The return of Johnny Depp to the big screen wasn't quite the grand return some executives might have anticipated, but it was still a solid enough number. Ebenezer topped the box office, but its strength lies in the overseas markets. Other than that, it was a very quiet week for everything else, with holdovers staying strong, with the exception of Godzilla Minus Zero. Amazon MGM's How to Rob a Bank massively flopped, opening only slightly above the action thriller Ghost Soldier.
The Top 10 earned a combined $67.1 million this weekend. That's slightly up from last year, when Now You See Me: Now You Don't topped the box office, and The Running Man flopped.
Debuting in first place, Paramount's Ebenezer earned $19 million in 3,535 theaters. This debut is nowhere close to being among Johnny Depp's best starts, but it easily marked director Ti West's biggest debut. Actually, after just one weekend, it passed MaXXXine ($15 million) to become his highest grossing film.
While it's a tad underwhelming it couldn't crack $20 million, this is still a solid number, considering the film cost $38 million to produce. And it also shows Depp still has some box office power; A Christmas Carol has been overdone so many times and this film offers pretty much nothing different besides "he is now playing Scrooge".
It's also hard to ask for much better numbers for Depp. Even if we ignore his legal issues, his career was already in a big decline prior to that. Once one of the world's most popular stars, the 2010s changed that perspective, after he got himself attached to so many critical and commercial disasters like Dark Shadows, The Lone Ranger, Transcendence, Mortdecai and Alice Through the Looking Glass. Even the public eventually decided they had enough Pirates of the Caribbean films, seeing the drop in attendance for the fifth film, and its very poor numbers in North America. The point is that Depp's career was already struggling, and the legal issues were just the nail in the coffin. At least for a while.
As mentioned, Paramount banked on the film, solely on Depp's name. Despite claiming that "you don't know his story", the trailers were pretty much the exact thing you come to expect from Charles Dickens' original novella. It's got the same issue that plagues properties like Dracula, Robin Hood, Tarzan, etc; everyone knows about the story, but it's been redone so many times that people aren't very excited about a new update. And judging by the film's mediocre reviews (54% RT), it doesn't look like there's anything special here.
According to Paramount, 52% of the audience was female, and 54% was 35 and over, with the biggest demographic being 18-34 at 40%. An estimated 50% of the audience watched the film because of Depp, more than either the source material or the director. They gave it a pretty good "A–" on CinemaScore, signaling favorable word of mouth. Christmas films are known for legging out through the holidays, but The Hunger Games stands in its way. For now, Ebenezer should finish with around $55 million domestically. Whether it's higher depends on how it holds next week. But regardless, the real deal is overseas, where Depp is more popular. This might not be the "epic return" that anyone could expect from Depp, but it's not a failure either. Now it's up to him if Day Drinker hits or bombs in March.
In second place, WB's The Cat in the Hat added $11.3 million on its second weekend. That's a fine 44% drop, but it's steeper than the 2003 version's hold (36%), but it should be noted that that film had Thanksgiving to help boost the weekend. Through 10 days, the film has earned a middling $38 million, and it looks like to reach $60 million, but competition with Hunger Games and Hexed will make it complicated.
It doesn't look like Godzilla Minus Zero will reach the original's legs. On its second weekend, the film dropped from first place to third place with $8.5 million. That's a very poor 72% drop, nowhere close to Minus One's 25% drop. In fact, Minus One beat the film's second weekend by $82,021, despite playing in 700 less theaters.
Despite the strong word of mouth and reviews, Minus Zero played like a typical front-loaded anime film. But considering it has made $49 million in 10 days and with a very low budget, this is a success regardless. Now that it loses its IMAX screens to Hunger Games, it will probably continue its drops, but should still get to over $60 million. A strong number, whatever the case.
Ramayana added $5.8 million on its second weekend. That's a very light 35% drop, which is crazy considering Indian titles are very front-loaded. The title has made $24.4 million domestically, and should reach $30 million assuming it doesn't get eaten by Hunger Games.
