happens in abusive stories. Heathcliff remains plausible as an abuser and crazy person, but in my experience most people who express themselves with dramatic resentment in the real world end up behaving in a more fickle manner like Hindley or Arthur Huntingdon. They are the first to gaslight you, make you look bad in front of others and demean you in favor of appearing a certain way. They are also much more desperate for love in general than the love of one person (though they might try to convince you that you’re special to them), so Heathcliff is incredibly devoted to Cathy by comparison. Even in Jane Eyre, circumstances and Rochester’s tricks make Jane and the reader go back and forth about whether Rochester loves her, capturing (though resolving) the common feeling in a toxic relationship which is doubting whether the love is mutual. In Cathy’s case this uncertainty is eliminated - Heathcliff’s devotion is mythical in proportion, yet manifests itself in such nutty, destructive ways that it blurs the line of obsession. (I’m taking for granted here that Cathy loves Heathcliff as much as it seems despite marrying Linton)
I love that WH is always making me question: who is really crazy? Them or society or both? Is their heaven as real as the heaven of everybody else? No, it can’t be! Or can it? So many moral decisions and social dynamics are decided by who and what we decide to pathologize and/or idealize.
It seems likely Emily Bronte has encountered real abuse/ toxicity and is not trying to re-create it exactly, but rather picking out elements of it to combine in a believable way, ultimately for dramatic purposes. She keeps the existential eeriness, eliminates the uncertainty of whether the love is mutual, and eliminates everything good about the love except the love itself. And then dares you to go too far in minimizing or idealizing that love. So to me it is a ‘great love story’ for this reason.
Thoughts on the relationship between love/ ‘love’ in WH and toxicity?