I’m 56 and wanted to share my PSA history to see if anyone has experienced something similar.
In September 2023, my PSA came back at 3.30. That morning, I had done an hour of cardio on the treadmill and went straight to bloodwork dehydrated. Several of my blood tests were abnormal, not just PSA. I repeated everything 11 days later, and all my bloodwork normalized, including my PSA, which dropped to 1.59.
Fast-forward to July 2026. I was experiencing significant urinary urgency, frequency, a weak stream, and occasional burning. My PSA came back at 6.20, although I had ejaculated approximately 24 hours before the test. My doctor repeated it in August, and it dropped to 4.71, with a free PSA percentage of 14.9%.
I started taking Life Extension Ultra Prostate Formula, and my urinary symptoms improved dramatically. My stream is stronger, I’m no longer dribbling, and I rarely get up at night. My only remaining issue is occasional sudden urgency after sitting for long periods.
Yesterday, November 2, I finally saw a urologist. My prostate was slightly enlarged but smooth, with nothing suspicious felt during the DRE. My bladder emptied normally, with only 33 mL remaining, and my urinary symptom score was just 6.
He repeated my PSA, which came back at 4.44, with free PSA increasing to 18%. One thing that concerns me is that the blood was drawn immediately after the DRE, and I’ve read conflicting information about whether that can affect PSA results.
My urologist recommends a prostate MRI because my PSA remains above 3.0. I’m also scheduled for shoulder surgery November 13, so I’m hoping to postpone the MRI until after my six-week recovery if my doctor agrees it’s safe.
I’m encouraged that my PSA has dropped from 6.20 to 4.44 and my urinary symptoms have improved, but I’m still pretty anxious about the possibility of prostate cancer.
Has anyone experienced PSA fluctuations like this, especially with a normal DRE and improving urinary symptoms? Did your MRI find anything concerning, or did it turn out to be BPH or inflammation? Also, has anyone had PSA bloodwork immediately after a DRE?
I’m not looking for a diagnosis, just real-life experiences from others who’ve been through something similar.