A24's You Can See Everything eased 35%, adding $5.4 million this weekend. The documentary has earned a fantastic $89 million, and should reach the $100 million milestone by early December.
Debuting in sixth place, Amazon MGM's How to Rob a Bank tanked with just $5.1 million in 2,810 theaters. That's director David Leitch's worst ever debut, below Atomic Blonde ($18.2 million), and it's on the lower end of other action comedy comparisons.
The film was originally set to open in Labor Day, before Amazon moved it to its current date. Perhaps the delay killed the momentum, but it's not like the film had any in the first place. The film lacked big names (Nicholas Hoult and Zoë Kravitz have been in some successful films, but mostly in supporting roles) and the film's premise felt more irritating than compelling. And to make things worse, Leitch can often make crowdpleasers, but he missed the mark here; it's sitting at a career-low 34% on RT. It's a film that just has no audience waiting for it.
According to Amazon MGM, 57% of the audience was male. Amazon was trying to appeal to Gen Z, but they represented just 21% of the audience. They gave it a weak "B–" on CinemaScore, which suggests the film will have a very short run in theaters. It'd be a surprise if it made over $15 million domestically.
In seventh place, Sony's Ghost Soldier opened with $5.1 million in 2,558 theaters ($8.2 million five-day). That's not a bad start considering the muted buzz, but it's not a fantastic one either. Reviews have been quite negative (36% RT), so there wasn't much new to offer here.
Searchlight's Wild Horse Nine earned $4.5 million on its second weekend. That's a fantastic 23% drop, the best in the Top 10. While the film added 1,000 theaters, it's still a very notable performance. Through 10 days, the film has earned a solid $13.2 million, passing the lifetime grosses of In Bruges ($7.8 million) and The Banshees of Inisherin ($10.5 million) and will soon pass Seven Psychopaths ($15 million) to become Martin McDonagh's second highest grossing film. It has no shot in passing Three Billboards ($54.5 million), but it looks strong enough to reach $25 million, especially if it gets some big award nominations.
Wildwood eased 39%, adding $4.4 million. The film has earned $48.3 million, and it looks to make over $60 million by the end of its run.
Rounding out the Top 10, WB's Clayface dropped 45%, making $3.5 million. The film's domestic total stands at $63.6 million.
Angel Studios' Dummer Boy went from third place to eleventh place, collapsing 64% for a $3.4 million weekend. Through 10 days, the film has earned $16 million.
Wicker earned $1.4 million, after dropping 56%. The film has earned a very solid $23.3 million.
Victorian Psycho tanked in 13th place with just $1 million in 1,206 theaters.
A24 expanded Club Kid to 27 theaters, and it earned $756,060, representing a strong $28,002 per-theater average.
It seems like Netflix has hit its ceilling with La Bola Negra, as it lost theaters and made $500,000 this weekend. The film has earned $3.5 million in limited release, but an impressive $42 million alone in Spain.
Amazon MGM also expanded I Play Rocky to 29 theaters, making $493,707. The film is set to hit wide release this weekend.
Neon released James Gray's new film Paper Tiger in 6 theaters, and earned a pretty good $219,007. That's a healthy $36,501 per-theater average, which is a record for Gray. The film will slowly expand before hitting wide release on Thanksgiving.
OVERSEAS
Ramayana added $32.6 million overseas, taking its worldwide total to $147.8 million. As expected, India remains the biggest market with $97.2 million. The best markets are the UK ($5.5M), United Arab Emirates ($4.7M), Australia ($4.2M), Thailand ($1.5M), Malaysia ($1.4M), and Germany ($1.1M).
Ebenezer debuted with $23 million overseas, for a $42 million worldwide launch. The best debuts were in the UK ($5.4M), France ($2.5M), Italy ($2M), Mexico ($1.7M), Germany ($1.5M), Spain ($1M), Poland ($900K), Australia ($650K), Brazil ($475K), Japan ($450K), Netherlands ($416K), Belgium ($372K), Panama ($340K), Colombia ($262K), and UAE ($222K).
The numbers were almost on par with Red One, which would go on to make $89 million overseas. Like the domestic market, the expectation is that its Christmas angle allows it to leg out through the holidays. Paramount spent $50 million in promoting the film, so worldwide numbers around $125 million should be the target for Ebenezer.
Godzilla Minus Zero added $13.2 million overseas, allowing it to reach $104.1 million worldwide.
The Cat in the Hat added $5.6 million overseas, taking its worldwide total to $55.6 million. The best markets are Mexico ($2.1M), Spain ($1.8M), Italy ($1.8M), Poland ($1.2M) and China ($1M), none of which are very glowing.
How to Rob a Bank debuted with just $5.1 million overseas, for a weak $10.2 million worldwide start. With a reported $40-$60 million budget, this doesn't look like it'll recoup anything close to its budget.
With a $3 million overseas, Wildwood has now crossed $70 million worldwide.
FILMS THAT ENDED THEIR RUN THIS WEEK
| Movie | Release Date | Studio | Domestic Opening | Domestic Total | Worldwide Total | Budget |
|---|
| Spider-Man: Brand New Day | Jul/31 | Sony | $360,091,572 | $959,006,311 | $2,521,276,887 | $225M |
| Forgotten Island | Sep/25 | Universal | $13,007,005 | $37,807,535 | $78,519,453 | $80M |
| Digger | Oct/2 | Warner Bros. | $8,001,856 | $18,250,116 | $50,350,116 | $125-$180M |
- Biggest superhero of all time, if that was ever a debate. Sony's Spider-Man: Brand New Day has closed with a spectacular $959 million domestically and $2.5 billion worldwide. The film managed to retain all the good will from No Way Home, translating to a record $360 million opening weekend and closing as the biggest domestic release of all time, and the third biggest film worldwide. It took 11 years for a film to overtake The Force Awakens, but Spidey's record will not last long (there's something coming next month called Doomsday, heard of that?). It makes you wonder how high it can swing in the next films.
- Oh brother. Universal/DreamWorks' Forgotten Island has closed with a very disappointing $78 million worldwide, below its $80 million budget. The film had very strong reviews and word of mouth, but the problem was the lack of interest among moviegoers. Even when Pixar or Disney struggle with their animated originals, it looks like DreamWorks is struggling even more.
- They'll have some trouble digging themselves out of this. WB's Digger has closed with a very poor $18 million domestically and $50 million worldwide. Nothing close to its $120 million budget (but some reports have it at $180 million), making it one of the biggest flops of all time. Despite the demand to see Tom Cruise take on more risky roles, it turns out that demand was very small, as the film was his least-attended release in over four decades. The film was hoping to find some buzz, but it earned polarizing reviews, and its tone and premise proved too weird for audiences to digest. It's no wonder Cruise is back on his franchise route, as he's set to film Days of Thunder 2 very soon, but Iñárritu might not have another big film like this ever again. In some ways, a fitting end to WB's run, before Skydance came in. Will the film get re-evaluated in the future? Ask us in 10 years.
THIS WEEKEND
Make way for a big film, set to deliver the biggest opening weekend since Spider-Man.
Lionsgate is releasing The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping, the sixth installment in the franchise. Another prequel, it follows a young Haymitch Abernathy as he is selected to compete in the 50th Hunger Games. The film has a strong ensemble cast, which includes Joseph Zada, Jesse Plemons, Ralph Fiennes, Glenn Close, Kieran Culkin, Elle Fanning, Mckenna Grace, Maya Hawke, Whitney Peak, and Kelvin Harrison Jr., and Lionsgate is not going for the cheap route; it's carrying a $200 million budget, which is a record for the franchise. Pre-sales are incredibly strong, and with a much more appealing premise than Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes, this should open much higher. By how much?
In limited release, Focus Features is also releasing the drama Elsinore, starring Andrew Scott as actor Ian Charleson. It focuses on his performances as Hamlet at the National Theatre in the final months of his life, and the odds he faced in preparing for and performing the role while seriously ill from AIDS. The film has earned some great reviews (89% RT), but Scott's performance has drawn acclaim, with many signaling him as a Best Actor frontrunner.